skip to content
Advertisement

Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Highlights: Dhankhar took unilateral decisions on matters like relocating statues, altering security apparatus, says Kharge

Parliament Winter Session Highlights: The Union Cabinet approved two Bills on Thursday — one Constitutional amendment Bill to conduct elections for the Lok Sabha and all state assemblies together, and another ordinary Bill to align elections for assemblies in Delhi, Puducherry and Jammu and Kashmir.

rajya sabhaVice President Jagdeep Dhankhar declined the Opposition MPs demand to discuss the controversial remarks made by Allahabad HC judge.

Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Highlights: Mallikarjun Kharge, the Leader of the Opposition in the Rajya Sabha, on Thursday expressed serious concerns about the suppression of the opposition’s right to speak and express opinions, claiming it had become a norm in the House. He accused Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar of arbitrarily expunging critical portions of speeches made by opposition members, undermining their voices. Additionally, Kharge criticised Dhankhar for making unilateral decisions on important issues, such as relocating statues and altering security measures, raising alarms about the erosion of democratic processes within the Rajya Sabha.

In the Parliament,  the face-off between BJP MPs and Opposition MPs continued today, with Rajya Sabha being adjourned for the day amid uproar over the alleged nexus between US hedge fund tycoon George Soros and Sonia Gandhi, Adani row among other issues. Lok Sabha proceedings continued and discussion on the Disaster Management (Amendment) Bill is underway. Meanwhile, Dhankhar has declined the notice filed by Opposition MPs seeking discussion on alleged derogatory remarks made by Allahabad HC judge. Terming the notice filed by Opposition MP Renuka Chowdhury to be in transgression of rules, Vice President Dhankhar has declined the demand. The Opposition MPs created ruckus over various issues including Adani row, farmers distress, increasing crime rates in Delhi.

Bills in Parliament today: Nearly three months after the Union Cabinet accepted the recommendations of the high-level committee chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind on holding simultaneous polls, it approved two Bills on Thursday — one Constitutional amendment Bill to conduct elections for the Lok Sabha and all state assemblies together, and another ordinary Bill to align elections for assemblies in Delhi, Puducherry and Jammu and Kashmir. The two Bills, it is learned, are likely to be introduced in the ongoing Parliament session.

Live Updates
22:43 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Live Updates: Treasury bench resorts to false allegations to divert attention from Adani issue: KC Venugopal

Congress MP KC Venugopal on Thursday slammed the members of the Treasury bench, alleging that they make false allegations against Congress leaders to divert the attention from the Adani issue.

"They want to divert the issue of Adani...Members of the treasury bench are misusing the parliamentary platform and making derogatory, baseless allegations against Congress party and opposition," KC Venugopal told ANI.

He also questioned why BJP MP NIshikant Dubey was allowed to speak on the same subject repeatedly in zero hours.

19:27 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Live Updates: Special debate on Constitution will begin in Lok Sabha tomorrow at noon

A Special debate on the Constitution will begin in Lok Sabha tomorrow at 12 noon and conclude at 5 pm on Saturday.

19:07 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Live Updates: Opposition picks holes in Disaster Management (Amendment) Bill

Many Opposition members in the Lok Sabha on Thursday criticised the Disaster Management (Amendment) Bill, 2024 stating that it is only talking about creation of a plethora of organisations.

Participating in the debate on the bill, TMC's Saugata Roy alleged that the Modi government was not able to manage the Covid pandemic properly as a large number of people died during that time.

This bill, he said, "creates a plethora of organisations" and has added a number of "English terms".

Congress member Captain Viriato Fernandes said while members are talking about following a holistic approach to deal with disasters, but this bill is against that.

19:06 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Live Updates: Draconian' One Nation, One Election Bill will erase regional voices, erode federalism: TN CM

The One Nation, One Election Bill approved by the Union Cabinet was "impractical" and an "anti-democratic" move that will erase regional voices and erode federalism, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M K Stalin on Thursday.

Expressing his ire over the move, he said the Union Cabinet has approved introducing the “draconian” ‘One Nation, One Election Bill' in the Parliament.

“This impractical and anti-democratic move will erase regional voices, erode federalism, and disrupt governance. Rise up #india!” Stalin said in a post on X. PTI

19:05 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Live Updates: Punjab CM Mann slams Centre over 'one nation, one election

Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann on Thursday said the BJP-led central government talks of 'one nation, one election' but is unable to hold simultaneous polls in even two states.

He also doubted the intentions of the Centre in implementation of 'one nation, one election' plan.

Earlier, the Union Cabinet, chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, approved bills to implement 'one nation, one election', and the draft legislations are likely to be introduced in Parliament in the ongoing Winter session, sources said.

"They talk of 'one nation, one election', but they cannot even hold 'two states, one election'. That means there must be something else in their mind," he told reporters in Parliament complex. - PTI

19:03 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Live Updates: TMC raises Bangladesh issue, demands statement from PM

Trinamool Congress on Thursday demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi speak in Parliament on situation in neighbouring Bangladesh.

The issue was raised in the Rajya Sabha in the post-lunch sitting by TMC's Parliamentary Party leader Derek O'Brien, who sought permission to raise a point of order.

He quoted Rule 251, and said he wanted the Prime Minister to come and give a statement on Bangladesh issue.

Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar however said it is not a point of order, and did not allow O'Brien to continue.

The refusal was followed by TMC MPs breaking out into sloganeering in the House.

Talking to reporters outside Parliament, TMC's deputy leader in Rajya Sabha Sagarika Ghose said a statement on the issue should be given in Parliament by the Prime Minister.

18:32 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Parliament Winter Session Day 14 Live Updates: Chirag Paswan bats for 'one nation, one election' after Cabinet approves bill

Union minister and BJP ally Chirag Paswan on Thursday came out strongly in support of "one nation, one election", saying it is in national interest as simultaneous polls will boost development.

Hours after the Union Cabinet approved the "one nation, one election" bill, Paswan said frequent elections are a hindrance to the country's development.

"It (simultaneous election) is in the interest of the country. It will boost development," he told reporters.

Paswan also said his Lok Janshakti Party (Ram Vilas) has for long supported the concept of simultaneous polls since the days of his father Ram Vilas Paswan, who founded the undivided LJP. PTI

18:30 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Cong reiterates its opposition to 'One nation, One Election' calls it bid to divert

With the Union Cabinet approving bills to implement 'one nation, one election', the Congress on Thursday reiterated its opposition to the very idea of simultaneous polls and accused the government of trying to divert attention from "questions being raised on the electoral integrity of the democratic system".

The Union Cabinet, chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, approved bills to implement 'one nation, one election' and the draft legislations are likely to be introduced in Parliament in the ongoing Winter Session, the PTI reported.

18:27 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: History will never forgive those not allowing level playing field in House, says Sibal

With the opposition seeking the removal of Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar, Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal on Thursday said history will never forgive those who do not allow a level playing field in the functioning of the House.

In a first, parties of the opposition INDIA bloc spearheaded by the Congress on Tuesday submitted a notice in the Rajya Sabha for moving a no-confidence motion against Dhankhar, accusing him of being "extremely partisan" in his role as the Chairman of the Upper House of Parliament.

In a post on X, Sibal said, "Jagdeep Dhankar. 60 Members of Rajya Sabha submit a Notice for his removal. Unprecedented. Sad day for the Mother of Democracy!" "History will never forgive those who do not allow a level playing field in the functioning of the House," the Independent member of the Rajya Sabha said. PTI

16:37 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Khrage accuses Dhankhar of arbitrarily expunging critical portions of speeches made by opposition members, undermining their voices

Mallikarjun Kharge, the Leader of the Opposition in the Rajya Sabha, has expressed serious concerns about the suppression of the opposition's right to speak and express opinions, claiming it has become a norm in the House. He accused Rajya Sabha Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar of arbitrarily expunging critical portions of speeches made by opposition members, undermining their voices. Additionally, Kharge criticized Dhankhar for making unilateral decisions on important issues, such as relocating statues and altering security measures, raising alarms about the erosion of democratic processes within the Rajya Sabha.

16:20 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Cabinet clears two Bills to kickstart simultaneous polls, focus first on Lok Sabha and State Assemblies

Nearly three months after the Union Cabinet accepted the recommendations of the high-level committee chaired by former President Ram Nath Kovind on holding simultaneous polls, it approved two Bills on Thursday — one Constitutional amendment Bill to conduct elections for the Lok Sabha and all state assemblies together, and another ordinary Bill to align elections for assemblies in Delhi, Puducherry and Jammu and Kashmir.

The two Bills, it is learned, are likely to be introduced in the ongoing Parliament session. “But it will just be the introduction and within minutes it will go to a Joint Parliamentary Committee, which will be set up by the House,” said a BJP source. However, the Union Government has not confirmed the timeline for implementation — whether simultaneous polls will begin in 2029 or 2034.

A top source in the government said there would be “extensive deliberations” on the Bill both inside and outside Parliament. Apart from the Joint Parliamentary Committee, the ruling BJP will also conduct an awareness campaign over the idea of ‘one nation one election’.

15:29 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: TMC's Sagarika Ghose gives privilege motion notice against Rijiju, 60 oppn MPs sign

Trinamool Congress' Rajya Sabha MP Sagarika Ghose on Thursday submitted a privilege motion notice against Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju for making a derogatory remark against opposition leaders in the Upper House. The notice has been signed by 60 leaders from opposition parties, the PTI reported.

"Yesterday in the house, addressing the opposition, Mr. Rijiju said you all are not worthy of being in this house... The Minister for Parliamentary Affairs, Mr. Kiren Rijiju, instead of doing his best to run Parliament smoothly, has chosen to repeatedly insult the opposition," Ghose told reporters. "Rijiju has insulted opposition members and used personal terms both inside and outside Parliament. This is totally unbecoming of the high office he holds and amounts to total misuse of his position," TMC's deputy leader in the Rajya Sabha said. She said she had moved a privilege motion against Rijiju for abusing his office with his "diatribes and unparliamentary language" against opposition. The motion has been signed by senior leaders of all opposition parties, she added.

15:05 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Rajya Sabha adjourned for the day amid din

Rajya Sabha proceedings were adjourned for the day Thursday afternoon amid ruckus as the treasury and opposition benches trades charges over no-trust notice against Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar, and the BJP's allegations of the Congress leadership's "connections" with billionaire investor George Soros.

The House witnessed two adjournments in the day before that. The first was during the Zero Hour in the pre-lunch sitting when Chairman Dhankhar rejected six notices to adjourn the scheduled business of the day and take up matters mentioned in the notices.

As several opposition members raised objections, Nadda criticised Congress president and Leader of the Opposition in the House Mallikarjun Kharge for holding a press conference and criticising the Chairman and Vice President Dhankhar.

14:38 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Laughter in Lok Sabha over Suresh Gopi's gesture to Kanimozhi's demand seeking relief funds for Kerala

A light-hearted moment unfolds in Lok Sabha as DMK MP Kanimozhi mentions about Kerala being deprived of relief funds and BJP MP Suresh Gopi responds with a gesture of hands. Laughter breaks out in the Lower House.

14:32 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Why state govt needs to approach SC for relief funds, asks Kanimozhi

The Disaster Management (Amendment) Bill is being discussed in Lok Sabha. DMK MP Kanimozhi asks why a state government needs to approach the Supreme Court for receiving funds for relief work after facing natural calamities.

14:16 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Reckless allegations made by BJP MPs, says Kharge; Rajya Sabha adjourned for the day

Citing rule 238 A, Leader of Opposition in Rajya Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge says, "The House is not in order...They are making reckless allegations. You are respected. Who is allowing this disruption ? ...You are the umpire of both Opposition and the ruling party.."

Rajya Sabha has been adjourned for the day

14:06 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Rajya Sabha proceedings resume

Rajya Sabha session has resumed and Opposition MPs are heard raising slogans.

14:05 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Lok Sabha proceedings resume

Lok Sabha proceedings resume and Congress MP Gaurav Gogoi said remarks made by Opposition MPs on a specific industrialist are expunged while the same rule is not applicable to ruling party MPs.

13:25 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: 'Is rule selectively applicable to Oppn MPs', asks Venugopal, more on what led to uproar in Lok Sabha

The faceoff between BJP MPs and Opposition MPs continued over the alleged nexus between US hedge fund tycoon George Soros and Sonia Gandhi as well as the Adani row. During the Zero Hour, Congress MP Jothimani made a reference to the alleged links between a prominent industrialist and the BJP and presiding officer Jagdambika Pal remarked that the businessman's name will not be on records, triggering protests.

Congress MP K C Venugopal criticised whether the rule was selectively applicable for references made by Opposition MPs. Venugopal argued that Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal had made certain references in the Lok Sabha which were not expunged by the chair.

Afterwards, BJP member Nishikant Dubey raised the issue of alleged links between Congress leaders and George Soros-backed outfits. Subsequently, Congress MPs ventured into the Well of the House, raising slogans against the BJP leading to uproar.

With PTI inputs

13:07 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Lok Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

Shortly after resuming, Lok Sabha was adjourned amid uproar over various issues.

13:00 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Lok Sabha proceedings to resume shortly

Lok Sabha proceedings set to resume shortly.

12:22 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Lok Sabha adjourned till 1 pm

Amid ruckus, Lok Sabha has been adjourned till 1 pm

12:21 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Ruckus in Lok Sabha

Ruckus in Lok Sabha as BJP MPs and Opposition MPs faceoff over various issues including Soros-Congress link, farmers protest.

12:14 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Govt turned blind eye to protesting farmers, says Cong MP

S Jothimani, Congress MP from Tamil Nadu, raised the issue of farmers in Lok Sabha. Jothimani said farmers have protesting for a long time at Shambhu border and police have been using tear gas, water cannon to disperse the agitation. The Centre has turned a blind eye to them, Jothimani said.

11:57 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Lok Sabha Speaker urges members to uphold dignity of House

Lok Sabha proceedings are ongoing and Speaker Om Birla has urged all members to uphold the dignity of the House by abstaining from engaging in personal attacks, fostering an atmosphere of respect and decorum.

11:44 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Rajya Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

After Opposition MPs created ruckus over various issues including Adani row, the Upper House has been adjourned till 2 pm.

11:26 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Ruckus in Rajya Sabha

Ruckus in Rajya Sabha after V-P Dhankhar declined Opposition's notice demanding discussion on Allahabad HC judge's controversial remark.

11:23 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Notice in transgression of rules, Dhankar on motion against Allahabad HC judge

Commenting on the six notices filed by Opposition MPs, Dhankhar says one out of the six notices, filed by Renuka Chaudhary demanding discussion on the alleged derogatory remarks made by Allahabad HC. Dhankhar says the matter can only discussed only on a substantive motion and the notice is in transgression of rules. Citing Rajya Sabha rules, Dhankhar has declined the notice.

11:14 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Motion moved for election to court of AMU

Union Minister Dharmendhra Pradhan moves motion for election to the court of Aligarh Muslim University. As majority voted in favour of the motion via voice vote, the motion has been adopted.

11:12 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Question Hour underway in Lok Sabha

Question Hour is underway in Lok Sabha while papers are being laid in Rajya Sabha.

11:08 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Oppn MPs protest against Adani row

Meanwhile outside the Parliament, Opposition MPs are protesting against the Adani row. Holding placards and raising slogans, the Opposition MPs are seen protesting in the Parliament premises.

11:06 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Parliamentary proceedings begin

Parliamentary proceedings have begun. Stay tuned to get latest updates on the developments in both Upper and Lower Houses.

11:03 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Here's Allahabad HC judge's controversial remarks

As Opposition MPs are likely to move a motion seeking the impeachment of Allahabad High Court judge Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav, lets rewind his controversial statement. Justice Yadav triggered row with his remarks against minorities during his address at an event organised by the VHP's legal cell on the Allahabad High Court.

While backing the Uniform Civil Code strongly, Justice Yadav targeted Muslims and said “you have a misconception that if a law (UCC) is brought in, it will be against your Shariyat, your Islam and your Quran… But I want to say one more thing… whether it is your personal law, our Hindu law, your Quran or whether it is our Gita, as I said we have addressed the ills (buraaiyan) in our practices… kamiyan thi durust kar liye hai (the shortcomings have been addressed) …untouchability… sati, jauhar… female foeticide…we have addressed all those issues… Then why are you not doing away with his law… that while your first wife is there…you can have three wives… without her consent… that is not acceptable.”

He then went on to say “it is taught to us that even a small animal should not be killed. Even an ant should not be killed. That is perhaps why we are tolerant and generous. Hame kisi ka kasht dekh karke kasht hota hai… kisike peeda ko dekhke peeda hota hai… par aapke andar nahin hoti hai… Why? Because when a child is born in our community, they are taught about God, the Vedas and Mantras right from the childhood… they are told about non-violence… lekin aap ke yahan toh bachpan se bache ko saamne rakh kar ke vadh kiya jaat hai pashuon ka (in your community, animals are slaughtered in the presence of children)… toh aap kaise apeksha karte hain ki sahishnu hoga woh… udaar hoga woh (how do you expect the person to become tolerant, generous).”

Justice Yadav said, “I have no hesitation in saying that this is Hindustan… and the country will run according to the majority who live in Hindustan.”

He said the “law will operate on the will of the majority… if you look at families or the society… the will of the majority prevails.”

He said “the people who we are talking about… all of them are not bad… Not all of them are bad and the ills that I am talking about… they are not in favour of four wives, they are not in favour of triple talaq, they are not in favour of female foeticide… Lekin jo … (derogatory remark)… kyunoki woh desh ke liye ghatak hai (dangerous to the country)… Janata ko bhadkane wale log hain, desh aage na bade is prakar ke log hain (those who incite people, who do not want the country to progress) … unse sawdhan rahne ki zaroorat hai (need to be on guard against them).”

10:49 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Nishikant Dubey offers sweets to NSUI members

In a surprise turn of events, BJP MP Nishikant Dubey offered sweets to NSUI members, who gathered at his residence carrying roses, to protest against his statement on LoP Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi.

With ANI inputs

10:23 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: Oppn likely to move motion seeking impeachment of Allahabad HC judge

The INDIA bloc MPs are preparing to give notice to move a motion to impeach Allahabad High Court judge Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav over his controversial statements against minorities. This follows his controversial statements against minorities during an event organised by the Vishwa Hindu Parishad last week. As many as 38 Opposition MPs have signed the petition, which may be moved today if 50 signatures are obtained.

10:20 (IST) 12 Dec 2024
Winter session of Parliament Day 14 Live Updates: What's on agenda today?

Bills to be discussed and passed in Parliament today

  • The Disaster Management (Amendment) Bill
  • The Readjustment of Representation of Scheduled Tribes in Assembly Constituencies of the State of Goa Bill
  • Union Minister for Finance Nirmala Sitharaman is likely to move the Banking Laws (Amendment) Bill in Rajya Sabha.
  • 10:09 (IST) 12 Dec 2024

    Hello and welcome to Parliament Winter Session Live blog! Rajya Sabha witnessed a stormy session yesterday over the no-confidence motion filed by the Opposition MPs against Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar. The BJP MPs also created ruckus over the alleged nexus between US hedge fund tycoon George Soros and Sonia Gandhi. Today also, the Upper House proceedings are likely to begin on a stormy note. The INDIA bloc MPs are also planning to move a motion seeking the impeachment of Allahabad HC judge over his remarks against minorities.

    Latest Comment
    Post Comment
    Read Comments