2019_RAMA_WushuSandaHIIT
2019_RAMA_WushuSandaHIIT
2019_RAMA_WushuSandaHIIT
net/publication/338713090
CITATIONS READS
7 2,445
4 authors, including:
Victor Coswig
Universidade Federal do Ceará
154 PUBLICATIONS 1,425 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Victor Coswig on 21 January 2020.
*
E-mail: [email protected]
g=1.56) y en la prueba FSOK (de 19.8±1.7 a 23.0±2.5 p=0,01, p=1,56) e no teste FSOK (de 19,8±1,7 a 23,0±2,5
patadas, p=0.003, g=1.38). La frecuencia cardíaca en chutes, p=0,003, p=1,38). A frequência cardíaca em
reposo disminuyó (de 120±8.3 a 107±11.4 lpm, p=0.03, repouso diminuiu (de 120±8,3 para 107±11,4 bpm,
g=1.20) y el tiempo hasta el agotamiento aumentó (de p=0,03, p=1,20) e o tempo para exaustão aumentou (de
8.5±1.8 a 13.1±1.4 min, p=0.003, g=2.63), así como el 8,5±1,8 para 13,1±1,4 min, p=0,003, p=2,63), bem como no
número de patadas (de 187±55.3 a 368±39.8 patadas, número de chutes (de 187±55,3 a 368±39,8 chutes,
p=0.001, g=3.46). Conclusión: A pesar del pequeño tamaño p=0,001, p=3,46). Conclusão: Apesar do pequeno tamanho
de la muestra, los grandes tamaños de efectos hallados da amostra, os grandes tamanhos de efeito encontrados
respaldan la conclusión de que añadir un protocolo HIIT permitem sugerir que a adição de um protocolo específico
específico de wushu sanda a la rutina de entrenamiento de de HIIT para wushu sanda à rotina de treinamento de
atletas amateur puede producir mejoras en el rendimiento atletas amadores pode levar a melhorias no desempenho
neuromuscular, aeróbico y anaeróbico. neuromuscular, aeróbio e anaeróbio.
Palabras clave: Artes marciales; deportes de combate; Palavras-chave: Artes Marciais; esportes de combate;
wushu, entrenamiento interválico de alta intensidad; wushu; treinamento intervalado de alta intensidade;
acondicionamiento físico. condicionamento físico.
1. Introduction
Sanda is a combat sport developed from wushu (also called Kung Fu), a set of Chinese
martial arts. It was developed in 1960 for competitive purposes with specific rules and equipment
(Vasconcelos & Del Vecchio, 2017). The matches last until 3 rounds of 2 min each with 1-min
intervals in between and occur in a squared elevated platform (leitai) 80 cm high and 800 cm long
and wide, coated with shock-absorbing materials (Theeboom, Zhu, & Vertonghen, 2017). Athletes
use motor actions such as punches, kicks, and throws, demanding speed, precision, and power,
which are considered unimpeachable physical capacities for competitive success in this modality
(Deng, 2017; Theeboom et al., 2017; Vasconcelos & Del Vecchio, 2017). Regarding technical aspects
and specific motor characteristics, wushu sanda is classified as a mixed-orientation combat sport,
with striking (punches and kicks) and grappling (throwing) actions (Del Vecchio, Silva, & Farias,
2015; Silva, Del Vecchio, Picanço, Takito, & Franchini, 2011).
Like other combat sports, sanda is an acyclic intermittent modality composed of blocks of
short duration and high-intensity efforts, leading to a high aerobic contribution (Del Vecchio,
Coswig, & Neves, 2012). Studies on the temporal structure of combat sports showed the relevance
of interval training in athletes’ physical preparation, since this training strategy attends these
sports’ specificities while simulating real competitive situations (Del Vecchio, Hirata, & Franchini,
2011). A recent systematic review tested the effects of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) on
Olympic combat sports' athlete's performance and most of them employing general and unspecific
exercises such as running, rowing and cycling (Franchini, Cormack, & Takito, 2019). Indeed, ome of
these findings showed relevant improvements in athletes' physical performance in both grappling
(Farzad et al., 2011) and striking (Ravier, Dugué, Grappe, & Rouillon, 2009) modalities.
Notwithstanding, some studies tried to structure HIIT protocols based on combat sports’
specific characteristics and their technical-tactical and time-motion structure (Franchini et al.,
2017). This kind of protocol can be designed considering the effort:pause ratio (E:P), the high to
low-intensity ratio (HI:LI) and specific motor actions of the modality (Del Vecchio et al., 2011). For
example, Andreato et al. (2013) suggested a training program for Brazilian jiu-jitsu (BJJ) where 3-5s
high-intensity specific efforts should be interspersed by 20-25 of low-intensity actions, which
respect the 1:6 HI:LI ratio of the modality. Another example was suggested by Del Vecchio et al.
(2011) for mixed martial arts (MMA) athletes. In this sense, unpublished data from our lab showed
that the E:P of 2.4:1 and a HI:LI of 1:1.6 was found from 245 rounds of 145 matches from the 13th
World Wushu Championships. Thus, it is suggested that specific training programs should be
designed based on that information.
However, up to date and to the author's knowledge, wushu training programs are usually
settled based on tradition, intuition and coaches’ previous experiences, just like many other martial
arts and combat sports (Artioli et al., 2009) and effects of specific protocols are not known. Thus, a
deeper understanding of the modality's technical and tactical aspects is required to enhance
specific training prescriptions, which may increase athletes’ competitive performance. Also, specific
HIIT protocols have been successfully applied to combat sports athlete's routines and may are
superior to unspecific protocols (cycling, running, rowing, etc.) to enhance their performance
(Ribeiro et al., 2015). However, studies on this subject in wushu sanda athletes are lacking.
Therefore, this study aimed to investigate the effects of the addition of a specific HIIT protocol to
the habitual training on the physical fitness of amateur regional level wushu sanda athletes. We
hypothesize that relevant improvements in physical fitness can be achieved when specific HIIT
protocols are added to habitual wushu sanda training.
2. Methods
2.1. Study type and sample
This is an experimental study approved by the local ethical committee (CAAE:
16607019.8.0000.0018) and all subjects signed the informed consent form. To be part of the
sample, athletes should practice wushu sanda for at least 1 year, train at least 3 times per week and
fit on the weight categories light (-60kg), middle (-75kg) or heavy (+75kg) (Chang, 2013). Also,
athletes should not present any restrictions that prevent or limit the execution of any of this study's
procedures, as recent injuries or illness. Those who did not complete all of the evaluations or had a
frequency of less than 75% in the training sessions were excluded. A total of 16 regional level
athletes were invited to take part in the study, from those 8 were excluded for not reaching 75% of
frequency in the training program and 2 left the study for personal reasons. Therefore, this study's
sample was composed of 6 male athletes (24.6±6.4 yrs, 1.70±0.1 m height, and 71.3±7.3 kg weight),
who underwent a 4-weeks training program.
2.3. Procedures
In the first meeting, the subjects arrived in the afternoon to the lab, at their usual training
hour and were informed of the study's objectives, then read and signed the written informed
consent form. After that, athletes performed a 10-min standardized warm-up composed by jogging,
calisthenics and specific actions of the modality. Physical fitness was evaluated using the tests of
countermovement jump, squat jump, horizontal jump, kick speed (FSOK) and aerobic fitness
(TKDtest), in that order. Subjects were asked to be rested, hydrated, fed at least 2 hours before the
tests, not to engage in physical activities for at least 24 hours, not to ingest any substance that could
potentially affect their heart rate and by dressing in their usual workout uniform. Firstly, subjects
were familiarized with the tests and then performed each one. After that, subjects underwent a 4-
weeks training program composed of 8 sessions 2 times per week. Before each session, subjects
performed a 5-min warm-up using exercises they were used to perform during their training
routine, such as jumping jacks, running and jump rope. After a 2 min recovery, athletes were
organized in pairs, in which one of them would hold the punching/kicking pad and the other one
was going to execute the HIIT protocol. When the first athlete concluded his HIIT protocol, the roles
were exchanged after 5-min of recovery. This time of recovery was arbitrarily chosen based on
training logistics and to provide enough time to hydration and equipment (pads and gloves)
change. After the conclusion of the 4-weeks training program, the physical tests were applied again.
3. Results
Physical performance outcomes are presented in Table 1, while individual and mean
percentage change values are presented in Figure 1. The performance on countermovement jump
and horizontal jump increased significantly with moderate and large effect sizes, respectively. The
number of kicks in 10s increased significantly with a large effect size. Between the progressive
test's variables, the heart rate in rest decreased and the total of kicks and the final stage increased
significantly, all with large effect sizes. One of the subjects did not present any changes while the
other one presented a decrease in squat jump performance. For the heart rate in rest, only one
subject presented an increase. All other subjects presented positive adaptations to the training
program. The heart rate outcomes are present in Figure 2. It can be noticed that, in general, heart
rate presented lower values at baseline, however, significant changes were identified only in stages
6 (t=2.8; p=0.03; g=1.52) and 7 (t=3.04; p=0.03; g= 1.89), both with large effects. It is possible to
notice that, meanly, subjects sustained four extra stages until exhaustion after the training program.
Gray bars represent each subject and dark bars represent the mean and standard deviations. CMJ:
Countermovement Jump; SJ: Squat Jump; HJ: Horizontal Jump; FSOK: Frequency Speed of Kicks; HRrest:
Resting heart rate.
Figure 1. Individual and mean percentage chance in physical performance pre and post a 4-weeks program
using a specific high-intensity interval wushu sanda training protocol (n=6).
Figure 2. Heart rate outcomes in a progressive kicking test pre and post a 4-weeks program using a specific
high-intensity interval wushu sanda training protocol (n=6).
Rev. Artes Marciales Asiát., 14(2), 47-55 ~ 2019 | 51
Monteiro, J.R.F, Veccio, F.B., Vasconcelos, B. B., & Coswig, V.S.
4. Discussion
The present study aimed to test a new specific HIIT wushu sanda protocol and its effects on
athletes’ physical capacities, looking for enhancing their physical performance. The main findings
were that adding 2 sessions per week for 4 weeks of this specific protocol to athletes' training
routine led to significant improvements in aerobic capacity, lower limbs' muscle power and kicks
speed in amateur regional level wushu sanda athletes. Considering that sanda is a combat sport
with high aerobic demands in which athletes need to have high anaerobic power in both upper and
lower limbs (Yoshida & Ribeiro, 2016), the protocol proposed here showed to be of interest for
enhancing these desirable capacities since these variables are determinant for competitive success.
These study’s findings suggested that the training program induced a relevant improvement
in subjects’ neuromuscular function. Athletes' lower limb power significantly increased on the
countermovement jump test, squat jump test and horizontal jump test, and anaerobic power on
frequency speed of kick test. There was also a relevant improvement in aerobic capacity since for
the progressive test, the resting heart rate decreased and the time until exhaustion increased.
These findings may be explained by HIIT’s properties, which are efficient in aerobic energy
utilization in which the maximum aerobic capacity can be greater than 100% and the passive
recovery is around 55% (Buchheit & Laursen, 2013).
The effects of HIIT protocols in combat sports athletes were previously tested in different
modalities, using general protocols (running, rowing or cycling) and specific task protocols. The
effects of adding HIIT sessions to international level karate athletes’ habitual routine was
previously tested (Ravier et al., 2009). The protocol involved 7 to 9 20s running bouts at 140% of
vVO2max in a treadmill, interspersed by 15s interval between bouts. The intervention group
presented impressive physiological adaptations in a progressive treadmill test, where athletes had
their time to exhaustion increased 23.6% and maximal oxygen uptake increased by 4.6%. Also,
peak blood lactate and post-test concentrations increased by 12.9% and 53.2%. In a similar design,
2 sessions/week of sprint interval training (6 all-out bouts of 35 min with 10s rests between bouts
and 3 min rest between sets. 1 set was added per week) were added to the training program of
national-level wrestlers for 4 weeks (Farzad et al., 2011). In a progressive treadmill test, athletes
had their time to exhaustion increased 32.2% and maximal oxygen uptake in 5.4%. In 4 successive
lower limbs Wingate tests, athletes had their peak and mean power output increased by 19.1% and
6.3% in the first sprint and by 36.7% and 9.1% in the second. Taken together, these findings
suggest that, even with general and unspecific protocols, positive outcomes can be expected when
HIIT is added to combat sports training.
On the other hand, specific modality tasks’ protocols were also tested. Ribeiro et al. (2015)
added 3 sessions/week of a specific protocol based on BJJ motor gestures to the habitual training
routine. For 10 weeks, a specific technique (a different technique per week) was performed for 1-
min in maximum effort with 1-min rests between efforts. Findings suggested that maximal oxygen
uptake increased 16.33% and specific endurance and specific speed increased 18.9% and 20.7%
respectively. Also, vertical jumping increased by 24.16%. However, despite specific motor gestures
were applied, the time-motion structure was not respected. A study by Franchini et al. (2013)
considered the time-motion structure of judo and proposed a protocol composed of two blocks of
10 sets of 20s of all-out effort interspersed by 10s intervals. The authors compared cycling HIIT for
upper and lower limbs against a specific HIIT protocol (uchi-komi). The main findings suggested
that after 4-weeks of training twice a week, the uchi-komi group increased both lower (16.7%) and
upper limb peak power (8.5%). Here, wushu sanda athletes’ countermovement jump performance
increased 15.4% and horizontal jump performance increased 35.3%.
Regarding HIIT training for striking-type combat sports, Kamandulis et al. (2018) a
simulated fight composed by three rounds (14 sets of 3s all-out punching with 10s rest) against a
punching bag. After 4-weeks of training thrice a week upper-body aerobic power and punching
abilities were improved in amateur boxers. Thereupon, HIIT can induce important changes in the
aerobic and anaerobic performance of combat sports athletes, as suggested in a recent review
(Franchini et al., 2019). Finally, our results seem to contribute to the body of knowledge about the
effects of HIIT specific protocols to improve the physical performance of fighters with low training
volumes. It is of interest to coaches, trainers and athletes since the reduction of training load can
reduce the risk for non-functional overreaching, overtraining and, thus, risk of injury. Therefore,
studies exploring the potential of HIIT programs among combat sports athletes are quite relevant,
especially with specific time-motion and technical-tactical based protocols, since aerobic and
anaerobic performance are fundamental for competitive success.
Finally, some limitations should be considered while interpreting our findings. First, the
small sample size could reduce statistical power, however, to minimize we presented individual
data. Also, small sample sizes are frequent in combat sports research due to sample specificity and
efforts to maintain homogeneity. Also, even with this small sample size, large effect sizes were
found. Second, a control group would be of interest, especially for comparisons between different
training protocols, however, we believe that our findings are still relevant as a descriptive/pilot
study, mainly due to its novelty and originality. Third, the low internal validity of these tests applied
needs to be considered as a limitation, however, we believe that it is a strength as well, since these
field tests can be easily implemented in trainers, coaches and athletes’ routines.
5. Conclusion
Despite the small number of subjects in our sample, the large effect sizes found here allow
us to conclude that the addition of a specific HIIT wushu sanda protocol to amateur athletes’
training routine leads to neuromuscular, aerobic and anaerobic performance improvements. With
this limitation in mind, this pilot study may serve as a significant reference for further studies on
the topic. Specifically, athletes presented performance improvements in the countermovement
jump, horizontal jump and in the frequency speed of kicks test. Regarding the incremental test, the
resting heart rate decreased and the time to exhaustion increased, as well as the number of kicks.
Together, our findings suggest that this HIIT protocol can induce improvements in physical fitness
while maintaining high training specificity.
References
Andreato, L. V., Franchini, E., De Moraes, S. M. F., Pastório, J. J., da Silva, D. F., Esteves, J. V. D. C., …
Machado, F. A. (2013). Physiological and technical-tactical analysis in brazilian jiu-jitsu
competition. Asian Journal of Sports Medicine. doi: 10.5812/asjsm.34496
Araujo, M., Nobrega, A., Espinosa, G., Hausen, M., Castro, R., Soares, P., & Gurgel, J. (2015). Proposal
of a new specific cardiopulmonary exercise test for taekwondo athletes. Journal of Strength
and Conditioning Research, 31(6), 1525–1535. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0000000000001312
Artioli, G. G., Gualano, B., Franchini, E., Batista, R. N., Polacow, V. O., & Lancha, A. H. (2009).
Physiological, performance, and nutritional profile of the brazilian olympic wushu (kung-fu)
team. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0b013e318187687a
Buchheit, M., & Laursen, P. B. (2013). High-intensity interval training, solutions to the programming
puzzle: Part II: Anaerobic energy, neuromuscular load and practical applications. Sports
Medicine, 43(10), 927–954. doi: 10.1007/s40279-013-0066-5
Bulten, R., King-Dowling, S., & Cairney, J. (2019). Assessing the Validity of Standing Long Jump to
Predict Muscle Power in Children With and Without Motor Delays. Pediatric Exercise Science,
1–6. doi: 10.1123/pes.2018-0277
Chang, B. (2013). On women Sanda athletes using wrestling techniques in 2012 Shanxi Wushu
Championships. Wushu Science, 10(4), 59–61.
da Silva Santos, J. F., & Franchini, E. (2016). Is frequency speed of kick test responsive to training? A
study with taekwondo athletes. Sport Sciences for Health. doi: 10.1007/s11332-016-0300-2
Del Vecchio, F. B., Hirata, S. M., & Franchini, E. (2011). A Review of Time-Motion Analysis and
Combat Development in Mixed Martial Arts Matches at Regional Level Tournaments.
Perceptual and Motor Skills, 112(2), 639–648. doi: 10.2466/05.25.PMS.112.2.639-648
Del Vecchio, F. B., Silva, J. J. R., & Farias, C. B. (2015). Análise temporal de combates de Muay-Thai de
nível nacional: Efeitos da fase competitiva. Revista de Artes Marciales Asiáticas, 10(1), 34–41.
doi: 10.18002/rama.v10i1.1635
Del Vecchio, F., Coswig, V., & Neves, A. (2012). Modalidades esportivas de combate de domínio:
respostas bioquímicas, hematológicas e hormonais. Revista Brasileira de Fisiologia do
Exercício, 11, 246–254. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.33233/rbfe.v11i4.3413
Breno Berny Vasconcelos (Brazil). Master degree student. Currently he is focused in wushu research. E-
mail: [email protected]
Victor Silveira Coswig (Brazil). PhD researcher at the Federal University of Pará. Victor coordinates the
Laboratory of Combat Sports Applied Physiology and have relevant experience and contribution to combat
sports science. E-mail: [email protected]