`````Tr.i.::::i..L=.
`J+i.
iE'•L^
•...
:I ...
*
`: `..
4`qif,
EH
{:*#
•a
bh:
:..r,i:.ri
rL_fi
+
`y*`_
,,
.?i!
.rt(:
```
¥:=fl:`±
.&
i
•ee\,\
,, y;,:S` j¥£
Alit_£*::`ir N oriad iG
fi" a i
culttim
++
~ ,~y L`,f:`rTraditidri:
"`:
.`
MONGOLIAI`I DAIRY /
Q~\,.#;%f<4,S~
H,il,
` \ :S`
`
E! ?
•i.:
:
,`:?
`\
:c{*
a.
+1
t€Q`
!ii
trya `
•,.Th
+
a
i
S
`
gi#1S¥:r'=_,;.`<\\tshfaf}'8,L4''`r,#._
`
S'`13,v
S:,: ,
i,:±i
'``~
1€51
Ministry of Food and
Agncullure of
Mongolia
Mongolian
Academy of
Sciences
EEEI
Mongolian University
of Sclence and
Technology
International lnstilute for
the Study of Nomadic
Civilizations
Mongolian Food
Industry
Assocation
rlomadic cultural Tradition:
MONGOLIAI`I DAIRY PRODUCTS
International Scientif ic Symposium
Published by The luternational Institute for the
Study Of Nomadic Civilizations
This book is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and
to the provisions Of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reprodidion
of any part may take place without the written permission of authors.
"Nomadic cultural Tradition:MONGOIIAN DAIRY
PRODUCTS"
Design and art editor:
Designed by:
Published by:
A.TUYA
Ch.MUNKHBAT
"BEMB[ SAN"
© International Institute for the Study of Nomadic Civilizations,
Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia
2003
ISBN: 9992957891
CONTENTS
I.
2.
3.
4.
Foreword
Opening speech
Greeting message from H.E. Mr. N. Bagabandi,
Presidertt Of Mongolia
Welcome address. H.I. D.Nasanjargal
MemberOftheGovernmentCabinet,theMinisterOf
Food and Agriculture of Mongolia
5.
6.
Speech from H.E., Academician B.Chadraa,
MentoerOftheParliamenl,PresidenlOfthe
Mongoliarl Academy Of science
Presentations
6.I. Presentation of scientific papers and reports
Tradition of milk processing in pastoral
extensive livestock system
By Prof R.Indra. /Sc.D/, Agricultural University
Transfer of Mongolian traditional methods of milk
processing to modem dairy technology
By Prof.,Do.Ing G..Gombo, MUST
B iotechnological basis of Mongol ian
national dairy products
By Prof. L.Damdirsuren, /Sc.D/, MUST
National dairy products tradition and renovation
D.Altangerel /Ph.D/, T.Gornbosuren /Ph.D/,
Research Institute Of Anirrlal Husbandry
Ecological condition and some scientific principles of
14
22
28
37
national technology for production and utilization of dairy
44
products from milk of grazing livestock
By Prof. . Stale Laureate N . Erden[sog[ /Sc. D/
Development of Novel Functions of Lactic Acid Bacteria
50
Fusao Tomila, Prof;essor, Laboratory Of
Applied Microbiology, Graduate School Of
Agriculture, Hokkaido University. Japan
Study of therapeutic significance of biologically
lactic acid bacteria /youghurt leaven/
53
Sh.Demberel /Sc.D./, J.Dugersuren /Ph.D/
Favorable effect of fermented milk drink containing
Lactobacillus casei strain Shirota on gastrointestinal
functions in human
60
Prof.YingChieh Tsai, Assist. Prof HutYu Huang,
Senior Researcher Koichi Wa[anabe
Improvement of lactic flora of kimchi
using biopreservatives and probiotics
61
Prof Yun Hee Park, Departmenl of
Biotechnology, Ajou University, Republic Of Korea
Researches on biochemistry and microbiology
of national dairy products
Prof : R.Baldorj /Sc.D/, D.Tumenjargal /Ph.D/,
B.Batjargal /M.Sc/ Mongolian Sla[e University
70
Study of mare milk and of its femented product
77
B.Ochirkhnyag. JM.Choberl, Ts` Narnsrai, Thomas Haerlla
Product development of Lactic acid bacteria
industry in Taiwan
Senior Researcher ChiiCherng Liao /Ph. D/, ITaiwan/
Significance of Bacterian camel 's milk
Ts`Ba[sukh, /Ph.D/, MUST
The ability of camel's milk to be processed into cheese
ProfJean Paul Ramet. /France/
Preservation of milk in a wami climate
Dr. Eva Jonsson, /Sweden/
92
Kefir fungi: the prospects of using biotechnological
properties to produce dairy products
Doctor, N. I.Khamnaeva, /Ph. D/, /Russian Federation/
97
Creation of milk product to functional
nutrition
99
S.Artyukhova /Russian Federaliowl
New approach of using Lactoacid Bacteria
in milk processing in Korea
103
Prof. Kang Kook Hee, /Republic of Korea/
Results of study on the diagnosis of mastititis in cow of yak, native
mongolian and dairy breeds, and the udentification of causal
agents of the mastitis
J. Damdinsuren, A.Magash, S.I:sevelmaa,
108
Lactoperoxidase system as temporary preservative for row.
milk in mongolia
109
D.Enkh[selseg , Researcl. Justitute of Animal Husbaridry,
Agriculture University Of Mongolia
The technological basis for goat molk processing in Mongolia
Ch.I:send~Anysh. PhD, M UST
Development of the accelerated ripening of
cheese by favour enchancing enzymes
on the cheese production
Prof Kang Chil. /Republic Of Korea/
113
116
An experimental result to invent some technical facilities
to process dairy products in farm
117
Prof B.Baldangombo,B.Lkhagvadorj, Agricultural University
7.
The Recommendation issued by
the participants of the Symposium
119
Nomdiw cuftura[ Trtidiition: gvi.ongohan deiry protuets
FOREWORD
One of the classical directions for proper utilization of milk from five
speciesoflivestockforcountrywithdominantextensivepastorallivestocksystem
was a Mongolian traditional dairy processing method, that is recognized as a
cultural heritage, which was being inherited from generation to generation till
today since the ancient time.
Many measures and activities on revering the traditions and cultural
heritages, recognition them for the next generation, advocacy of history, culture
I:l;.;rib;;`*d#;H:':OHfi#,;;'\%+b::+4#%r::#H:onw"€:54?c&3":yit£:rf%}¥jrf,
3pnw#,`iii\f/t.!irA!i
S`;:;g;t`zcei#;!l:enfrL:*1,i,ij;`r;s!!'ijfu3o§f{i:'';i::n§ii"`§{'[:{&:¥T!i,£:ii,:;i:g.i.:se°KDhuaGa:S"
::afi;§§?23a8';,\y,%:.f?,r,:T2'o[dzu,{18,!i}t,li!i`?i
in
if;;;I;;;:{,Prof.,
Open
symposium` I)i.
Acadendc.lan
I).Badarcl.,
B.Chadraa,
Presidenl
Pres.id.ent.?!.I~h_e
Of the MUST, P_Darnli.ndo.r.j,
¥A_S, iv!:in.bet o.if.t!:
Sta.te secrelarr .?f
•Ii;inl;I;;e; ;; food and Agrlcullure, Academic.lan B.Enkl!tu_vshi.n, V`i:.e:.c_halrman of lhe
organlzlng coinmitlee, Direc;or Of IIIe IISNC,
Prof.,Dr.Ing G.C;ombo, MUST.
Interrrationa[ S cientiflc Symposlum
and tradition to the foreign world have been taken in the frame of celebration of
the 840'h birth of the Great Emperor Chingis Khaan and the 800'h armiversary of
establishment of United Mongol Empire, which are exciting every Mongol to
make a contribution in these activities.
The Organizing Committee of the lnternational Symposium, was chaired
by Mr.D.Terbishdagva, the ViceMinister of Food and Agriculture and Vice
chairman ofthe organizing committee Academician B.Enkhtuvshin, VicePresident
of the MAS, Director of the IISNC.
The lnternational Scientific Symposium, which was coorganized by
Ministry of Food and Agriculture and Mongolian Academy of Sciences on 2023
September, 2002, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, was successfully fullfiled its goal with
active initiative and broad participation of members of the Organizing Committee,
staffs of Ministry of Food and Agriculture, the Presidium Office of Academy of
Science, administration of Food and Biotechnology School of MUST, teachers,
scholars, involved in dairy science, NCOs, Research Institutes, Corporations and
the IISNC. Along with Mongolian researches more than 10 delegates from Sweden,
Russian Federation, Republic of Korea, France, Japan, Taiwan participated in this
Symposium to discuss and present many interesting papers by their theoretical
and practical importance on the issues of the current level of Mongolian dairy
science, further trends, scientific and technological basis for traditional milk
processing methods, the way of transferring these methods to modem dairy
production technology, achievements and results of experiences and the
development of production of functional dairy products, containing biological
active substances and alive milk acid bacteria.
Although, due to time limitation and work schedule, many researchers
were unable to present their papers at the Symposium, the written variations of the
papers were received by the Organizing Committee with much appreciation and
translated in English and Mongolian languages respectively for publication.
In order to give a valuable information on milk and dairy study,
technological and industrial aspects, which will be useful book for researchers,
students and business people, the IISNC is honored to take the financial
responsibility to publish this book.
B.Enkhtuvshin
ViicePresident Of the MAS, Director Of the IISNC
8
Nomadic cu[tura{ q=r:Iediition: "ongo[un chiry products
OPENING SPEECH
(Prof., Doc. D.Badarch.President
Mongolian University Of Science and Tleclinology)
Dear distinguished scientists and researches!
Dearparticipants!
Ladies and gentlemen!
Good moming!
International Scientific Symposium "Nomadic Cultural Traditions:
Mongolian Dairy Products" was initiated by Mongolian University of Science
and Technology and Mongolian Food Industry Association in occasion of
celebration of the 840th anniversary of chingis Khaan birth and the 800th anniversary
of establishment of the Great Mongol Empire. Enormous preparation works have
been done to organize this symposium with strong support of the President and
the Government of Mongolia and now is ready to be opened.
It is my pleasure to announce that scientists and researchers from Russian
Federation, Republic of Korea, France, Japan, Taiwan, Switzerland have come to
participate in today's symposium. Ministry of Food and Agriculture, Academy of
Science, University of Science and Technology, State University, Agricultural
University, Food Production and Research organizations, representatives of private
entities and companies, students gathered also in this event.
I would like to note that among participants of symposium we have H.E.
academician B.Chadraa, Member of Parliament and the President of Mongolian
Academy of Science, academician L.Lkhagvaa, Adviser for the President of
Mongolia, academician B.Enkhtuvshin. VicePresident of Academy of Science,
Mr. P.Damdindorj, State Secretary of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture, Prof.
G.Gombo, the President of Monglian Food Industry Association.
Today's gathering of foreign and local scientists, researchers involved
in the fleld of milk and dairy study and skilled engineerstechnologists in one
place to share their experiences and intellectual resources in order to implement
results of research studies into practice is relied on the success of the symposium.
Let me open the symposium . Thank you.
Ulaanbaatar, 20 September 2002
Intemationa[ Scientific sympos.urn
9
GREETINGS MESSAGE FROM H.E. BAGABANDI,
PRESIDENT OF MONLGOLIA
From participants Of the Jnterriational
Scientifilc Symposium on "Nomadic cullural
Tradi[ion: Mongolian dairy prodrc[s"
I would like to congratulate and greet all of you foreign and Mongolian
researches, who have come to participate in the lnternational Scientific Symposium
on "Nomadic cultural tradition: Mongolian dairy products", dedicated to the 840th
anniversary of chinggis Khaan birth and 800'h anniversary of the Mongol empire.
As one Of tl.e basic food groups und ll.e filrst foundation Of human
I.ealth an[l nutrition, milk an(I (lairy products are biologically essent.ial
nutritious items that help people live long, I.appy and lieallhy lives.
Traditionally the ``Mongol" nation created in enormous lnlellectual anal
cultural heriluge Of dairy processing technology resulting in possibly the widest
range Of dairy protlucts in tl.e World loday, wllile developing on an extensive
livestocl[ grazing system. TI.is tradition evolved over tens Of tllousand Of years.
TI.ese ``Mongol" nation traditional methods of processing dairy products
have been upgraded and improved over many centuries until today. Tl.ese express
the best acliievements Of tlle various periods of our h.istory.
You scientists and researchers may agree willl my thinking lliat specioilty
dairy processing tecl.nologies, developed around tl.e World exemplify national
traditions and tlie pride of tl.eir countries.
Scientists and researches sl.ould make signifiicant efforts at studying in
detail these metl.ods and inheritances, using modern scientifiic methods and
disseminating knowledge about these metllods.
I believe tliat you I.ave a good cliance to inform, excl.ange and learn
from eacll otlter at tl.is symposium. Tlie knowledge and experience you sl.are
will take a considerable conlribulion lo developing da.Iry production for liuman
well being and personal taste enjoyment.
I wish success to this scientific symposium on "Nomadic cultural
tradition Mongolian dairy products".
I also the scientific work you share will be beneficial to all.
Ulaanbaatar, 20 September 2002.
io
Nbind;ic cu[tura[ q`radetion: gwlongohan chivy products
WELCOME ADDRESS
By H.E. D.Nasanyargal, Member Of the Governmenl Cabinet,
ll.e Minister Of Food and Agriculture Of Mongolia to the participants of the
lnternaliol'ral Symposium " Nomadic Cultural Traditions
Mongolian National Dairy Producls" , 21 September 2002
It is a great honour to extend a warm welcome to all participants of the
Symposium.
We have satisfied with successful organization of the International
Scientific Symposium "Nomadic Cultural Traditions: Mongolian National Dairy
Products", which has been held in occasion of celebration of the 840th birth of
Chingis Khaan and the 800'h amiversary of establishment of the Great Mongol
Empire.
Respectful scientists and scholars from Sweden, Russian Federation,
Republic of Korea, France, Japan, Taiwan and representatives of international
organizations have come to participate in the symposium along with leading
scientists and specialists of our country. Many interesting research papers and
presentations on tradition and renovation of Mongolian national dairy practices
and technologies by Mongolian scientists and on new directions of biotechnology
and functional food by foreign delegates have been made and discussed during
the symposium. Although, I was unable to attend personally the symposium due
to a busy schedule of my work, I have been informed timely about the process and
result of the symposium.
Judging from the themes of presented papers, the biotechnology oriented
papers account for the greater proportion, from which the development trends of
modem dairy industry can be understood.
In order to renovate the Mongolian dairy technologies into industrial
ones, first of all, traditional practices and technologies can be combined and
richen with the achievements of engineering and biotechnological methods.
Iritemationa[ Scier.tiife¢ Symposium
11
Effective measures on the development of the starter cultures production should
be taken in our country. The significance and value of the today's symposium are
high in line with the further possibilities to solve the above issue. In the same way,
this symposium provides opportunities to share own experiences among scientists
and specialists of the dairy sector, to support each other in professional sphere, to
disseminate the cultural heritage of the Mongolian traditional dairy practices to
other countries through the foreign participants.
The needs to promote the international cooperation between research
institutes, private entities, NGOs in order to introduce advanced technologies
and equipment and to bring up the current industrial level in countryjustly arising
out of the recommendations and outputs of the symposium.
We highly appreciate your efforts to bring near the development of
Mongolian dairy industry to the world level and populating and transferring the
technological achievements.
I believe that our cooperation will be not only limited with the frame of
this symposium, this is the beginning of the further fruitful international cooperation
of scientists in the dairy sector.
The published materials Of the symposium will be disseminated to each
participants.
I wish you all success and best regards.
12
Orormdic cu[tura[ Tradiition: qviongo[ian alairy i]roducts
SPFECH FROM H.E. MR. B.CHADRAA,
Member Of Parliament, President Of
Mongolian Academy Of Science
Distinguished Scholars
Ladies and Gentlemen
Foreign participants who have accepted our invenlation to participate in this
International Symposium.
The international Scientific Symposium on "Nomadic cultural
Traditions:Mongolian Dairy Products" is organized by Mongolian Government,
the Ministry of Food and Agriculture and Mongolian Academy of Sciences in the
frame of thje celebration of the 840th anniversary of Chinggis Khaan and the
800thanniversary of the Mongol State.
The big pond of knowledge on the top of the mountains was simply
beyond their reach and the water of knowledge,which would quench their thirst,
was not available at the bottom of the mountain. Until now, not enough efforts
have been made to provide any solution to the problems.It is quite clear what we
should do now.
It is about time to dig a ditch form the top of the mountain to the bottom,
so that everyone can enjoy the water of knowledge.
We are here to discuss thew aspects of the Mongolian traditional milk and dairy
product technologies and the nomads' technologies, wich have been contributed
to the development of this technology.
I can see from the program that there are many interesting papers will be
presented which will help the goal to be achieved in this field.
As you know that, Mongols from the early XIII century bridged the West
and East and not only played a significance role in the development and exchange
of the knowledge, technology but worked out its own nomadic way of the
technology of the traditional milk and dairy products.
[r.tematiotia[ Scientif ic symposium
13
Mongolia has been great contributed towards the exchange of the new
information in the field of milk and dairy technology by inviting many international ly
renowned scholars and experts to this country.
We are living in the era of Globalization, in the era of the dialogue among
civilizations. Thus, I am certain that this gathering of eminent scholars and experts
from around the world wi 11 make great contributions to the development of sciences,
though fruitful exchange of information and new technology.
At the end lt is my pleasure to inform you that the Government of
Mongolia gives a significance to this international symposium and the President
of Mongolia Natsagiin Bagabandi sent a message.
I am delighted to announce of the opening of the International Symposium
on "Nomadic Cultural Traditions:Mongolian National Dairy Products"
Thank you for your attention.
14
Nomadic cu[tura[ a:raditron: "ongolian dairy I)roducts
TRADITION AND CULTURE OF MILK PROCESSING IN
PASTORAL EXTENSIVE LIVESTOCK SYSTEM
Prof. R.Indra, /Sc.D/
The history, culture and life of
nomads have been always under a deep
interest of scientists, researches of Europe
and America since long time ago. The vast
territories of central Asia are characterized
by its typical harsh continental climate with
lot of winds and storms, extreme cold winter,
hot summer, adverse living conditions which
resulted in all 4 season's around movement
for nomads to choice the better pastures and
even in the big movement and pacing up the
East and West areas of EuroAsia long time
ago. To overcome these natural climatic
obstacles, often movement, trek's difficulties it is naturally important to have an
energy rich qualitative food and meal. Therefore, animal's meat and milk were the
main staple food for nomads in all times.
There were no chance for the development of the crop production in
these widely spreaded areas due to the living characteristic of nomadic livestock
husbandry and harsh climatic conditions of the Central Asia. Cereals like barley,
millet and wheat were grown and planted only by herders not by the crop farmers
in fewer areas of Khangai region of Mongolia.
A milk processing method of traditional dairy products was developed
during the nomadic civilization. This traditional method of processing with less
trouble, whole utilization, storing and usage of milk from livestock had been
evolved for hundred years in nomadic extensive livestock system and transferred
through all generations and brought till nowadays.
Intermationa[ Scieritif ic symposium
15
The wide usage of dairy products by nomadic people in their daily life
was mentioned in historical review about Mongolia and notes made by travelers
who visited country during different periods. An ability of Kidan people to produce
various dairy products from milk of cow, sheep, mare and camel was noted in
history of Lyao State.
The famous traveler Marco Polo mentioned in his book that Mongolsmade
delicious beverage c]i.rczg /fermented mare milk/ through acidifying the mare's
milk, used sAc!r /os /melted butter/ in meal, soldiers took dried powdered milk to
journeys. P.S.Pallas recounted all dairy products used by Khalkh, Buriad, and
Mongol nationalities from western part, including mare's milk, cow's milk, fclrag /
yoghurt/, sfej.in;.j.# or4Aj. /milk alcoholic beverage/ crrz, sAcrrs/drinks from different
stages of the distillation process/, flc}rww/ /dried curd/ as well as fas /melted butter/
Two European monks Plamo Karpini, Wilgelm Rubrukwis who visited
Mongolia during the empire of King Mukkh described the life style and tradition
of Mongols and also recounted all kinds of dairy products used by Mongols with
especial notice on sole usage of cultured dairy products during summer season.
In Secret History of Mongols, Mongols lived in that century used to use
czj.rc7g and other fermented milk. During the XVIII century, in dictionary of Manj
language attached with 5 scripts and issued by edict of Tsyani luyi King the
names o[ airag, tarag, holison tos, khuruud as well as ezgii lcurd evz\porated
with whey/ were indicated.
The names of dairy products like dyas/ag /cheese/, sA¢r /as /melted
butter/, I.Beg /acidified milk/, /c]rag/yoghurt /, Az/rwwd/flavored curd/were included
in MongolianChinese HuaIIYui dictionary issued in 1389. These historical data
indicate that varieties and types of Mongolian dairy products are pristine /not
changed/ till nowadays.
Nevertheles, concrete information about the technological practices of
Mongolian dairy products are not found in these historical documentation.
Travelers and missioners who came to Mongolia impressed by fact that Mongols
could process and utilize milk from various species of livestock, consume in
summer period only dairy products and widely use fermented milk beverages,
especially mare's cri.rag.
Research Institutes, organizations and scientists, involved in Dairy
Research have been working on following directions: study of composition and
quality of milk of livestock reared in Mongolia, technology practices of national
products and elaboration and implementation of new, nontraditional technologies.
Following publications and research works can be mentioned regarding
the basic study made in dairy research:
16
aromadic cu[tuTa[ Tradition: Mongohan alairy products
Tsevel guai initiated the first publication about Mongolian dairy products,
Prof.R.Baldorj studied technology of mare's airag, Prof N.Namsrai studied the
protein composition of mare's milk. Technological aspects of national dairy
products and milk composition of all livestock was studied by Prof.R.Indra,
micro flora of tarag and other fermented milk products by D.Tsoodol, R.Sukhbaatar
and milk composition of cattle breeds reared in country was studied by J. .Sukhdolgor
respectively.
Mr. D.Nyamaa implemented project of processing national dairy products
on industrial base, Ts.Batsukh conducted research on composition and
technological properties of camel milk. Mr.Khokhoo elaborated a technology for
airag fermentation at industrial level, D.Sc L.Damdinsuren /2002/ worked out the
scientific technological basis for development of industrial production of milk
and dairy products in Mongolia. D.Sc B.Ochirkhuyag /2002/ made study on protein
composition of camel and yak milk. Properties of sheep milk was studied by Prof.
C.Tsendsuren and fat composition of yak milk by Mr.Lkhagvajav respectively.
The history of Mongols to adore milk is related with specific purpose to
nourish babies and off springs, the high nutritive property of milk, desire for
health and safety live, to posses the productive livestock. Milk and dairy products
is respected and placed of honour during idolizing of mountains, celebration of
weddings, #crdcrm festivals and besides of that milk is traditionally used in ritual
milk sprinkling of people going to farjoumeys, trips and in handling of feadc]g /silk
scarf/ with milk to respectful guests and awarded persons.
National products are classified into three big groups:
\.
Fatty prochcts.. urum, shar tos, tsagaan tos, airgiin [os
2.
Fermented products: a/.rc!g, 44oormog, w#dcrer, tsegee
3. PTotein prodrcts.. byaslag, aarls, aaruul, khuruud, ezgii
Technology practices of Mongolian dairy products were evolved during
a nomadic animal husbandry system and are considered in possessing several
specificproperties.
I . Technology practices and methods are simple and require less labour.
Daily milk can be processed within same day. Depending of the number of milked
animals there is no need for extra labour to process in average 2030 kg of milk per
day.
2. Very simple ordinary tools and utensils are used in milk processing. At
least pot and pan are the both essential for processing of initial main products.
Big sized or special equipment required necessary skills, tools and equipment
unsuitable for often movement and transportation from place to place and special
Internat.ona[ Scierltif a symposium
17
premises are not used in traditional dairy processing practices. Otherwise, utensils
and tools used at household level every day like pots, pans, pails were taken to
elaborate the technology of national dairy products. The main processes as milk
boiling, formation of cream layer, dyas/agcheese and ezgii making, distillation of
soured milk and /Grog to make sAi.in;.;.# orAfo;. /milk alcoholic beverage/, boiling of
/segee/souredmilk/tomakecrar%zf/andoflr/s/driedandsourcurd/,fatmeltingare
all taken in ordinary pot. Mongolian pot is mainly made from brass or castiron and
has volume of 1013 litres. In modern times the pot made from aluminum also can
be used. Traditional pan is usually made from brass and has volume of 0.5 litre
with round bottom and wooden paddle.
In production of c7f.rc7g and other fermented products fermentation
process is taken in kAo4fe#wr thide sack/ . KfeoAA"#r `s volume is mainly 400
litres and made from 2 hides patched together and hanged with wooden shelving.
A wooden vessel is also used in c7;.rag making as well a wooden paddle in order to
churn and aerate the fermented milk. Varied sized wooden barrels are used for
storing #r#m, /of /cream/. 30x50cm wooden board with fi.ame is used to display
c}orzt%/, ezgj./. /curds/ for drying. Very simple distilling apparatus, consists of still,
cover and dish is used in sfe;.mj.;.# orkA;. processing. As all these tools and utensils
are so ordinary it is no way for more simplifying of technological processes in
traditional practices.
3.Bioproductsarenotobtainedduringthemilkprocessingduetowholly
utilization of all ingredients of milk. Fat, protein and lactose of milk are separated
during consecutive steps of processing and converted into varied products. For
example:Freshmilkisboiledandcreamlayerformedandremoved/fatseparation/
. Remaining milk is fermented to produce /czrc}g, a/.rag /convertion of lactose into
milk acid/ that is further used in alcoholic beverage orkAj.i. /convertion to spirit/.
Remaining fsegee after distillation process is filtered and used to produce crafts,
flc}r#z(/ /curds/. Whey is used in treatment of hides and skins and other purposes.
This is a good example of waste less technology.
4. The assortment of dairy products is varied due to processing of all milk
from5mainspeciesoflivestock.Duetodifferentmilkcompositionofmare,camel,
cow, yak, ewe and goat, the composition of dairy products made are also varied.
If look into every herding family, the tradition to rear the combined herd
not only one specie of livestock has been transferred from long times ago. This
tradition relates with pasture using, riding, wearing, carriage and meeting the
demands for wool, hide , skin, meat and milk.
If required nutrients can not be provided by milk from one species, other
milksourcescancompensate.Inotherwords,asmilkcompositionandtechnological
properties are differ from each other, it seems to be a difference in the technology
18
Nomadic cu[tura[ Tradiit.on: 914ongohan alatry product:_
practices too. Ewe milk is rich with fat and protein and therefore, is suitable in
processing into /4rcrg, ztr#m, dyas/ag. In yak milk size of fat globules is higher
than in other milk, fat content and casein component of protein are high that
allows high yield and therefore suitable for the production of /os and dy`c7s/erg:
protein based products. Mare's milk is rich with lactose and less protein and fat,
therefore is used mainly in fermented beverages. The buffer properties of camel
milk don't allow to use it in making tarag /yoghurt/ and cheese and is good for
tsegee /acidified milk, curd./
Due to changes of milk composition and quality, which relates with
lactation period and season, the types of dairy products are varied by season.
rscJgoclH /as /white fat/, ezgii /curd evaporated with whey/ and tarag can be made
in early spring in period of animal dropping. SAc}r /oJ, wrwm, a¢rww/, dyes/crg are
suitable to be made in the end of lactation period then milk is thickened. Just
before the cold season, in autuirm, the herding households start to store dairy
products like ros, aarts, A#rwwd for winter consumption.
5. Each product obtained during different stages of milk processing can
be used as raw material for next stages or can be used directly.
Nomads in Central Asia, including Mongols made several big movements
and voyages in their history. Besides the permanent seasonal moving to better
pasture in spring, summer and autumn, nomads faced to move suddenly and
unintentional due to extreme situations like epidemic of diseases, fire, drought,
winter extreme cold, war campaigns and etc. Destiny and final of such voyages
were depended from availability of food provision. Nomads, whose main food
stapleweremeatandmilkwerealwayswithsufficientfoodduringdrivingof their
livestock from place to place. The one of features of national dairy products is the
possibility to eat direot|y at all stages of processing. There is no any meaning of
immaturities and raw product in national practices, that allowed nomads to have
provision in all period of movement.
6. The practices of national dairy products are based on ecological
condition of central Asia and specific properties of milk of Mongol herd. Mongolia
has vast territories with different ecological regions and zones. Every region has
own tradition to process dairy products. For example: SAj.w;.i.# orkAj. /alcoholic
milk beverage/ is not used to be processed in some provinces due to lack of
technology practices for fermentation of milk by combined milk acidspirit. In
warn climatic Gobi regions, the making of fcJrczg and wrwm faces the difficulties of
quick souring and therefore milk is acidified into /segee and hereinafter a fat of
milk is removed by churning and remaining part is converted into czar/s and AwrwtfcJ
/flavored curd/.
[nternat+om[ Sctenttfic Sympos.urn
J9
Due to lack of human recourses, herders do not milk camels in Hangai
region and in some places of eastern part sheep is not milked too. However, in the
present market condition, whole utilization of milk from all animal species should
be resolved completely.
7. Central Asian resistant weather is suited for production of national
dairy products. Dairy product such as "rwm can be processed only in a such
climatic condition since urum's skin consisting of proteinlecitin accumulated at
dryer and cooler condition.
Mongols widely use dry protein based products like acJ"w/, Awr""cJ,
ezgi.;.. Dry dairy products are designed to be stored for a long time and usage at all
seasons with high nutritional value and ideally suited for nomads' style of living.
8. Among national traditional dairy products fermented products have
an important place. Yogurt, fermented mare milk, fermented Aoormog from camel
and cow milk are consumed every day and these products can be used as a raw
material for other dairy products as well as they considered as one of method to
convert milk casein into digestible form and for better store of milk.
Mongols used to make fermented products from earliest times and
developed own starter culture for the fermentation process. In Central Asia, it is
considered that domestic livestock was derived from wild animals. We can note
that Mongols developed different strains of milk acid bacteria from wild plants,
fruits and flowers.
Everybody knows, that there are lactic acid bacteria and ferments in the
plant coverage. Even nowadays some households keep the tradition to inoculate
milkwithcrgj.a#dsAczri./jplantsbybeatingandstirringmilkformanytimesinhide
sack for the fermentation of clj.rcJg and tscgee.
However different strains of lactic acid bacteria and yeast have been
developedovermanycountriesandspecializedlaboratoriesareworkingtoisolate,
process and pack these starter cultures and distribute to modem dairy plants.
There is a question how mongolian nomads even without knowledge about
microbiology how they could keep these bacteria till now?
Someone can ask is there any different kinds of starter cultures for each
kind of fermented product: yogurt, mare's fermented milk, camel femented milk,
yogurtfromsheep,cow,yakmilkbecauseofitsowntasteandspecificproperties.
For nomad's style of living it would be impossible to keep these different
milk acid bacteria separately. Generally, Str. Thermophylius or Lbm. Bulgaricus
bacteria are the main bacteria in taragyogurt. For fermented mare's milk
SaccharomycesorTorulopsisdecomposethemilksugarintolacticacidandalcohol.
20
NorrLadic cu[tura[ qraditlon: Ouongo[ian d;airy prodructs
In this way, these microorganisms are coexisted in proper combination
temperature or technological
in traditional starter culture. Just regulating the
regime for each kind of product, the activation of different bacteria in different
stages can be taken. In /c7rcrg making the inoculation temperature is 45°C to activate
thermofilic bacteria and process is taken without air in closed condition. Yeast is
an aerobic culture and can not multiply at high temperature.
In the mare milk fermentation to produce airag the aeration process is
taken place at 2025 °C condition in order to activate yeast. So different strains of
milk acid bacteria have been coexisted and evolved into compact, unified culture,
suitable to the pastoral extensive livestock system.
This technology of hand practices is considered as an specific production
method involving the complex of different physical and biochemical factors as
flotation, homogenization, external forces, milk acidification as well prop ionic
spirit fermentation. However, this traditional hand operated technology, developed
by nomads can be used only for herder selfsufficiency to process few liters of
milk at household level. There were created industrial facilities for milk and dairy
processing during the centralized plarming system. Butter centers were established
in rural areas, milk processing centers in province centers and Dairy plant in
Ulaanbaatar.
About 2700 butter centers produced approximately 5000 tons of butter,
sufficient to cover whole population demand in butter wee operated b'efore 1990
s. 44 mechanized dairy farms were run to supply with milk and dairy products the
population of cities and centrally located areas.
Due to obstacles and difficulties of the transition from planning system
to a market based economy many of these industrial facilities have ceased their
activities, resulted in sharp down of milk and dairy production.
To fill the gap in milk supply, the small milk processing factories have
been established in cities and centrally located places. Mare, camel, goat milk are
widely used for human therapy at sanatoriums and rest houses. 40 milk processing
plants, 22 centers to produce national dairy products, 273 icecream units and
entities have operated throughout the country currently. Most of them are small
scaled enterprises, employing 23 employees and processing I2 tones of milk per
day. MomSuu, GUM, Tsenguun Erdene, Zech, Jonon Suu, SuuVit Co.Ltds and
SUU Shareholding Company are successfully have been operated in Ulaanbaatar
city. However, the biggest SUU company with appropriate facilities and capacity
to process 200 tons of milk per day and 148 employees, only can utilize I 3% of its
capacity.
Nowadays, the population is concentrated at centrally located areas and
capital city. Therefore, the meeting of demands for milk and dairy products has
lrttematlona[ Scientif ic symposium
21
become the big problem. By the estimation of Ministry of Food and Agriculture,
306 thous. tons of milk are required at country level and loo thous. tons of milk for
Ulaanbaatar residents.
The major part of the required milk and dairy products have been covered
now through the importation. The recent statistical data indicates that 6752 tons
of dairy products have been imported in 2001, from which 1246 tons of milk,1193
tons of concentrated milk, 965 tons of milk powder, 271 tons of yogurt, 58 tons of
butter,14 tons of cheese respectively. The import of liquid milk has a tendency of
increasing in recent years and has been increased 66 times by 2001 in compare to
1995 and 26 times to 1999. This figures highlight the serious problem of meeting
the demand through local resources. Few dairy farms and herding households,
located nearby cities and railway stations are supplying the population of
Ulaanbaatar with milk and dairy products.
Historically mongolian nomads used to consume dairy products since
they domesticated livestock and different practices of milk processing were
evaluated. Information about mz./4 asc}ge was programmed in Mongols throw
back. For mongols used to consume dairy products every day and exclude meat
products from their diet in summer season, the current situation on milk shortage,
which have raised only during the certain historical period /transition to a market
economy/ is unacceptable issue. Mongols are suffered from the deep stress if
they have to drink tea without milk.
There are enough milk resources in Mongolia. According the estimation
of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture, there is a possibility to produce 377
thous.tons of milk from different species of livestock. The milk supply to the
population should be solved through the State Policy. Firstly, it is important to
form the high productive herd stock of milk direction and establish several dairy
farms with 40 high productive cows nearby cities with own arable land. The
automatic, electrical milking machines, milk cooling tanks, machines for fodder
preparations should be installed in such farms as well as introduction of artificial
insemination and usage of embryo transfer and other biotechnological methods.
These farms should be supported from the State to assign the right management.
The National Cooperative Association can play a crucial role to improve the
situation.
Milk collecting and cooling centers should be established in local areas.
In order to provide year round milk resources it is necessary to organize facilities
for milk cooling, freezing and drying. Packaging of dairy products to improve the
appearance is also important. External donors assistance to support introduction
of new technology in dairy sector is needed in our country.
22
Nomdic cu[tura[ rltaditton: Mongohan dairy I)roducts
TRANSFEROFMONGOLIANTRADITI0NALMETHODS
OFMILKPROCESSINGTOMODERNDAIRYTECHN01.OGY
G.Gombo, Prof., Doc.Ing
MUST,Ulaanbaatar46,P.O.Box590
Erna.Il:
[email protected]
Mongolian traditional methods of processing
milk has thousands years of history and contains all
achievements of modem sciences in accordance with
milk content and characteristics of pasteurized
anina]s.
Traditional national dairy technology is based on
mainprinciplesofmechanics,physics,chemistryand
biology and defined procedures of milk processing
regimes are determined.
In the report engineering design and
resolutions of conversion of Mongolian national and
traditional methods of making dairy products to modern technology are
investigatedonthesampleoffementationofmare'smilk(airag)andmakingdried
high protein containing foodueezgii. The results of the work are based on many
years of author's research.
Kev words: mechanics, chemistry, physics, biology, technology, methods,
airag, eezgii, tarag /yogurt/, fermented dairy products.
I.
Background
Dairy products are a main source of livelihoods for Mongolian people
where they have developed a pastoral nomadic system as a basis for economy.
Milk is a unique nutritious and easy digestible food which contains different
proteins, fat, minerals, vitamins and a great number of aminoacids.
Intemationa[ Scient.fie Symposium
2j
Consequentlymi[kprocessingisadelicatetechnologythatrequireswide
knowledge and skills and Mongolian people have evolved this technology and
beinginheritedfromgenerationtogenerationtilltodaysincetheancienttime,and
that should be recognised as a traditional culture.
Mongolians have a long tradition to process milk from socalled five
types of animals according their specific characters and composition and make
many kinds of dairy products and drinks, which are regarded as a unique product
in the world. One of the specific features of the milk processing in Mongolia is
every herding household as an independent milk processor. Different groups in
different ecological regions of Mongolia have developed different processing
technologiesforproducingdairyproducts.Reasonsforthatincludemicroclimate,
vegetation, water and natural minerals quality, which have big influence on milk
quality and those become primary conditions to make different products. It is
important to find out that technology suitable to particular ecology. Based on the
experiences and wisdoms of Mongolian people, the traditional milk processing
technology has been evolved for thousands years through careful improvements
and achieved its desired level as "an ideal" technology.
Result of the research shows that the traditional Mongolian milk processing
technology has scientific basis.
2.
Scientific basis of the traditional milk processing methods
According research results, Mongolian traditional milk processing
technology and methods are based on the following principles tha`t are closely
related to modem scientific approaches:
•
Keeping and following "the sterile environment" during the all stages of
•
milk processing. This tradition has been developed and is still in use by
the people as an unwitting law. This tradition can be seen from the
utensils/vessels used during the milk processing including milking,
filtering and waning. The utensils are usually made from copper, silver
and special wood that creates the sterile conditions or environment.
Selection of milk processing methods and technology strictly accordance
withmilkcompositionandspeciflccharactersofdifferentkindofanimals.
For instance, famous drink airag is the one of the example how processing
is defined by chemistry and physics and biology of mare's milk
composition. The unique drink airag only can be made from the mare'
milk. Also good cheese only is made from sheep milk and good butter
from yaks milk are known.
24
Nomadic cu[tura[ Tradition. "oingoftan diairy proofuct5
Milk processing is done by series of methods in strict sequence based
on chemistry and physics and biology. In other words, a result of the
previous stage of processing becomes a precondition of next stage. For
instance, prior to make a cheese by Mongolians milk is warmed at 9095°c
which means firstly, sterile environment ensures secondly, creates
conditions for precipitation when acids are added. Then by wrapping up
curdled milk with special cloth and pressing in between boards prevent
•
biological changes and keep freshness.
Considering seasons, specific microclimate conditions of areas. For
instance, mares are milked 56 times in a day and all milk is kept during the
day in special vessels and as soon as cool evening starts, milk is added
to old airag and stirred more than 5000 times to ferment it. Because day
temperature reduces almost twice in the nights and lactic microorganisms
breeding conditions are created. Especially this creates food environment
for turalactis yeast strain.
During traditional milk processing is based on the followings principles:
•
•
Mechanical and thermo
Chemical andmechanical
•
Biologicalandchemical
Integrated
•
2.I
Mechanical factors and thermo effect principles of the traditional milk
processing methods.
Mechanical factors including filtrating, pressing, moulding, stirring and
ladling up and thermo effects such as boiling, warming, freezing and cooling are
widely used during the traditional milk processing. Results of those mentioned
above usually depend on processors skills and approaches but all are followed by
the same sort of principles.
Lets take an example how mechanical and thermo principles are used in
milkwarmingandmakingaoromisskimmedoff/cream/frommilkbyboiling.As
soon as animals are milked, the milk is warmed that creates sterile environment for
milk. Good orom only can be making from fresh milk. You see here the perpendicular
correlation of the chemical, physical and biological principles. You can not make
good orom out from the spoiled or "suffered" milk. We consider that this
phenomenon has been identified by our researches first time.
lntemationa[ Sc.entrf uc sym|)osium
25
Also we should not forget that all vessel used for milk processing are made fi.om
sterile materials such as silver, copper, bronze, cast iron, hides and woods that are
resistant to heat and mechanical factors.
Firstly, when milk is ladled up and poured down, the milk cools down by
3638 per cent and absorbs air in large quantities. Secondly, then together with
protein the fat globules in milk compounds are light, so when milk is warmed, the
globules float up and foam /suspension/ on the surface of the milk. When the milk
cools down and the foam disappears, good orom is formed as result. It is again
warmed by a low fire in order to raise the cream up.
You can see how to make a new product by physical and thermo effects and also
this method can be converted into production technology.
2.2
Physical and mechanical principles ofthemilk processing
Milk depends on all kinds offactors and changes. Impacts of the physical
and mechanical factors can be seen during mare's milk stirring and churning. One
of the traditional method separating creams from milk is based on the principles of
the mechanics. This method is well known in western Mongolia. Milk is fermented
witliout warming. Then about 65 per cent of the milk fat is removed by fermentation
and mechanical power/stirring. Finally, the skimmed milk is warmed for next stage
of the processing.
As result of stirring, fermentation process is activated by aerating, and
certain changes take place in the composition of the fat and protein and also fat
globules are disposed by high pressure and activate process of microorganisms.
I`his process is similar to make butter.
2.3
Biological principles of the traditional milk processing methods.
Traditional products such as airag, hoormog and yoghurt are produced
by fermentation or based on biological theory. Yeast is used to ferment milk.
2.4 Traditional milk processingcrossroads of the different sciences.
During the milk processing, all principles of the above mentioned sciences
are applied in particular orders determined by processing stages. Through out the
processing stages, the milk is shifted from one state to another under the influences
of different factors and effects. For instance, in order to ferment mare's milk, it is
required thermo and mechanical powers and conditions to breed microorganisms.
26
eviomaoftc cu[tum[ a;radi.i.or.: gilongohan chiry products
3.
Sliifting milk processing methods to production the traditional
technology
Our research findings show that traditional milk processing methods are
ideally developed based on the scientific basics and could be converted into
production technology. We consider that traditional methods can be shifted to
production technology if you can enrich with modem technological and scientific
achievements.
All traditional milk processing methods for dairy products have some
scientiflc basis thus methods should be possible to convert into production
technology. For instance, we stir airag 50007000 times after that fermentation is
activated, then airag is matured.
3.1 Eezgii national special dairy product
Mongolian eezgii is a unique, nutritiously traditional dairy product
produced by special methods and technology and easily digestible and absorbed
by human organisms and has curative features.
When producing eezgii, curdling process takes place. When dregs
descend, the curdled milk is boiled until the whey is absorbed into dregs. According
to our research results, eezgii could be produced using modem dairy processing
equipment. For instance, it is possible to convert milk protein into liquid form and
make different kind of products including pasta.
3.2 Traditional methods and modern biotechno]ogy
In generally, traditional processing by fermentation is based on
biotechnology. All dairy products were fermented only in wooden or skin vessels.
So it is possible to make a conclusion that those vessels serve as catalyst for
activating the lactic acid microorganisms. Dairy products such as airag, yoghurt
produced in wooden or animal skin and hide vessels have a good flavour and
quality. This is may be explained by nature of vessels' materials. Vessels wall
mightcontainsomemicroorganismswhichgiveaspecialflavourtodairyproducts.
Future investigation should be encouraged.
International Scientif ec symposium
27
4. Conclusions:
•
Mongolian traditional milk processing methods and technology has
detailed functions in strict sequences with timing, mechanical factors
•
and thermo regimes. In other words, dairy product processing is regulated
by one model.
Mongolian traditional milk processing methods and technology have
scientific basis and followed by their principles so that allows designing
the engineering model which contains and integrates functions of milk
processing.
•
Deep study of the fermented dairy products will allow to design an
engineering model that would become a basis for making reform in dairy
production technology
Eezgii producing technology should be investigated in details and
based on the research findings start the production of the new dairy products.
28
Nomadic cu[tura[ Tradition: "ongo[ian d;airy prod:uct5
SCIENTIFIC BASIS OF BIOTHCHNOLOGICAL
APPLICATIONS FOR MONGOLIAN
DAIRY PRODUCTION
Prof : L.Damdirisuren /Sc.Dr/, MUST
Some regular biotechnological actions and
operations have been determined by our research
study in the traditional method for preparation of
Mongolian dairy products. Through improvement
of these actions and operations by
using
biotechnological achievements, the scientific basis
for elaboration of technologies of fermented,
protein and fat based dairy products have been
formulated.
The results of these studies have been
described in details in two research works with same
name and disseminated to the public in the form of scientific papers and reports. It
has received five patentscertificates for new products and technologies have
been implemented into practice.
The research work on yogurt production technology has been consisted
fromtwomainparts.Atfirst,milkacidbacteriaStr.ThermophilusandLbm.Bulgaricus
were selected for mother starter culture and secondly, assigned conditions of
continuous cultivation of starter cultures were determined.
Str. Thermophilius M96 and Lbm.Bulgarius M13 0 strains were selected
as mother culture according the scheme used in Russia and Bulgaria as well as in
our country by its morphological, physiological and technological properties and
were tested at laboratory and production level. Method of preparation of
Mongolian yogurt starter culture was registered and received the patent of new
product in 1992 (3).
Internatiora[ Sclentif ic sytrlpo§tum
29
Theoretically, continuous bacterial growth depends upon many factors.
By nature, it is a biotechnologically complex process where the main indicator is
speed of reproduction. At time of highest peak of bacteria reproduction, the main
factor of keeping reproduction process is to ensure a constant level of culture
medium. The reproduction speed of`bacteria is defined by the J.Monod formula
that is shown below:
¢nx..¢rtxo
tis biomixture, Xoincreasing amount, X,.time for growth
In production condition, the nutritive medium level (F) compared with total amount
(V) and will representthe regeneration speed and level ofcultivation
(I/cek).
Consequently bacteria reproduction growth come very close to infinite
level n and in case of continuously going process it can be expressed by formula
D= H max. In other words, the theory of nutritive medium and parameter which
supports bacterial continuous cultivation in factorial conditions will be expressed
by means of milk regeneration speed. Traditional and existing biotechnological
concepts of yogurt fermentation method consists on getting from newly prepared
yogurt portion of starter culture for next fermentation process. Theoretically, it
means to prepare bio culture where Str.Thermophilus bacteria is dominant. This
kind of culture will have good mild flavored taste and is the basis for preparation
of less acidified yogurt. For that purpose, the main reproduction parameters of
Str.Thermophilus bacteria and its behavior in milk medium have been calculated
and speed has been determined (Fig. I ).
5
6
7
8
time
9101112
30
Nomadic cu[tuta[ Tradition: 9riongofiian chivy proofuct5
Fig.I Production parameters for milk cultivation
I
amount of bacteria, 2speed of cultivation, 3general acidity, 4conditions of
acidify development
The required and adjusted level of bacterial cultivation speed and its
correlation with regeneration speed within nutritive medium level has been
determined (according to fig. I ). The general acidify level and applicable nutritive
medium volume (in milk) and speed within medium has been calculated. The
regeneration speed of nutritive medium (milk) has been determined experimentally
and graphically it is presented in Fig.2, where correlation between regeneration
speed and level of acidify is presented.
It is clear, that the speed of regeneration of nutritive medium volume (in
milk) depends from many factors and they are: milk quality, condition for bacteria
growth and many others.
•
30
35
40
0.043
45
acidify, T
Fig.2 Correlation between regeneration speed of breeding ground (milk) and
acidity level of fermentation process.
But tradition of Mongolian yogurt production where milk before hand heated up
within 30 minutes up to 9395°C degree would not affects our research result
significantly, because that is not really affects the industrial production regime.
The new proposed theoretical method of yogurt production and our results of
experiments conducted at our laboratory and within factory regime presents results
of constant production of yogurt starter culture and constant regeneration
processes of starter culture. This work received a new patent and it has been
widely introduced into production on factory level (4). The main characteristics of
Intemationa[ Scientif ic symposium
31
the obtained new product are: Firstly, the quality of the new product is high and it
has active biochemical features; secondly it is prepared under a certain temperature
regime (starting from 4850°C, then till 35°C); third, the final product does not
demand in case of production at small factory special freezing equipment,
fourth at fully mechanized factory it will be possible to make regeneration of
soured milk by pasteurized milk and it will not demand additional equipment. This
technological production basis has a continuous regeneration step going on
process. The current method of starter culture preparation design and solution
for constant regeneration presents ready technology to prepare Mongolian yogurt.
Also, it make possible to prepare yogurt, acidophilus and other fermented dairy
products using current technology.
The theoretical background of airag production under factory regime consisted
from process going on inside mare's milk at microbiological level. The main steps
and theoretical fundamental based on continuously repeated biotechnological
process of acid bacteria cultivation and acidify regeneration process within
fermented mare's milk. The acidity level is constantly increasing.
Fig.3 Continuous regeneration of bacteria and Yogurt fermentation process
Nomadic cu[tura[ Tradition: qvIongohan chirp products
I
2
rawmilkcontainer
line ofheatand cooling up process
3souring container
4
minre
5
indicator
6
potentialpowermeter
7
thermo container, heater
This constant acidity regeneration process within fermenting mare's milk
theoretically based on ability of Str.Lactis bacteria to cultivate and own
characteristics ofmare's milk buffering capacity. Non refreshed fermented mare's
milk will have I.6 tines more acidify level then refieshed by raw milk. This peculiarity
has been used in airag production regime at industrial level. (fig.4).
Duration,hours
Fig.4 Main features of acidification process within mare's milk fermentation
process.
I
Non refreshed milk(test solution)
2
Refreshedmilk
Internationa[ Scientiflc symposium
33
The biotechnological concepts ofmare's milk acidification process is, theoretical ly,
a continuously repeating process and therefore, we can present it in such a way:
Fig. 5Steps of mare's milk fermentation
The main consideration within factory production regime is management of
continuously repeating biotechnological process. Thus can be programmed and
we showed by presented formula:
Where:
FN(V)biotechnological functional process
U , + U2+ .... Un=V Capable limitation of process management
FN., (VUN_,), N , maximum number of step processes on unmanagement level
Fermented camel milk after bottling has to be pasteurized within 10 minutes at
105°C and this can extend storage capacity of product up to two months. Current
technology can be resolved by fementation of current milk within prepared culture.
Also, this can help to improve the acidify level of milk product prepared by different
families. But at any case, the final and appropriate level of acidify of fermented
camel milk should not exceed 120oT.
Technological basis of preparation starter culture for production of fermented
vodka and spirit consist in idea of maximizing process of ethyl spirit development
from milk lactose (sugar). For our experiment we used Sach. Fragil]is active starter
culture selected from collection of the department of Biochemistry and
Microbiology of the Mongolian National University. We developed technology
of. vodka production by separation and fermentation of whey. This process has
been introduced into factory regime. Selected whey with 0.5% of total biomass
has been go through fermentation process within 72 hours on the level of 20+ to
22 °C where lactose has been separated. We found, that from loo liters of whey it
is possible to prepare I.32.2 liter ofethyl spirit. Process of whey fermentation and
preparation of vodl(a in further on has been introduced within 20 small factories.
In general, prepared vodka have amount of spirits up to 18%, efiroaldegid 14.1 mg%
and other fatcomponents include 160mg%, but methyl spirit has been not found.
34
Nomad;ic cu[tura[ qratiitron: anongo[ian datry products
Technological basis of cow milk fermentation process consists on milk fermenting
by selected starter culture and acidification level of the current process. For this
purpose we conducted three types of experiments. The starter culture contained
Str. Lactis, Str. cremorius and Str. Diacetilactis strains has been selected for our
study (Fig. 6). Soured by this starter culture final product has the same taste, smell
and composition as whey prepared by traditional methods. The time for souring
alsohavebeendecreasedbytwotimes.Thenewtechnologyofproductionacidified
milk products has been introduced into factory regime. This has been by
presentation of continuous steps of our conducted research, carried out
experiments at our laboratory and in factory regime. The performed research
determined the optimal temperature of heating, temperature of whey separation
into curd part and production of products with particular fat composition (6). The
main features of this technology is on milk fermenting up to 2025°C degree by
selected starter culture. Then this solution is heated up to 5557 °C where happened
separation of whey. Then obtained whey is processed at temperature of 8587 °C.
The final outcome is products with selected fat composition. The above mentioned
methods of production acidified milk products will lead to production of products
containing 1315mg% of non refundable and 31 33mg% refundable amino acids
and total calorie content within loo gram of the product is 1900kDj.
005000500050
C
275b
250
0
I
F=
Ia
a95
30
115
<
5.
6.
7'
8'
9'
10
11'
12.
v`
16
Duration hours
Fig.6 Results of conducted expel.iments of milk fermenting within different
starter cultures.
White butter, yellow butter
Interl.atrona[ Scientif ic sympcl5ium
35
This butter is prepared as a final product of melting of collected milk fat froth and
froth. Therefore, production of these products has been also under experimental
investigation, performed altogether.
The basis of the technological production of this product will be on determination
of relational processes going on biochemical level within milk fat froth and froth.
We received a new patent for introduction into factory regime this technology of
production white and yellow butter. Our research has been directed towards
development of current technology and on use of special starter culture. For this
we calculated special melting parameters of traditionally prepared milk fat froth
and froth and parameters of separation of milk into sour cream. Our designed
technology consisted from two biotechnological steps, for example milk cream at
first is processed by starter culture composed from Str.Lactis, Str.cremoris,
Str.Diacetilactis bacteria. At this moment fat and protein are will be separated. The
solution then processed by yeast bacteria and fungi, such as Mycoderma,
Torulopsis and Penicillium, at temperature of 2025 °C within 14 days. This will
serve as a start culture and it is the same as for case of collected milk fat froth and
froth. The theoretical background to use starter culture containing yeast and
fungi bacteria is to develop in milk fat free acids, fragrance and taste components.
We determined by our research, that such process can also go on by traditional
ways of preparation of such products. White butter can be prepared by
technological methods, which contains 26 types of acids, where 39% is non
satisfied acids, easy decayed 2%. This all showed the impacts of particular types
of yeast and fungi bacteria. White butter protein contained all types of non
refundable amino acids. By its chemical composition, white butter is very near to
Roquefort type of cheese and its calorie amoiint is 17001800kDj. Yellow butter
produced by technological cycle is contained 96.598% of fat and easy decaying
acids, has a specific taste and smell and its calories amount is 36003700kDj.
Conclusion
1.
Mother culture of yogurt and its bacterial strains have been determined. The
main existing ones are L.Delbriicki sub.sp and Lbm. Bulgarius. This made
clear the various opinions of some scientists. We carried out the experiments
using different milk acid bacterial strains at production level and
Str.Thermophilius M96, Lbm. Bulgarius M 130 have been tested. Starter Culture
2.
prepared from these bacterial strains has been introduced into production
process.
Research on development of technological processes of yogurt preparation
within continuous cultivation process of milk bacteria has been made. The
}6
Nomadic cu[tuta[ Ttadiition: "oingo[iait diairy prod:ucts
speed of milk refreshment by cultivation
speed of Str. Thermophilius,
Lbm. Bulgarius bacteria have been determined experimentally. The correlation
of cultivation speed and amount of acidity in milk solution has been calculated.
The one step process of bacteria cultivation
has been developed and put
into practice.
3.
Research on technological production of fermented
milk products
dairy
products, fatty
and their biotechnological regimes has been tested. The
technological cycle of production of this products by using starter culture
contained taste and smelldeveloping streptococcus has been put into
practice. Technological and biotechnological versions of production of white
and yellow butter by use of Mycoderma, Torulopsis yeast bacteria and
Penicillinium type of fungi have been studied and developed.
4.
The main feature of airag fermentation process and development of
technological cycle is on determination of parameters of continuous processes
within mare's milk acidification. This process has been determined and
programmed and expressed by mathematical formula. This all will serve as a
biotechnological basis for technological production processes. In further, we
will need research on production of airag culture, development of continuous
technological production cycle and conduction of experiments.
5.
The traditional Mongolian way of production of dairy products serves as a
basis for production of popular "Probiotics" and "Prebiotics" products, which
contains protein and fat. Because many types of dairy products can be stored
for long time and because of their medical and prophylactic effects, they can
be put widely into production practice.
Intematlorla[ Scientif ic symposium
37
MONGOLIAN DAIRY PRODUCT
TRADITION , NEW TRENDS
By Dr.Prof. D.Altangerel,
Director Of Research Institute Of Animal
Husbandry (RIAH) and T.Gombosuren, project leader
Summary
The report deals with the Central Asian highland and steppes area wild
animals had been domesticated in the mid stone age, i.e. 157 thousand years ago.
This region is one of the 3 spots of the world where nomadic husbandry
had been developed this way.
Nomadic pasture cattle breeding had been developed in early Hun empire
era and ever since those times the dairy products became the principal main meal
of nomadic cuisine.
The various types of diary products of Mongols, their quality and
features, preparation methods and unique technologies as well as consumption
customs and habits, ancient traditions and first steps of industrial production had
been described.
Background
lt is well known tl.at tlie ancient inhabitants of the vast pasture land of
Central Asia and among them the Mongols were pastoral folks dealing will.
cattle breeding. As recently tl.e scientists unanimously came to one position
Mongolia is one Of the 3 gradles wliere tlle wild animals had been domesticated.
The petroglyphs of the `Mojoogiyn Gol' rock of Saguil som (the basic
administrative unit) of uvs aimag (the principal administrative district) that belong
to the mid stone age , i.e. some 157 thousand years ago, are depicted by figures
of wild rams, wild rock goats, camels, human beings and dogs. One can see there
domesticated cows led by ancient herdsmen and in the same time certain episodes
38
Nordic cwhura[ q:radiiit]on: Mongotien deity pToifucts
as a man with bow and arrows is hunting the wild cows. These evidence is proving
the fact that the folks of those times went through the long process of
domesticating.
On the basis of thorough analysis of the petroglyphic findings such as
the artifacts ofthe `Shar Chuluu' burial on the Northern slope ofKhahgai mountains
therefore the so called `Okunev' petroplyphs on the gorge rock of the Ghuluut
river in Southern Siberia where a herdsmen and flock of cows with a shaft bow
are seen, the archeologists came to a conclusion that the pasture cattle breeding
originates from the beginning of the earlier bronze age i.e. 56 thousand years ago.
/3,4/
At the time og Hun empire where the majority consisted of the Mongol
tribes /from the 3d century B.C. till the ls` century A.D/ pastoral cattle breeding
had acquired its classic features and became the main style of husbandry.
There are historical evidences of those times. For instance, a soldier of
Ham empire that took part in an offensive into the Central Asian Hun territories had
left a note `we have burned the gers (the national round shaped felt shelter)
erected on wagons with all the dried yoguil that were put to the sun on the roof of
gers' . A Chinese citizen Chang Ham Yu who had later applied Hun residence wrote
` the milk and airag (mare's brewed sour milk) are much better than what the
Chinese use to consume./2/
The great variety of dairy products of Mongols, the technology of
processing and preparation , the traditions of their consumption are described in
such Assembly fundamental historical documents as `The Secret Scripts of
Mongols', `The Assembly of Manuscripts ' and `Script of Yuang Empire'. The
medieval merchants , the Western and even Oriental travelers ofxYIIIXX centuries
who visited Mongolia also left numerous descriptions of the specific features of
these main meals of Mongols.
The unique culture of the round the year pasture cattle breeding and
thriving on the `white meal' as we call the delicious creations made of dairy product
came to us, the contemporary successors, from ancient times and probably by
this heritage we, the Mongols , may suppose that we have contributed to human
civilization in our o\m way , either.
The very fact that dairy products were dominating in the cuisine of the
Mongols is connected with relatively long period of their availability, with the
great variety of the end products and perfect ways and technologies of their
conservation . The fluctuation of availability ranging from a certain extent of
shortage to huge excess is directly connected with the species of cattle. For
instance, if the milking period of small cattle, i.e. sheep and coats, or mares is
Internationa[ Sctentific symposium
39
short, the cow has much longer dairy season. As for camel she gives milk round
the year.
The customs and habits of collecting, processing of milk and of producing
the endproducts significantly differs depending on the geographic and climatic
features of each area and comer of the vast territory of Mongolia. Thus, for
instance if the natives of the highland cool regions of Mongolia such as Altai,
Khangai and Khentei mountains and the surrounding valleys are eager to consume
in summer time prevailingly milk products and at cool autumn evenings they
worship yogurt mixed with milk cream or, enjoy fresh curd , the aborigines of
southern steppes prefer the "boz"(milk end products boiled with the cream of
airag) and "khomog" (kefir softened with milk). They love also to sip hot milk and
swallow thick soft lumps of curds.
The Khangai tribes use to collect the thick protein rich milk of sheep and
goats when the cattle delivers calves or the milk when it gets short and becomes
thick again, this time due to arriving of winter pause of milking. They boil the milk,
filtrate it do collect the thick protein rich coagulated custard like substance and
make the so called "tsurum aaruul" that is the well dried to a state of stone hardness
yogurt of small cattle.
The herdsmen of Gobi area use to collect the goat milk into a dried cow's
stomach handing it out so that to let the liquid part to leak away. Then they let it
freeze and consume it small by small throughout the winter soundly cracking it
with their strong teeth that never knows caries exactly due to such nutrition. The
forest tribes prefer to slice the semidried yogurt into thin layers to enable it to
reach that tough hardness thus to keep longer in edible condition whereas the
desert tribes like it to be sliced thick and keep it in a quite creamy state making it of
gray color compared to the snow white yogurt of North. Thus, such habit of
consuming hard type of dairy products is a very specific tradition of training teeth
that at the end of the day the nomads never experienced toothache and died quite
aged still having all the 32 healthy teeth.
The Mongols managed to develop specific technologies of milk processing
that significantly differs from that of other nomadic nations. The Mongols kept
them to principal of perfect adapting to the local conditions of each land comer
and unique vegetation features of a given pasture. They paid special attention to
full utilization of dairy products with no waste what was crucial in nomad conditions,
The list of principal kinds of dairy endproducts would as follows still
embracing only a minor part of the great variety: the thick and fatty milk craem
being extracted after long boiling; boiled plain milk; "khusam", the scratched
down crusted milk at the bottom of the pan after boiling; sour milk cream; the white
and yellow milk fat (butter); brewed kefir of various consistency grades; "tsagaa",
4o
Nomad.c cu[tura[ Itadition: mongohan alairy pl.od:ucts
any boiled thick milk products of various composition; curd; dried curd; conserved
kefir; airag butter; milk liqueur; double distilled milk liqueur; yogiirt; cheese; fresh
or dried (coagulated, boiled and precipitated) milk protein etc.
The milk whey extracted from curd and cheese is also used in husbandry.
It is the best fermenting agent in the hide processing. Thus, the unique feature of
dairy product exploitation tradition of Mongols is the nonwaste absolute utilization
of resources.
The dairy products of Mongols in conditions of virgin untouched and
unpolluted healthy nature and originating from the purest water and absolutely
Virgin pasture land grass components is undoubtedly a perfect ecologically pure
product. The archeologists had found in "Oyu Tolgoi" hill slope of Khaanbogd
sum area a stone scoop for copper melting in a spot of ancient foundry of 5
thousand years B.C./5/ Recently the German scientists had determined that Coli
bacteria remain a live on a black intal alloy surface for 23 days where as on the
surface of copper they die within 32 hours. This fact confirms the empirical skill of
ancient Mongols to keep their dairy products in copper or brass dish which has
the mentioned bacericide property.
The expedition team that conducted explorations in mid l990s under
guidance of the Research Institute of History of the Academy of sciences of
Mongolia had foundin ancient burials of Hun period ,i.e. of 3 thousand years ago,
the remnants of dried products. When the scientistis gave some of those samples
to dogs they ate them with no sign of disgusting thus, proving the excellent
nutrotional properties of dairy products of Mongols of all times.
They very technique of processing and preparation of dairy end products
in Mongolian cuisine style is taking into account all the surrounding environmental
and hygienic conditions. From the point of viem of science they to having had
high academic skill and empirical experience of basing on using each specific
microflora for each specific dairy product processing. As for Mongols they used
for fermentation aand producing of kefir and airag since ancient times 3 basic
cultures of bacteria such as lactic acid Streptoccoccus, lactic acid lactobacteria
and yeast. The very specific techniquee of procedures ever since the hazy ancient
past keeping the one and same culture medium sourse depost. The centuries long
experience of Mongols shows that these representatives of micro flora are
symmbiotic and "cooperate" in a certain way compensating each other to deliver
that unique quality of brewing process. Thus, why not to conclude that our
ancestors managed not only to domensticate the cattle but also some extremely
useful "wild" species of bacteria and fungi.
Irltemattorla[ Scientif ic symposium
41
The method of keeping the sample colonies of bacteria in a sponge like
tissue in a dried form had been proved by history as the mosst reliable tachnique.
There are some references that the conserving the culturre media.
The traditional methods of processing and preparing the dairy end
products in general are designed to meet a family size consumption needs.
Throughout the history the Mongol tribes had minimum of cattle in their husbandry.
There was practically no family without a domesticated animal. As the common
folk use to say at least the "five cows for fine yoghurt" or the "tea milk goat" was
always at hand. The herdsmen used to barter their dairy excess to the Chinese
neighbors and at the times of Manchu occupation had paid their contribution
dues and taxes in dairy products. At the time of theocratic Bogd Khan
administration, i.e. in 19191920 Mongolia exported 100 metric tone ofmi]k cream
fat and even in the first years of communist domination, i.e.19241924 over 60
000 lbs (avoirdupoiso of the same commodity to Russia and China.
With the new trends in economic and social development many new
scientific and technological innovvaaations are spreading in every walk of life.
Parallely with these new attitude and relevant changes technological evolution is
gaining space in the dairy industry and business.
The latest principal reforms in this field especially in the second half of
the 20'h century are due to intensive urbanization and growth of settlements and of
densely concentrated population as well as because of introduction of high tech
technologies and industrial methods.
In 1941 the government had set up 82 butter producing workshops in
Arkhangai, Bulgan, Selenge and Central aimags which meant a new era of industrial
processing of dairy products in Mongolia. As the result of such policy in 1960 275
plants embracing 850 milk farms produced over 5000 metric tons of butter. Early in
1970s first steps had been made to introduce industrial methods in the field of
producing the other types of dairy endproducts. Thus, in Ikh Tamir ofArkhangai
aimag and in Khujirt of uburkhangai aimag had been introduce medium capacity
milk liqueur enterprises equipped with Polish machinery.
With an aim to meet the ever growing market request becoming hot topic
parallel to unprecedented overpopulation in all the major cities of the country
such as Ulaanbaatar, the capital city, therefore in the main industrial conglomerates
as Darkhan, Erdenet as well as generally in Selenge and Central aimags a campaign
to improve the livestock productivity by a task oriented selection and respective
breeding works took place. This large scale program included development of
dairy infrastructure by introduction of industrial farms with all the necessary
innovation such as mechanization of basic routine works. Thus, there farms built
by Russia in frames of intergovernmental assistance had all facilities for stalled
42
oromdimu[tura[ qJraditron enongo[ian ddiry proofu::i
keeping the animal with water tubing and fodder lines, waste cleaning system,
electric milking devices and other hygienic conditions.
In 1958 the first dairy product plant in Ulaanbaatar had been completed
that was to supply the capital city on industrial basis. In 1985 the plant had
beenextended and renovated. The expected capacity is to process up to 200
thousand liters of milk per day or 60 million annually. In mid 1990s the plant had
beenequippedwithhightechcoolingsystemfmancedthroughtheaidprogramof
Japan. In these very years a small capacity milk, yogurt and curd workshop for
infancy had been built in Ulaanbaatar and smaller ones in Darkhan and Erdenet.
Theseworkshopscollectthemilkfromanintermediarycoolingsystemunitswhere
the farms deliver their production. Each such workshop has a for measuring the
specific properties of milk like fat content, density and fermentation and
pasteurization standards.
In l990s 42 fully equipped dairy farms each calculated for 400 cows
provided stalling for 19 thousand milking cows from the livestock of totally 40
thousand cows being in their possession. The average annual milk production per
cow was 2.5 thousand liters of milk. These industrial farms delivered over 30
million liters of milk thus meeting at a time the market request of ulaanbaatar.
With transferring to market oriented economy these farms had been split
intonumeroussmallsizeunitsof1030cowseach.Someofthemhadbeenprivatized,
the others sold. This refom is called setting up of a real farmer system.
As the industrial outcome grew and more sophisticated technology of
international standard had been implemented so increased the need in highly
skilledprofessionalstaff.Thus,aneweraoftrainingofthesespecialiststookstart
in frames of new national education policy.
At the top universities and research institutions of Mongolia a
comprehensive research work is being carried out in the field of studying the
composition of milk of local cattle species and especially of cows. Further on
biochemical investigation is going on concerning the chemical and nutritional
propertiesofindustrialdairyproducts,thenthemicrobiologicsurveyofprincipal
bacteria cultures with an aim to identify the dietary effects of their interaction and
to breed them in industrial quantities,
Recently significant had been achieved concerning new technologies of
productionofcowandmare'smilkpowderforextendedstorageandofproducing
sheep milk's cheese products in accordance with the European recipe and know
how so that day by day new commodities see the hight and are being introduced
into market.
Intemat.ona[ Scientif lc sympo5ium
43
However, there are still many backlashes and consequences of
irresponsibility are causing severe shortcomings I dairy industry of Mongolia.
Due to destruction of numerous facilitated farms and deterioration of cattle breeding
technology the number of livestock is substantially decreasing and per species
outcome is falling
too. Hygienic and elementary sanitary conditions of dairy
technology chain are also seeing the worst days.
The rising market request for dairy products and the striving of the
government to promote this industry seem to make promising the perspectives of
its development.
The medical studies are providing the basic nutritional
norms what
concerns dairy products. Thus, the nationwide request for milk is over 300
thousand metric tons of milk and 23 thousand metric tons of butter annually. As
for Ulaanbaatar. Darkhan and Erdenet where 40 per cent of total population is
living the annual consumption rate ought to be 135 thousand metric tons of milk
and 8 thousand metric tons of butter.
The Government of Mongolia had recently adopted a so called "White
revolution" broad scale program aimed at developing in forthcoming 10 years of
a sophisticated comprehensive dairy production network so that nationwide new
technologies shall be implemented. This program may spark out a real reform of
dairy industry of Mongolia in the 2 ls` century.
Literature:
1.History of the Mongolian People's Republic. Monography. State
Publishing House, UB.1984
2.G.
Suchbaatar "The ancient Mongol tribes". Monography. State
Publishing House.UB.1989
3.D.Tseveendorj "The 8 thousand years history and civilization of
Mongols". Article. "Omen" newspaper, No.53 , 2002
4.D.Zaankhuu, N.Altantsetseg "Lectures on the Mongolian history".
Monography.UD.1999
5.D.Garamjav "Discovery of oyu Tolgoi deposit by the 150th drill well".
Article. "Unuudur" newspaper.No.113 , 2002
6.D.Navaan "Cultural heritage of Huns". Onography. Mongolian State
University Printing House, UB.1999
44
Nomadic cu[tuta[ q=Tad:ition: anongo[ian dairy products
ECOLOGICAL CONDITION AND SOME SCIENTIFIC PRINCIPLES
0F NATIONAL TECHNOLOGY FOR PRODUCTION AND UTILIZATION
0F DARY PRODUCTS FROM GRAZING LIVESTOCK
N.Erdenetsogl, ScD, Professor State Laureate Of Mongolia
Member Of Academy of Agriculture Sciences
Extensive publications of animal husbandry, biology and productivity of
livestock in Mongolia, especially on composition, property and yield of milk, and
on traditional techniques for processing dairy products have been written by
national scientists and researches.
It is wise to mention about some highly qualitative and greater ones
among them. These are as follows:
"Dairy production, composition and property of milk of various kinds of livestock
bred in Mongolia People's Republic" (in Russian by R.Indra,1983); "Mongolian
native pastoral livestock" (in Mongolian by M.Tomorjav, 1989); "Mongolian
nomadic animal husbandry", "Mongolian nomad" (in Mongolian by M.Tomorjav
and N.Erdenetsogt 1999): and "Scientific principles in developing industrialized
technology for Mongolian dairy products" which are monographs and ScD
dissertations.
What specifities are found in native breeds of livestock, breeding and
milkingthem?
Five kinds of small and large livestock, bred by our nomads are raised on
only natural pasture in accordance with the states of four seasons in Mongolia.
Highly productive purebred livestock are kept under stationary or semistationary
condition independent on natural factors. These highly productive livestock
populations have been created as a result of intellectual and practical efforts of
scientists and specialists. When highly productive livestock is began to be evolved,
the activities of breeding and selection were organized and realized toward for
single or combined production such as meat, milk, wool, cashmere etc. Therefore,
these purebred livestock populations are specific with their own greeted
advantages of intended productivity, that native Mongolian breeds.
Intematlona[ Scientlf ic sym|)osium
45
However, our native breeds were developed only for meeting and daily
consumption of`such as meat, milk, wool and skin for nomads, but not for intended
production.
For instance, native Mongolian small livestock (sheep, goat) produce good quality
meat, milk, wool, cashmere and skin. So, breedingselection activities tended to
improve animals along with only lines product yield were not conducted and not
required so much. Above mentioned products are yielded and utilized from native
breeds of large animals (horse, cattle and camel) by the nomads as well as they are
broadly used for riding and other exploitation.
Such specifities of Mongolian livestock are completely absent in highly
industrialized countries. There are not dairy breed among Mongolian breeds of
five kinds of livestock. Comparatively small amount of milk is yielded from lactating
animals of all kinds. Such way of milk yielding and use is peculiar that it is closely
related with four seasons and practice of pastoral Mongolian animal husbandry in
Mongolia. Otherwise, if the yield of milk from native breed animal will be higher,
husbandry practice of those animals must be emphasized. Husbandry practices
differ with four seasons of year. As well animal milking, milk yielding and quality
vary greatly with year's seasons.
Mongolian nomads have developed the serial three closely related
different technologies for milking animals then processing the obtained milk and
then utilizing them. It is at first the processes of milking lactating animals from
offspring delivery to drying period.
In Mongolia, dam animals are bred in summer and autumn and their off
springs are produced in spring. Only camel concef ves during mid winter period
and gives it's off spring in spring of the next year or the camel is pregnant for 13
months duration.
Therefore native breed dam animals after parturition can be used for
milking from spring till first months of winter, sometimes till mid winter. However,
each animal which gives off spring must not be milked. Such animals as younger
ewes or does giving their first off spring and lean dams are not used for milking,
because the growth of their off spring can be arrested. Animals giving their first
offspring, especially, large livestock are trained for milking by all means. At second,
the contribution that, national complex technology has been developed as a result
of processing milk and producing Mongolian dairy products for the centuries,
must be seen to be made by Mongolian nomadic herders.
National complex technology for manufacturing Mongolian dairy
products is adjusted to ecological state under nomadic condition. This national
complex technology is the serial technologies, which is continuously shifted into
46
Nomadic cu[tura[ r[radition: 9vlongo[iaii drairy I)rodructs
subsequent stage beginning from initial milk processing one. As a result, numerous
kinds of dairy products are manufactured in wasteless way. Any artificial or
synthetic agents are not employed for making Mongolian dairy products. Raw
material ofdajry product is the milk of livestock kejot on only natural pasture and
therefore it is rich in biologically active substances and has good quality.
The national technology for manufacturing Mongolian dairy products
consists of three processes which are interconnected each other. These three
processes have deep bases of modern sciences. These processes have been
developed not as a result of laboratory experiments but as a result of multiple
empiric experiments under living condition of nomads for centuries. Essence of
these processes is completely in agreement with modern scientific explanations.
These are as follows:
a.
Microbiological method of obtained fermented food.
Essence of this method is the process of fermentation based on lactic acid bacteria.
Fermentation souce is prepared from the food in which fermentation takes
intensively place and used for activating the fermentation. Besides of fermentation
by lactic acids, ethanol fermentation process takes place. By using this method,
such fermented products as koumiss, youghourt, khoormog, (fermented
youghourt) fermented mare's milk and shimiih arkhi (vodks) are obtainad.
b. Physical methods of obtaining buttery products.
Processing of milk and fermented food with temperature regime and mechanical
procedures is the essence of this method. Milk skin, (orom) cream, stored milk skin
(zookhii), ghee, white butter, etc are produced by processing of milk and fermented
food with physical methods.
c. Chemical methods for producing protein rich food
This method is based on production of various protein rich food processing dairy
and fermented food with temperature regime and souring agents. In this method a
lot kind of protein rich dairy products which differ with their quality are created as
a result of chemical reactions in dairy and fermented food. For example, cheese,
boiled colostrums, cottage cheese, curdle, wet curd, dried curds, milk scale (husam),
etc. can be named.
Iittemationa[ Scientif c `Sym|)osium
47
There is a traditional way of obtaining each food product which is included
in above mentioned 3 dairy products such as fermented, buttery and protein rich
ones. Each was has its own specific procedures.
At third, there is way of utilizing the processed dairy products and milk.
Traditionally, Mongolian nomads use milk and dairy products all year round. But,
milk and dairy products are used above during summer and autumn seasons.
Because, Mongolians begin to milk their animals process dairy products since
spring season when livestock produce off spring, the utilization of milk and it's
processing are also of seasonal character. Mongolians use the milk in native fom
or with tea. During the off spring delivery, protein rich products are made by
boiling colostrums and curd, etc. It is peculiar that such dairy products are widely
used for food and diet of elderly people and infants during severe seasonspring.
As well there is a tradition that the youghourt made of milk of small or large
livestock in intensively used for nutrition of elderly people and babies in spring
and winter.
Milk yield of grazing livestock increases during summer and autumn
season and good ecological condition suited for processing various dairy products
js provided. In this period every household utilizes their own livestock for milking
within their capacity and tries to process as much dairy products as possible. To
this extent, Mongolian uses more milking dairy products and limited amounts of
meat for their food in summer and autumn.
In such warm seasons, except of supplying themselves with milk and
dairy products, herders also reserve the products for their own use in winter and
spring, for use of their relatives living in urban areas. Because milk yield of animals
is lowest during winter and spring, the dairy products to be consumed in such
period is traditionally prepared in summer and autumn.
Fermented mare's milk is widely used during national holidaynaadam
(since 10 July) and further through autumn season for various celebrations;
wedding, banquets etc. In early winter period, fermented mare's milk is frozen for
storage and used broadly during tsagaan sar celebration in spring after thawing.
Mongolian nomads have tradition to use broadly milk and dairy products
for curing various human diseases, dietary nutrition and improving human body
vigor, except of using for food. For instance, fermented mare's milk, camel's
fermented youghourt ghee and milk of white mare and goat are believed to cure a
lot of human ailments in practice of folk human medicine.
The tradition of Mongolian nomads in using milk and dairy products has 3 basic
features.
First, they furnish human body with nutrients.
48
Nomadiic cu[tura[ qtadiition: Onongo[ian d;airy products
Second, they restore and improve the vigor of tired and weakened human
body.
Third, they prevent and cure various diseases.
What ecological specificity's are there in progressing and using milk and
dairy products?
Milking of animals and collection of milk is closely associated with
seasons ofa year and it is a major ecological variant. The natural environment and
territorial ecological condition are existing beyond the seasonal states. Especially,
Mongolian nomads assume that milking animals is closely related with animal
husbandry practice in accordance with seasonal and climatic conditions. In spring
and winter the milk is yielded in accordance with normal physiological states of
bath mother animals and their off springs. But milk is yielded as complete as
possible without adverse influence on gaining bodyweight of both mother and off
spring during summer and autumn. The reason is that `milk production in lactated
animal udder is intensified in summer and autumn. According to this regulatory,
herders try collect more milk within short period during warms seasons.
On the other hand, there is regularity that gaining of animal body weight
and its stability is also intensive in such warm seasons. Herders have tradition to
organize milking not exerting adverse influence in this process.
As well the technology for processing milk and manufacturing dairy
products is also adapted to regional ecological condition. However, this adaptation
is specifically provided through ecological condition of Mongolian ger. For
instance, there is a specificity that combination of natural seasonal air temperature
and temperature inside the ger provides the regime of making dairy products.
Except of both temperature regimes, an artificial temperature regime by fire is used
and the temperature is regulated by reducing fire intensity to ember. To make good
quality milk skin (orom)the boiled milk is put on shelf at the highest point of the
ger's wall, where is the warmest place inside ger.
Dried orom and stored orom can be preserved in rumen or alone in coolest
place inside the ger near to the floor points.
The technology for preparing and processing any kind of Mongolian
dairy products by the nomads employs greatly the regimes of natural, Mongolian
ger's and artificial temperatures. Thus, using warn and cool temperature regimes
intensifies or reduces and terminates the microbiological and chemical processes
in milking dairy products. For example, the temperature regime is strictly complied
with during fementation ofmare's milk and making youghourt. Dairy products are
dried under slightly windy condition outside and stored in cool place. If it is seen
as necessary, milk and fermented mare's milk is directly frozen for storage. It's a
I:::i:::i:1_ona[ Sc.eritifro sympo5ium
49
whole these are the processes building up the technology for production of milk
and dairy foods, and ecological and hygienic conditions for preservation.
Mongolian herders use the milk for food in any seasons of the year. It is
an evidence of that the milk is produced, preserved and used in accordance with
ecological condition of four seasons of a year.
Ewes became dried too early, whereas goatdoes and mares are milked to
late autumn. Fewer cows and shecamels are traditionally utilized for milking till
mid winter period. It is a tradition associated with meeting the food demand of
elderly people and babies. These activities are the processes of detailed learning
of natural, climatic, seasonal ecological condition and elderly people, by nomads.
Conclusion
I. Mongolian nomads have developed the national three interconnected
complex technologies for processing of milk and dairy products. These are as
follows:
First, the technologies for milking only pastoral livestock.
Second, the complex technology for processing milk and dairy products.
Third, the technology for using Mongolian dairy products.
2. The complex technology for processing Mongolian dairy products
consists of interrelated three methods. These are as follows:
a.
b.
c.
microbiological method for processing ferinented food.
Physical method for processing buttery food.
Chemical method for processing protein rich food.
3. The national technology for milking pastoral livestock, production
and utilization of Mongolian dairy food is specially well adapted to the condition
of environment, Mongolian ger and nomadic ecology.
50
Nomadiic cu[tuta[ q'Tadiition: "ongotral. dray products
DEVELOPMENT 0F NOVEL FUNCTIONS
OF LACTIC ACID BACTERIA
Fusao Tomita
Laboratory Of Applied Microbiology Graduate School Of
Agriculture Hokkaido University Sapporo, Japan
Lactic Acid Bacteria have been
studied for a long time as targets of
scientific and practical points, but much
has remained to be resolved through new
insights from biochemical and molecular
aspects. There are various immediate
problems to be solved such as resistance
or tolerance bacteriophages, acid
tolerance or acid sensitivity, reduction
mechanisms of cholesterol and so on. In
this presentation, two examples of such
approaches being conducted in our
laboratory.
Ceneration of acid sensitive mutants
and its mechanism of acid sensitivity.
Lactic acid bacteria have intrinsic characteristics of producing lactic acid bacteria.
However, the excessive production of lactic acid will kill their producer or will
cause deterioration of products due to low pH. Thus it will be desirable to have
mutants sensitive to low pH so that bacteria will stop or slow down the rate of
lactic acid production, then it may be possible to prevent excessive production of
lactic acid and result in the prolongation of shelf life of products.
Thus we have focused on the role of H+ ATpase in lactic acid bacteria. We
attempted obtain mutants having lower levels of H+ ATpase to uncover the
mechanism of those mutants sensitive to low pH. Namely, H+ ATpase will act as
the producer of ATP providing the energy of cells. However, it will also act as
1 I.ternationa[ Scieutlf ic sym|)osium
51
pumping out of proton to keep intracellular pH at neutral in order to maintain
normal metabolic functions. Therefore, it would be expected that low H+
ATpasemutants would also have lower a lower capability of pumping proton out
of cells and affect productivity of lactic acid.
We have successfully obtained would low H+ ATpasemutants among neomycin
resistant mutants. Among mutants, one mutants, the strain No.1061 56 was selected
for the further studies. The strain possessed about 30% of the parental strain. It
grew and produced lactic acid well as the parental strain inder neutral pH conditions,
while the mutant strain grew slower under pH lower than 4.0 and its production
rate of lactic acid was also lowered. According to pH measurement of intracellular
environment, the mutant could not maintain its internal pH neutral at lower pH
conditions and thus resulted in reduction of its growth and the production of
lactic acid. It was also found that the mutant has two point mutations in its H+
ATpase gene. The mechanisms that causes its physiological changes in the mutant
was estimated to be as shown in Fig. I .
Uptake of cholic acid by Lactic acid bacteria and its potential uses as
probiotics.
It has been known that cholic acid in our digestive juice acts as an emulsifing
agents for fats in our digestive systein and plays important roles foe digesting fats
in our digest track. In our body, cholic acid is produced as conjugated bile acids
from serum cholesterol in liver and excreted into our small intestine and then
reabsorbed there to return liver again to complete recycling system. In this recycling
system, parts of conjugated bile acid are converted to free bile acids, such as
cholic acid, chenodeoxycholic acid and so on. These free bile acids have very
strong hydrophobicity, and thus exhibit very strong inhibitory effects to intestinal
microbiota. The secondary bile acids are known to be promotes of carcinogenesis
and it is very important for probiotics to prevent the formation of these acids for
preventing colon cancers.
It has been said that lactic acid bacteria may lower cholesterol, but no
scientific basis for this hypothesis has been proved. Furthermore, no studies
have been done in involvement of lactic acid bacteria to the above stated bile
acids metabolisms. Thus we have initiated studies of bile acids resistance of lactic
acid bacteria and their transport mechanisms of cholic acid through membranes.
We found that cholic acid was taken up by lactic acid bacteria by energy dependent
manner and there were big variations in capability of accumulating cholic acid in
their cells among species and even strains.
Lactic acid bacteria produce lactic acid, acetic acid and other organic acids through
sugar metabolisms by which ATP (energy source) can be produced to be used as
an energy source and also for biosynthesis of other cellular components.
52
tNomadic cu[tura[ q'radition: t:ivtongo[ian d:airy I)rodiuct5
Moreover, ATP can be hydrolysed by H+ ATpase, which pumps out proton to
outer environmente thus keeping intracellular pHat neutral or weakly alkaline. These
mechanisms bring about the accumulation of bile aid inside their cells. Cholic acid
is a weak acid (pKa=6.4) and larger parts ofcholjc acid present as an undissociated
form and passes through the cellular membrane due to its hydrophobic
characteristics. While once incorporated, cholic acid is dissociated in the alkaline
intracellular environment to become a strong hydrophilic acid, and thus it remains
inside the cell. Through these mechanisms, bile acid can be accumulated in cells of
lactic acid bacteria. The energy required for these accumulation can be obtained
from such oligosacharides as raffinose, oligofructose and so on that are approved
as prebiotics having bifidofactor. Lactic acid bacteria play important role to exclude
bile acid with faecis and thus bile acid will be synthesized from serum cholesterol
in the liver and result in reduction of serum cholesterol. Furthermore, lactic acid
bacteria do not form secondary bile acids and it is highly probable that lactic acid
bacteria will prevent carcinogenesis in colon and circulatory disorder due to hifll
serum cholesterol.
Intemationa[ 5cieiitlf ic sym|)osium
53
STUDY OF THERAPEUTIC SIGNIFICANCE 0F
BIOLOGICALLY LACTIC ACID BACTERIA
(YOUGHURT LEAVEN)
(Sc D)SH .Demberel, (Ph D)J`Dugersuren
Laboratory of yclung animal physiology and pall.ology,
lns[ilule Of veterinary Medicine ,Zaisan,Ulaanbaatar 210153 MONGOLIA
i;el:
976Il34183J
. 976J]341553
Enrail:
[email protected]
Abstarct
Liguid milk yoghoull was fermented by using local strains of lactic acid
bacteria (Lactobacterium Acidophilus LBO 50, Lactobacterium Plantarum LBO 78)
which were isolated from rumen and stomach of native mongolian lamb and calf
and selected with numerous biologically useful proporties such as antogonistic
effect on E. coli and Salmonell rods, the pathogens of widely occurred digestive
disorders under condition of our country,capability of lysating carbohydrates,
which are sourse of nutrition without production of gas, and ability to reproduce
in digestive tract and the biological preparation for veterinary use and human
food supplement product such as concentrated pastSTO and dried powder
Lactobacterin STH which are applicable in both medicine and diet. The product
contains 80 to 90 % dry matters, including 50 to 60 % proteins consisting of
various aminoacids of 17 types and 10 8 CFU / g. It has been investigated that this
biologically clean product probiotic is capable of increasing both lactic and
total acidity of stomach contents during disorders with
symptoms of
diarrhea,resuming the multiplication of lactic acid bacteria and recovering digestive
organs impairments by way of curing disbacteriosis. As well above mentioned
products have been seen highly effective in treatment of infants ailments especially
diarrhea and provided and proved the feasibility of using this product as food
supplement.
Keywords: Lactic acid bacteria, cud, lamb, probiotic, antogonistic action,
food supplement, Lactobacterium Acidophilus LBO 50, Lactobacterium Plantarum
LBO 78, carbohydrate lysating activity
54
Nomachc cu[tura[ rrrad:itron: tMongo[ian tairy products
Introduction
Traditionally, Mongolians process animals milk by using 3 basic
techniques such as boiling, curdling and fermentation (J.Sukhdolgor,1990) and it
is revealed that the youghourt, fermented cow's and camel milk, coumiss, etc, that
are seen as fermented drinks are of greater therapeatic and prophylactuc
significances
(Semenishev,A.U,
1971,
Ivashura,A.I,1976,
D.Gombosuren,1988,R.India,1983,Sh.Demberel,1996,2001;J.Dugersuren,1999,
2001).
In our country, youghourt is traditionally used for curing C vitamin
deficiency, various poisonings, and various digestive organs and dermal diseases
as well as the lactic acids, vitamins and antibiotic like substances, produced by its
leaven lactic acid bacteria are seen to be capable of ceasing decay in digestive
tract,preventinganimalbodyfrompoisoning,stoppingthereproductionofcasual
agents of some diseases such as dysentery, typhoid, salmonellosis, tuberculosis
and brucellosis and of causing urine excretion as reported by in numerous sources.
Of them the traditional method of Mongolians that is used for human and veterinary
medicine with therapeutic and dietary purposes, and preservation of the leaven of
youghourt. Is one of the most interesting solutions and its faither development,
supported by modem theoretical thinking and progressive technology, has great
importance.
To solve this problem, the necessity of higher attention to feasibility
of technology for processing milk in summer and autumn seasons in order to
convert into the product which is capable of with standing longterm storage with
minimalqunlitativechange(L.Damdinsuren,2000).Itisclearthattomakefermented
food, especially therapeutic dietary youghourt, the biological property of its
leaven lactic acid bacteria plays pivotal role and as described by prof. R.Indra (
2000), there are enomous possibilities of obtaining any of desired fermented
foods by both activating some microorganisms and inactivating some microbs in
accordance with definite regimen of technology. In the last years, the
pharmacenticals of chemical origin are avoided as much as possible in human and
veterinary medicine, especially in controlling digestive processes and tendency
of broader using the preparations of bacteria of various biological importances
and high activity has been overweening.
The products containing these useful live bacteria biologicals are
referred to as probiotics and the demand or using them as therapeutic, prophylactic
and dietary means has been growing. The probiotics of lactic acid bacteria origin
are seen as major ones. Taking into consideration such trend and tradition of
Mongolians, for the centurias the present study, undertaken by us , aimed to
Intematlol.a[ Scientlf ic symposiuin
55
discover the local strain of highly active lactic acid bacteria from the digestive
tract of mammal, to make youghourt by using the bacteria, followed by development
of new product relying on addition of subsequent technological solution, and to
open the opportunity of delivering the product foi. curing diseases of neonate
animals first of all and fai.thermore for conti.olliiig matei.ial and neonatal diseases
as well as for human consumption as food additives.
Material and methods
The three serial investigations were performed in order to accomplish
propounded aims. As initial step of our study the samples were taken from rumen
and stomach intakes and exretions of lamb and calf and rectum of wolfcub, young
fox and newborn human baby, which can represent mammalians, and then samples
were diluted in Deitch mineral solution till 108 followwed by transferring through
both solid Rogoza and liquid media to obtain primary cultures of lactic acid bacteria,
the local strains Lactobacterium Acidophilus LBO 50 and Lactobacterium Plantarum
L8078, with higher activity in terms of their capacity of cultivation, staining,
curdling liquid milk, exerting antogonistic
influence on enteric pathogens,
morphological characteristics and biochemical and biological activities were
selected (Patent of Mongolia I 1583,1584) and utilized for further study.
In second trial, youghourt of liquid milk fermented by Lactobacterium
Plantarum L8078 was filtered and then powdered to get Lactobacterun STH (patent
I 952). The efficacy of preparation was investigated in 9 lambs with fistula on
stomach, divided into 3 groups. Lambs of first group were suckling their mothers
twice a day in both morning and evening, and kept in a fence with green hay. In the
second group, lambs received STH, soaked in 50 ml distilled water twice a day
before suckling their mother in moming and evening in doses of200 mln microbes.
The samples were taken at 7 day of experimentation. Samples were collected through
fistula mounted on stomach of lambs of all three groups at 30, 90 and 180 minutes
before and after suckling and total acidify and free hydrochloric acid were measured
by titration, pH was measured by Bekman34 pHmeter with glasscolomel electrod
and lactic acids were determined by using Velosy Dy photometry method.
Results and discussion
The selected Lactic acid bacteria were grown in liquid culture medium
preparedbypreseriptionofRogosawithslightprecipitationanditproducesevenly
brimmed colonies which is dark in the centre and bright in thr periphery. The
microbe is grampositive, immobile and alone or uncoiled chauns in 3 to 4 mm
56
Nomadic cu[Lura[ Tradition: enongo[ian alauy prualucts
length. The strain is capable of stopplng the growth ofo Ill, 041, 026, 078 strains
of. E.Coli and OT77 strain of Sal.typhi, and can grow ill the medium added food
salt and phemolic solutions. Incolulation of 23 loop culture of the rods into fat
free inilk medium in a tube forms compact curdle with little macula lutea.
According to our study the production of acids by the strain is at
Ilo to 120° Temer and their growth is good at 39 to 45 Terner, as well as the sti.ain
breaks down 13 carbohydrates such as arabinose, mannite, maltose, cellobiose,
lactose and mannose, without production of gase. Comparison of above
characteristics with that of standard strain, the selected culture was similiar to
L.Plantarum. Studies (Bannikova,L.A.et al I 987, Ivashura,I.A,1976) demonstrated
lactic acid bacteria are gramposituve, produces no spore, immobile, impossible of
causing catalysis and require no any special additives for its growth. As well Berg
( 1980) divided the lactic acid bacteria into to families such as Streptococcace and
Lactobaci llaceae and the genera of Lactobacteria, Streptobacteria and Betabacteria
in Lactobacillaceae family is of industrial signficance and Lactobacterium Plantai.urn
belongs to Streptobacterins. It is capable of growing in the medium added saline
up to 6% producing acidity till 180°Terner.
Above mentioned information are in agreement with our studies on
L. Plantarum the local strain of lactic acid of obtained by us and it suggests that
they function physiologically beneficial during their multiplication un animal
digestive tract, exert influence of ceasing reproduction of enteric pathogenic
bacteria, as well as they can be utilized as the leaven or fermentation source for
making youghourt. Relying on this outcome of the study a preparation
"Lactobacterun STH" containing 108 CFU/g has been created by filtration and
dessucation of formed youghourt by cultivating above local strain in the liquid
milk which is obtained during separation of cream from whole milk, and the
perparation contains 80 to 90% dry matters, including 5060% of proteins,
comprising 17 kinds amino acids, such as methionine, Iysin ,etc.
Product composution shows its nuitritive value is pretty suitable for
feeding of younger animal, especially for dietary nutrition. Therapeutic erricacy of
the preparation in more than 80 calves and lambs with dietary diarrhea achieved 80
to 90%. Further results of the study demonstrate pH of stomach contents of lamb
ranged to alka]ic side for 90 minutes after suckling under normal condition, followed
by repeated drop after 180 minutes, while its amount increases at first 30 minute of
using STH preparation, but the tendency of reduction is seen for the next samples
(figure I). In other words the dilution of hydrogen ion concentration in stomach
content to suckled milk during the use of STH was lower than normal condition.
As well, use of STH in loo mln microbe dose, soaked in 50 ml distilled water at 30
minute before suckling in the morning decreased the decline of acidity of stomach
Intil.nationa[ Scientif ¢ Symposium
57
content ( total acidity and lactic acid) for the period after suckling and there is a
tendency of easier resuming (figure 2). Because the acidify of stomach content in
mammalian neonates is easily restored, the application of Lactobacterin STH during
the ailments with singns of diarrhea is found to provide an optimal condition for
correction
of digestive organs
functional
impairmeiits and termination
of
redroducing various bacteria. The condition and circuinstances of growing youiig
animals in our country and wider use of feeding bottle for young animals cause
the drop ofacidity of neonate animals stomach for the definite period and especially
the stomach content become neutral and alkalic during digestive organs disorder
and therefore the ground for domination of the rotting and other pathogenic
bacteria is formed (D.Tserendorj.1972, S.Ba]dan.1980, SH. Demberel,1979,1995).
As a result the reproduction of enteric pathogenic bacteria is activated and
functional failure of lactic acid bacteria is takes place, as wel I as the pathogenesis
of the disease become exacerbated and it provides the condition of causing
colibacteriosis, salmonellosis and other infections diseases. Because the use of
STH preparation keeps the acidify of laiiib stomach eliminate the tendency of
shifting into slight acidity and nauti.ality by dilution errect of suckled milk for a
very short period, and enhances significantly the concentrations of lactic acid
and total acuduty, there is basis that it plays major role in terminating favorable
condition for progressing pathological processes. Based on the common
outcomes, theoretic background and literature data obtained by the studies, the
product was administered in 28 children with disbacteriosis of chronic and acute
diarrhea in the gastroenterology division of the Centre of Maternal and neonatal
Research and it has high therapeutic effect (Lkhamsuren, Erdenechimeg,1999). As
well relying on the products composition and experimental results ,the relevant
authorties approved its administration for human consumption in the liquid and
powder forms in accordance with the corresfonding standards (MNS 48771199,
48772, 200) and for food supplement.
Conclusion
1. Lactobacterium Plantarum L8078 the local strain, selected from cultures of
lactic acid bacteria isolated from digestive tract of mammalian neonates has
numerous useful physiological and biochemical properties, as well as it exerts
adverse influence on Escherich ia, Salmonella bacteria which are broadly distributed
enteric pathogens under ecological condition of our country and can be utilized
as a leaven for making youghourt from liquid milk.
58
Nomadic cu[tul'a[ qJrad;ition: "ongo[ian d:airy proaluct5
Size of steril e zone inhibiting the gro`wh
ofpal`ogenicstrans
a f strains
E. coh
E coil
Ecoh
0111
041
026
LB01
I
18,015,012,0
15,0
23
LBO2LBO3
45
LBO5LBO9
6
LBO I 0
78
LBC) 34LBO35
12,0
17,0
S typ,
munum0045
I coll
13.0
L4,0
18,0
12,017,0
12,0
S typ,M
urlumT7
17.0
9,0
16,0
19,020,5
21,017.0
14.0
910
LEO 36LBO38
11
LBO 4 I
13,0
12
LBO 4 3
14.0
14.0
18,0
13
L8049
14,0
20.0
18,0
21,0
24,a
LEO 50
LBO 78
16,0
13,0
15,0
25,0
22.0
13.0
25,0
30,0
28,0
LBO 87
14.014,7±0,912,0
14,0
12,0
19,0
'4
1516
M±m
12,0
14,8±
I.5
17,5±
19,014,0
1.7
18,4±
25,0
25,0
13,0
2,35
16, 5± 9,5
22,3±
1.32
Table
Result of study on adverse influence of lactic acid bacteria
on growth of local strains of enteric pathogenic rods
2. The strain Lactobacterium Plantarum LBO 78 is applicable as a fermentation
source for making youghourt from liquid milk, the byproduct obtained during
manufacturing of cream butter.
3 . Lactobacterin STH, a preparation made from liquid milk youghourt fermented
by this strain is effective in veterinary medical practice especially, it has 88 to 90%
therapeutic efficacy to cure ailments with sign of diarrhea, resumes rapidly the
acidity of stomach and corrects the impairments of digestion.
4. The use of Lactobacterin STH in liquid and powdered forms during neonatal
ailments with symptoms of diarrhea, as dietary food and food additives is
important.
Cited literature
I.EaTlj|aH C.1980: TOT"rill HHjlx ve, aMbzlpax qaj|Bap. yB
2.BaHHHKOBa JI.A Hap [987: MHKpo6HOJTorHtiecKHe ocHOBbl MojloqHoro
IIpoH3Boj|cTBa. M.ArponpoM
I nteTirationa[ Scientific syinposlum
59
3.Bepr 1980: KpaTK14ii olipeneJ"Tejll, 6aKTepllii
4 roM6Ocyp3H j|. ig88: cyy IIII{MT xoojl. yE
5. J]aMz|14Hcyp3H,JI 2ooo: MOHrojll,IH Max cyy"ri Heel|, IIIIIHx qaHapl,iH
oHi]jlor, 6ojloBcpyyjlax "rj]3im MOHrojl yTlcblH xyHCH14fi ax yiiur83p xyHc
cyHJlaJlblH xor%14jl 70 %iiJ]. TOBXHMOJI 106117 x
6.Hyr3pcyp3H X. 1999: MOHroJI xypraHbl T3x33J] 6ojloBcpyyjlax 3aMaac
raprax aBcaH cyyHxyqT"riH 6altTeplriH 6HojlorHfiH mHHx tlaHapl,Ir cy;|ajlcaH
HyH. BHOJlorHiiH yxaaHI.I AOKTopblH H14ccepTal|H, VE
7.H3M63p3JI Ill.1976: Tenl{iiH r3j|3c"ii ;|Hc6aKTepllo3blH Tyxaii. IIIHHx]13x
yxaaH, aMbj|paJI c3TryyJ].I. 25x
8.H3M63p3]I Ill. 1996: XypraHbl T3x33jl 6oJloBcpyyllaJIT, ocejlTHiir
Hj]3BXxvyJlx, 3Mr`3rT3ii T3Mi|3x Hb. Marl 3MH3J]rl4iiH 11114Hxjl3x yxaaHbl
z|ol(TopblH J|14ccepTauH. yl5
9.H3M63p3TI Ill. 2ooo: 3Mqrmr33 c3p"rijl3TI"#H 63]Ij|M3T"iiH 3MH3jl 3yfi,
a)H3HOJlo"iiH 14H3Bxl4iir cyj]aJlx, yHanr33 erex. 3/in"ii ax7II,IH
TafijlaH.
rap 6HqM3jl yE
lo.HBalllypa A.H 1976: Moj]ol(o H xl{3Hb. M KOJloc
I I.HHj|pa P.1983: Cyv, cyyH 6yT33rq3xyyH
yB
12.14unpa P. 2000: MOHrojl I|araaH j|33 6ojloBcpyyflax aprblH eBepMel| qaHap
MOHroJI yJlcblH xvHCHHii ax yfiJlj|83p xyHc cyj]JlaJlblH xerxllJI 70 xllJI,
TOBXHMOJI. 98X
13.JlxaMcyp3H, 3pr|3H3tmM3r 1999: JlaKTo6aKTepHiiH TaparHbl xaTaaMa]I
3M33p xyyxHIIiiH xoj]oo;I r3H3cHHji 3Mr3rHfir 3MtlHjlc3H ;]yH. rap 6HqM3]I
14.CeMeHIIueB A.H 1972 : KHc]IOMOTloqHble IIpo[|yKTbl IIPH Bblpall|IIBaHHH
MOTloj|HjlKa. M. KOTloc
15.Cyxj]oJII`op X IIap 1990: I|383p ecreBPHiiH xepellroep 6ypc3H TaparHbl
6IIOxHMIIM14Kp06Hojlo"riH IIIHIIx qaHap, yyprHiiH aMIIH xyqJ"iiH
cyj|ajlraaHaac.MyHCHiiH 3pj]3M milHxrmr33H14ii 6HqHr. 3.1929x
16.I|3p3Hj]opx.1974: Xejlyj]otlHoKHmeqHble 3a6oJleBaHHfl H 3j"MeHTapHafl
HHCTpodyl4fl jlrHjlT 8 xp3flizcTBax MHP. ABTopedy. Aol{T. j|Hcc. MocKBa
17.Dugersuren. J. 2001 : Biological activity of some strains of LAB obtained
in Mongolia. Book of Abstracts First Asian Conference on LAB Industrial
Application and New Technolody. 115 p.
18.Demberel Sh. 2001: The study on efficacy of dieticotherapeuntical
preparation Lactobacterin STH of LAB in Mongolia. Book of Abstracts First
Asian Conference on LABundustrial Application and New Technolody. I 14 p.
19.Velosy,Dy 1979:Tejsav meghatarozasa fatometrias mikromodszerrel.
Kizerlet es Orvostudomany. 31. 662665 p.
60
Nciinad:ic cu{lura[ aradition.. tonongo[ian d;ally pl.ciduct5
FAVORABLE EFFECTS OF FERMENTED MILK DRINK
CONTAINING LACTOBACILLUS CASEI STRAIN SHIROTA
ON GASTROINTESTINAL FUNCTIONS IN HUMAN
HutYli Hiiang, len Lan Wei,Koichi V]'a[anabe,
ChiiCherng Liao, YingChieh Tsai
Graduate Jns[ilue Offood an Nr.itli{ion. Shihchien university, GI.aduale inslllue of
biochemistry, Yan~Ming University, Food industry Research And Development insilu[e,
Y(lkull Honsha Co.LTD,Yaklill Central for Microbiological I.esearch
Probiotics have characterized as viable microbial cultures that influence
the health of the host by balancing the intestinal bacreia and thus preventing and
correcting the microbial dysfunctions.The aim of this study was the investigate
the effects of fermented milk drink containing Lactobacillus casei straim Shirota
on micro flora, in digestion, and absorbtion on gastrointestinal tract.Forty healthy
adult volunteers (10 males and females) singned an informed consent form
participated in this double blind, placebocontrolled intervention study. All
subjects received either 2 bottles (200ml) fermented milk dring containing
Lactobacillus casei (experimental group) or placebo (control group) dialy for I 0
weeks.
At the initali period, a clinical guestionaire was used to obtain subjects medical
history and demographic profile. Stool excretion frequency of subjects was also
recorded dialy within the study period. In the 2nd, 5'h,7'h and lo'h week of study,
feces
from
all
subjects were
collected
for gastriontestinal
microflora
analysis.According to results from quentionaires, subjects in experimental group
had no constipation and their stool excretion frequencies were increased but
conditions of flatulence were reduced when compared with subjects in controll
group. With respect to fecal analysis, the number of Bididobacterium and
lactobacillus casei shirota was increased but the number of clostridium perfingens
was decreased.However, there was no difference in numbers ofLactobacillus and
Enterobacteriaceae in both groups.In conclution,fermented milk drink containing
lactobacillus casei strain Shirota enhansed the gastrointested function in human.
lntermtlona[ Sclentif ¢ Symposium
61
IMPROVEMENT 0F LACTIC FLORA OF KIMCHI
USING BIOPRESERVATIVES AND PR0BI0TICS
Yun Hee Park
Department Of molecular science & technology,
Ajou Urrversity Suwon 442749, Korea
Introduction
Kimchi, a typical fermented food, is a wellknown lactic acid fermented
vegetable product. It is important to prevent kimchi from overripening, especially
kimchi produced for export. However,it is difficult to control the fermentation of
kimchi, because it is a spontaneous and incomplete process involving the complex
interaction of several species of lactic acid bacteria ( 1 ).
In kimchi fermentation, more that 50 species of LAB belonging to different
genera have been reported, and among them the strains to fewco#or/os spp. are
known to be the most desirable organisms. In contrast, strains of fc}cfobcJci.//ws
spp. are considered to be an undesirable species, responsible for the over
acidification ofkimchi. For that reason, to control kimchi fermentation, it is desirable
to suppress the growth of fc}c/obacj.//z/a spp. to prevent overripening if kimchi
and to improve its quality at the same time. However due to the extremely complex
nature of the microbial community involved in kimchi fermentation, there has been
no attempt to selectively inhibit lactobacilli,
Therefore, we have investigated the possibility of using a bacteriocin,
nisin and low molecular weight chitosan to control lactic fermentation of kimchi.
Nisn a small antimicrobial peptide produced by Lc7c/ococcz+s /crc/i's and is approved
for use as a food preservative in the food and dairy industry (2), Chitosan is a
nontoxic natural biopolymer which has several bioactive properties, thus widely
used in the variety of products. The antimicrobial activity of chitosan is the most
important for its potential application as biopreservatives (3).
Recently, although the health benefits of kimchi in the Korean diet have
been intensively studied, the effect of lactic flora in kimchi is completely unknown.
62
T`rorrad:ic cu[Lura[ TTadiition: tMoitgo[1an d:airy prod.uct5
Therefore, because of the importance ofkimchi in Korean diet, we have investigated
the viability of some probiotic lactobacilli and bifidobacteria in various conditions
to develop potential supplements for kimchi.
Materials and methods
Strains
LAB were isolated from home made and commercial kimchi using MRS`
Rogosa, and Phenylethyl Alcohol Sucrose (PES) Media. Probiotic lactobacilli used
in this study included Lcrc/obc7c/.//2„ GG, i. casei. Shirota strain (YIT 9018), and
eight strains of belonging to the I. 4c[.dapfef./ws group; i. c7cf.dap4;./cfs NCDC 13,
CH 27 (Chr. Hansen), JCM 3205, IAM 1084, KCTC 3168, KCTC 3170, and 145
(WIESBY GmbH & Co.) and N2. Bf#doboc/eri.w#7 /o#gzim JK2 was isolated from
human faecal samples. £c7c/obc}c/.//zfs p/c7w/ar!fm 4115 and Le"co#os/os
mese#/croj.des 41 4, isolated from kimchi were used chitosan inhibition test.
Preparation of mulkimchi
Mulkimchi, a type ofkimchi with added water, was prepared from 250g
Oriental radish,10 green onion, 3g garlic, and 2g ginger. All the ingredients were
added to 750ml brine containing 3% (w/v) Nacl and loo IU/ml nisin. The mixture
was placed in a glassjar, fitted with a lid, and fermented at 15°C. Kimchi brine was
obtained from the mulkimchi preparation when the pH was reached pH 4.1 and pH
3.6, respectively. The brine was filtersterilized.
Determining nisin sensitivity
The nisin sensitivity of lactobacilli isolates from kimchi was determined
in MRS broth containing loo IU/ml nisin. The broth was inoculated with a 1518h
culture of the lactobacilli strain to give a final concentration of 107 cells/ml, and
incubated at 20°C. cell growth in the presence ofnisin was monitored by measuring
the optical density of the culture broth at 600 nm.
Chitosan preparation and inhibition test
Chitosan (MW 50.000, Degree of deacetylation 98.5%) was prepared from
a commercial chitin from crab leg using 50% NaoH solution for 5 h at 140°C. the
cells were inoculated into TS broth containing 25 ppm and 50 ppm of chitosan at
a level of 107 cells/ml and incubated at 30°C.
Supplementation of kjmchi with probiotic strains
Cells of lctobacilli were cultured in MRS broth for 18 h at 37°C. the cell
mass was harvested by centrifugation at 4,000 g for 15 min, and washed twice with
0.85% Nacl. The cells were added into kimchi prepared described above at a level
of 107 cfivml.
For bifidobacteria, the mulkimchi was flushed with a mixed gas consisting
of 95% N2 and 5% C02 and poured into capped tubes. Cells of B./oHg3!m JK2
grown at 37°C in Brain Heart Infusion bioth to an O.D. 6co of I.0, were harvested by
[Tltematiorta[ Scientif ic symposium
63
centrifugation at 4,000 g for 20 min. cells were resuspended in mulkimchi at a
concentration of log cfu/ml .
Viable counts
Tlie total population of LAB was counted by the spread plate counting
method on an MRS agar plate after 23 d of incubation at 30°C. Leuconostocs were
counted after a 23 d of incubation on PES agar at 30°C. Lactobacilli were counted
after a 3to 4d incubation on modified lactobaci llus selection (LBS) agar.
To determine the viability ofprobiotic Lactobacilli, samples were plated
on MRS and MRSoxgall agar after tenfold serial dilution of the kimchi brine in
0. I % peptone water. After 2 or 3 of anerobic incubation at 37°C and/or 40°C in Gas
PakTM system, the number of colonyforming units was determined. To determine
the viability of the bifidobacteria, BL (GlucoseBloodLiver) agar (4), TP
(TransgalactooligosaccharjdePropionate) medium (5) and modified MRS (6) were
used.
Results and discussion
Controlling fermentation of kimchi with nisin
Table I shows the nisin sensitivity of40 Iactobacilli isolates from kimchi.
Only two isolates appeared to be resistant to nisin, and four were weakly sensitive.
Thirtyfour isolates, a significant majority, were either sensitivity or very sensitive
to nisin at a concentration of loo IU/ml, which is the level recommended for use in
food in many countries.
No ot`isolated tests
No. of resistant isolates
28
2
7
0
0
0
No. of sensltive Isolates
Species
Lacl.I)lanlaram
Lacl. Brevis
l.acl.rnalefernlenlanls
Lac'.sp
4
I
W.S*
s+
v.sH
4
0
0
0
20
2
I
6
3
I
I
0
The sensitivity to nisin was tested in MRS broth with loo IU/ml of nisin at 20°C.
The growth was determined by measuring optical density of culture at 600 nm.
*W.S: weak sensitive; Growth was detected after 48 h.
+S: sensitive; Growth was detected after 96 h.
itv.S: very sensitive; Growth was not detected after 96 h.
When nisin was added in the preparation of kimchi at a concentration of
loo IU/ml, the effect on the genus fezico#os/oc was quite similar to that on that on
the total LAB. In contrast, the viable population of fc7c/obc7c7.//zfs spp. was
considerably lower for the first three d and then it increased slowly. However, the
numbers of fclc/oboc/.//z/s did not match control levels seen in kimchi without
nisin for 10 d, indicating that the inhibitory effect of nisin on Lerc/obczc7.//!fs spp. is
64
Nomdic cu[tura[ qradition: tMoiigo[Ian drairy protuct5
substantially different from that on LAB belonging to the genus 4ezrco#o5/oc
(Fig.1)
To control kimchi fermentation, it is desirable to suppress selectively the
growth of L#c/obc7cj.//ws spp., to prevent the overripening of kimchi, but not the
otherLAB, especially the growth of fezicowos/oc spp. Foi. most strains of
lactobacilli, the growth could be delayed for one the three d at a level of 100 IU/ml
of nisin. Compare with the fezfco#as/oc spp., they appeared to be more sensitive
to nisin and resulted in substantially inhibited growth during kimchi fermentation.
Table I. Nisin sensitivity of Lactobacillus spp. isolated from kimchi.
Fig.I. The effect of nisin on the growth of lactic acid bacteria in kimclii
fermentation. Nisin was added in the preparation of kimchi at a concentration of
loo IU/ml and fermented at 15°C.
/a/
£cwco"osloc spp. (b) £ac/obac/.//ws spp. Open symbols indicate the
control without nisin. Values are the average of triplicate.
The SEM micrographs demonstrate dameged cells in kimchi by nisin at a
concentration of loo IU/ml. In mulkimchi without added nisin, a variety of cell
shapes was observed, and a major proportion was lactobacilli. In contrast, when
nisin was added at the time of preperation, most of the cells found in mulkimchi
after 8 d fermentation appeared to be cocci. Therefore, these observations confimed
the results, demonstrating the predominance of cocci cells in kimchi containing
nisin. (Fig.2.)
1nternationa[ Scientific symposiuin
65
This suggests the possible use of nisin to selectivity inhibit facfobczcj.//#s
spp., especially Lc7c/. P/c7#/err#m, which is considered an undesirable species
responsible for the overacidification and possible spoilage of the kimchi.
Fig. 2. Scaning electron micrographs of lactic acid bacteria in liquid from kimchi
after 8 d fermentation. Nisin was added in preparation ofkimchi at a concentration
of loo IU/ml and fermented at 15°C. (a) cell in control kimchi (b) cells in kimchi
containing nisin.
Inhibition of LAB ofkimchi with low molecular weigth chitosan
Figure 3 and 4 show the growth and viability of Lac/obc7c/.//zis p/c7#/crr2!m and
fc"co#as/oc mese#/ero/.des in TS broth containing different concentrations of
chitosan. Our results suggest that chitosan migth be added to kimchi, in which
feztco#os/oc mese#/eroJ.des is a very desirable lactic strain, while fac/obaci.//#s
p/c]#/c7rwm is responsible fro overacidification.
(
LILH.\.:ill 5`r:.TfuLi `. I
:*'
¢S I..ilm:Finn,rTesl I.:3uLts
:,,.i,:`:"
8:L,,,.,;
"Li ,. I ; •`J'.
2
;n
.:/
Tmtsitl'
I.
xt
r=
,.
1£
66
tjN.omadic cu[tura[ `Iradiition` gltongo[ian d;airy prod:ucts
F.ig.3. GrovNth o[ L[ictobacilliis pl[Iiimrum 4lls (a) Leucoiioslt)c niesenteroi(les
414 (b) in TS broth containing different concentration of chitosan. .: control,
^ : 25ppm' I : 50ppm.
=i:ii=B=::?:
niBI
__i
.~__*__J
?.€,
`,a.
6S
,`2
Time (h)
Fig.4. Changes of viable counts of i//c/ob¢cJ.//ws p/¢/I/ar#m 4115 ( . ) and
fcwco"o5/oc "csc#/cro/.des 41 4 ( ^ ) im TS broth containing S0 ppm of chitosan.
Open symbols indicate the control without chitosan.
Incorparation of probiotics into kimchi
The viability of nine strains belonging to fcJc/obc7cj.///zis was investigated
under various conditions.Kimchi brine at pH 3.6 and 4.I was inoculated with
fclc/obczc/.//ws GG,
I,.case/. SA/.ro/¢,
and seven strains belonging to the
fcJc/ob¢c/.//its c7cj.dapA7./2" group at a concentration of 107 cfulml. The viability
was measured after 14 d at temperatures of 5°C and 15°C.
Four s`ral\ns of the L.acidophilus group, Lactobacillus GG, and L.casei
showed no significant loss of viability in brine at either pH or temperature. However,
the viability of the other three strains of i. arc;.dapAf./z# was redused from 107cful
ml to 104 sfu/ml in kimchi brine at pH 3.6 and 15°C after 14 d (Table2., Fig. 5). The
results showed there were two distinct groups of lactobacilli strains regarding to
the survival in low pH at 15°C.With storage at 5°C, the loss of viability of these
strains was less then one log cycle in kimchi brine during ]4 d at either pH,
resulting in the viable counts above 106 cell/ml which is a recommended level for
probiotic foods.
The viability of four wellknown starins, Lc7c/obcJc/.//"a GG, Loc/obc7cf.//!fj'
casei Shirola, Laclobacillus acidophilus N2, aind L. acidophilus KCTC 3\68 was
Intemationa[ Scientif ec symposium
67
tested when they were added to mulkimchi containing 3.0 % Nacl at a
concentrationof 107 cfu/ml
Table. I The survival of probiotic lactobacilli inoculated into kimchi brine after
14 d incubation.
Temp, pH
5"C
Strains
15uC
pH41
pH 3.6
pH41
pH 3.6
010
0.09
0.19
0.06
L.casei Shirola
0,10
0.13
0.06
0.06
Lac doohilus NCIX I 3
004
0.09
0.04
0.32
L`acidoDhilus CH 27
0102
0.04
012
0.06
L.ac dophilus JCM 3205
003
0. I I
0,02
0,07
Lac
0.03
0.14
000
0.21
L.acidophilus KCTC 3168
015
065
0,60
4'27
L.acidoi)hilus KCTC 3170
008
040
022
3.99
L. aci¢]ophilus 14 5
0122
0.70
1,84
434
I.actobacillus sp.GG
dopliilus JAM 1084
Cell were inoculated at concentration of 107 cfu/ml.
The data represent log reduction ofviabl6 cells after 14 d storage.
I a I Lth.JiTb i] itJ/I I.i I.r. . C:a
Lt)) i. .I:/rlc:F}/..I./(J`€
:.1.==r,i.++.I
145
:I+ .I.. .I
+...
.```.``.
I
I
II,`=..'r ,.,.,, I,.<..
i,n, t., ^' ,...... `
|'I..rs
: I
.r',.u
i ;,i;:h:n:::: ;.,,::,:;
I+...'..._
I.I
2
4
5
r.
ic
Tll``e td.|y9t
.2
11
....,,. `
..., I,
,I „t' 1
U.I,
.... ` =,
n. , + ...I ,.,.. : , t .'t
±
i
6
I
10
\i!
"
T)mEL (du./2/
Fig.5. The viability of /f[c/ob4ci.//«s GG(a) and I.acJ.day/I;/z/s 145 (b) in kimchi
brine during
. After 10 d at 15°C, no loss of viability was observed with either fcrc/ob¢ci.//ws GG
or L.casei Shirola. Cour"s o£ L.acidophilus N2 a.nd L.acidophilus KCTC 3\68
68
Nomadic cu[tura[ qradiLion: MongoRan chiry prod:uct§
were sligthly redused, approximately 0.3 and 0.5 log, respectively. The addition of
the probiotics to mulkimchi did not produse any significant changes in the
population of indigenous lactic acid bacteria, pH, or acidity (data not shown).
Mulkimchj containing 2 % (w/w) without pH adjustment was prepared
and inoculated with 8. /o#g"in JK2 at concentration of log cfu/ml (Fig.6.).During
10 d of incubation at 4°C, viable cell counts decreased from 108 cfu/ml to 107 cfu/ml,
a lofold reduction. The total number of lactic acid bacteria started to develop
rapidly after three d and reached to 107 cfulml afire 6 d, accompanied by an increase
in the total acidify to 1. I g/I. These results demonstrate that consumption of mul
kimchi that had been inoculated with I O8cfu/in of B./oHgzt#7 JK2 and incubated
for 10 d would result in ingestion of more than 107 cfu/ml of viable cells.
Lorg. Ofu mi
•lt, ..
•1
'u
,i
I
1.
I'7]
. r.
C.,
h. L '.`..'`,
+
I
+``` ., I
\q€+`
...L
`i= E!.
pl
I...
a.IL
cJ
f'
CL\
'S`a
_I_I
Jfl
'8.
'3
•1..+I
I
I
.I.
=i=
A=itity (ctt4
Fig.6. The survival of introdused B./ong#m jK2 ( . ), the growth of total lactic
acid bacteria ( ^ ), and changes in pH (I) and total acidify (V) during fermentation
of Mu[kimchi containing 2 % (w/w) ofNac] at 4°C for 10 d. Cell were inoculated
at a concentration of 108 cfu/ml.
Intemationa[ Scientif lc symposium
69
References
I.
Cheigh, H.S. and Park, K.Y.(1994) Biochemical, microbiological, and
nutritional aspects of kimchi (Korean fermented vegetable products).
Critical Reviews in Food Science and nutrition 34: 175203
2.
Hurst, A. and Hoover, D.G. (1993) Nisin. In antimicrobials in foods
ed.Davidson, P.M. and Branen, A.L.pp.369370. NewYork: Marcel Dekker,
Inc
3.
4.
Wang,G.H.(1992) Inhibition and inactivation offive species offood bone
pathogens by chitosan. Joumal of Food Protction 55:916919.
Teraguchi, S., Uehara, M., Ogasa, K„ and Mitsuaka, T. (1978) Enumeration
of bifidobacteria in dairy products. Japanese journal of bacteriology 33,
753761.
5.
Ji,G.E.,Lee, S.K. andKim, I.H (1994) Improved selectivemedium forisolation
and enimuration ofbifidobacterium sp. Koreanjournal of Food science
and technology 26,526531.
6.
Roy, D. and ward, P. (1990) evaluation of rapid methods for differentiation
of bifidobacterium species. Joumal of Applied Bacteriology 69,739749.
70
Norlradic cu[tura[ q=radition: "ongo[iai. d;airy prod.ucts
BIOCHEMICALANDMICROBIol.OGICALSTUDYOFFERMENTED
MARE'SMILK(AIRAG)PREPAREDBY
TRADITIONALMONGOLIANTECHNOLcray
R.Baldorj , D.Tumenjargal, B.Ba[jargal,
Department of Biochemistry and Microbiology,
Naliona[ University Of Mongolia.
Abstract
As a result of our research conducted to specimens of fermented mare's
milk from different geographic regions of Mongolia such as Gobidesert, Steppe
and Foreststeppe, we determined alcoholic fermentation yeasts such as
Saccharomyces lactis, Saccharomyces carliloginosus species and Lactic acid
balcter.lz} s"ch as Lactobacillus bulgaricus, Streptococcus laclis, Streptococcus
di.ace/7./oc/;`s in the micro flora of fermented mare's milk, prepared by Mongolian
traditional technology. It is also noted that generic and species composition of
microorganisms in the start culture of femented mare's milk is the same in the
different geographic regions of Mongolia, however their quantitative ratios were
significantly different among the natural zones. In the winter, the yeast content
made up the majority of fermented mare's milk. In the spring and fall the yeast and
bacteria ratio is almost equal. In the summer, the amount of lactic acid bacteria
increased in the product.
Kev words: Fermented mare's milk, Lactic acid bacteria, £ac/ob¢c/.//zfs
bulgaricus, Streptococcus lactis, Streptococcus diaceti[actis, Yeasts,
Saccharomyces lactis, Saccharomyces carti[oginosus
Introduction
Fermented mare's milk prepared by traditional Mongolian technology
play an extremely important role in the Mongolians diet from the ancient time.
Written records confirm that the conquering armies of chinghis Khan lived on this
food. History tells us that by the year 1206, Chinghis Khan had unified all of
InLemation,a[ Sclentif\c sympos\un
71
Mongolian tribes under his banner. By 1215, the Mongols held most of the Ch'in
Empire and had vanquished Turkistan and Afghanistan. They even penetrated
southeastern Europe. Higlily mobile, the Mongols rode small, swift horses that
were bred to traverse the vast plains of the Mongolian empire. These hardy horses
were what helped make this army invincible. Not only did they carry soldiers into
battle, they also provided the rich milk that was femented and enjoyed by every
member of the conquering hordesfrom the Great Khan to the lowliest slave.
Knownasairagatumiss),thisisoneoftheearliestknownfermentedmilkproducts.
Highly nutritious, airag not only sustained the Mongols, it kept them healthy.
Biochemica] and microbiological study of this healthy food started in the
latter I)alf of 19d century and in Mongolia it began by Russian scientists in 1931.
(2,6) As far as Mongolian scientists, professor R.Indra, professor R.Baldolj,
professor Ts.Namsrai, doctor R.Sukhbaatar have continued the research in this
field.(I,2,3)
The research project toward study of fe[Tnented mare's milk has been
carried out at the department of Biochemistry and Microbiology, the National
University of Mongolia, under supervision of professor R. Baldoj since 1970. We
have determined the generic and species composition of microorganisms in the
start culture of fermented mare's milk and established a national fund of pure
cultureandsymbioticmicroorgnismsoftheMongoliantraditionalfermentedmilk
product. To keep the start culture effective for long tine without loss natural
symbiosis, we have developed a conservation method of stalt culture.
Nutritiona] and treatment value of the fermented foods considerably
depend on composition of microonganisms, which are used as a start culture. The
mainpuTposeofourstudyistoprovidethemanufactureoffelTnentedmare'smilk
with pure culture.
Materials and metliods
The samples of airag (fermented mare's milk), which are prepared by
traditional technology, were collected from provinces of Bulgan, Arkl)angai,
rmdgovi and Tuv. An Isolation of pure culture of lactic acid bacteria and yeasts
wascarriedoutbyusingselectivemedia.Wesfudiedmotphological,physiological
and biochemical characteristics of isolated pure cultures and determined
taxonomical groups of bacteria by using Bergey's Manual and yeasts by Manual
of Kudryavtsev.
Results and discussions
Study of Lactic acid bacteria isolated from fermented mare's milk.
72
Nomadic ¢u[tura[ qiradit.or.: anoingoRian d;airy prodiucts
An investigation of lactic acid bacteria, isolated from fermented mare's
milk was conducted based on the research methods of Russian and Bulgarian
scholars. We have studied the ability to ferment lactose and other sugars, lactic
acid formation, cell number dynamic, cell and colony characteristics of Lactic acid
bacilli and compared our results to characteristics of 4c7c/ob¢c/.//2ts bzi/gar/.c!is,
which is determined by Bogdanov, V.M. and Koroleva, C.A., in dairy products.
(4,5) (Table 1 )
Table I
The colony and cell characteristics of Lactic acid bacilli,
isolated from fermented mare's milk
Bacterial
Colony shape
e
cell shape
i3'5;
spccics
LactobacilJus
bulgar.cue
=u
Surface
colony
is
wavelike,depthcolonylikecotton
Large
ro ds
with
rounded
C:a'E!
='5
1,
j!
8in
=i
i:ii
aI
+
.+
a?i??
I.actobaciHus
bulgancus
I,actobacitlus
bulgaricus
colony
is
wave.like,
depth colony
like cotton
Surface
col ony
is
wave.like,
depth colony
like cotton
Langc rods in
chains
with
rounded cnd
>
•+
8Io
C?i
00
S!
t`t<
IJarg¢
'?
is
:::.u,s:pal.'fyin a
Surface
:®a
8i¢
et®a?
!£>®
ro ds
with rounded
end, usuallyin achains,
00t<
+
8n
PT
§§
ca
i
5
ig
When pure culture of Lactic acid bacilli, isolated fermented mare's milk was
fermented at 4041°C for 60 hours in a lowfat milk culture, the general acidity
increased to 220280 °T and at 2025°C for 60 hours general acidity increased to
220280°T. It shows that there is a possibly to produce sour drink without alcohol
by using this culture.
Intemat.ona[ S ¢ier.tif ic sympo§.urn
73
Lactic acid bacteria were fermented in lowfat milk and determined the
acid formation, lactose reducing, lactic acid formation and cell number during 72
hours. The results are shown in the table 3.
Table2
General acid formation of Lactic acid bacilli ( £acfob¢ci.//ws bw/garJ.cwsJ
Time (hour)
0
6
12
24
36
48
60
72
TemperatureCulturemedium
Fermentation temperature (404t °C)
F.at%i;50
Lowfat milk
Whole milk
Average
20.I
55.0
150.0
'90.0
233.0
265.0
290.0
310.0
20.i
50.0
115.0
'45.0
180.0
205.0
225.0
245.0
20.1
52.5
132.0
165.5
206.5
235.0
257.5
277.5
TemperatureCulturemedium
Fermentation temperature (202 5 °C )
Lowfat milk
Whole milk
Average
20.I
42.4
115.0
157.9
202.3
240.0
265.0
280.0
20.1
28.I
59.1
loo.8
132.0
170. 5
205.0
220.0
20.I
35.2
87.05
129.3
167.I
205.2
235
250.0
Table3
Biochemical characteristics of Lactic acid bacilli,
cultivated in lowfat cow milk.
Fermentation
time(hour)
General acidity (°T)
Lactose (%)
Lactate (%)
Cell number (mln/ml)
0
6
12
24
36
48
60
72
20.I
55.0
150.0
190.0
233.0
265.0
290.0
3 10.0
4.2
3.6
2.8
2.4
2.2
I.8
1.5
I.2
0.2
0.6
I.5
I.8
2.0
2.3
2.7
2.8
70.2
94.0
110.0
162.0
170.0
166.0
156.0
142.0
Study of lactic acid streptococci, isolated from fermented mare's milk
We conducted research on the morphology, physiology and biochemistry
of Lactic acid streptococci isolated from samples of fermented mare's milk. To
isolate Lactic acid streptococci, we enriched and cultivated the samples at 2830°C
for 2448 hours in the selective medium. Length of subsurface colonies of Lactic
acid streptococci was 1 2 Hm. We determined that the optimum growth temperature
74
Nomadic cu[iura[ qTaditioit: froi.gotitan alairy i]roduct5
of these bacteria was 2830 °C, maximum growth temperature was 3540°C and
minimum growth temperature was 1012 °C.
Basing on comparing results of
morphological, physiological and biochemical characteristics of isolated pure
cultures, we determined that isolated streptococci are S/rap/ococczf5 /c7c/i.s,
S/rep/ococc"s c//.¢ce//./c7c//.s. Results of biocliemical study of pure culture during
fermentation in lowfat milk medium were shown in below.
Table 4
Biochemical characteristics of Lactic acid bacilli,
cultivated in lowfat cow milk.
Fermentation temperature (2825 °C)
Fermentation time
General acidit}'
Lactose
Lacta'c
Cell ilunlber
(hour)
(I)
(%)
(%)
(mln/ml)
0
28.6
4.2
0.2
353.0
2
30.8
4.0
0.3
373.0
4
36.2
3.8
0.4
491.0
6
38.5
37
0.4
539.0
8
60.5
3.5
0.6
539.0
12
705
34
07
550.0
24
90.2
32
09
580.0
36
112.0
3.0
I.I
562.0
48
]20.0
2.9
I.2
482.0
Study of yeasts isolated from fermented mare's milk
The study of yeast taxonomy has been carried out since 1970 and was
determined the presence of several yeast species such as SaccAc]ro#7};ccs /oc//.s,
Saccharomyces cartiloginosus, Saccharomyces torulopsis in the Mongol:lim
fermented mare's milk according to Manual of Kudryavtsev.
We prepared airag by using pure culture of Sc7ccAc7rom};ces /ac//.s,
Saccharomyces car[iloginosus a,nd Lactobacillus bulgaricus. T`hese pure cultures
were mixed with proper ratio and fermentation process was carried out for 36
hours. After 36 hours of fermentation general acidity increased until 136°T, alcohol
content was I.81 %, lactose content was 1.92% and lactic acid content was I.30%.
The general acidify of 132°T, alcohol content was I.81 %, lactose content
was I.92% and lactic acid content was I.30% when SaccAc7rom};ces /oc/;.s,
Sc7ccAorom);ces ccrr//./ogj.#of#s was mixed at a certain proportion with
S/rep/ococccis /c7c/;'s and duration of fermentation is 36 hours. We established
that the proportion of bacteria and yeasts in fermented mare's milk ferment differs
from region to region in geographic regions and found that in the Gobidesert
Intei.nationa[ Sc.er.tif lc symposiuin
75
region bacteria and yeast ratio was 2 : I, in the Steppe region I : I.5 and in the
foreststeppe region it was I : 2.
It is also noted that in the winter, the yeast content made up the majority
of fermented mare's milk. [n the spring and fall the yeast and bacteria ratio is
almost equal. In the summer, the amount of. lactic acid bactei.ia increased in the
product. The culture environment and temperature by which the number of
increases had the largest impact on the taste and property of fermented mare's
milk.
Conclusion
I.
We determined the alcoholic fermentation yeasts such as sacchc7/.om};ces
/c7c//.a, Sc7cc4c7ro/7?);c.eb. cc7r//./og/.#osz/s species and lactic acid bacteria
such as Lactobacillus bulgaricus, Slreplococcus lac[is, Streptococcus
c//.occ//./c7c/;`s in the micro flora of fermented mare's milk, prepared by
Mongolian traditional technology.
2.
Generic and species composition of microorganisms in the start culture
of fermented mare's milk is the same in the different geographic regions
of Mongolia, however their quantitative ratios were significantly different
among the natural zones. In the Gobidesert region bacteria and yeast
ratio was 2 : I, in the Steppe 1 : I.5 and in the Foreststeppe region it was
1:2.
3.
In the winter, the yeast content made up the majority offermented mare's
milk. In the spring and fall the yeast and bacteria ratio is almost equal. In
the summer, the amount of Lactic acid bacteria increased in the product.
The culture environment and temperature by which the number of
increases had the largest impact on the taste and property of fermented
mare's milk.
76
Ncrmadiic cu[tura[ TTadiitwn: 9vi`ongohar. diairy products
References
I . Bajlj|op%.P., "Pa3pa6oTKa l4 BHe;|pe"e npoMbllnjleHHori TexHojlo"H
MOHroJlbcl(oro KyMI,Iea "
2.
3.
Z|ol(.j|I{cc„ (1988), MocKBa, c.175200
BaJIHopx. P, HaMcpaii.1| (1980) "MOHroJI aiipar", yjlcblH
x3Bjl3j"fiH ra3ap. yJlaaH6aaTap, x. I 8
Ba]Ij|opx, P., HaMcpaii,I|., (1985),
"A#p"iiH xepeHreHHii
MHKpoopraH113Mblr coHrox IHIIH)rm3x yxaaHI]I yHH3c ", MyHC 311]8,
35: 48
4.
EorI|aHo,B.M., (1969), "MIIKpo6IIojlo"jl MojloKa H MOTlotlHblx
nponyKTOB ", H3j]. "IIHII|eBafl rlpoMblllljleHHocTb ", MocKBa, c.8297
5.
KopoJ16Ba, C.A., ( 1974), "OcHOBI>I TexHIIqecKoii MIII{po6IIOTlo"H
MOJ]o"oro jle]Ia ",113H. I]IIu.npoM113jlaT, MocKBa, c. 344
qoMaKOB,Xp., KapH6ueBa, X„ KapnHpoB, M. ,1968, "MHKpod)Jlopa
MOHroTlbcKoro I(HCJloro MOJloKa ", Mo7IoqllaH IipoMI,ImJleHHocTI> , 4 :
2527
Intemationa[ Scientif ic symposium
77
STUDY 0F MARE MILK AND 0F ITS
FERMENTEI) PRODUCT
8. Ochirkhayag, JM. Choberl,
Ts. Namsrai, Thomas Haertla
N ational University of Mongolia, Departrnenl Of
Biochemistry and Microbiology,
PO 46377, Ulaanbaatar, Morigolia
lnstilti[ National de la Recherche Agronomique. Laboraloire d'Etude des
Interactions des Mol6cules Alimen[ail.es. B.P. 71627, 44316 Nanles Cedex 3, France.
Medical University Of Morlgolia, Department Of chemistry and Biochemistry
Correspondence and reprints, email: ochir
[email protected]
Abstract
Caseins from individual mare of
Mongolian animal stock were fractionated
according to their sensibility to
temperature. Individual caseins were
separated
by
gel
per fusion
chromatography and further purified by
HPLC. The obtained individual caseins
fractions were analyzed by polyacrylamide
gel electrophoresis, and their amino acid
composition, phosphorus content and N
;i terminal sequence determined. Equine milk
casein complex consists of at least three
classes of proteins Such as Cls,, Qs2•, and Pcaseins. Kappalike casein could not
be detected in Mongolian mare milk by the applied methods. Only recently, a small
quantity of alike casein was found in poney milk.
The identification of the origin of the bioactive properties of koumiss
and the characterization of the lactic acid bacteria strains producing bacteriocin
like substances is the subject of further studies.
78
Nomadic cu[tura[ qradiitlon: gviongo[ian datry prorfucts
Results and discussion
ln the past decade, numerous studies were devoted to the impact of cow
milk and fermented bovine milk products on health benefits of a consumer. Milks
and milk products from other species were much less studied. In this area, mare
milk and koumiss (fermented mare milk) look as very promising. While mare whey
proteins are relatively well known, equine caseins remain still relatively poorly
apprehended.
Whole mare (Mongolian and French breeds) casein was obtained from
skim milk by isoelectric precipitation (pH 4.6) at 22 °C. In another series of
experiments, equine caseins were fractionated after isoelectric precipitation at 4
°C, according to their sensitivity to temperature, on one hand, the pH of the
resultingpelletwasadjustedto6.5beforecentrifugation(45000gfor30min)at4
°C; on the resulting casein fraction which precipitated was named the cold
precipitated (CP) fraction. On the other hand, the supematant obtained from the
centrifugation of skim milk at pH 4.6 and 4 °C was warmed to 30 °C before being
centrifuged at 30 °C, 45 000 g, for 30 min. The resulting casein fraction which
precipitated was named the thermally precipitated (TP) fraction. Equine caseins
were then purified by high resolution gel chromatography on an anionexchange
column followed by reversed phasehigh performance liquid chromatography.
The casein fractions were analyzed by urea and SDSpolyacrylamide gel
electrophoresis, their amino acid compositions were determined and their first 15
Nterminal amino acids were sequenced. This analysis showed the presence of cts
likecaseinsisolatedfromtheCPfraction.as,Likecaseinshowed4majordouble
bands by electrofocusing with a pl range of 4.34.8. In the same conditions, Cist
like casein showed 2 major bands with a pl range of 4.35.1. The TP fraction
revealed the existence in equine milk of 6 sub fractions of Plike caseins, occurring
in the following ratios: 1:5:18:20:15:10, differing at least in their degree of
phosphorylation (as shown also by the action of acid phosphatase). Since no
evidence of the presence of kcasein was found in equine milk, it is proposed that
partofitsfunctionsinthemilkoftheEquidaecouldbeassumedbythepopulation
of less phosphorylated acaseins.
Jnten.atiotta[ Scierttif ic symposium
79
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT 0F LACTIC ACID BACTERIA
INDUSTRY IN TAIWAN
ChitCherng Liao,Ph.D
Senior Research Fellow and Deputy Director
Food Industry Research and Development Institute
Hsinchu,Taiwan
Lactic acid bacteria products in Taiwan could be calssified into five
categories, including ( I ) fermented milk (more than 25 brands and 80 items), (2)
powdered milk (more than 30 brands and 90 items), (3) tablets, powder and capsules
(more than loo brands,150 items), (4) snack food (more than 40 brands and 70
items), and (5) others (more than 20 brands and 50 items) . The market value of
fermented milk products in Taiwan was N.T. $ 4.5 billion in 2001.
The sale value of fermented milk and probiotic products has increased
rapidly since 1998. New products have been developed and commercialized,
including AByogurt, ABCyogurt, microcapsulestyle yogurt8 milk powder with
probiotics and/ or prebiotics,LABcracker,green tea LAB, Frozen yogurt or icebar
with LAB, yogurt with SODinducer, no cholestrol, low fat and low calories yogurt,
and drinking yogurt with plant fiber.
Department of Health has approved eleven LABrelated products as Health
Food since the enforsement of Health Food Act in l999.The industries have
developed varieties of diluted flavored fermented milk products since 2001.In
addition, the drinking yogurt for kids and vegetablefruit juice mixed with LAB
have also been in the market since 2001.
8o
Nonadic cu[lura[ qJradition: "ongoftan dairy proofucts
THE SIGNIFICANCE OF BACTRIAN CAMEL MILK
Ts.Batsukh / Ph.D/
Mongolian University Of Science and Technology
The lives of generations of the
Mongols have been closely linked with
the camel herd and they provided their
food, clothes, housing, labor utensils,
transport and fuel needs with what
camel yielded.
9.6% of the entire camel herds in the
world are Bactrian camels. Over 30% of
this kind dwell in the Gobi area which
holds 42% of the entire Mongolian
territory.
Fig.1.The camel spreading of Mongolia
Internationa[ Scienlif ic symposium
81
The population census and the employment status of 200l showed that
those living in the Gobi area who are engaged in camel husbandry are fully
dependent on the camel yields. If we look back at the history of food consumption
beginning from the time of chinghis Khan until today camel milk and camel milk
produce constitute more than 50% of the herders food intake in the Gobi region
including those who are engaged mainly in camel breeding. Meanwhile the share
of fruits, berries and vegetable which are the source of the biologically active
substance holds about 3 %.
E meat
I dairy produse
Eflour,cereals
I fruit, vegetables
1900
1940
1980
2000
Fig.2. The main food items of Gobi herders
( kg/month )
According to the fig.2. the share of camel milk and dairy produce in
the composition of the Gobi population is comparatively high. Out of the food
items that are included in the food composition, by the content of the
biologically active substance that is needed by the human body the dairy
produce lead.
substance
Camel
dairyoroduc'
Probiotlc
loo
Vitamln C
95
Bkarotin
Meat and meat
Flour,
products
cereds
Fniit. vegetables
5
85.5
15.5
Ca
P
lrmunoElobulin
Lyzosime
90
10
95
5
Pro'eln
35
loo
loo
55
10
82
Nomadic cu[tura[ qJradiition: "ongoRan d;aity products
Tabl.I.The resourse of the biological and nutritious substances/%/
The table shows that the Gobi population obtains the majority of the
biological and nutritious substance from the milk and dairy produce. For the
nomadic Mongols the camel milk has been not only the source of food and drinks
in the severe Gobidesert conditions, but also has been the basic means of
preventing from illness or of healing diseases.
The number of these animals which have been so much helpful in the
lives of generations after generations in Mongolia, has been drastically decreasing
over the recent years. /fig.3/ There are several factors that had led to this. From
among them we can note that the good tradition of milking every shecamel and
processing of the camel yields has been disrupted over the recent 30 years; there
was unfavorable weather conditions; the breeding, caring, pedigree and selection
work was not sufficient. The camel meat yields is much and its fat content is low.
Having no unusual taste and smell it is most suitable for making sausage. It can be
another factor for the decrease in the camel herd since the time when the country
moved into market economy.
1000
900
BOO
ts.head#:
500
400
300
200
S
i"`),('r,:¥
k'
z i ,:a , `, ,i. i
+
¥
100
a
I
'111
'1
grf`Fborbshyfk€fsk;forfAq3hFhTfssrh¢s.`
years
Fig. 3. The camel population of Mongolia
Internationa[ Scierttif ic symposlum
83
Out of the factors that would prevent the decline in the number of camels
we should note that there is a greater need to pay attention to the utilization of
camel wool, fleece and milk. This is related to the issue of creating the advanced
technology suited to the local areas for processing camel milk basing on the
biological and nutritious qualities, arranging the highly demanded new products
that are significant for health care and making an adequate use of camel milk in
other social areas.
The lactation period of camel is 17 months. Depending on the natural,
environmental and feeding conditions a camel can produce 0,5 kg of milk a day on
the average and it's possible to use 260265 kg of milk a year. If we milk about 80%
of the entire shecamel herd of Mongolia and obtain 0.5 liter from a camel it is
possible to use a 33 million liters of milk a year.
The Mongols have a specific technology of processing camel milk, that
had come down generation to generation. As we know by now they make over 50
types of dairy products through the traditional method. we have summarized in
Table 2 the types of dairy produce that are made through the traditional method.
Tabl.2. The comparative index of the camel dairy products
The camel dairy products
Aaruul / Mongolia/
Oggt Saudi Arabia
Hoormog
Susa East Africa
By english
Dried curd
Acidified milk
Suusac Somalia
Thos
Tsagaa
Aarts
Shimiin arkhi
Shmen ~ Algeria
Ghee Somalia
?
?
?
Clarified fat
Cultured milk
Asidifled curd
Alcochol drink
We have a reason to say that the technology of making these products
has been refined all the way down today and is the most suitable and perfect
method in the animal husbandry conditions. But we are facing today the issue of
making a technological solution of transferring these traditional methods into the
production method. The essence of this method is that one dairy product would
proceed from another one. For instance, the camel sour milk is an independent
produce itself. But it is further processed to make curd and that would be the raw
materials for making other dairy items such as dried curd etc. We can summarize
the technology of processing camel milk and making dairy product as following:
84
g(orlradi¢ cu[tura[ Tradit.on: grf.ongo[ian chny pToduct5
Camel milk
Aarts
/acidified curd/
Shimiin arkhi
/alcochol drink/
Shar thos
/ clarified fat/
The camel milk and dairy products not only meet the Gobi dwellers'
needs in food and drinks. They are also widely used for folk medicine. Traditionally,
the camel milk is effective for reducing clubbing and are used for digestive organ
ailments. Also in combination with various herbs it was used for medicinal purposes.
We have outlined some results of the research conducted since 1986 for
the purpose of defining the biological and nutritious quality of the camel milk on
the basis of the research of the camel milk qualities and the traditional method of
processing it, and of creating the technology of the health oriented products.
We have defined the composition /%/ and quality of the Bactrian she
camel with that of the dromedary and showed it in fig. 4.
E bactrian
|dromedary
total
solids
fat
protein lactose mineral
Fig. 4. Tlte comparative study of bactrian and dromedary milk
Intemationa[ Scientific symposium
85
EE casein
E casein
lwhey
1whey
protein
protein
Fig.5. The protein content of cow /a/ and camel millJa/ /°/o/
When we compared the milk of Mongol shecamel to that of dromedary
camel the contents of fat, protein and the total dry substance were high. It is
related to the natural and climatic conditions and the animal pedigree.
The protein composition of the camel milk is shown below as compared
to the same index of cow milk./fig.5/
The diagram shows that the amount of albumin and globulin in the camel
milk is I,52 times more than the cow milk. This result of the research is an expression
of the biological significance of the camel milk.
We have observed one specific feature of the camel milk during the
research. The camel milk preserves its freshness longer than that of other animals.
In other words, the sourness of camel milk progresses comparatively slowly.
We relate this feature of camel milk to its mineral contents. According to
some research materials this quality of camel milk was explained in a link with the
contents of its bactericide substances.
Tabl. 3. The comparative index of mineral content of the
different animals milk
I
1
2
3
Milk of
animals
Mineral
content,%
Na
Mare
Cow
Camel
0.3
0.6
34
50
0.9
96
mg%
CL
K
P
Buffer
capacity/acid/ml
Bactericide
time,h
64
64
54
I.8
1.5
Ilo
146
90
94
2.5
3
3.8
6
144
Also we have established the following specific features of camel milk
technology. At the separation of camel milk protein by a production method it
took twice as much time for the souring substance (fermentation, acid etc) to act.
The moisture of the protein products prepared by the above method was more
than the cow milk. There we faced some technological difficulties. There is a
ground to consider that this specific feature of camel milk is first of all related to its
the mineral contents and the ability to connect casein water.
86
Nomadic cu[lura[ a:radition: 5Vtongo[iar. d:airy pi'od.ucts
Another specific feature of camel milk is that its fat has a light color and
that comparatively high temperature regime was necessary for exti.action. When
we made cream and butter with the extracted fat its taste and quality were not as
good as those of cow milk.
The results of the experience of the use of camel milk fat for the beauty
purposes showed that the face cream could increase the nourishing quality and
can be significant for enriching it with biologically active substances (A, D, E
vitamins, unsaturated fatty acid etc).
We have worked out the technology of a new product with culrure
L.
acidophilus as a result of the experiment made on the production technology of
fermented dairy produce, leaning on the peculiar quality of camel milk protein and
fat. It has been confirmed during the clinical observation that this particular product
is quite suitable for children's care and health care treatment.
The results of the research and experiment have shown that the selection
of the technology of using the biologically active substance of the camel milk for
the health treatment and children's nutrition would give an impetus for solving
some social and economic problems of the Gobi inhabitants.
References
I.
Ts. Batsukh. Technological properties and processingmethods ofbactrian
camel milk, Diss.1994. UB.
2.
J.Wangon. Chemical and technological properties of camel milk. Diss.
1997. Zurich
3.
Z. Farah. Composition and characteristics of camel milk. J.Dairy. Res. 60
V.P. Cherepanova. The correlation between fat and protein in the milk of
camels. Zhivotnovodstvo.10:3 334
Jntemattona[ Scientific symposium
87
THE ABILITY 0F CAMEL'S MILK T0 BE PROCESSED
INTO CHEESE
Pr. Dr. J.P. RAMET, Ecole Nationale Sup6rieiire
d'Agronomie e[ des Industries Alimen[aires, BP 172,
F54 505 Vandoeuvre les Nancy
Summary
`Cheese is a common mean for preserving milks of various animal species,
however for camel's milk such tradition does not exist because it is impossible or
very difficult to get milk to set. Thus surplus of milk are often wasted by lack of
appropriated cheese technologies.
From about 15 years ago, our field and academic researches have shown
that the situation for dromedary's milk was mainly originate by a specific
composition of casein and mineral, a low reactivity of milk for enzymes clotting
and for acidifying.
Adapted alternatives were found to make the milk set, such as adding
Calcium salt, as lowering the pH, as choosing pepsin as clotting enzyme and ( or)
mixing a small amount of sheep our cow's milk. Procedures of manufacturing have
been established for production of the different ( fresh, soft, semihard, hard)
types of cheeses and published in FAO manuals.
Extension of the methods is running over the distribution area of
dromedary, mainly in Samarians zones and in the Near and Middle East countries.
A small camel cheese factory has been also erected in Mauritania to provide the
urban market in Nouakchott.
Perishability of raw milk
Presence of spoilage agents:
micro flora
enzymes
Presence of sensitive substrates
88
Nomadic cu[tura[ q:radiiitior.: "ongofiian diairy pnod.ucts
lactose
proteins
fats
Presence of favourable physical factors
Temp.
2535°C
pH
6,68
AIM
0,se
Principle of cheese processing
Inhibition or lamination of activities of spoilage agents
Action on physical factors
Reducing the activities of spoilage agents by heat
treatment of`milk
Lowering pH : 6,68 down to 4,25,5
Lowering Aw : 0,99 do\m to 0,750,95
Lowering Temperature : 37°C down to 714°C
Resulr:
Improvement of preservation time from few days to several months
Flow sheet of cheese processing
1Preparationofmilk
Selection of raw milk with high microbial and chemical quality standards
Standardization of fat content ( 27 30 g/I)
Heat treatment (6575°C1530 s)
Adjustement of temperature ( 2240°C)
Adding of technical aids ( lactic starters, Ca chloride)
Maturation time
2Coagulation
Changing the physical status of milk from Liquid to Clot
Adding the milk clotting enzyme
Clotting time : Flocculation time +Hardening time
3Draining
Slow syneresis of the curd with progressive separation of
Cheese and Whey
Improvementofdraining by :
Cutting
StirringHeating
Pressing
Inte rnationa[ S cier.tif ic symposium
Salting
•
Acidification
Evaporation
89
4Ripening
Changing the sensory properties of cheese
(Vlsual aspect, Taste, Odor, Texture)
Keeping the cheese under controlled conditions
( pH, Aw, Red ox, Temperature)
Preservation time from some days ( humid cheese) to several months (
hard cheese)
Poor ability ofcamel's milk to cheese making
Situation
No traditional methods of processing
Surplus of milk are lost
1986: Development of researches sponsored by FAO :
Evaluation of clotting properties ofcamel's milk
•Laboratory investigations in Sadie Arabia
Academic researches on Camel's milk composition in France
Identification and validation of specific methods of production of
cheeses ( Saudia Arabia, Tunisia, France)
Publications of manuals
Field extension of the methods for cheese production by smallholders (
Maghreb, Sahel, East Africa, Near East) and by dairy industries (
Mauritania).
Results of the researches
Specific composition of camel's milk :
Low Total solids and casein content
Casein micelles are characterized by a high size and a low percentage of
Kappa casein
High salt ratio Na/Ca
Consequences of camel's milk composition on ability to cheese making :
Ability to clotting
Poor reactivity to milk clotting enzymes (rennet)
Poor ability to acidification
( Microbial inhibitors : LPS, Lysozyme, Vit. C)
High buffer capacity)
No or weak structuration of curd
90
Nomadic cu[tuTa[ Tradition: 5Mongohan dairy i>roduct5
( Long clotting time, crumbliness)
Ability to draining
Low syneresis
Crumbly texture of cheese
Very high losses of TS into the whey
Low cheese yield :
( Cheese weight : 510kg/ loo kg milk
Milk TS recovery : 30%)
Milk TS recovery for :
Ewe's milk : 68 %
Cow's milk : 50%
Goat's milk : 45 0/a
Ability to ripening
Scarce observations
No specific flavor, sometime bitter or salty
Rough texture of cheese due to low fat content and hydratation of
casein
Sometime sticky texture due to high melting point of fat matter
Methods for correcting the poor ability of camel's milk to cheese making
Preparation of milk
Selecting a raw material with high chemical and microbial quality
Heating the milk ( thermization, low pasteurization)
Increasing the total solid and casein content
(Adding ewe's, cow's milk, milk powder)
Increasing the Calcium content of milk
( Calcium chloride, dihydrogeno phosphate)
Lowering pH before renneting
( lactic starters, maturation time
acid lactic, glucono delta lactone, carbon dioxide))
•Coagulation of milk
Selecting the milk clotting enzyme
(Pepsine, rennet, chymosin, microbial enzymes)
Increasing the ratio MCE/milk
lncresasing the clotting temperature
Lengthening the clotting time
Draining of curd
Reducing the intensity and time of physical treatments
( Cutting, Stirring , Pressing)
Reducing salting intake
I ntermtiona[ S cientif ec symposium
91
Ripening of curd
Checking the susceptibility to drying
Conclusion
Camel's milk is an unique resource in arid areas
Preservation has been traditionally and mainly carried out by production
of fermented milk and butter
Original and simple methods are now proposed for processing the milk
into cheese
The technology of cheeses fiom camel's milk
Dr. J.P. RAMET
The most appropriated products for long time preservation in fleld
conditions are :
Hard or dried cheeses
Semi hard or soft cheese pickled in salted brine or oil
•Further investigations would be necessary to find new original products
in accordance with local authenticity and habits of consumption
92
Norl.adiic cutitun[ rltTadi.tion.. MongoRan d;airy I)rodiucts
INCREASING DAIRY PRODUCTION IN MONGOLIA
Dr Eva Jonsson
Department Of Food Science Swedish University Of
Agricultural Science Uppsala. Sweden
Abstract
Mongolia, a very special dairy country, with a large area but few inhabitants, has
an ancient and rich dairy tradition. Milk is of great importance both for consumers
and producers.
A major problem is to collect and process milk from remote areas of the country in
order to supply the urban populations, mainly of Ulaanbaatar, with high quality
dairy products.
Milk has to be collected and processed as soon as possible after milking. If not
refrigerated, its keeping time is very short and the distances it can be transported
and limited. An option is to arrange collection points equipped with cooling tanks
close to the milk production sites. If cooling is not feasible, the lactoperoxidase
system can be used to prolong the handling time of milk while retaining its quality.
A payment system, which reflects the milk quality, should be used and the farmers
should have access to education, advice, veterinary and other services.
Processing of the milk could include dehydration and concentration of specific
nutrients (milk powder, butter, butter oil, dried yoghurt, cheese or ultrahigh
temperature treatment (UHTmilk)). As the milk supply is highest in the warm
summer, the need for all these dairy products is evident.
General
Although not a Mongolian, I have taken the liberty of making an overview of the
Mongolian dairy sector, with emphasis on the raw milk production. The background
for this boldness is contacts with Mongolian dairy experts and studies of dairy
Intematlona[ Scientiflc symposium
93
development in connection with my work with the Swedish lnternational Dairy
Training Program and the course "Udder health, hygiene and milk quality".
Conditions
Mongolia is a country with very special conditions, having an extensive land area
with few inhabitants. In fact it is one of the countries with the lowest number of
persons per square kin.
About 80% of the land is suitable for extensive animal husbandry. The climate is
continental with cold winters and hot summers and the rainfall is sparse. The rain
that falls comes mainly in the summer months.
For survival in this mountainous and road less country, the survival has been
closely connected to a nomadic and herding lifestyle. A large number of domestic
animals are kept in different parts of the country according to suitability of the
climate and the environment, comprising cows, sheep, goats, horses, camels, yaks
and reindeer.
Both milk and meat are of great importance in the diet of the people. Mongolia has
thus an ancient and rich dairy tradition where milk is of great importance both for
consumers and for the producers.
In 1990, Mongolia decided to abandon central planning and a privatization process
was started. In connection to this, the dairy sector suffered serious drawbacks as
wellestablished, large state dairy farms were closed down and the milk collection
system also went out of function.
Supplying the country with dairy products
There is a great need of dairy products for the urban populations, especially in
Ulaanbaatar, which harbours approximately a third of the country's population of
2,37 millions inhabitants. However, the major part of the milk production is taking
place in the countryside. It is estimated that 290 million tons ofmilk were produced
in the country in the year 2001, but only I,2 million tons were delivered to the
dairy plants (less than 0.5% to be compared with the figures of 1990, when 60
million tons of milk were delivered to the dairies).
The consumption patterns also reflects the uneven distribution of milk and dairy
products; city people consume approximately 55 kg of milk per person and year,
while the rest of population takes around 153 kg per person and year.
The milk production is pronouncedly seasonal, with a peak during the summer
months. As milk is highly perishable, especially if not kept cool, it carmot be
94
Nomads cu[tura[ Tradit.on. "ongohan alatry protucts
transported over large distances, for example from the countryside to an urban
area, without being processed.
To make milk available to the city populations and to even out the seasonal
variation, milk can be concentrated and/or treated for long shelf life. Products like
cheese, butter, butter oil, UHTmilk and dried yoghurt are suitable for this. Such
products should be made close to the production sites and the products then
transported to the urban areas. In this way the transportation costs could also
bereduced.
Collection of milk
The milk should be collected and produced as soon as possible after milking,
preferably within a few hours, unless it is cooled or otherwise preserved. The
processing thus has to be made locally. This means that small scale processing
units (>5000 I/day capacity) are required, or possibly even microscale processing
units (>500 I/day capacity).
To get the necessary amounts of milk for the processing units, the system with
collection points should be reintroduced. The large distances involved and the
lack of roads and infrastructure makes this a challenging task.
Preferablythereshouldberefrigerationfacilitiesatthecollectionpointsascooling
is the first choice for preventing spoilage of milk. In cases where this is not feasible,
the second choice recommended by FAO/WHO is to activate an antibacterial
system already present in the milk. This system is based on the milk enzyme lacto
peroxidase and it can be used to prolong the handling time of milk while retaining
its quality. For example at the temperature of 30°C milk gets a stability time with
LPS of 78 hours, while at 15°C it is stable for 24 hours.
Lacto peroxidase system ups)
Milk contains naturally the enzyme lactoperoxidase which has the natural function
to help the young calf to destroy bacteria that might grow in its stomach. Milk also
contains as ion called thiocyanate, just like the blood ofhumans and animals. This
ion occurs in high levels in the blood of people who smoke or eat cabbage.
When these two components of the milk encounter the substance hydrogen
peroxidase, an antibacterial reaction will take place. The numbers of bacteria in the
milk will be drastically reduced and hence the keeping time of the raw milk can be
extended for several hours depending on the temperature. Eventually part of the
bacteria will recover and start growing again, so it is no method for sterilization.
Intematlona[ Sclentif ic symposlum
_
95
The use of LPS in srfuations where milk cannot be properly chilled is strongly
promoted by FAO/WHO and the IDF. The Codex Alimentarius Commission
regulates its use in Codex Guidelines CAC/GL 131991. It is, for example, also
allowed to be used in Sweden since 1980.
Activation of LPS requires that hydrogen peroxide is added to the milk. This is
most commonly done in the form of an enzyme and a substrate. The amounts of
hydrogen peroxide involved are extremely low. In case the cows do not eat cabbage
related plants, small amounts of thiocyanate ious are also added. The effects on
human health of LPS have been investigated and found negligible. Also, the milk
will still be ale to be used as a raw material for production of the usual dairy
products.
Addition of LPS to raw milk should be done in a controlled way by trained staff, for
exampleatamilkcollectionpoinlFordetailedinformationpleaseseew\"r.fao.org.
Quality control
High quality products have to be based on high quality raw material and this
requires a payment system, which reflects the milk composition and hygiene.
Also, it is important that the legislation of the country is up to date when it comes
to quality demands.
Important qualfty aspects are fat and dry matter or fat and protein content, while
the hygienic parameters could include numbers of bacteria, number of somatic
cells, absence of veterinary drngs and water addition. Today, the clotronboiling
method is commonly used for testing the quality of the raw milk at the reception at
the dairy plants. In the future, this method could be exchanged for the more
sensitive alcohol test method.
Benefitscouldbederivedfromhavingacooperativesystemforlocalmilkcollection
and processing, but the farmers/herders themselves should take the initiative to
establish such a system, otherwise it is not likely succeed.
The best way to induce production of high quality milk is if the market will pay
higher prices for high quality dairy products and that this can be reflected in the
prices paid to the milk producers. Premium prices for high quality raw milk and
lower prices for milk of a lower qualfty are efficient means to direct the quality
work.
However, when introducing a payment system based on milk quality, the current
situation has to be the starting point. The milk producers must also be given the
means and the knowledge for a high quality dairy production. This could include
access to extension services, production means as well as veterinary and other
96
Nomadic cu[tura[ Tradition: gylongoRari alalry |]Toducts
services. Education and training with handron practices are also important for the
progress of the sector, both for the milk producers and for the people working
with milk processing.
Another important aspects is that the public, i.e. the consumers, have to be aware
of quality aspects of the dairy products and also the potential dangers with raw
milk. For example, tasting raw milk in the market or on the doorstep may be
hazardous with regard to the bacteria Brzfce//cr and E. co/r..
Supportfordairydevelopment
The Food and Agriculture Organization ¢AO) has staff that works with the
stimulation of dairy production in developing countries. Recently they also started
collaboration with the lntemational Dairy Federation (IDF) for this purpose. There
is plenty of information available on the web site www.fao.org regarding many
different developmental and technical aspects, for example how to find sinal I scale
dairy processing units.
In 2000, FAO also organized an email conference on "Small scale milk collection
and processing in developing countries". This material is availat]le on their website.
There is also a Dairy Development Newsletter spousored by the FAO and produced
in collaboration with the IDF. This newsletter is free of charge and it can subscribed
to by contacting Mr. Antony Bennet, c/o Animal production and Health Division,
DAO, 00100 Rome, Italy or send him email under the address:
Antony.Bermett@,fao.org.
There are also possibilities to send participants in international training program
on various subjects in different countries in the world, for example the Netherlands,
Denmark and Sweden. Some courses for example on Rural development and Dairy
Technology are given on a yearly basis, while other courses on more specialized
aspects are arranged on a more temporary basis. For example Sweden via its
development assistance agency Sida (www.sida.se) will provide the intemational
course "Food safety, quality control systems and legislation on food and food
production", starting 2003 .
Another most important aspects is to establish networks with countries with
similar conditions and development goals. Such networks often have the best
success if they are based on individuals that find it stimulating and worthwhile to
collaborate.
Internatiorta[ Sclentif lc symposium
97
KEFIR FUNGI. THE PROSPECTS OF USING
BI0TECHNOLOGICAL PROPERTIES
TO PRODUCE DAIRY PRODUCTS
D.Sc (Engineering) N. 1. Khamnaeva
EastSiberian state University Of Technology
Research into kefir fungi as a symbiotic conglomeration of prokaryotes
and eukariotes fundamentally differing in their properties is of both scientific and
great practical interest. The mechanism of utilizing nutritious substances from
medium, namely lactose, by microbial fungi cells is connected with the function of
specific permeas, catalyzing preparatory and subsequent metabolic processes
metabolism. On the basis of literature review, the process of utilizing lactose by
procariote cell can be shown as follows. Dimeric carbohydrate (So) after hydrolysis
and subsequent phosphorizing forms two different monomers a phosphorolyzea
one (SMP), which catalyzes to an end native one (SM) which can be absorbed and
used by prokaryotic cell and excrefed out through cellar surface due to development
of concentration gradient in the system "cell medium", and flun in the course of
exhausting in the medium SD, SM is a subject to utilization again.
Provided mixed proand eukariote population is developed, if will be
evident that instead of reutilization, monomer SM is the source of eukariote
counterpart nutrition which is responsible for availability of connection like
prokariote eukariote through the substrate SM.
Production value and ecological safety of feods take a particular
importance the uptodate problems of developing food technology.
Technologies providing fermentation of milk for 3.5 5.5 hours, good
theological data of protein structures, season variation stability of milk composition
are found to be more suitable.
Methods of obtaining dietelu beverages with shorttime technological
cycle and highquali stable indices in the finished product have been worked out.
The main point of the first method is to mix skim milk with curd whey in
ratio 5: I, then the mixture is pasteurized and cooled. The starter consisting of
98
Nomadic cu[tura[ qJradiition: Iuongo[ian drairy products
str.acidophibim, kefir fung oid culture, str.cremoris st. 3M5, taken in ratio I :4.5:4.5
accordingly are introduced into the mixture. The culture process takes plane at a
temperature of from 200 to 220.
The second method of obtaining a sour milk beverage offers milk whey
use. Whey is subjected to initial pasteurization, filtration, cooling. Then 35%
starter of acidophilus bacillus is introduced and held for 4.0 4.5 hours, 57%
starter of kefir fungus at a temperature from 30 to 32°c is next introduced, and
fermentation up to acidify at 95100°F is brought about 4.05.0% black cuurants
are added.
The new ways of making sour milk beverages are patented (No 1813394
A I and No 1741720 A I ).
Intemationa[ Sctentif lc symposium
99
DEVELOPMENT OF DAIRY ACIDIFIED FUNCTIONAL
MILK PRODUCTS
Ph.S.I.Arluhova
Omsk city, Russia
The problem of proper and healthy
food was one of the most important faced
problems of the humanity. Milk products
have one the most significant role in
human
food.
Russian
scientist
|I~.I.Mechnikov(18451916)kn?unby.his
famous theory of fighting against aging
was the fist who studied and evaluated
importance of dairy acidified milk
products. Among many different dairy
acidified milk products sour cream is out
standing due to very high nutrition
characteristics. Sour cream is a Russian
national dairy acidified milk product. It
can be produced in a way of processing of nomalized and pasteurized sweet
cream by starter culture souring, which has been prepared using clear culture of
the milk acidified streptococcus on a lower temperature. Outside of our country
sour cream is not well known and the sinilar products have names such as "acidified
cream" or "cream for dressing". Current product named in relation with word
"sweep", e.g. it means to sweep away from milk surface captured and
spontaneously soured layer of sweet cream. Sour cream differs from other milk
product by very high fat presence. This quality assign to current product high
nutritious value and outstanding taste quality. Sour cream contain many vitamins
and it is enriched by fat dissolving vitamins. Due to change happening with milk
protein in souring process, sour crean assimilates by human body faster and
loo
Nomadic cu[tura[ q=radition: enongoaan d;airy prod:uct5
easily compared of sweet cream having the same fat presence. The specific quality
of this product allow to prepare many different dishes. All these characteristics
made sour cream very popular in our country.
Currently has been elaborated direction of development and production
of dairy acidified milk products by starter culture having wide spectra of micro flora
(such as bioproducts and products of functional dietary e.g. probiotics). The
metabolic outcome of this starting culture plays important role in different diseases
prevention. It has been proved, that probiotical products is necessary and can be
used to prevent and to medicate functional and inflectional disbalances of the
gastric and intestinal alimentary canals, disbacteriosis and in case of long term
consumption of antibacterial medicaments.
The role of the functional diet in support of the human bacterial ecology,
the most significant is to support micro flora of gastric and intestinal alimentary
canals. In particular, among different representatives of the normal human micro
flora lato and bifidobacterias are very important. They have leading role of
supporting and normalization processes of microbiozenosis inside of the gastric
and intestinal alimentary canals; helps to increase nonspecific resistance of the
human body; inproves the protein and mineral balances and etc. All current features
shows, that lato and bifidobacterias could be served as a basic and main parameter
for functional diet design. Moreover, the bifidobacteria nutritious characteristics
showed strong resistance to pathogenic and conditional pathogenic micro bodies.
This could be used to increase sanitary and hygiene safety of the traditionally
consumed and the most bacteria vulnerable of the dairy acidified sour cream milk
products.
Many biotechnological principals are exist for production of fermented
products. One of them is based on construction and combination of different
micro bodies (starter culture) consortiums and bifidobacterial concentrates. The
main objective is to guarantee sustainable micro ecological level (called
bifidogenetical factor) and amount of viable cells of micro bodies (not less then
108~109 in one cm/gr3) and mininum amount ofbifidobacterias (40%). Some other
methods of production dairy acidified functional milk products is also possible by
enrichment of starter culture within different species and polycomponents. The
starter culture at this case will have very high biochemical activity status and
resistance to unfavorable factors of the surrounding environment compared to
starter culture prepared by single culture. The outcome product will have very
new functional features. In our particular case will be very important, that cultures
used in composition ofpolycomponential culture should be biologically compatible
with each other.
InternatiorLa[ Scientif a sympostum
101
At present microbiologists determined that the main characteristics of
culture micro bodies is not dependant from external factors of the environment
(temperature, composition of nutritious ground, technogenic factors and etc) only,
but characteristics of used particular bacterial stains is also important. We proposed
to produce dairy acidified functional milk products by use of starter culture
composed from different genus taxonomic bacteria's. This designed multi type
starter culture having contents and symbiotical composition is not always stable
and cannot keep valuable characteristics important in production. This can be
understandable in matter of influence of external factors and also by interaction
process within different type and sub type of bacteria on molecule level within
each other. In multi culture types processes of genetic material exchange, closters
flow, formation of big conjugated closters, transfer of closters from one cell to
another and other changes on cell and population level are happens. This changes
within cell culture is the main factors which promotes changes of single stems and
cultures in general.
In Omsk State Agricultural University carried out research in order to
select optimal proportions and cultivation temperatures for 4 types of national
bacteria to produce sour cream and bifidobacterial concentrate having probiotjc
characteristics.
The main objective of conducted research was on design of
polycomponential culture and to produce sour cream having stable biotechnological
valuable characteristics of different lato and bifidobacteria. The objective included
selection of optimal cultivation temperature and conditions for immediate culture
insertion into normalized mixed solution.
In order to select optimal culture has been used different versions of
starter culture. Experimental work selected necessary parameters of acidifled milk,
bifido bacteria and starter culture in order to produce dairy acidified milk product.
We considered following parameters: souring acidify of the milk; limitation and
amount of energy of acid process; the reaction to bacteriophage, phenol, alkaline
amount of the ground, fragrance ability, sensor indicators, micro preparation,
moisture capability of the blobs and compatibility of cultures within each other.
As a result conducted research helped to design polycomponential starter
culture composed from Lactococcus lactis subsp.Iactis; Lactococcus lactis
susp.cremoris; Lactococcus lactis subsp.biovar.diacetylactis; Streptococcus
salivarius subsp.thermophilius; Bifidobacterium longum; Bifidibacterium bifidum.
Current culture has stable composition and valuable biotechnological
characteristics of existing micro bodies. The optimal poloycomponential starter
culture and production parameters for sour cream production, such as optimal
relational level of laktobacteria and bifidobacterias cultures and temperature of
102
Nomadic cu[tura[ Tradiitron: 9rf,ongohan alairy products
cultivation has been selected. The results of carried out experiments shows, that
temperature degree of cultivation have relation and influence to blob moisture
holding capacity and amount of presenting bifidobacteria cells. Experimentally
has been determined, that negative impact of different cultures within each other
were not observed. Received polycomponential starter culture is highly
biochemically active, has good fragrance development ability, resistant to
bacteriophage, phenol and alkaline reaction of the ground. The produced sour
cream has high antibacterial, prevention features and therefore increased biological
value. Conducted literature research and obtained results showed, that to produce
dairy acidified milk product having new functional features will be necessary to
use designed consortium of different micro bodies. By other words is useful to
use different bacteria association and their combinations and possibly it should
be cultivated separately. Long term cultivation of polycomponential starter culture
showed negative effects to their stability features. Now days is known more than
20 types of bifidobacteria. The basis of human body micro flora mainly composed
from B.bifidum, B.Iongum, B.adolescentis,B.breve and B.infantis type. Russian
microbiologists determined, that B.bifidum is found among all age groups within
healthy population and it is dominant within baby groups and it is clearly identified
within 70% of the observed and 40% of the children of4 to 6 years old. B.Iongum
is distinctive for children and adults people group. Within children group it was
detemined from 40 to 60% of the babies of first year of life and within 70 to 75% of
the children grown up age, adults of middle age and within old age people it is
present only in 30% of observed cases. B.adolescentis is distinctive for adults
and children of grown up group and was determined of 6065% of the observed
cases. This type get dominant in old age groups later on (around 85%). B.breve
and B.infantis and their sub type has been determined and it is dominant with
children of baby group. Taking into consideration the fact, that in polycomponential
starter culture composition we use B.bifidum and B.Iongum type mean, that current
received sour cream product possibly could be recommended within specific age
groups such as children and middle age adults. In this regard selected
polycomponential starter culture based on lakto and bifidobacteria could essentially
increase production amount of final product, help to increase sanitary and hygienic
safety and have medical and prevention characteristics and possibly to expand
assortment of probiotical milk products which can be used within particular age
groups. The main technological characteristics of sour cream production will be
on selection of national polycomponential starter culture, which should have
immediate insertion capability and final product should have long time storage
capacity.
Intematrona[ Sclenlif c sym|}osium
103
A NEW APPROACH FOR INDUSTRIAL USE 0F LACTIC
ACID BACTERIA IN KOREA
Prof. Kang Kook Hee
Faculty Of Life science and Technology,
Sungkyungwan Univers ity
Lactic acid bacteria are used for 3 fields of yogurts, kimchi and
probiotics for men and animals in Korea. The fermented milk was begun since 1971
in Korea. The first product was Yacult which is fermented by lactobacillus casei.
Now we have 20 companies for fermented milk production in Korea.At that time,
we had big problems for the production of fermented milks that are raw milk quality
and bacteriophage contamination with seed culture.The phage contamination in
the Yacult plant was solved by using phagecured strain. The research institue of
Korea Yakult succeeded in research to remove this phage gene.At coming into
fermented process, we experienced various kinds of many problems. Other yogurt
makers are now using the mixed starters of lactic acid bacteria and have no problems
of bacteriophages.
Acid quality problem of raw milk was improved rapidly introducing grade
system of bacteria and somatic cell number since 1996. Recently about 80% of raw
milk production was below 100.000/ ml in bacterial count.
Kimchi is very famous as Korean representative traditional food which
makes raw materials. We does not sterilize vegetable and appetites and make
kimchi without adding starter.
Even if we does not add starter for kimchi, lactic acid bacteria attached to
raw material of kimchi are growing exactly. Lately, research is going on adding
lactic acid bacteria to Kimchi and improve functional quality. For example GABA
produsing lactobacillus is using as starter to make Kimchi.
We are expecting a new uses of lactic acid bacteria as probiotics in silage,
domestic anilmals feeding, fish and shrimp fain, and agriculture etc.
I. What are probiotics?
Probiotics have been defined as live microbial food supplement which
beneficially affect the host by improving the intestinal microbial balance, or more
104
Nomadic cu[tura[ q:raditton: 94ongotiiari d;airy products
broadly, as' living microorganisms, which upon ingestion in certain numbers, exert
health affects beyond inherent basic nutrition'(I)
2. Desirable characteristics of microorganisms for probiotics
The most important properties for future probiotics include the acid and
bile tolerance, adherence the human intestinal mucosa, temporary coloniztion of
the host gastrointestinal tract, production of antimicrobial substances and
inhibition of pathogen growth(2)
In summary, to fulfill these criteria probiotics microorganisms should:
*Be of human (host) origin
*Demostrate nonphatogenic behavior.
*Exhibit resistance to technological processes (i.e., viability and
activity in delivery vehicles).
*Prove resistance to gastric acid and bile.
*Adhere to gut epithelial tissue.
*Be able to persist, albeit for short periods, in the gastrointestinal tract.
*Produce antimicrobial substances.
*Modulate immune responses.
*Have the ability to influence metabolic activities (e.g., cholesterol
assimilation, lactase activity, vitamin production).
*Heat tolerance (survival during pelleting of creep feed)
3. Isolation of potential probiotic bacteria
The development of new probiotics has been based on the outlined
decision tree presented in Figure I (3). Most current probiotics have been selected
in a similar marmer.
Strain
Origin (components ofa healthy human intestinal micro flora)
Criteria
Biosafely (Safel in human use)
Biological
properties
Activity and viability (activity in the intestinal conditions)
Resistance to low pH
Gastricjuice
Bile
Pancreaticjuice
Physiological
Adherence to intestinal epithelium and mucus properties
and/or
Antogoism against phatogens
Antimicrobial activity
and/or
Stimulation of immune response (GALT)
and/or
Internationa[ Scientiifec symposium
lo5
Selective stimulation of beneficial bacteria and suppression of harmful
bacteria
and/or
Beneficial systemic effects on the gut barrier system
Fig. I . Selection criteria for probiotics to enhance gut barrier
mechanisms (3).
4. Beneficial effects of probiotics
Lactic acid bacteria, which are frequently used as probiotics, possess a
number of antagonistic properties that operate by (4):
*decreasing the ph by the production of lactic acid
*consumption of available nutrients
*decreasing the redox potential
*production of hydrogen peroxide (under aerobic conditions)
*production of specific inhibitory components, such as
bacteriocins
Fuller (5) listed the possible modes of action of such selected probiotics
as follows: suppression of the vialble counts of phatogens and harmful bacteria,
alteration of microbial metabolism (enzyme activity), and stimulation of the immune
response. When Escherichia coli infect the bladder, they can adhere using
electrostatic and hydrophilic binding, but most likely require type I fimbriae for
irreversible adhesion (6).
5. Probiotics for farm animals
1. Microorganisms used in probiotics
Lactobacillus, together with Bacillus sp., yeasts nad filamentous fungi
are the main components of the probiotics commonly used for farm animals today
(Table 1) (7)
Table 1. Microorganisms used in probiotics for farm animals
Lactobacillus acidophilus
Laclobacillus casei ss,casei
Lactobaillus reuteri
Lactobacillus plantarum
Streptoccocus salivarius ss,thermof illus
Enterococcus faecium
Enterococcus faecalis
Bif ildobaclerium pseudolongum
Bif idobacterium brevis
Bacillus subtilis
Bacillus cereus
Bacillus mesentericus
Bacillus licheniformis
Clostridium butyricum
P ediococcus penlosaceus
]06
Nomadic cwhuta[ a:radi"on: 9vi.ongo[ian d:airy prorfucts
Sacchoromyces cerevisiae
2. Probiotic effects
The potential benefits that can arise from applications of the probiotic
concept are shown in Table 2(7)
Table 2. Potential beneficial effects ofprobiotics for farm animals (7)
Greater resistance to infectious diseases
Increased growth rate
Improved feed conversion
Improved digestion
Better absorption of nutrients
Provision of essential nutrients
Increased milk yield
Improved milk quality
Increased egg production
Improved egg quality
Improved carcass quality and less contamination
Health control such as the prevention of intestinal disturbances.
Especially in young animals
Predigestion of antinutritional factors.e.g. trypsin inhibitors.
Phytic acid, glucosinolates
3. Probiotics for pigs
Sedo (8) compared postweaning performance of pigs fed a starter feed
with the same microbial culture to a feed grade antibiotic.
They observed that the pigs reseiving the probiotic in their feed were
equal to or superior in daily gain, intake, and feed efficiency compared to pigs fed
the antibiotic (table3).
Treatment
Number of pigs
Antibiotica
36
lnintial weight (Kg)
Final weight (Kg)
Weight gain (Kg)
Daily gain (8)
Feed intake (Kg)
Feed/gain ratio
Probioticb
41
8.6
7.6
38.4
41.2
29.8
33.6
473
525
®
72.8
232
2.17
4. Sefely of novel probiotics
New and more specific strains of probiotic bacteria are being sought.
There is a potential risk associated with introduction of novel probiotic organisms
into foods for human consuption.Before their incorporation into products new
|r'ternat.or'a[ S c'er'tf ic syrnpostum
J1|
strains should be carefully assessed and tested for the safety and efficacy of their
proposed use.The fol lowing suggestion and recommendations have been proposed
as suitable models and methods to test the safety of probiotic bacteria (5)
Determine the intrinsic properties of bacteria and strains selected for
probiotic use. E.g. adhesion factors, degradation of intestinal mucus, antibiotic
resistance, plasmid transfer potential, enzyme profile.
Assess the effects of the metabolic products of the bacteria.
Assess the acute and subacute toxicity of ingestion of extremely large
amounts of the bacteria.
Estimate the in vitro infective properties of probiotic bacteria using cell
lines and human intestinal mucus degradation.Assess infectivity in animal models,
e.g., immunocompromised animals or lethally irradiated animals.
Detemine the efficacy of massive probiotic doses on the composition of
human intestinal micro flora.
Carefully assess side effects during human volunteers studies in various
diseasespesific states.
Conduct epidemiological surveillance of people ingesting large amounts
of newly introduced probiotics bacteria for ingestion, and surveillance of the use
of traditional strains.
Undertake the most rigorous safety testing along the above lines for
genetically modified strains and strains derived from animals.
References
I. Schaafsma G.State of the art concerning probiotic strains in milk products.IDF
Nutrition Newsletter 5:2324.1996
2. Lee YK.Salminen S.The coming of age of probiotics.Trends in Food Sci
Techn.6: 24 I 245 .1995
3.
Huis lntt Veld,
J.H.J.,and
Short
C.Selection
criteria for probiotic
microorganisms.The Royal Society of Medicine. International Congress and Symposium
Series, 219:2736,1996
4. Havenaar R. Brink B.T, and Jos. H.J.. Huis in `t Veld. Selection of strains for
probiotics use ln:Fuller R(Ed) Probiotics`the scientific basis (pp 209224).Chapman and
Hall,London,1992
5.
Fuller, R. Probiotics in man and animals, J. Appl. Bact., 66: 365,1989
6. Reid, G., Howard, J„ and Gan, a. S. Can bacterial interference prevent infection
?, Trends in Microbiology, 9(9) September : 424428, 2001
7. Fuller, R. Probiotics for farm animals. In: Tannock, G.W.(Ed) probiotics. A
critical review (pp 1522), horizon scientific , England,1999.
Sedo. Agricultural Experimental Station Report. University of Barselona.
Barselona. Spain.1986.
108
Nomadic cu[tuta[ qraditron: 5MongoRan d;a.ry pud.uct§
Results Of study on the diagnosis Of mastititis in cow Of yak,
native mongolian and dairy breeds, and the udentification Of
causal agents Of the mastitis
J.Damdirsuren, PhD, A.Magash,ScD. S.Tsevelmaa. MSc,
State Central Laboratory Of Veterinary & Sanitation
School Of Welerinary Science & Biotechnology,
Mongolian State University Of Agriculture
Summary
I. Of all yak cows in the aimags involved in the survey, 14% suffered from clinical
mastitis, 25 ,4% suffered from subclinicaL mastitis, where as it was 12,0% and 3 5,71 %
respectively in native mongolian cows.
2. Fourty five persent of dairy cows of simmental, alatau breeds and their hybrids,
bred around Ulaanbaatar city suffer from clinical mastitis and inflammation of
udder accounted for 19% of them. Subclinical mastitis represents for 42%.
3.The percentages of correct diagnosis of subclinical mastitis by using
bromtinolblau, Bemburgs and California mastitis tests were 3 5%, 97,7% and loo,0%
respectively.
4.Such pathogenic bacteria as S.aureus, S.epidemitis, Str.agalactiae, Str.uberis,
Klebsella pneumoniae, E.coli and Bacillus cereus were detected from milk and
infiltrate from inflamed udder quarter.
Intemationa[ Sctentif ¢ Syapouium
109
LACTOPEROXIDASE SYSTEM AS TEMPORARY
PRESERVATIVE FOR ROW MILK IN MONGOLIA
D. Enkhlsetseg, Research Institute Of Animal Husbandry,
Agricultural University Of Mongolia.
Summary
The effectiveness of the lactoperoxidase system (LPS) on the longterm
storage of raw milk was tested under varying field dairying conditions. The raw
cow milk supplied by individual farmers was treated with LPS. Nonactivated raw
milk served as control to compare the preservative quality of LPS. The samples
with and without LPS activating was stored at 4, 10, and 25°C for 72, 48, 12 hours.
The immediate changes in the acidify of milk samples were tracked and the time
when the acidify exceeded over standard value was recorded. It was found that
the acidify of samples of raw milk without LPSactivation showed much faster
increase in comparison to LPSactivated ones. A conclusion was drawn that LPS
can be used as an agent for extended storage of raw cow milk in field conditions of
Mongolia.
Introduction
To keep quality of milk in developing countries, generally, is still not
feasible and will remain so for some time. This is because of following reasons.
collection and transportation of milk still face technical and organizational
problem;
milk is produced at bad /poor hygienic conditions;
lackofcoolingfacilities.
Cooling during collection storage and transportation is the best way to
keep the quality of raw milk. However, because of economic and practical reasons,
this is stil I not possible to apply in developing countries. Consequently, supporting
the natural antibacterial system in milk can offer an immediate and practical solution
to these current problems. Since the effectiveness of the system is reported to be
I io
gviomdic cu[tura[ Tradition: mongoaan chtry products
dependent upon the temperature, it is essential to assess the effectiveness of LPS
under Mongolian conditions, where the temperature is around 30°C at summer
time.
Literature review
Lactoperoxidase system (LPS) is an indigenous antibacterial system in milk and
human saliva. The activity of this system dependent on three components
Lactoperoxidase, thiocyanate and hydrogen peroxide. Lactoperoxidase and
thiocyanate are naturally occurring in milk while hydrogen peroxide has to be
supplied from an exogenous source, Bjorck,L( 1979).
The lactoperoxidase (LP) from cows milk is characterized by its heat stability,
since it retains its activity in normal pasteurization of milk( 63 °C in 30 minute or 72
°C in 15 seconds) but is destroyed at 80 °C in 2.5 seconds, Korhonen,H.(1980).
Thiocyanate is a ubiquitous anion in animal tissue and secretions. It occurs in the
mammary, salivary and thyroid glands, in the stomach, kidney and in fluids such
as synovial, cerebral, spinal, lymph and plasma, Reiter,B.( 1985).
Cows milk norlnally contain I 10 ppm, depending on feeding regime of the cow,
Hope,K.( 1971 ). Cows in natural pastures, containing clover and other non grasses,
give milk with higher concentration of thiocyanate than cows on winter feed grass
only, Lawrence,A.J.( 1970).
Hydrogen Peroxide is generally assumed to be absent from milk. Although the
mammary tissue is metabolically very active during lactation, any H202 formed is
rapidly reduced by catalase or peroxidase, Reiter,B.( 1985).
Objectives
Identify the effectiveness of LPS system on the changes of acidify of
raw cow milk stored in different temperatures;
Determine the time when the acidity of milk exceeds the standard values;
Materials and methods.
Chemicals..
1. LPSactivator of scientifically controlled composition and quality according to
the
national specifications of the Joint FAO/ WHO Expert Committee on Food
Additives. LPSconsists from Sodium Thiocyanate ( NascN) and Hydrogen
Peroxide (30%) .
2. Raw milk samples
Intemattona[ Scientrf u: Symposium
111
Raw milk samples were obtained from bulk storage tanks at collection point of
" Jargalant" village at Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia.
Methods:
1. Guidelines for the Preservation of Raw Milk by Use of the
Lactoperoxidase system ( CAC/GL 131991 )
ActivatorI thiocyanate
Activator2 hydrogen peroxide
2. Titratable acidity test
Experiment design
Six glass bottles of 1000 ml consisted of control and treated milk were
assigned to one of three storage temperatures. The three storage temperature
were 4°C,10°C and 25°C. Lactoperoxidase (LP) activated and control milk were
tested for acidity according to the titratable
acidify test at two hours interval.
Criteria was the time when the acidify exceeds over the standard value.
Results and discussion
As specified in Materials and Methods, LPS activated and control samples
were undergone to twohours interval acidity testing. A comparative analyses of
the way acidity of LPStreated and control samples perfomed as shown in Figure
1 a and Figure lb.
The initial acidity of milk samples used in this experiment was 18 °T( 1820
°T ) which is to be regarded as standard values. In terms of changes in the acidify,
LPSactivated and treatmentfree samples behaved differently in a strong
dependency with the temperatures they stored in. In general, the acidify increased
faster in high temperatures while low temperatures significantly retained the acidify
to remain at much lower value for longer time.
As far as the character of changes in the acidify of samples kept at
different temperatures are concerned, for those samples stored at 4, only 36 hours
required the acidity to be in limits of the standard values, whereas LPStreated
samples were more durable and unchanged for 72 hours. At 10 °C, acidify of LPS
activated samples resisted to be lower than standard values, although non
activated samples lived shortly 22 hours.
Nomadiic cu[tura[ qraal.tion: Mongohan d:airy protucts
112
Figure la. Acidity oT mi)k in (LPS) activated and control milk at 4°C
tl
19
20
21
22
Acidity CT
€
Nontreated
I
+LPDactivated
Fi]!:.pela.Addity.fnilkilLPSactivatedallc®|tr®lmilE8t®[edat10°C
and |®|co.led CS°O
18
19
20
21
22
Acidify OT
Nontreated 10 C +. lJrs <ictivated at 10 C ± l\brrfeated 25 C ```...`.~t``.`` LF§ <ictivated at 25 C
Internationa[ Scientif e¢ Symi)os.urn
113
THE TECHNOLOGICAL BASIS FOR GOAT MILK
PROCESSING IN MONGOLIA
Ch.TsendAuysh, Ph.D, MUST
By early 2002 the number of livestock reached 26.0 million and 9.6 million
36.8% is goats.Mongolia is the second leading country in number of goats per
loo people.The one main factor that influences the growth number of goats are the
market demand on high quality cashmere.There fore the goat is herd even in the
mountainous and Gobi area.The result of Dr.Damdinsuren`s research showed
that 60.0 million litres of goat milk can be processed to produce milk and other
dairy products.Mongolians have an ancient tradition where goat milk has been
used as a children`s nutritions food.But any serious researches haven`t been
done on defining the particularities of goat milk quality and it`s processing
technology.There fore we have worked out the technology basis to process goat
milk and produce (fermented) food for babies and using it as a curative agent.
I.
Composition and structure of goat milk.
According to the research which done in spring and summer,it`s clear
that goat milk is rich in proteins and lipids.(Table.I)
Milk components%
Mongolian
Dry substances
Fat
Protein
Caseins
Lactose
Minerals
Goat milk
European
Cow milk
1 3 . 9 I + 1 . I
11. 76+1.07
12.50+I.2
4.30+0.20
3 .44+0.31
3.80+0.50
3.93+0.15
3.00+019
3.45+0.20
2.46+0.16
2.80+0.10
4.78+0.21
4.30+0.19
4.70+0.06
0.90+0 04
0.71+0.08
0.70+0.15
3.30+0.33
114
Nomadic cu[tura[ q:T;a&itron: 9wlongohan chny products
Goat milk is very nutritions,high in quality,and rich in whey protein
particularly in essential fatty acids,linoleinic acid content in goat milk two times
more than in cow milk.Micell is much simular to mother`s ones.
I. Speciric technology characteristics
We have done our experiments on loo different samples of goat milk and
also we established some technological particularities.Our research shows that
goat milk is not good to withstand the heat therefore it must be considered to
produce milk and dairy products. (Fig.1)
11
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Time,month
But goat milk could keep its bactericid particularities for 48 hours.
1.
Processingtechnologyofgoat milk
According to Mongolian tradition and other countries experience goat
milk should mainly be used for producing fermented milk products,traditional
dairy products,soft cheese and nutritions for babies.(Fig.2)
JJJ
Intematrom[ S tie ntif ic Symposium
Much research works and research were done in the field of fermented
milk technology depending on market demand and nutritions factor.Also we set
the quality and mechanical characteristics,composition and storage limit of goat
milk.The research result concludes goat milk is pleasant environment for
bifidobacterium, acidifilium bacterias to grow as well as the period of is much
shorter than cow milk.We are carried out the technology of processing of goat
milkdependingonchemicalcompositionandalsofermentinggoatmilkbybifidium
and acidifilium baci
as.We are studied biochemical and microbiologial changing
during the fementation.
I
I
01234567
Time
General and active acidig change during fermentation of goat milk
1 ` 1 Fermentation by pure strain of L.acidophilus
2`2Fermentation by pure strain of Bifidium
Goat milk was a suitable medium for growth of acid and bifidobacterium
and femantation time more shorter than in cow milk.We are established
quality of fermented goat milk products,structure,mechanical
particularities and shelf life of products.
Conclusion
1.
The whey protein contents in Mongolian goat milk is high and
therefore this particularities give a possibilities to use it as a curative
agent.
2.
We are established the suitable technological processing of goat
milk and producing fermented products.
Fermentiumofgoatmilkby,purestrainbifidiumandacidofiliumbacterias
gave a healthful baby foods,also a good functional foods.It was confirmed by
clinical investigation.
116
Nbmedtc cu[tuta[ Tradiitron: "ongo[ran chtry prorfucts
DEVELOPMENT 0F THE ACCELERATED RIPENDIND OF
CHEESE BY FLAVOUR ENHANCING ENZYMES 0N THE
CHEESE PRODUCTION
Prof Kang Chil. Korea
I.The purpoes of study: this experiment was conducted whether the
bitter taste of accelerated ripened cheese (ARC) and enayme modified cheese(EMC),
which was prodused by a severe degradation of cheese proteins, cuold be degrated
or not by the hydrolytic action of aminopeptidase and X prolyl dipeptidyl
aminopeptidase from L casei FEPB5.The practical conditions and technology for
production of ARC cheese and EMC cheese were also studied.The flavour
characteristics of ARC cheese was compared with those of normal ripened Chedar
cheese and processed cheese products using the EMC cheese prepared
experimentally were cyaluated by the trained students and the industrial staffs.
2. Results and conclutions : The degree of ripening of ARC cheese made
experimentally according to the methods developed by this study was different
with the ripening periods. The degree of ripening of three or four ARC ripened for
2 month were close to that of midium cheese, while one of them was close to that
of extra old cheese. Two ARC cheese with the live cell and thecrude enzyme of L
casei FEPB5 were ripened withour bittemes andfproduse the full flavour of old
cheese (8 month lpd).The textural properties of ARC ripened for three month with
a commercial proteinase, neutrase, were close to those of old cheese rather than of
mild cheese.The debittering actions of the aminopiptidases from L casei FEPB5
were verified when bitter taste was prodused in hydrolysis of cheese protein by
the severe action of Neutrase and flavourenzyme, which has been considered as
one of the important processing steps in making EMC.
The debittering action of aminopeptidase was found when commercial
endopeptidases were inactivated by heating at 80°C. Commercial lipases
contributed to produse acceptable falvour without flavour defects.The taste of
EMC prepared has not been disappeared completely, but it could be masked by
the tastes of other ingredients and was evaluated as the acceptable level of taste.
On comparing the different type of processed cheese spreads with two
commercial cream cheeses which were improted. The process cheese spreads
containing EMC as well as tuna, peanut and a combination of garlic and red
pepper seed oil, respectively, were preferred to the cream cheese.
Iritemationa[ Sclellttf ic symposium
117
AN EXPERIMENTAL RESULT TO INVENT SOME
TECHNICAL FACILITIES TO PROCESS DAIRY
PRODUCTS IN FARM
ProfBaldangombo
B.Lhagvadorj
This is an attitude to develop cooperation between farms and cooperatives
in the transitional period of market system in Mongolia. There is few herdsmen
who are succeeding in raising their domestic animals and their product ivyty even
though all herdsmen wish it. Because of technological backwards of our animal
husbandry many factors influence negative on intencification of the production.
There are :
I. There are not any solutions to the problem ofherdsmen's manual work
and mechanization of the production because of lack of electrical supply
in the counrtyside.
2. There are few possibilities to keep cooperative kind of like because the
herdsmen still keep nomadic life.
3.
Low level of herdsmen's knowledge and skills and shortage of their
creative initiative is influencing negatively on animal husbandry
intensification that herdsmen organi zes the animal husbandry production
directly especially lack of milk processing and reprocessing equipment
the herdsmen do their work on their own hands (manual work) that causes
negative influence on productivity of labor.
Considering this situation lecturer of animal husbandry mechaization
electrification departmant invented simply made partly mechanized
technical facilities for herdsmen (houshold)
and have successfully experimented.
There are:
I.An invention and experiment of mechanical smallsized sucking
apparatus to milk Mongolian wellbreed cows have effectively confirmed for
production.
118
9vibndc cu[tura[ q=radiitton: anongo[ran d;airy prod:uct5
The apparatus's milking diametr is 19.6 mm and length is 43.03 mm for mechanical
massager is being used and confirmed as creative work based on increasing
milkmaid's labor productivity.
Mechanical reneved sucking apparatus compared with hand milking the speed
has risen by 37.5 per unf.
2.The invention of model of milk cooling equipment using natural frost
has been confirmed as a creative work of Mongolia.
3.In the scheme the experimental result of manual buffer processing
equipment in shown.
Considering this scheme we can see from picture 3 factoral changes depending on
rotation of the buffer processing barrel.
4.A smallsized equipment has been confirmed to make (worm shaped)
curds based on effectual experiment.
5 .Curd drying board
This equipment is portable and it has a waterproof roof. The curd also could be
dried in the sun.
This equipment has been confirmed in a milk farm of Arkhangai aimag lkh Tamir
sum by scientific station based on the effectual experiment.
6.The sour milk (aarts) and cheese pressing mechanization has been
invented and effectually introdused in the production.
7.Aarts (sour milk) and fodder drying collector is going to be introdused
in the production.
This equipment will dry not only dairy (milk) products but also varies kind of
fodder without losing their quality for a short tine.
8.Dairy product mixing equipment is placed mixing spare parts inside the
bucket with 20 liters capacity.This mixer is determined to mix dry materials 97 %
kinds within 23 minutes,
Consultation
1.
In the storage (lack) of electricity in the countryside introducing this
simply made (invented) dairy processing reprocessing technical facilities
will raise (improve) milkmaids and dairy product produsers on the products
quality.
2.
These smallsized equipments we considerthere is an sample opportunity
to introduse sufficiently these smallsized equipments for households
use.
IriteTriatiorLa[ Sciendf ic symposium
119
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSU ED BY TIIE PARTICIPANTS 0F TIIE
INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM "NOMADIC CULTURAL
TRADITIONSMongolianNationalDairyProducts"
To the State, Governmental and Research
Organizations, and scientists and researchers
We, the scientists and researches, express our deep appreciation to the
Ministry of Food and Agriculture, the Mongolian Academy of Science, the
Mongolian University of Science and Technology the Scientific Academy, the
Mongolian Food Industry Association for organizing the lnternational Symposium
"Nomadic cultural traditionsMongolian dairy products", dedicated to the 840th
anniversary of chingis Khaan birth and the 800th armiversary of establishment of
the Great Mongol Empire and provided the opportunity to share information on
our discovery studies for the scientific basis of Mongolian traditional method to
prepare dairy products and its conversion ways into modem technology, to sum
up our findings and ideas.
The warm greeting message from H.E. N. Bagabandi, President of
Mongolia to the participants of the Symposium and his mind to develop in further
a fruitful cooperation among the researches and scientists in many countries
treated with deep honour.
This recommendations ;.sswec7 to the State, Governmental and Research
Organizations, private entities and scientists and researchers in different countries,
€mpAasi.zJ.#g that in Mongolia with dominant pastoral extensive livestock system,
the traditional dairy production is the main way to utilise milk resources and to
improve the population needs for the dairy products, #of!."g a support from the
Government of Mongolia for the traditional technology practices and the
importance of expanding all kinds of cooperation among state and research
organizations and institutions and bclsed on following:
I. To provide all kinds of support and assistance in frame of cooperation
between lnternational organizations and Governments, in order to implement the
12o
Nomditc cu[tum[ Tradition: enongohan d:airy prod:uct5
"White revolution" National program of the Government of Mongolia on milk and
dairy production;
2. To establish the lnternational Research Center of Mongolian dairy
products, in order to deepen the study of nature of the traditional dairy processing
method, to explore possibilities to convert this method into modem technology,
that further resolve the issue. of development of small and medium scale industries
in country and to organize the Scientific Symposium on certain subject once in
every two years;
3 . To provide condition and opportunities for the active participation of
Mongolian Research organizations, Institutions, researchers and specialists at
International forums, conferences, workshops and other events, organized by the
lnternational Dairy Federation, Asian Association of Milk Acid Bacteria;
4. To expand the international cooperation between Research
organizations, private enterprises and nongovernmental organizations in direction
to introduce the latest technologies and technique of dairy farms, small and medium
scaled milk processing, suitable in Mongolian condition, to improve the current
technological level of producers and to provide the food security; To implement
the specific programs, projects and measures through international organizations
and bilateral cooperation;
5. To cooperate in the areas of training and retraining of the Mongolian
researches, scholars, young research workers, engineers, specialists involved in
dairy study;
6. To assist the Mongolian Research institutions and scientists with
providing science and technology information on milk processing technologies
an dairy study.
We strongly believe that Governmental, Scientific and Research organizations,
scientists and researchers, enterprises and individuals after handed over this
recommendations, issued by the participants of the International Symposium
"Nomadic cultural traditions Mongolian dairy products" will contribute in the
development of Mongolian milk and dairy production sector, especially in the
production of traditional dairy products based of modern scientific and
technological achievements.
Participants orthe Symposium
22 September, 2002
Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia
RE
"BeM6u cail"
x.8Jiunuilil 2a3a|)
ISBN: 9992957891