Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” Reflections and Responses

Reflections on and responses to Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery" for discussion in Introduction to Literature class.

Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” Reflections and Responses Lisa Kneifl 9/20/18 “The Lottery” was written in 1948, what makes it so enduring is that no matter what year it was when the author wrote the story or what period she may have been thinking about when she created the setting, it could be any day in any community at any moment in history. Jackson’s opening tone was intended to give us a sense of an experience that could transcend time. “The people of the village began to gather in the sawyer, between the post office and the bank…” (221) “…the village, where there were only about three hundred people…” (221) “…in time to allow villagers to get home for noon dinner…” (221) Her choice of words, all very generic statements that don’t clarify time, but paint a picture of more of a “community” feel which could apply to any small town, anywhere in the world, at any time of history. Doing so, it makes the story relatable to all readers, no matter what generation they happen to be from. The ancient Aztec practice of human sacrifice along with the modern-day legal lapidation in many middle eastern countries came to mind as I read this story. The methods in "The Lottery" are not a new concept, scapegoating or selecting a sacrifice from one member of the community to assuage the gods or decision makers is still present in many places over the world. When Tessie draws the black spot and lets the words “It isn’t fair" (226) slip out for the first time, it is a plea to the townspeople to open their eyes to the ludicrous nature of this tradition. "…she held out her hands desperately as the villagers moved in on her..." (226) With minds numbed and conditioned to the cruelty, they are unable to hear any sensible reasoning. We get the sense of a sick stomach-turning lack of emotion, a deadness to see the value of life over ritual. "Come on." "Hurry up." (26) Blind to rational, the townspeople quickly, almost eagerly compel her to be a compliant contender and willfully accept her duty. "Come one, come on everyone." (226) Without reservation, they are quick to participate in the stoning. "Mrs. Hutchinson screamed, and then they were upon her." (226) The symbolism, or maybe it is better said as the social theme, concentrates on how people tend to cling to customs over reason. Even when those practices are brutal and have no connection to the qualitative transformations of contemporary social structure, many choose to seemingly move forward while adhering to antiquated which are in essence, holding the community back. Why do you think stories like “The Lottery” have drawn such a following within American society? Do you see similarities in books series such as "The Giver,” “Divergent,” The Hunger Games,” “Enders Game,” or “Atlas Shrugged?” What reaction do you think titles like these would play in other regions such as Asia or the Middle East?  Kennedy, X.J., and Dana Gioia. “Literature: An Introduction to Fiction, Poetry, Drama, and Writing,” 8th Edition. Pearson, 2016. 221-227. Print.