Should the Jury Find... - Production & Contact Info

Cast	+ Add Cast
67 cast members

Name	Known for
Errol Morris Self - Filmmaker and Author Self - Filmmaker and Author See fewer	The Fog of War (2003)
Bill Posey Self - Helena's Neighbor Self - Helena's Neighbor See fewer	Inside Story (1974)
Prince Beasley Self - Fayetteville Police Detective (archive footage) Self - Fayetteville Police Detective (archive footage) See fewer
Jim Gaddis Self - Nashville Police Officer Self - Nashville Police Officer See fewer	Nazareth (2017)
Robert Brisentine Self - Army Polygraph Expert Self - Army Polygraph Expert See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Jeffrey R. MacDonald Self (archive footage) Self (archive footage) See fewer	Crime Stories (1998)
Freddy Kassab Self - Colette's Stepfather (archive footage) Self - Colette's Stepfather (archive footage) See fewer
Bob Keeler Self - Reporter, Newsday Self - Reporter, Newsday See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Bernie Segal Self - Defense Attorney (archive footage) Self - Defense Attorney (archive footage) See fewer
Christina Masewicz Self - True Crime Fan Self - True Crime Fan See fewer	48 Hours (1988)
Wade Smith Self - Local Defense Attorney Self - Local Defense Attorney See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Jim Blackburn Self - Lead Prosecutor Self - Lead Prosecutor See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Fred Thornhill Self - Juror Self - Juror See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Mike Malley Self - Jeff's Friend Self - Jeff's Friend See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Mildred Kassab Self - Colette's Mother (archive footage) Self - Colette's Mother (archive footage) See fewer
Colette MacDonald Self (archive footage) Self (archive footage) See fewer
Arthur Adams Courtroom Attendee Courtroom Attendee See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Maria Alessi Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	Where the Light Enters (I) (2022)
Kalyn Altmeyer Colette MacDonald Colette MacDonald See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Jackson Barre Assistant Prosecutor Crawley (as Mark Jeffrey Hayes) Assistant Prosecutor Crawley (as Mark Jeffrey Hayes) See fewer	Here Love Lies (2023)
John Beckwith Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	The Strange Dark (2024)
Heather Beeman Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	Bernie (2015)
Audrey Nita Bennett Mildred Kassab Mildred Kassab See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Evgeniia Borisenko Courtroom Attendee Courtroom Attendee See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Clay Boulware Joe McGinniss Joe McGinniss See fewer	The Woodshed (2012)
Megan Bruno Stenographer Stenographer See fewer	The Juror (2021)
Chris Cartusciello Freddy Kassab Freddy Kassab See fewer	The Once and Future Smash (2022)
Fig Chilcott Christina Christina See fewer	Random Acts of Flyness (2018)
Quinn Corcoran Police Officer Gaddis Police Officer Gaddis See fewer	The Alpha Omega Man (2017)
Annalyce D'Agostino Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	Heartbreaker (2014)
Nick Dietz Colonel Rock / Legal Counsel Smith / Juror (voice) Colonel Rock / Legal Counsel Smith / Juror (voice) See fewer	Keeping Up with the Guptas (2010)
Jessica Finn Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	Son of Gacy
Joe Gambino Freddy Kassab / Juror (voice) Freddy Kassab / Juror (voice) See fewer	Right Type of Wrong (2007)
Roger Hervas MP Paulk / Reporter / Foreman (1979) MP Paulk / Reporter / Foreman (1979) See fewer	Saving Borshia (2015)
Brooke Hutton Jeff's Motel Woman Jeff's Motel Woman See fewer	Cindy (II) (2015)
Avery Ilardi Kimberley MacDonald Kimberley MacDonald See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Ben Jorgensen Robert Brisentine Robert Brisentine See fewer	The Basketball Diaries (1995)
Bryan King Detective Beasley Detective Beasley See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Fred Klie Witness Underhill (2012) Witness Underhill (2012) See fewer	The Union
Rick J. Koch Judge Dupree Judge Dupree See fewer	The RAs (2011)
Kelley Lord Witness Bailey (1979) Witness Bailey (1979) See fewer	The United Nations: The Border and the Coast (2022)
Dmitry Lytvynenko Court Officer Court Officer See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Adam M. Rosenfeld Prosecutor Blackburn / Soldier Prosecutor Blackburn / Soldier See fewer	The Wish (III) (2016)
Anthony Malgioglio Defense Counsel Smith Defense Counsel Smith See fewer	The Food That Built America (2019)
Ed Malone Prosecutor Murtagh Prosecutor Murtagh See fewer	Suspicious Minds (II) (2023)
Andy Manjuck Prosecutor Blackburn / Juror (voice) Prosecutor Blackburn / Juror (voice) See fewer	Whispers of a Machine (2019)
Chris Mastrocola Courtroom Attendee Courtroom Attendee See fewer	Twenty-Nine (2024)
Gina Mazzara Helena Stoeckley (1979) Helena Stoeckley (1979) See fewer	Monsters Among Us
Maria McGlade Court Clerk (as Maria Ryan McGlade) Court Clerk (as Maria Ryan McGlade) See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Kenneth Mewhort Courtroom Attendee Courtroom Attendee See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
John Morgan Jeffrey MacDonald Jeffrey MacDonald See fewer	Chatsworth (2023)
Alan Niebuhr Witness Underhill (1979) Witness Underhill (1979) See fewer	Simulated Theory (2018)
Alley Ninestein Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	The Bride of Frank (1996)
Noah Parker Court Spectator Court Spectator See fewer	Who by Fire (2024)
Lisa Roth Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	Melvin Goes to Dinner (2003)
Peter Samuel Court Spectator Court Spectator See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Cornelia Schnall Witness Bailey (2012) Witness Bailey (2012) See fewer	Antrag auf Liebesheirat (1980)
Shelly Shenoy Court Clerk / Juror (voice) Court Clerk / Juror (voice) See fewer	The Walking Dead: A New Frontier (2016)
Julia Sjakovs Juror (1979) Juror (1979) See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Paul Spriggs Jeffrey MacDonald Jeffrey MacDonald See fewer	Law & Order: Special Victims Unit (1999)
Logan Stearns Jeffrey MacDonald (voice) Jeffrey MacDonald (voice) See fewer	Afterlife Defense Department
Shawthel Stephenson Prosecutor Blackburn Prosecutor Blackburn See fewer	Confidentiel (2014)
Jay Striker Drug Addict Veteran / Juror (1979) Drug Addict Veteran / Juror (1979) See fewer	A Wilderness of Error (2020)
Leonid Sukala Court Officer (as Leonik Sukala) Court Officer (as Leonik Sukala) See fewer	The Saint of the Impossible (2020)
James Trenton Bernie Segal Bernie Segal See fewer	The Ben Stiller Show (1992)
Walker Vreeland Bernie Segal (voice) Bernie Segal (voice) See fewer	I Don't Need an Acting Class (2020)
Suzanna Woodhead Reporter / Juror / Coffee Shop Patron Reporter / Juror / Coffee Shop Patron See fewer	Bull (2016)