Everand Logo

Welcome to Everand!

  • Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

    From $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

    Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality
    Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality
    Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality
    Ebook76 pages39 minutes

    Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality

    By Razie Mah

    ()

    Read preview

    About this ebook

    In Spirit and Reality (1939), Nicholas Berdyaev, an Orthodox exile from communist Russia, frequently writes the word "spirit", but rarely pens the word "reality". How should I appreciate this? Here is my guess.
    In Philosophy of Nature (1935), Jacques Maritain presents an argument that allows this reader to construct diagrams of the Positivist's and the empirio-schematic judgments. The empirio-schematic judgment belongs to 'what ought to be' for the Positivist's judgment. So, a modernist poses two judgments at once, a judgment within a judgment. That is totally confounding.
    In this close reading, features of Berdyaev's argument are diagrammed using models developed in the commentary on Jacques Maritain's Book (1935) Natural Philosophy.
    Berdyaev places the Positivist's judgment into a new category-based nested form, polarizing the judgment until it takes the character of a dyad. Berdyaev emphasizes the character of the intellect-noumenal side. Ironically, the Vienna Circle (meeting between 1924 through 1936) celebrates the empirio-schematic judgment-phenomenal side.
    What does this say about the historical moment?
    Surely, between the two world wars, the nature of science is under scrutiny. Yet, inquirers lacked semiotic tools for inquiry. The tools are here. They transform Berdyaev’s argument into something both familiar and novel.

    LanguageEnglish
    PublisherRazie Mah
    Release dateDec 30, 2018
    ISBN9781942824589
    Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality
    Author

    Razie Mah

    See website for bio.

    Read more from Razie Mah

    Related to Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality

    Related ebooks

    Science & Mathematics For You

    View More
    View More

    Related podcast episodes

    Related articles

    • UNLIMITED

      Rome Vs. Chicago

      Jan 31, 2019

      Rome Vs. Chicago
      3 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Lessons To Live By

      Sep 18, 2020

      Lessons To Live By
      4 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Flawed Genius

      Jul 18, 2021

      Flawed Genius
      2 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      What Love Meant in 4500 B.C.

      Feb 21, 2022

      What Love Meant in 4500 B.C.
      2 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Found Mystic: Thomas Traherne

      Sep 25, 2019

      Found Mystic: Thomas Traherne
      3 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      5 Transmutation

      Mar 23, 2021

      5 Transmutation
      2 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      This Philosopher Helped Ensure There Was No Nobel for Relativity: Henri Bergson’s debate with Albert Einstein reached and swayed the 1921 Nobel committee.

      Apr 21, 2016

      On April 6, 1922, Einstein met a man he would never forget. He was one of the most celebrated philosophers of the century, widely known for espousing a theory of time that explained what clocks did not: memories, premonitions, expectations, and antic

      12 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Was There a Fifth Noble Truth?

      Jan 22, 2019

      MORE THAN TWENTY YEARS have passed since twenty-eight fragile birch bark scrolls, now known to be the oldest surviving Buddhist manuscripts in the world, came to light. Dating back to as early as the first century BCE, the scrolls—originating in the

      2 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      All Beings Liberating, Together, At Once

      Jun 5, 2020

      All Beings Liberating, Together, At Once
      6 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Frosted Veil

      Nov 30, 2021

      Christmas is coming! What images these words conjure up in our minds. A happy sigh of relief is recurring amid the collective experience of emotional turmoil created by imposed hardships over the nearly two years of the pandemic! The pandemic appeare

      2 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Paradox Is Illuminating the Black Hole

      Jan 31, 2019

      An Introduction to the Black Hole Institute Fittingly, the Black Hole Initiative (BHI) was founded 100 years after Karl Schwarzschild solved Einstein’s equations for general relativity—a solution that described a black hole decades before the first a

      7 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Why Science Should Stay Clear of Metaphysics: Meet the philosopher who revived anti-realism.

      Sep 8, 2016

      Philosophers of science are not known for agreeing with each other—contrariness is part of the job description. But for thousands of years, from Aristotle to Thomas Kuhn, those who study what science is have roughly categorized themselves into two ba

      11 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Paradox Is Illuminating the Black Hole

      Apr 11, 2019

      This essay is one of the five winners in the 2019 writing competition held by the Black Hole Initiative at Harvard University. “The Black Hole Initiative offers a unique environment for thinking about the topic of black holes more creatively and comp

      6 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      The Reality Ouroboros

      Sep 4, 2024

      “Among the roots of your classicism you must include your passions for the stars.” —Cesare Pavese, This Business of Living What is reality? And is there just one reality or many, perhaps infinitely many? And how should we describe these realities, wi

      4 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      How Teacups and Demons Help Demystify Physics

      Aug 26, 2024

      In his 1967 short story “The Southern Thruway,” Argentine writer Julio Cortázar conjures a catastrophic traffic jam just outside of Paris. The gridlock endures for months, forcing motorists to build an entirely new society around their immobile cars.

      8 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Electrons May Very Well Be Conscious

      Dec 30, 2020

      Happy Holidays. This week we are reprinting our top stories of 2020. This article first appeared online in our Facts So Romantic blog in May, 2020. In May, the cover of New Scientist ran the headline, “Is the Universe Conscious?” Mathematician and ph

      5 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      The Observer Effect

      Nov 2, 2018

      The Observer Effect
      6 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Infinite Energy

      Apr 19, 2021

      Infinite Energy
      11 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Letters

      Nov 1, 2024

      Peter Godfrey-Smith does well to take a closer look at the reception of Jakob von Uexküll’s Umwelt theory in recent books by Jackie Higgins and Ed Yong [“Visi-le and Invisible Worlds,” NYR, June 6], but like much recent critical engagement with Uexkü

      5 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      Is the Universe Open-Ended?

      Jun 16, 2021

      One of my favorite albeit heavily paraphrased quotes from Albert Einstein is his assertion that the most incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it is comprehensible. (What he actually said, in his 1936 work “Physics and Reality,” is more l

      7 min read

    • UNLIMITED

      We Have to Talk About Doubt: How to tell the difference between scientific and conspiratorial skepticism.

      Sep 1, 2021

      What is the role of reasonable doubt in advancing science? And how should we contrast scientific doubt with the cavilling doubt of conspiracy theories which play little part in advancing understanding? Over the last year we have seen the scientific m

      5 min read

    Related categories

    Reviews for Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality

    0 ratings

    0 ratings0 reviews

    What did you think?

    Tap to rate

    Review must be at least 10 words

      Book preview

      Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality - Razie Mah

      Comments on Nicholas Berdyaev's Book (1939) Spirit and Reality

      By Razie Mah

      Published for Smashwords.com

      2018

      Notes on Text

      This work comments on book by Russian Nicolas Berdyaev, Spirit and Reality.

      Single quotes and italics are used to group words together.

      Prerequisites include A Primer on the Category-Based Nested Form, A Primer on Sensible and Social Construction. Suggested readings include Comments on Jacques Maritain's Book (1935) Philosophy of Nature, abbreviated as CJMNP.

      Table of Contents

      The Beast Crouching at the Door

      Maritain’s Model of Positivist Judgment

      What is Real?

      Attributes of the Subjective Realm

      Models for the Subjugation of the Spirit

      Example of Sensible Construction

      Asceticism

      Subjective Evil and Suffering. Objective Sin.

      Purification

      Contemplation

      The New Spirituality

      The Beast Crouching at the Door

      0001 Nicolas Berdyaev publishes Spirit and Reality (1939) when he is 63 years old, a Russian exile in Paris. His residence in that city overlaps with another notable author. Jacques Maritain's book, Natural Philosophy (1935), examines positivist scientific attitudes through the lens of scholastic thought.

      Surely, Berdyaev and Maritain struggle with the same two-faced beast: positivist and empirio-schematic judgments. Talking to a modernist is like speaking to a ventriloquist and a puppet, both at same time. One has history on his side. The other has science.

      0002 A two-faced monster crouches at the door.

      There seems no way to stop it, because its desire is for our desire.

      Each of us wants to be on the right side of history. Who does not believe in science?

      0003 Maritain, trained as a chemist, tries to isolate the beast. But, he cannot separate the two faces. In order to neutralize the scientific facade, Maritain revives natural philosophy. He applies the scholastic approach of three degrees of abstraction to the creature. He configures an optical analogy in which the second degree is viewed through the first and third degrees. He claims that abstraction is visualization. Science is a lens to view the world.

      What a lens it is.

      Natural Philosophy shows that moderns view their world through two interconnected judgments. The relational structures of the positivist and empirio-schematic judgments are not nested. The empirio-schematic judgment occupies the position of what ought to be in the positivist judgment.

      0004 So how the beast devour?

      Noumena organize the positivist intellect, while that same intellect brings an empirio-schematic judgment into relation with a phenomenon.

      The beast devours because, unlike Aristotle’s judgment, the positivist judgment is full of its own righteousness.

      The empirio-schematic judgment - the scientific construction - is what ought to be.

      There is more.

      Models are more real than phenomena.

      History is destiny.

      Science is the truth that destiny reveals.

      0005 In this work of semiotic visualization, I start with Maritain’s model of positivist judgment and imagine that Berdyaev places this relational structure, as an actuality, into a new vessel. He places it into a new nested form.

      This polarizes the triad into a dyad, a dance between subjective and objective. He envisions this interplay as a dynamic expression of a new spirituality.

      0006 In this manner, the monster may be recognized and tamed.

      Or so, Berdyaev imagines.

      Maritain’s Model of Positivist Judgment

      0007 Judgment exhibits a triadic structure. It has three elements (P,Q,R). Judgment is a relation (P) between what is (Q) and what ought to be (R).

      In reflective judgment, categories are not assigned to each element.

      In actionable judgment, categories are assigned. A different category inheres to each element. The assignment permits the actionable

      Enjoying the preview?
      Page 1 of 1