As a sophomore, Eller helped lead the Gophers to a Rose Bowl victory. While Eller shared the starting position as a sophomore he became a full-time, two-way player as a junior and senior and was voted All-America both years. During his time in college the Gophers were National Champions as well as Big Ten champions. As a senior (1963) Eller was the runner-up for the Outland Trophy. Following each football season, the Carl Eller Award is given to the University of Minnesota's Defensive Player of the Year. He was elected to the College Football Hall of Fame in 2006.
The sinkhole appeared in the Carl Eller Road parking lot Sept ... "J.F ...Bennett said the sinkhole occurred because of a culvert that runs the creek down through that stretch of road that has deteriorated and caved in at a spot along Carl Eller Road/N.C.