She Still Calls Me Daddy: Building a New Relationship with Your Daughter After You Walk Her Down the Aisle

PRAISE FOR

She Still Calls Me Daddy

"She Still Calls Me Daddy is for any father who will one day say the words, ‘Her mother and I do.’ With humor and wisdom, Robert shares from his life experiences how to navigate the inevitable journey of letting go of your little girl to embracing the ‘new normal’ after she says, ‘I do.’ You will be surprised what you will learn!"

—Alan Jackson, singer and songwriter

As father of the bride, I’ve felt the same emotional roller coaster Robert Wolgemuth so eloquently describes in this must-read book for all dads with daughters. You’ll learn that along with the changes, the challenges, and the credit card bills comes the real payoff—the opportunity to have a great lifelong relationship with not only her but also the new man in her life.

—Dr. Kevin Leman, author, What a Difference a Daddy Makes

Here’s hoping all dads will benefit from my friend Robert Wolgemuth’s book. The title alone captured my heart, as a daddy of three daughters, having recently walked my oldest daughter down the aisle.

—Max Lucado, minister and best-selling author

I have done what my friend Robert Wolgemuth has done. With a priceless daughter on my arm, I’ve taken that long walk down the aisle. Like Robert, I’ve said, ‘Good-bye.’ And I have tried to do the hard work of remodeling this relationship with my daughter, now that there’s a new sheriff in town. Every dad who has ‘given his daughter away’ and every dad who is going to must read this important, page-turning book.

—Dennis Rainey, president, FamilyLife

© 2009 Robert D. Wolgemuth

All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means—electronic, mechanical, photocopy, recording, scanning, or other—except for brief quotations in critical reviews or articles, without the prior written permission of the publisher.

Published in Nashville, Tennessee, by Thomas Nelson. Thomas Nelson is a registered trademark of Thomas Nelson, Inc.

Thomas Nelson, Inc. titles may be purchased in bulk for educational, business, fund-raising, or sales promotional use. For information, please e-mail [email protected].

Unless otherwise noted, Scripture quotations are taken from the New King James Version®. ©1982 by Thomas Nelson, Inc. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

Scripture quotations marked NLT are from the Holy Bible, New Living Translation. © 1996, 2004. Used by permission of Tyndale House Publishers, Inc., Wheaton, IL 60189. All rights reserved.

Scripture quotations marked NCV are from the New Century Version®. © 2005 by Thomas Nelson, Inc. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

Scripture quotations marked KJV are from the Holy Bible, King James Version.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Wolgemuth, Robert D.

She still calls me Daddy : building a new relationship with your daughter after you walk her down the aisle / Robert Wolgemuth.

   p. cm.

Includes bibliographical references.

ISBN 978-0-7852-2170-8 (hardcover)

1. Fathers—Religious life. 2. Fathers and daughters—Religious aspects—Christianity. 3. Parent and adult child—Religious aspects—Christianity. 4. Marriage--Religious aspects—Christianity. 5. Wives—Family relationships. I. Title.

BV4529.17.W65 2009

248.8’421—dc22

2009001459

09 10 11 12 13 QW 5 4 3 2 1

Information about External Hyperlinks in this ebook

Please note that footnotes in this ebook may contain hyperlinks to external websites as part of bibliographic citations. These hyperlinks have not been activated by the publisher, who cannot verify the accuracy of these links beyond the date of publication.

To my sons-in-law:

JONATHAN DAVID SCHRADER

and

CHRISTOPHER ORIN TASSY

The marriages of these men to our daughters

were not arranged by me,

but our relationship to each other was a total setup.

Missy and Julie, now their wives, decided

we would all be in the same family,

and I could not be more grateful.

Bobbie and I love Jon and Christopher

more than we could ever express.

They are our sons.

CONTENTS

With Gratitude

Introduction: Welcome to the Rest of Your Life

1. Saying Good-bye

2. New Normals for Everyone

3. Protection: Safeguarding Her Marriage

4. Conversation: Can You Hear Me Now?

5. Affection: Widening Your Embrace

6. Discipline: The Hard Work of Letting Go

7. Laughter: A Preacher, a Rabbi, and a Priest Went Fishing . . .

8. Faith: Where the Real Power Lives

9. Conduct: It’s Showtime for Dad

10. Her Mother and I Still Do

Conclusion: For Dads in Special Situations

Notes

About the Author

WITH GRATITUDE

HOW DO I LOVE THEE? LET ME COUNT THE WAYS . . .

—Elizabeth Barrett Browning

Call me a soppy sentimentalist, but at the start of our wedding ceremony on March 28, 1970, I quoted Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s lovely poem in its entirety to my bride as she stood at the back of the church, her hand resting on her father’s arm.

A few moments later when the processional hymn ended, her dad, Dr. Raymond Gardner, gave that hand to me. I took it, along with the precious person connected to it, and a few days later, moved my bride from her parents’ home in Washington, DC, to my home in Chicago. Even though she continued to love her father—still calling him Daddy—I assumed the primary male role in her life. Ready or not.

I was not qualified to assume this responsibility. I had not done anything to deserve it. I knew far less about love and leadership than Bobbie’s dad knew. But these disqualifications didn’t stop the procedure. Pastor A. W. Jackson asked Bobbie’s dad the question, and Dr. Gardner answered in his gentle southern Virginia drawl, Her mother and I do. He smiled at me, turned, and walked to his seat next to his wife, Bobbie’s mother.

On the chancel at Cherrydale Baptist in Arlington, Bobbie’s dad exhibited the generous grace of entrusting his daughter to my care. I inherited the sweet relationship she had with him; the confidence my new wife had placed in a man who was responsible for protecting her was transferred in full measure to me. Today, as I was back then, I am so thankful for Bobbie’s dad.

A few decades later, this tight-fitting shoe was on my own foot. I gave my two daughters away, turned, and sat down next to their mom. The men who received these gifts were no more qualified than I had been, but I spoke the same words Dr. Gardner had spoken, and our daughters were gone.

In addition to my father-in-law, I have just identified five people without whom this book would not have been written.

My wife, Bobbie, like every bride, had no idea what she was in for when we married that spring day. She’s my companion, friend, confidant, and lover. Bobbie’s contribution to this book is far more than simply showing up in some of the stories; her editorial touches are legion. Any awkwardness in the writing must be places where I talked her out of what she wanted to do with the words. The rest—if it makes sense—you can credit to her.

Life has been an amazing adventure with Bobbie. My sister, Ruth, said to me one day, You two make a great team. She’s right. I’m very, very thankful for my doubles partner.

Our daughters, Missy and Julie, brought more change to my life than marrying their mother had brought. Perhaps you’ve noticed this, but once babies arrive, they have a tendency to be quite selfish and demanding. Evenings of carefree What do you want to do tonight, honey? are gone. Young children rarely check to see if you’re available at the moment they call on you. Wonderful as they were, our daughters turned everything upside down. But any kind of inconvenience they caused was eclipsed by the indescribable joy they brought to this father’s heart.

Early on, Missy and Julie called me, Daddy. They still do. Today, even though they’re both married and are old enough to have schedules that legitimately crowd out their dad, hardly a day passes when we don’t speak by phone, e-mail, or text message. Sometimes it’s no more than, I love you today. Sometimes it’s a little more than that. Always it’s enough. I’m very thankful for them.

I’ll admit it. I wanted a son . . . a boy who, by some quirk of genetic fate, would be the athlete I never was. Gratefully, in the providence of God, I did get a son—two of them. Jon Schrader and Christopher Tassy came by way of our daughters, fully grown and, sure enough, more naturally athletic than me. But our relationship has been more than tumbling around in a racquetball court or scratching numbers with a pencil on a scorecard. So much more. I am extremely grateful for these men. These friends. My sons.

In many ways, this book is primarily about Jon and Christopher. So, as you’d imagine, I gave them plenty of time to review every story, checking for accuracy and fairness. What you have here has been blessed by them both.

These five people—Bobbie, Missy, Julie, Jon, and Christopher—are dearer to me than could ever be expressed. With these words, I thank them.

Because writing isn’t all that I do, I’m very grateful for the team of colleagues with whom I have the honor of working each day: Erik Wolgemuth, Andrew Wolgemuth, Michael Ranville, and Susan Kreider. Their faithful work gives me the margin I need to seamlessly squeeze the writing into the open gaps. Thanks to each one.

To my publisher, Mike Hyatt—a special friend with whom I shared a brain and checkbook for almost sixteen years of business partnership—who now leads Thomas Nelson as CEO. And to those on his team who have made this an absolutely delightful journey: Debbie Wickwire, Jennifer Stair, Emily Sweeney, Matt Baugher, Mark Gilroy, Lisa Rollins, and Tami Heim. Thanks to each of them as well as Mark Schoenwald and the highly capable Nelson sales professionals he manages.

Finally, thanks to you for spending a few hours with me. My hope and prayer is that this book is as encouraging as it is helpful. God bless you as you gather your construction tools for this amazing remodeling adventure.

INTRODUCTION

WELCOME TO THE REST

OF YOUR LIFE

Do you think we could have breakfast tomorrow morning?" Jonathan Schrader asked me, doing his best to sound deliberate and calm.

I knew what this breakfast meeting was about.

Jon knew that I knew what this breakfast meeting was about.

I knew that Jon knew that I knew . . .

Jon and our older daughter, Missy, had attended the same university for two years and had been friends. Just friends. Then, after her sophomore year, Missy transferred and they lost contact with each other. In the spring of 1993, just for the fun of it, Missy decided to drive from Nashville to Indiana to attend Taylor University’s graduation ceremonies. She knew this would be a good opportunity to see her old college friends before they scattered.

During the weekend festivities, Missy bumped into Jon. Or perhaps Jon bumped into Missy. Regardless, they gave each other an old-friend hug and spent a few minutes catching up. Jon was getting ready to move to Charlotte to take his first postgraduation job. She was living and working in Nashville. Not surprising for two twenty-one-year-olds, the subject of each other’s current significant other surfaced. Ironically, neither had one at that moment. Something clicked for both of them, and they agreed to stay in touch.

When Missy returned to Nashville, she circled by our house on her way to her apartment and filled her mother and me in on the weekend fun with her buddies. The report included a mention of Jon Schrader. As we listened to her talk about Jon, Bobbie and I sensed some interest, all right, but we didn’t detect any weak-kneed infatuation.

These were the years before e-mail and text-messaging, so Missy and Jon’s follow-up to their graduation conversation was restricted to telephone calls and a few letters. During one phone call, Jon mentioned to Missy that in his move from his parents’ home in Chicago to his new home in Charlotte, he would be passing through Nashville. A meeting was set, including a visit to our house where Bobbie and I would have a chance to meet Jon.

A few days later, the meetings—ours and apparently Missy’s—went very well. Friendship soon gave way to romance.

Just over seven months later, Jon invited me to breakfast. His purpose was indisputable. This young man wanted to ask my permission to marry my daughter.

By this time, Bobbie and I had grown to love Jon and were convinced that he would be a good husband to Missy. My answer to Jon’s question was an unqualified yes.

In the months that followed, as Bobbie and Missy finalized their wedding plans, a growing sense of apprehension began creeping into my consciousness. Twenty-four years before this, I had permanently scurried Bobbie away from her father. Now it would be my turn to stand on the front porch and watch my daughter drive away with another man. Back then, I had no idea what I had done to Bobbie’s dad. Now that shoe was on my foot, and to be perfectly honest, it felt a little tight.

Five years later, I received another breakfast invitation. This time the host was a young man named Christopher Tassy. The agenda was the same. He knew that I knew.

I knew that he knew that I knew . . .

Our younger daughter, Julie, had chosen this man, and he had chosen her. And as it was with Jon, we couldn’t have been happier.

To say that the

voyage of becoming

a father-in-law

has been exciting

would be an

understatement.

To say that the voyage of becoming a father-in-law has been exciting would be an understatement. This was a role as new and unfamiliar as becoming a father had been. Of course, I had seen other men go through the process, including my own father-in-law.

But the difference between watching and doing are very different. Chances are, you know exactly what I mean.

ENTER THIS BOOK

My wife, Bobbie, wasn’t crazy about the idea of me writing this book . . . for two reasons. First, she wondered if there would be enough material to fill the pages. I wondered about that too. She also wasn’t sure we should expose our family to the inevitable glass house of allowing others to see the inner workings of people in process. Then, as we started talking about all the possibilities—and the ways we could help others to avoid our mistakes—we soon realized that there was reason to share what we’ve learned in the process of becoming a remodeled family.

With our anxieties behind us, Bobbie and I talked and carefully went forward, putting our observations and learned lessons on paper.

SHE STILL CALLS ME DADDY

Our grown daughters still call me Daddy. What’s interesting to me is that even though my daughters’ name for me is the same as when they were little girls, their relationship with me over the years has radically changed.

Even though my

daughters’ name

for me is the same

as when they

were little girls,

their relationship

with me over the

years has radically

changed.

When I was writing She Calls Me Daddy in 1996, I had a chance to look back over the years of raising Missy and Julie. At the time, they were twenty-four and twenty-one, respectively. Only Missy was married at the time, but because they weren’t living at home anymore, I felt quite finished with my task as Daddy.

I asked their permission to write the book, and they approved the manuscript. They even changed a few things before the publisher took the book to press, happily charging their dad with possessing a large memory.

In that book, I used the metaphor of building. Even though there are some midcourse adjustments when a builder begins new construction, it is, for the most part, a matter of rolling out the blueprint on the hood of your pickup truck and following along.

But being Daddy to married daughters is different. Rather than building, it’s a lot more like remodeling. Of course, for major remodeling projects, blueprints are also created, but these plans make assumptions about what the contractor is going to find while he’s remodeling. Sometimes things turn out just as the architect planned, and sometimes—usually—they don’t.

This time, as I write these words, Missy is thirty-seven and Julie is thirty-four. They’re both married and have five children between them. But I’m far from finished with my job of being a father-in-law or granddaddy. And I’m still in the process of learning how to be Daddy to grown and married daughters.

Each of the above ten people has granted me permission to tell our story. If you read the first book, She Calls Me Daddy, you’ll be able to follow along since the themes are the same.