Name	Known for
Janet Montgomery Mary Sibley Mary Sibley See fewer	Black Swan (2010)
Shane West John Alden John Alden See fewer	A Walk to Remember (2002)
Seth Gabel Cotton Mather Cotton Mather See fewer	Big Sky (2020)
Tamzin Merchant Anne Hale Anne Hale See fewer	Carnival Row (2019)
Ashley Madekwe Tituba Tituba See fewer	County Lines (2019)
Elise Eberle Mercy Lewis Mercy Lewis See fewer	Shameless (2011)
Iddo Goldberg Isaac Walton Isaac Walton See fewer	Snowpiercer (2020)
Joe Doyle Baron Sebastian Marburg Baron Sebastian Marburg See fewer	Salem (2014)
Oliver Bell Boy / John Boy / John See fewer	Salem (2014)
Lucy Lawless Countess Marburg Countess Marburg See fewer	Xena: Warrior Princess (1995)
Jeremy Crutchley Hathorne Hathorne See fewer	American Gods (2017)
Samantha Hanratty Dollie Trask (as Sammi Hanratty) Dollie Trask (as Sammi Hanratty) See fewer	Yellowjackets (2021)
Michael Mulheren George Sibley George Sibley See fewer	Fool's Gold (I) (2008)
Thomas Francis Murphy Reverend Lewis Reverend Lewis See fewer	Mindhunter (2017)
John R. Bennett II Selectman Selectman See fewer	The Killer (2023)
Desiree Page Acolyte Witch Acolyte Witch See fewer	Salem (2014)
Steve Craig Officer Marburg Crew (uncredited) Officer Marburg Crew (uncredited) See fewer	The Ultimate Commitment (2015)
C.W. Johnson Jr. Marburg Guard (uncredited) Marburg Guard (uncredited) See fewer	Consumer Burger (2020)
Floyd Knight Dead Guy on Cart / Puritan / Essex Witch (uncredited) Dead Guy on Cart / Puritan / Essex Witch (uncredited) See fewer	I Saw the Light (2015)
Michael Plata Puritan (uncredited) Puritan (uncredited) See fewer	Jerico (2016)
Bruce Roberts Selectman (uncredited) Selectman (uncredited) See fewer	Bob Birdnow's Remarkable Tale of Human Survival and the Transcendence of Self (2013)
Jeremy Summers Townsfolk (uncredited) Townsfolk (uncredited) See fewer	The Tale (2018)
Mallory Thompson Water Hag (uncredited) Water Hag (uncredited) See fewer	Avatar: The Way of Water (2022)
Rorie Vogel Prostitute / Townsperson / Pox Victim (uncredited) Prostitute / Townsperson / Pox Victim (uncredited) See fewer	The Tale (2018)