T oprt ' c c roain o

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 1 of 50

2FoorSn0r 8WtCAt1e 1Ls,e0tt 8geEs 9 e n evS d eh Lsn e oA 7

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

23 285t( 16722e w wctaotn.m w .e tLiso tgsuo c

No e e 2 , 0 9 vmb r 4 2 0

'

tC3:'U '2''(.*'. k 'h l - h. ,. '* ' ?t .si -f m' T O ' ' - v ' . .N * * z ? 'O #e!7J 4 .N . '' u v . o ' l., n''.l,. ' L N .. .? t ' ' s t v ? ' m h-k. izTf7'>.-'e l T'.7'Li.f-i'', 1. . z t- t r ?
I. C-i k h2'. '$) k.'p/-.'. t. ,- '.. ., t, u( - l - z ) U6 J, . .
74 ** . h % Mt * ' t m .+e R: /. 3 jv Q q.4 '> , V. .. y' $J k >Z Q ' J' $: i .=

j .A ) $, )

FE . ID L - --.. ----. AlxKoisi e znk DCEE OKTD .DT . -.... . -;.-'. -. A. E 1;. C ' C f 2 9 S vnhSre, 5 e et t t e S nFacso CA 9 193 3 a rnic , 4 1-9 9 Re Kae Goisi/ : u Crs/ u S ilAsoit n : rn l k /ToBle osBle hed scai n o CaeNo 0 8 13 s . 907 Der iMan a Sr dm: /

Werhrwi rtrigte ret, ne OdrEhbtAtcmet)Rqet ae ee t eunn h Odrs Amedd re,xii t h nt, eus h ) , a s Fr swhc weee e rgrigteaoeatndmat. omt i rci deadn h bv cpi e tr l h v o e
BleCos u S il Asoito in titdo o reod o o terc rso teSae u rsYle hed scain s o l e n u rcrs r n h eod fh tt s o CA. f Veyt l yus r r y o r, u Je S e ad ol hp r Cop rt Op S eilt Co t co roae s pcai - nr tr s a Lo /5 5 7 5 6 g/ 17 6 7 F d Takn #7 1 16 44 eEx rc ig 9 5 2 1 10

CaionaSceayo Sae- 12/16/2009iesS acof- roainS ac Reut 10 a e1o 1 l ri ertr 09-80173CaionaB snPage: rh 50 pID:t erh DktEntry: P g f f f tt l ri u s e 2 Co r o f sl s Case: 7166651
'

&v;'j . .$ P;'.r. l N4 * t. I ' N'. .r . j x* * .X ,A k:i j' . es .i . . (:l)f . 1k111''' 'IfI11I r.lC'9:. 1 -f1.%. l4':I1! 1 k 1# I'? .2 $l'kL$ f. -. ' l t1$d. .I N l,'l l li : J.. ) rt ) t; t 13 2 1 $' 11 1 !Ji 9l F. I . iI I ' : ' - L'

. L ? 7 .

. .

@ .

p D

: *

. '' , . - ''p '

# , :' '

z Bspstac k uierirh Cnoaes o ss n r o

N w S ac e e rh S ac Tp e rh is FedD fnt n il eiio s i Sau D f io s tts ei t n ni N meA alblv a v i it a i C roaeR c rs op rt eod B sn s E t is u ie s nie t Retiaee Fr eoictsr om crsOr d d C rf C pe o is Sau R p rs tts e ot

..., . ,l -i ; .l p .h ( 9 .

.. r l S . a* = t' j t s' l . . :

T eifr t nds ly dh r ic r n a o ' C 1 , 0 9'n iu d tdwe h nomai ipae ees ur t s f' 12 0 'a ds p ae e o e DE in t c mpeeo c df drc r o teCop rt n s o a o lt r e ie e od fh roai . i o F rnomaina o te ict no croaerc rso fr d io a c roae o ifr t b u c dfai f op rt e od ro a dt n lop rt o i o i ifr t n pe s rfroC p rt Re od .f o aeu a lt Ict arc r nomai , lae ee t oroae c rs Iy u r n be oo ae e ot o mydqnsamtsetri scre yrei isiselq Re adQrvt e fareugas oerpnaeiacbodenlitt-rjdFvpn itc o oer t tu eetv nlh o trga3 ue jj.eq-:nd r r r i ar x sr eu d nh Qt ra: no; sr suI o e d p j r r j Cetiae a do cdf dc pe c nas b rq e tduigteod rom. rf ts n /re ie o is a lo e e u se sn h re fr ic i N rs l mac e tes ac tr :' u Crs / u S il As o it l o e ut th d h e rh em ' e o sBle hed s cai s Bl o N e h lwi y u s ac ? ed ep t o r e rh h

FQ AS
C roain ManP n o p rt s i a e o St S ac i e rh e

h p/ e lr o.ag vcrdt h wLs l :k pe. sc.o /op ais o it / s

1/42 0 21/0 9

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 3 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

UNI S TED TATESCOURTOFAPP EALS

FOR THE NI H CI T NT RCUI

FRULCTO O PBIAIN

F lL E D
*V1 2 8%
M IcD E GEK a Y WYq LR

u C TFEC . YROAPA i S

I THEMATT OFKARE N ER N GOLNS e u . I KI t x

No 0 -01 3 . 98 7
ORDER

R O f ! !9 E D 7F ' 7 . MEY. r-?E L c pt R,LR L .-? , E K '' G tY

USC !- k p, E L ..0.. ' sPAS .t) c $- y v Fr .

lr22 c 28 KOZI M , ifu g : NS Che Jd e

FElDt. DCEE OKTD
.-

DE A T

II NA I' TL

Mypirdso io i timalr i dJn ay1, 0 9a dalc e ro ip st n n hs te fl au r 3 2 0 n t h d i e a

hrwi ihrb odrdpbihd ee t s eey ree u l e. h s

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 4 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

UNI S ATESCOURTOFAP TED T PEALS FORTHENI CI T NTH RCUI

F IL E D
vu c ov

I THEM TT OFKARE N ER N GOLI KI NS

x xp& vs m 0RDE R

JN1 m A 3

D.6rajux -0 j y . S0 j

M e ly ehscmpando wok lc dsrmiain Kae Goisi mpo e a o lie f rpae ici nto . rn l k n iasafatre ateNit Cicihaqatri SnFacsoCai ri.l s tf tony th nh rut eduresn a rnic, lona n f 2 0 ,h mare AmyCunnhswi wh m sehsafv-erodsn Sne 0 8se rid n igi, t o h a iey a-l o. ic h hrsn'brh Goisi a pi fra lhat isrneu drh Feea e o s it, l kh s ad o fmi el nuac n e te drl n y h

E lyeHe1 BeetXc. t marigGoisipldtadhr f mpoes at nfs tAfr r n, l kapi o d ewi h e y n e e

t hr el isrneb t s eidbcueo Cl nnhsssx o ehat nuac,u wa dne eas f l igi' e. h n Th safatre'ofc igvre b teNit Cici'e ly n e tf t nys f es o end y h nh ruts mpomet o dsuerslt npa, ihpo ii dsr nto bsdo sxadsx a ip t eoui lnwhc rhbt ici ain ae n e n eul o s mi

oinain Gois cmpan tasehsbe dne h at isrnebn f retto. l l o lishth a en eid el nuac eehs nd h
frhrso s.S ei al,h p itt s lrys tdhtrsx a o e p ue pcfcl se onso i al i e eeoeul y mi ma e lye wh rcie el isrn e eet frtersossadag e ta mpoes o eev h at nuac bnfs o hi p ue n rusht h tet qatet n io acu t feu lrett nadsxnmeytesx h meulramets n con o sx aoinai n e, a l h e o o hr f.'h aalblyo hat isrnefroeefado esfmi ia f ewie r e viait f el nuac o n sl n n ' a l s i h y vlalbnft fmpometaddnao sc abns o act o sxad aube eeio e ly n,n eil fuh eetn comt fe n

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 5 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 2 ae

sx aoinainvoae tetr o teE pa tacvr Goisi eul retto iltsh ems fh EO lnhto es l k. n

Tednaocn dwhnte rcoote miirt eOfc ote h eilcu' e h Di tr th Ad nsai se fh e e tv

UntdSae Co rsrfsdt cri Goisi itiaino hrp uea i tts ut eue o ety 'l k' dnict f e so s s e f n s f o fmi ,eas h blvdtasc a iet ct nwa bne b teDees a l bcue e ei e htuh n dni ai s a-d y h fne y e f o

oMarg Ac( MA.1 SC j7 DO poieta, hnitprt g f rae tDO ) U... . MA rvdshtw e ne en i i

fdrla tetr d rig'men ol alglno bt e o ema ad eealw,h em d rae' as ry eau in ewen n n n ma l o ewo n adtewbdip ue'eesolt apro o teop sesxwh n ma,n h r s os'rfr ny o esn fh p oi e o s t

iah sado awie As t esaditeDi co hsrfsdt criy s ubn r f. 1mdrtn t h r tr a eue o et , e f

Goisio fmi cvrg bcuehr f in t osdrdasos fr l k fra l o eae eas ewi s o cniee p ue o n y e

proeo fdrla adtu i 'da l' shtemiue i5 SC. upss feealw,n hss tsmi ' tatr s sdn U.. j n f ya 80()whc iproteFdrlmpoe He1 Beek Ac(E BA) 931, i s atfh eeaE lye ah nfs tF H . h t
T ascinatole teOf oPesr l ngmetocnrcfrhat hteto uhrzsh f f romeMaae n t otato el ke h

bnspas oeigSmpoesnninsg dme es fhifnie .. eetl cvr s lye,nut t a q mbrote nnis . n ne a n r l

'S mbr fn l'i,ntr, e e a a e ly esso s adci rn 'd eo fmi 'si 'ndsnd sn mpoe' p ue n hl e. Me y u d

5 SC, 80() T e rcorashspoiin a ai ttno te' e U.. j 915. h Di tred tee rvs ss l ai nh tp e o mi o y
o pa fr zhOP ma cnrc.Un eticntu o , M wol at f ln o wlc M y otat drhs o s din OP ud c i r
byn i atoi iiweet cnrcfr ee tbyn toeseie i eodt uhrt ft r o ot to bnfs eod h s pct dn s y a l
scin8 0 . eto 9 3

Bu tiin'teol pasberaigo teF thss th ny luil edn fh EHBA.Antewa o ohr y f

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 6 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 3 ae cntl gteesauoypoiin ia ast f eeagieie fr dcl o sni hs tttr rvsoss s eo gnrl udl so meia n n

bnf pasa welsan mbro mii m rqie nshtuhpas s eeh ln,s la u e f nmu eurmettasc ln mut stsy Un eticnt t nOP wolb at gotietesoeo i aif. drhs o smci , M ud e ci usd h cp ft o n s atoi iicnrce fr pa taddn to e,a,ne lyescirn uh ry ft otatd o a ln ht i o cvrsya mpoe' hl e, t d b t oiicnrce frtn shtxedtemii msamoyrq ie n, u ntftotatd o en taece h nmu tt r eurmet

F rxmpescin80()nlds tite eiio o 'a l'a o en l,et 9 15 icuewi nh df tn ftmi 'n o h ni f y

e lyesSeedn ci u dr 2yaso ae'Un etebodr mpoe' d pn etll n e2 er f g. drh rae d ld ' cntut no tescin OP wo lb rqie t cnrcfrapa cvrn osrci fh eto, M ud e eurd o otato ln oeig o ci rnmet gtesauoydf io ,u wol b 9e t n gtaecvrg hl e ei h tttr e nt nb t ud e e o eoit oeae d n i taicu e odrci rn a utlg 2.-rohr mbr o te htnlds le hl e-sy niae 5 0 teme es fh d e lyesfmi ,uha prnso sbig l igi tee lyeshueod mpoe' n l sc s aet r il si n n h mpoe' o shl. y n v

Un e tibodrcntut n OP wo l as b fe t cnrcfr'mi ' drhs rae o s ci , M ud lo e reo otato fa l' r o f y

bn f fridvdas od n t ulya so ssmdreealw,u wh eekso n iiulwh o o qal spue t efdrla bt o f aecniee so ssu drsaelw. r o sdrd pue n e tt a Adpigtebodrcntut no tsa ent nyhr nzste ot h rae osrci fh tmt o ol amo ie h n o sa oyshmewi orE pa,tv isdfiut osi oaise.I1 tmtr ce t u EO ln iaod if lcntminlsus f h c t weet itrrth F I Aa ecu igsmesxso ss1 udfshv t r o nepete EO s xldn n -e p ue, wol l t aeo r

dcd whte sc a ecuinfrhr algt t gvrmetln .Beas eie ehruh n xlso utes eimae oen naed cue i meemoadsp rvl f o sx acnuts'sc a ed teas ro r rl iapo ao h moeulo dcintuh n n ,h nwet

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 7 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 4 ae
tiqet nialat obfl hs usi s tesdvtt. o l

IRo r .vn, 1 U..2 (96, eSpe C uted n mevE as57 S60 19)t urme orhl h
u cnt inlna nmetoteCooaocntuintapoiidcvl n osi o aa med nt h lrd o si t ht rhbt ii mt to e rgtpoet n frgy,ebasn bsx as Th sae b ssfrht ihs rtci so aslsin ad ieul. e ttd ai ota o a nmet ssmpyS rl iapoao h moeulo dc,h smesr med n wa i l d adsprvlf o sx acnutte a ot mo

omoadsprvlhtrdcdh cn isodci nla tag e or f rli poatapoue te emr -l r alwshtt C ut a e mi h q hlcntuinln( wes , rwi ,7 U..8 (96,vrue b ed ostt ai Bo rvHad c 48 S 16 18)oerld y io k Lwrne . xs59U..5 (0315J.t4 (cl,.dset g.T e a ec vTea,3 S5820),- a64 SaaJ,isni ) h .( 1 i n
Co rh ltaa1wta(lsie hmoeuln tofrhrapoe lgsaie utedht a htdass s o sx as o t ute rpreilt c v

edbtomaete ueuloeeyn es'ak aaoabssL.t 3 n ut k hm nqat vroe l lcs rtnlai.4a65 e i

( jryoiin.I liiticnlsnitadsprvlfo sxai maoi pro) mpitnhsocui sht i poaohmoeuly t l c o a t

i ttefapoe lgsaieed s i l rpreilt n . n' s v

MoevriRet rvMuky37U..6 (97, eSpe C ut roe,n i i. le,8 S39 16)t urme or ma h

src d wnaCai rih uiglw.T e1wwa fcalnurl trseto tuk o lona osn a h a sail etawi epct f y h rc:Byi o tr ,ti l poetdcrano esi adslrgto ae t wn emsismpy rtce eti wnrhp n aeihs f s poeto es Bu teCorcnlddta,ntebsso tecnet n rpry wnr. th uto cu e hto h ai fh otx ad cru tne o telw'psaeihdteSeinaditn'o weknn te icmsacs fh a s asg,t a h d sg n net f aeigh d '

s t'atdsr nt nl .J.t 7 . i ncusld'iigfcs n t es ni ici ai a . a34 Rema onee Cfn atad a - mi o ws ( t st

wegigcru tn e o acs-ycsb ss t dtr n whteteSae ihn icms cs n aeb-ae ai'o eemie ehrh tt a '

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 8 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 5 ae hsbcmeSinfcnl ivle i piaedsrmiain,whc ifridn a eo sgi at n ovd n rvt ici nt s' ih sobde. s y o '

J.t7 (traqoainmak adcaino td. . a38ienlutt rsn it mie) d n o to t

WhteDOMA's eigcasfct nhsapoe lgsaieedo ehr swepn lsi ai a rp reilt n,r i o v whteirGetn moeta a ivdosdsg t simaieaddsd atg ehrte cs o r hn n niiu eip o t t n iavnae g z

smesxculsiahr qet n eiq l cn utdb teCori a -e ope,s ad usi .Th nur o dce y h utn o y Ret nit tehsoyadcnet fh Caio a1wwa sacigad i noh itr n otx o te l mi a s erhn n ma f crfladt cnu asmirn ur o DOMAwol b adl aead aeu,n o o dd i l iqiy f a ud e el t n c
dfclts. isutak

A sprt l eo atoi wo l as rqiemet dtr n whte eaaei f uhry ud lo eur o eemie ehr n t DOMAi emisbypmi e hmoeuly I La ec v. xs5 9U. mpr sil t s s o sx ai . n wrn e Tea,3 S. h t

58(03,h Spe C t'naiae a ea sater nligsmesx 5 20)te urme ouivl td Txstttci ain a -e t d z mi z
sdmy Th uhi fcsaenro i rao igadteptnilcp o is o o . og t at r arw,t esnn n h oet so e ft s s a h ligaebod La ec rssepiiyo tepo oiintat-a ad odn r ra. wrne et x l t nh rp st htdulws n cl o o
taio afr ont inlrtcint pro addso seaigtmarae rdt n fod o si o apUet o esnl e in rlt o rig, i mt o n porain cnrcpin fmi rlt nhp,hl rai ,n eucto ,ad rcet ,otaet ,n l eai siscid er ad d ain' n o o y o ng '

taoeseulrnainteeoeejy poet n9o pmin n.L.t htn'sx aoi tt hrfr nos rtci m t smet 4a e o o l
54 T eCorwet nt domslgisatmps yteSaeo acutt 7 . h ut n o os t eaantte tb h tt,r or,o c

df eh menn oteeaosi otsttbudr sbetnuyta ei te aig fh rlinhp ro ei onai asnijr o n t s e

pro o aueo a isttntea poet. J.t 6 . esn r b s f n ntut h lw rtcs - a5 7 io '4

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 9 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 6 ae T ebu d o La ec'hligaeu certiiiefadfkut te h o n s f wrn es odn r nla;hsst l i lmatr s f

o cntuinla a wercnlrcgie i Wi vDe'o AiFoc,57 f osito alw,s eet eonzdn t . pt f r re 2 t y t

F3 869hCr20)Wihltate laysro'As, nt el .d 0 (t i.08. t edhth mitr' nt kDo'T1' t i '

p lywhc po iis pnh moeulyi teame fre, a t srie oi , ih rhbto e o sxai n h r d ocshd o uvv o t hihee srt ya apidt ec srieme e dshre .Gie te egtnd cui s p l o ah evc mbr icagd vn h n e 'tde l to tevraaayii La ecrwedcie teivtto o Ctidi s fh eblnlssn wrne' el d h n i in f sz mi ' n a

teprist tikt uhLa ec wi af -otp cmbadt gv l at odo hog wrn e t metoh d o n o ie l e p h

ceec t te atuatrs f hae sd'J.t 1.We lmae rdn eoh prcl un o pxsue. . a 86 ut tl i r i y fsindamut-rn e blnigtsfrsaesnt no hmoeuly ahoe l pogd aacn eto tt aci f o sx ai i o t drvd9o yt nte sprt l eo Spe Coratoi , el .Untd eie m eaohr eaaei f urme utuhrt Slv i n y e

Sae,3 U,.6 (03. tts59 S 16 20)

Th efd o La ec adWi o adsr ntr bnft1waefr e fe f wrn e n t n ioi aoy ee sa r a t mi
9o cer l udhv t cnie,o ea l,h rlt emantd o te m la. wo l aeo osdrfr xmpete eai giue fh v

saesnto hr:La ec iv le aci n l eat,u tapnl wa tt acin ee wrnen ovd r apnl btht eat s mi y y o l as lf e Goisi asotop cet p rhs adt nl el ny mali . l k py u f okto ucae dio ah at n n i h isrnefr e so s,n hrepne eo mot ece tettlme nuac o hrp uead e x ess ah nh xedh oaf

i oe iLwrneI udnetapyWi'mutpogd aac gts mpsdn a ec. wol edopl ts l-rnebl i et t i nn

o fsinmyo itrrtt no La ec'rqie ns nete cs,a raho wn nepeai f wrneseurmet-i i r ae o h

ma r eiinocntuinla j dcs fostt al o o i o w.

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 10 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 7 ae Whnasaueamiswocntut n,n o whc rq ie adcso e ttt d tt osrci soe f ih euzs eiin o

o ahr qeto o cntuinla ihsln be orpatc t peete n ad usin f o sitoalw,t a o g en u rcieo rfrh t

atmaie Aswadr . enValyAuh,9 U..8,4- 6(96 l t . h nevTn. l t. 7 S28354 13) e v e 2 ( adi,.cnur g.T e icsinaoeiuta sh cntuinl BrnesJ ocri ) h dsus bv ls t te osit a , n o l re to
tiktnowhc tedsrmiaoycntzto das s Ihrfr cns z hceit ih h ici ntr osncin rg u. teeoe o t e n

teFdrl lyeHe1 Bee s topr th cvrg o smesx h eeaEmpo e at nftAct emite oeae fn -e h
SO SS P Ue. T eDi co o teAd nsrt eOfieo teUntdSae Corsi h r tr fh miitai lc fh i tts ut s e v e

teeoeodrdt sb t rnGoisi He1 B nss lcinfr 20 , hrfr ree o u miKae l k' at eetBet om 89 n s h o whc sesg e adsb t do Spe e2 2 0,oteaporaehat ih h ind n u mie n etmbr ,0 8t h prpit el t h isrnecrir An ftr hat bnf fr aeas t b poesdwi ot nuac are. y uue el eei oms r lo o e rcse t u h t h rgr ttesxo altdsos. eado h e f ie p ue s

? l -oT z
e Koisi x znk Che Jde ifu g

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 11 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

FI ED L
FOR P UBLI ON CATI NOV 1 2 0 9 09
MOL.on oEpC E K uL C D FRpLs .Y - A, AR sc WY Eu r

UNI S TED TATESCOURT OFAPPEALS

FOR THENI CI T NTH RCUI

I THEMATTER OFKAREN N GOLl S Ie u . N K tx

No 0 -0 7 . 98 1 3 ORDER

Kae Gois i a b e d ne abe eio fd rl mpo me t e a s rn lnk h s en e id n f f e ea e ly n b cu e t s emare awo nrte ta ama .1pe iu l d tr n dta voae ti h rid ma ah rh n n rvo sy eemie h t iltshs cu tsg aateo e u l mpo me t p otnt.S el r Goisi2 0 WL o r' u rne f q a e ly n o p ru i e n e l k, 0 9 y n

2284a* (tCi Jn l,09. T aodadfiutosit nl 22 87t 19h r a.32 0)* o vi i clcntui a . * f to

po lm, hr nzdteDees o Mar g Ae( rbe l amo ie h fne f ri e tDOMA)1U.. #7 te a , SC. 'h ,
saue cet gteb n ft rga a ise teFe ea Empo esHe 1 ttts rai h e eipo rm tsu ,h d rl ly e at n h

B nfs rga (E )5U.. q 8 0 esq; n ticut cmmi n e ei Po rm F HBP, SC. j 9 1 te .ad hs o rs o t t t ' me
t e t l mpo me t p otnt.l r Gois i2 0 WL2 2 8 4a * -3 o ql e ly n o p ru i n e l k, 0 9 a y n 228 t 1 .
lh ne trdteflo n od r te nee h olwig re:

* hl p ro n l t r aeodn rl c n ie t lMs Gois i a W e ' i es n e mat s r riai o fd ni , . l k h s e y a n c n e tdt teu eo h r a i ti od r o sne o h s f e n me n hs re. *Be a s lrl o ia b c go n frti od rI a edrce my * cu e ey n t s a k ru d o hs re, h v ietd erirod r ep bih d al re b u l e . e s

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 12 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

P# 2 ae

Th Dietro teAd nsrt eOfieo teUntdSae Co rs e rco fh miitai fc fh ie tts u t v i teeoeod rdt s b t rnGois isHe l Be ei sh rfr ree o u miKae l k' at n ft n h s Elcinfr 2 0 , ihsesg e a dsb t do S pe e 2 e t om 8 9 whc h in d n u mie n e tmb r , o t 2 0 ,otea po raeh at is rn ecrir An ftr h at 0 8 t h p rp it el nua c are. y uu e e l h h b n f fr aeas t b po esdwi o t e adt tesxo a e ei oms r lo o e rc se t u rg r o h e f t h ltds o s. ie p ue s
1 .t* .NoS at o idvd a a giv d' ymyd cso a p ae i S eU.. d a 3 l ry rn iiu l g re e 'b p e iin p e ld t e S . Co ro Ap e lfrteNit Cic i E ly n Dip t ReouinPa 9 u t f p as o h nh rut mpo me t sue s lt ln , o

(97 (eenf r DRPa) 19)hriat E ln. e T eAdmnsaieOfieoteUntdSae C ut( cmpidwi h liirt f fh i tts or AO) o l t t v c e s e h
myod r n slmie Ms Goisisfr 2 0 t teBleCrs a dBle re a d t t d . l k' om 8 9 o h u o s n u b t n
S il S rieBe eiPln Ms Goisish at is rn ecrir Th tsa i hed evc n ft a , . l k' el nua c are. a' s t n h

solb;h AOisbetote'uevs naddrcin o teJdca hud ete stjct h s prii n i t ' fh uiil l o eo Co frn e fh UntdSae, 8U... 6 4a,n 1 xrie atoi neec o te i tts2 SC j 0 ()ad eecsd uh ry e t
d lg tdb teJ dca Co frn ewh nIod rdrl flAfe teAO ee ae y h u iil nee c e ree ei . trh e

l i c utsEDRpa wa a o tda tedrcin a dwi tea po a, Ths o r' ln s d pe th ieto , n t h p rv l h o teJliil n ee c o teUntdSae,e Jdca Co frn eo te f h t ca Co frn e fh i tts se u iil nee c fh d e

UntdSae, dl DRPa ,h 1jlh riatr dl DRPa )E i ttsMo eE ln c ., (een f Mo eE ln, DR e e '

l9 2 3(9 6.Jdca of es cigp ru n t or DRpa hv te 9 5 - 19 ) t iil fi r at usato u E ln aeh l c n

Pa a l a p ro teta io o d c nll e a miitaina dlcl ln t , s at fh rdt n f ee tai d d nsrt n o a i -z o ma a e n o tefd rl o rs J dca Co frn eo teUntdSae, td n g me t fl e ea c ut. u iil nee c fh i ttsSu y n e o Jliil a c Co ea eP ru n t teCo geso a Ac oltblyAc o f t ca Brn h v rg us a to h n rsin l c t a it t f d n i ls o sblya da toi opo ieterg t, rtcin , n rme is'o - p n iit n uh rt t rvd h ihspoeto sa d e de't e i yt

jdcae lye ejydb cnrsinlmpoesadd s itenmeo u iilmpoesnoe y oges ae lye,n o onh a f o

teJliil nee c .S ei. tl . h t ca Co frn e e d a 5 d

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 13 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

PV 3 aC

j8 0l4 9 .0 .
Th E etieBrn h at gtru hteOfieo P ro n l n g me t e x clv a c , ci ho g h fc f es n e Ma a e n t n

( M)to g t tewi .ldrce teisrn e ar r o t poes . OP ,h u h ohr s t i td h nuac cri n to rcs Ms e e e

S eLetrfo Lorie e te rm ran

E. t n Asitn Di.Is S rsP o rmsU.. fc o PesMg .t Det , ssa t r,n . ev . rga , S Ofie f r. mt,o ma Na c E. r , p t Asitn Di.Ofieo Hu nRe.Ad n Ofieo n y Wad De uy ssa t r, fc f ma s, mi. fc f

wh tfrh rse saen csayt poet . l s i n teitgi o te a tte tp r e esr o rtc Ms Goi k a d h ne rt fh l n y
J dcaysEDR pa s u iir' ln .
Rer s etv Reif to p cie l e

MsGoisi a rq etda a r u drh BakP yAc.5U... j . l k h seu se n wad n e te c a t SC j n

5 9 e sq Tlsc utsEDR pa po ie ta rl f n e teBakPa Ac i 5 5 t e . n o r' i ln rvd s h tei u d r h c y ts e

aalbeE Pa a9 1 ,e Dosnv Gr s, 9 F3 16 l5(dCi v i l, DR ln t - 0 se to . i a3 8 .d 5 ,7 2 r a . e . 2 0 )Bln esi v Mc nl, 7 F3 19 , l5(t Ci 19 )ad1 s 0 5; aknhp . Do ad 16 .d 12 l9 9h r 9 9,n mut .
rs lea ycam frsc rl fi tefrtisa c .EDR Pa a 3 eov n li o u h ei n h is ntn e e ln t .

5 9 ()2, u l l a r o n pir eemiaina t whth wigte mut 5 6a()b t a wae f o r dtr nt so a so n hy s m o o

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 14 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pv 4 ae

maet lciea a r. I o cu ete mut rv tretig:1 teehs k o-eev n wad2 cn ld h y spo ehe hn s()hr a

be aesn eat n'ta()sdnutido uwarne'ad()eut en i ronlci ' ht2 i ujsie r n ratd' n 3 rsl p o' f ' s ial tda lreutno alr at ftee lyespyalwacso n ' hrwao rdci f1opro ( mpoe' a,l ne,r wi o h j o dfeet l. l. 59 ()l. i rni s' d j 5 6b() f a'
1 Th BakP yAc d f e ap ro n l cint icu elh o sino . e c a t ei s esn e at o n ld ' e miso r n o t

fir ttk a atnt cneabnf. 1. 59()5.Ias cvrt al eo ae n ci o ofr eei' dj 56b() tlo oes$ u o t' a dcso cnenn pygrbnfs' eiin ocrig a o) eei. t'
po ieMs Goisi i h at isla c fr e wiestsisete d fnt n rvd . l k w t e l nt n e o h r f aife i r eiio . n h h r h i

2 IidOP 'df io ote haelnutido twarne . f M s eitn fh p rs jsie rl ratd n ni u f n

p ro n l cin' es aie F r tp sso ti c utsEDRpa Iteeoe es n e at 'p ru sv . o pl o e fhs o r' o r ln h rfr d fn ta p rs t men: eie h t hae o a

( Iat f o sino a at f mi in(e,alr t tk a AI co cmmi o r n c o o s o i.fi e o ae n ' I s s . u at no cne ab nf)htnapo r t atoi sbeunl ci r o fr eei ta a p rpi e ul ry u sq et o t a t y
' h v n c nrligpe e e t nwhc t rl. OP ' rg lt n d nt l a e o o tol rcd n o ih o ey M s e uai s o ' n o

apyo ter wnfre5U.. j59()adticamdentrsudrh pl fhio oc, SC. 56c,n hs li os'aie nete jrdcino teCol o Fdrl amsteFdrl i utteMeiSse ui it fh ttf eeaCli ,h eeaCr i h r ytm s o r c, t Poet nBor ( P ) r smir ni cagdwi itrrt gte t rtci ad MS B o a i l ety hre t nepei h Ac. o a t h n T ebd wi sprioyti it noetipoedn teJdcaC u cl h oy t bevsrjrdci vrhs rceig h uiil oni hl ls o
o teNit Cicl h sn ts fra I n w, a o c so t itrrth Ac. fh nh rtt a o, o a s k o h d cain o nepe te t i No a la r o a ysmi ruig fo oh rcrut' u iil u cl o te r m wae f n i l rl s rm te ic i Jdca Co n is r h a n s J dca Co frn eo teUntdSae.Mya ay i i, o v rc n itn wi u iil nee c fh i tts e n lss sh we e, o sse t t h ta i arcn od r fa oh rEDR tiu a i teNit Cic i.S eI r h tn e et re o n te rb n ln h nh rut e n e

Lvno, .98 12sio.t02 (t CiNo.82 0) eesnNo0-07,l pa2- 2 9h r v 1,09. p .

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 15 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 5 ae d tr n so teb sso sb tnieo po eu a d fcst h v eemie, n h ai f u sa t r rcd rl eet,o a e v

be ujsf do twarne u drplallw, xct e en ntti rl r td neapi bea E eui lie n a c v

od rrl,e uain o ma d tr p ro n l oiyetbih db re,ue rg lt , r n aoy esn e p l sa lse y o c a a e c o tru hac let eb rann are n.S c at n n g n y rho g olci ag iig geme t u h ci s v o

icuepronlcin adpyat n (ln o icmbnt n. nld esn eat sn a ci saoe rn o iai ) o o o 5C... 5 083 h ign y' eeiteUntdSae Co ro Ap elfr FR j 5 .0 .T e ec'hr sh i tts ut f p as o a e teNitCiut5U... 59() )2 U.. j60ad1 ocueta h nh r i SC j 56a( '8 SC. 1,n cnld ht cn 2,
d n iga e ly eab n f b sdo h r e o sx a oinainvoae o e e yn n mpo e e ei ae n e sx r e u l re tto ilts n t
o 0. n aoyp ro n l oiis' S eE Pa a 2 f 1-E d tr esn e p l e. e DR ln t . 1 ma 1 c '

3 l lofn OP Sd f io o a , l wa cs a ddfee tas' . as id M' ei t n f y al n e,n ifrnil' ni p o

p ru sv .lh rfr d tr n ta teAc c v r S a ,ev , n oh r esa ie teeoe eemie h th t o esG y la e a d te p mo eaye ly n b n ft t whc a e ly eie tldb saueo n tr mpo me t e ei o ih n mpo e s nie y ttt r s t

rg aina dwhc aep y beb tee lyn a e c t a e ly ed rn eult n ih r a a l y h mpo ig g n y o n mpo e u ig o

pr d o F d rl mpo met'5CFR. 5 08 3 h cmmetr t ta ei s f eea e ly n. .. j 5 .0 .T e o nay o ht o '

rg lt nsy iicu e ' e ei rcie u d rteF d rl mpo e h at e uai a stn ld st n ft e ev d n e h e ea e ly e e l: o b s l

b nfs n go pleisrnepo rms' 6F d Re. 82 l5 ,7 ( c eei ad ru i ntac rga ,4 e . g 5 ,7 , 82 2 De. t f l ' 18 )s l o cu eso sl el isrnebn fs uly As . l si 9 l,o cn ld p uah at nuac eei q ai . MsGoi k h t f n
h sb e d ne teb n fto isrn h rwie AmyCu nn hsh rla , a en e id l e ei fnu ig e f, a n ig i, e y p

alwacsgrdfeetl' aebe l i da gj reugd. l ne,oj i lnishv ens t rw n o rd cej' o f- a wh 5 3

51as c n ld ta l pirod r t l isa at orcino te lo o cu e h tmy ro re ql ie s ' reto fh af c

(o t u d. cni e .) n .

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 16 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 6 ae 4 Bae o tea o e 1c n ld Ms Goisise tldt a a r u d r . sd n h b v , o cu e . l k i nie o n wad n e n t teBakP yAc,n l ee ti matroteAp elt Co sin rt h c a ta d rfr hs te t h p l e mmiso e o a

d tr iei a u t W i i 7 dy teCo sin rs alowadt me wi eem n t mo n. t n 0 a s h mmiso e h lfr r o , t s h h

c pe t tep risarp ra drc ml n aina t tea r 1so de tr o is o h at , e ot n eo me d t so h wad h ul ne e o

( cu igatres fe adayohr ntr a r t whc MsGoisi i ldn t ny'es n n te mo eay wad o ih . l k n o n

ma b etldu drh Ac) y e nie n e te t. t

Bea s Ms Gois i a ara ywatdtoln frrl fI s t a od c u e . l k h s led i o o g o ei , wih o v i n e e ten e fra dto a po e dn st d tr n tea u t f e a r .l h e d o d i n l rc e ig o eemie h mo n o h r wad i teeoeofrteCo sin rh flo n gl a c :Co e str d ma e h rfr fe h mmiso e te olwig ti n e mp naoy a g s d

ae t eo ea l u d rti c utsEDRpa , Plna 1 ,oMsGois is rn'rc v rbe n e hs o r' ln EDR a t 0 s . l k i n

e tldo l t a a r e u lna u toteb n ft sewo l h v rc ie , nie ny o n wad q a i mo n t h e ei h ud a e e ev d t s

b t a b e dne, n e teF HB ,eadeso whte sesset r (r u hs en eid u drh E P rgrls f eh rh ' p n moe o ls) nisrn ei teitr 1 eemieh rlvn mesr o toe es o ntac n h nei dtr n te eeat aue fh s l m.
b n f sob tec s o o tiigc mp rbepiaeis rn efrh rwie se5 e ei t e h o t f bann o aa l r t nua c o e f, e t v

U.. j5 9 ()1( ( , ihteCo sinr h udcl lto a nhy SC. 5 61()A)i whc h mmi o e so l ac ae n mo tl 3 ) s u 3.cniud (. t e) .o n pro n lcin'5U.. j5 9()1( ,o p roe o teBakP yAc. esn e at v SC. 5 6b() fr up ss fh c a t o A) 2 M... 2 0 2 2 7 (9 4. 1 SPR. 7 , 7 - 3 18)

De yn b c p ysmpyb cu earme il ereh sb e fu tae wo l b n ig ak a i l ea s e da d ce a en rsrtd ud e ie utbe l a ye etIsen rao ta b c p ycn o b a re n q i l. n n v n, e o e sn h t ak a a n t e wad d a c ne o a e u l wi ac retv a t n.S eRo is nv De 'o teAr , o tmp rn o sy t orcie ci e bno . pt fh my h o

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 17 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 7 ae

bss o terlv n pr ds o t . aifrh eeat ei t) fi o me

Pr s etv Reif o p cie l e Ana r o b c p yo l c mp n ae Ms Gois io dsrmiain wad f ak a ny o e sts . l k fr ici n to n

sess fee u tlo a .Ih v n rao t b l v ta tidsrmiainwi h ' ufrd nitd y a e o es n o ei e h ths ici n to l e l caewi o t ute ato o myp r, o1 loc n ie wh te t ga t es t u frh r cin n ats as o sd r eh ro rn h

popcieeif s l hraetreotn:1aanodrnol no rset rl a wel ee r he pi s()gi re erl t f v e .T o me MsGoisi wi i aF HBPisrne lnwioteadthre;2 etr . l k' f n E nuac pa t u rgr o e sx()ne n s e h
a od rp-s et eya rigb c p yt Ms Goisip y beo sme n re l p ci l wadn a k a o . l k, a a l n o o v n rgla b ssu tl h i p r t dt e rlh roh r s-l il so s fr e t r ai, nis e s emie o nol e tewieei be p u e o l t g

islnebn fso () on tigadlae . l si t teb re o ntac eei , r3 d ohn n ev MsGoi k wi h udn f l t' n h
fl gan w c mpan e eyt sewo l l et p rh s h at isla c fr in e o lit v r i h ud i o u c ae e l nt n e o i me k h r h rwie e f. Th tido t nice ryia po rae F riga e ly et e desy e hr pi s lal n p rp it. ocn n mpo e o n lsl o

liaetesmecam wolb ujsadwatflfh cut E Rrstcs igt h a li ud e nutn seuo te or' D eol e. t s r
Nod u toa odta v r rsl,h EDR pa se iial a toie a od r o b t v i h t ey eutte ln p cf l uh rzs n r e c y

dsg e t rset eyisre cmpin e wi ticut g aateo ein d o opci l nugq o l c' t hs o r' u rne f p v a ' h s
eu l mpo ne t p otnt.EDR Plna 9 Tod n tigi tic s wo l q a e ly nn o p rt i ly a t . o ohn n hs ae ud ra ta ln u g o t fh pa . ed h ta g a e u o te ln

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 18 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

PV 8 aC 1cn ie tesc n o t nia po raeb ct eiwo l b ac lsa o sd rh eo d pi n p rpit e al t ud e oo sl o s wat o tx a e mo e .Unietee ly ei I r Le e s n Ms Goisis se f a p y r n y l h mpo e n n e v n o , . l k i k n ara ysg e t frafmi pa t c v rh c i rno temara e Ad ig led in d l o a l ln o o e te hl e fh rig . dn p y d h rwiesn met tepa wo l c s teg v rme t ohn , l r e f' a o h ln ud oth o en n n tig ;e n e

Le e sn No 0 -012 si o .t1 -1 & n., i po iigpop cie v n o , . 9 8 7 ,l p a 3 4 6 whl rvdn rse t p e v rl fi tefr o sb tueisrn ec v rg wo db e p n ie ei n h om f u si t n ua c o ea e ul e x e sv . e t Alo imih b i osbet fn a isrn epa o tepiaemak t s ,t g t e mp sil o id n n ua c ln n h rv t re ta po ie e atytesmeb n ft a po ie u d rteF h t rvd s x cl h a e ei s rvd d n e h EHBP.Gru pa s s o p ln
amot l y po iebo d rc v rg ta idvd a pa s l s c n ie te l s awa s rvd ra e o ea e h n n iiu l ln . mu t o sd rh

h sl a de p n eo fn igsc apa , v niid e e ita wel Ia as ase n x e s f idn u h ln e e ft o s xs, s l. m lo

u c ranwh te l rs et e' akp ywo l p t . l sinap st na n eti eh rs op ci 'b c a ud u MsGoi k i o io s p v n i av na e u a ih r f weec v rdb pe u ta aea tmaial d a tg o s s f e wie r o ee y rmimsh t r uo t l c y d dltd petx fo h rp y h c .An , v nitoemu d n c n en e t e , r-a ,rm e a c ek d e e fh s n a e o crs c wee 'pee tteei a ih rn ieu lyi alwigsmee ly e t rnt rsn,h r s n n ee tn q ai n lo n o mpo es o t

p rii t fl i teF atcpae ul n h EHBP, i gvn oh r awa o cs t g eswh r. y whl iig tes d f ah o o le ee e
Ev nited siainitesme i'si teb c o teb s e fh etn t s h a ,ts tl h ak fh u . o l Th EDR pa po ie ta l yod ra e esr a dap o rae' e ln rvd sh t ma re c say n p rpit' n rme yfr rpaedsrmiain EDR Pa a 9 o tedsrmiainses e d o wok lc ici n to . ln t .F rh ici n to h '

sfee i tep s, cno frMsGois i nymo e .Th rme yta' ufrd n h atl a fe . l k o l n y e e d h ts n

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 19 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 9 ae ip rp it'frh ftr, o v rie rl n o Ms Gois iswieit te ' po rae'o te uu e h we e,s nol t f . l k' f no h a me n

smeporma op sesxsos wo lejy le n jsictnfr a rga n poi-e pue ud no. se outiai o t f o

gvn Ms Goisi lse rme ya slsa ta tx a e e p n ewh nsecn iig . l k a esr e d t t tnila p y r x e s e h a n b
h v aflrme ya z r c s t tetx a es a e ule d t eo oto h a p y r.

Mya toi t od rsc rl ficer n e teln u g o teEDR uh rt o re u h ei s la u d rh a g a e fh y e

pa .I. tl 9 1 .Ho v rOP Sato si ti c s sg eth tfrh r ln d a , - 0 we e, M' cin n hs ae u g s ta ute

e pa aini e esra Oreige r l n ip o e a dwi i my x ln t s csay' d rn nol ts rp r n t n o n ' me h

jrdcinbcueCogesitne titiu atb teslfrmfr ui it eas nrs neddhsr nlo eh oe ou o s o b

ajdct gcmpans f rpaedsr nt nb e lye o te dt iai o lito wok lc ici ai y mpoes fh l n mi o

J dcay.' i ta rso sblymut on p we e u lotets . u iir W t h tep n iit s c ne o r q a t h ak h i 1 Co gesh sd cd dta teJ dcay'EDR tiu asaeteo l . n rs a e ie h th u iir s , rb n l r h ny

frmwhrjdcae lye ma se rdeso ulwflesneatn. ou eeuiilmpoes y ek ersfr na upronlci s o

S eDosn 3 8F.da 1 1 6 Bln e s i,1 6F3 a 1 9 , ev Hu h s e to , 9 3 t 7 -7 , a k n hn 7 .d t 1 5. . g e, . Le

15F3 17,26(1hCi 19) Ou e lye cntp eloteMS B, 4 .d 22 l7 lt r 98. rmpoes a 'apat h P 4 .

te h v n Bie sat na dte ae t rvd drme isb teCiiS r ie h y a e o v n ci n h y rn'po ie e de y h vl evc o
4Ha myoiia od rc mefo teMS ,teewo l h v b e n d rgn l re o rm h PB h r ud a e en o

qet ntaiwolhv hdtb oee.Se5U.. j10()2' rv usi htt ud ae a o e byd e SC. 24a()Ker . o , NEA,2 F2 7073(e. rl8) Ou E tiu asaetepaeo te 76 .d 3,3 FdCi.94. r DR r nltk h lc fh b MS Bfrt iilmpoess imae snetaCoges aeor DR P ojdcae lye,ot kses ht nrs gv u E l
tiu asp wesc e tn iewi to eo teMS r n l o r o xe sv t h s fh PB. b h

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 20 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 1 ae 0

ReomAco sael e,..Dosn3 8F3 a1 17 .lauiil fr trtt a eeg, to,9 .d t7- 6 f jdca w.S e lyesfesa tjsie pronlcin sc abigfe o acut f mpoe ufr nlutid esneat ,uh s en id n con o n f o r
rc , e o rl in teo l rme yp sil wo l c mefo a EDRtiu a. ae sx r ei o ,h ny e d o sbe ud o rm n g rb n l Ou EDR tiu asmu th rfr h v teatoi t ga tul eificu ig r rb n l steeoe a e h uh rt o rn flrle,n ldn y

lisae n (r tepopcierltadbc py Ita'ntrejdca -nttmeto ohr rset eil n ak a. fht ot ,u iil e v e s u

e ly e wh aevci o dsrmiainwo l h v n rme ya al mpo es o r it f ici n t ms o ud a e o e d t l . 2 OPM ' at n i l aea e e moefn a na c n en te . s ci s mpi t n v n r u d me tl o cr 'h o c . a tn mya did p n e c o teJdcaya ac -q a b a c o g v rme t uo o n n e e d n e fh u iir s oe u l rn h f o en n. I efc, M h scame ta i itrltto so terg t a db n fso n fetOP a li d h tt nep- ain fh ihs n e ei f s e t

jdcae lye aeetldt spe c oetoeoteJdcay T a' uiilmpoes r nie o urmay vrhs fh u iir. hts t
ic reta dteEx c tv mu t e c frhrseth J dcaysitrrtto n orc, n h euie s h n eot ep c te u iir ' nepeain

o telwsapialtjdcae lye.An ohreut udpeeth fh a p l beouiilmpoes y terslwol rvnte c

Jliir fo kc o l hn i c n tuin l asg e fn t n , Nio v t cay rm s c mpi ig t o si t al sin d u ci s' x n . d a s s to y o '

Ad 'o Ge . ev.4 3U.. 2 ,4 (9 7,ysr ul u dr nn o r m r f n S rs 3 S 4 5 4 3 l7 )b ei s n emiig u , o y

3l 1 lyO C 1 1O'1l at1.C i ima b c n e in t h v te .t ' ' V 17 - 1- m t - l t y e o v ne to a e h tO1 l - CS 1C eS Wh e Ol 1

pronlytmo g eJdcay cvrdb tepronl ngmet ewok esnesse ft u iirjoee yh esnemaae nnt r h
o tee e uieba c ,ti c nrr t ted crn o sp rto o p wes' fh x c t rn h i s o tay o h o tie f e aain f o r. v '

H.. p 1 1701,t (9 0,er tdi l9 U.... . . 79 1 1. R Re. 0 -7 4)a6 19 )rpi e n 9 0 SCCAN l0 , 7 0 n

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 21 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pv 1 ae 1 OP h sad t t tk cr ta telwsb fi fl e e ue , u ima M a uy o a e ae h th a e at ul x c td b tt y h y

n t irg r ac odn t ba-hsc n tu t no telwsta a pyt i o dse ad o riae rl ' o srci fh a h t p l o t l c o s e ly e .Nols ta teoh rba c e o g v rme tteJ dcayi mpo es es h n h te rn h s f o en n,h u iir s d p n e t np o l t cryo tt miso .Barn u fo d tr nn , ti e e d n o e pe o ar u i sin rig s rm eemiig wi n s h
rao a l b u d,h rg t a ddliso o r es n e u d rh lwspo iig e sn be o n s te ihs n t e f u p ro n l n e te a rvdn t frtere ly n wo l ma eu a a d ie o teE euie' Untd o h i mpo me t ud k s d n mad n fh x c t . i h v ' e

Sae v S t,9 F2 5 4 5 9(t Cr19 ) T e o r oht itrrt tts . mi 8 9 .d 6 , 6 6h i.9 0. h p we b t o nepe h

a de etea1w i tep we t c nrlh s g v re b i CfTh F d rl t n x cl a s h o ro o to to e o en d y t . e e eai t . s

No 4 (a e Maio ) . 7 Jm s dsn.
Co cr a o t u haft i p riual auefrh J dca Brn h We n en b u sc ae s at lry c t o te u iil a c . c
rl o Co gest fn a dteEx c t et cryo t n ap cso o rd y ey n n rs o u d n h eui o ar u ma y s et f u a v

t-a o eain .GS ma a e teb i ig wh r wewok Trauyc t o r od y p rt s A n g sh ul n s ee o d r, es r us u c ek , S Masaspo ieo rsc rt a dOP a miitr o re ly e h c sU.. rh l rvd u eui n M d nses u mpo e y
b n ft po rms Bu itete r o sp rt p wesmen a yhn ,tsta e ei rga . tfh h oy f e aae o r a s n tig i h t s '

teEx c tv c n o u ei d mia c o e lgsist d sryo ra tn my h e uie a n t s t o n n e v ro it o eto u uo o . s c

Wo l wep r t M t itrrt saues a t rq ieu t rcal ud emiOP o nepe a ttt o s o e ur s o a il y dsrmiaei wh t p yo r mpo e s Co l teU. Mas as eu et ici n t n a we a u e ly e? ud h S. rh lrfs o poe t u c uto ssb cu ete dsge wi o rd cso s Ma te rtc o r o rh u e e a s h y ia re t u eiin? y h h

Tesr rfs tctacek tjdcae lye iblvsaentutbe rauy eueo upyhcsou iilmpoestei e r o si l e a

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 22 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 1 ae 2 f1te1p st n? o-h i o ii s - o

Th th s rg t aen ti qlsinh r i i ee a t Th p we te a to e ihs r o n t to ee s r lv n. e o rh e r

Ex clv h sarg tdt i efntic s wo l b e o g t s santoe e tie a ro ae o t li hs ae ud e n u h o u ti h s t s at n a wel No iiaya s rh t ci s s l r st n nwe ta OPM c udst u apa sbe o . o l e o t lu il

itrrtto o te1w t s p ott ato si ti cs. S meba c mut nepeain f h a o u p r i cin n hs aes o rn h s s

hv tef asyo a1w'menn.Atesa tlwsgvriguiil aeh i la n a s aig latsoa oenn jdca n

e ly e,h tse trl o r uya do rpo ic .Wewo l n t eac -q a mpo esta i niey u d t n u rvn e ud o b oe u l
ba c o g v rme t tewie rn h f o en n oh r s.

Hitr rv asta Co gesitn e teJ iir t h v ,ieCo rs soy e e l h t n rs ne d d h udcay o a e l nges k

ieftealoi t maaei o pronln ajdetwok lc t l h thryo ng t wn esnead duiae rpae s, t t s cnpans UniteC nrsinl cutblyAco 19 ( ,oeo oalit. t h oges aAconait t f 95 CAA)nn f b l o i
5l fc,temoealw teEx c t ea miitr io e t itrrtto , n at h r a h eui d nsess p n o nepeain v tegetrh sp rt no-o r c n en .I io l b cu eOP h sbo d h rae te e aai -fp wes o crs ts ny e a s M a r a o p we t a miitraga t f o wh t e uo sal oi t c nrc frh at o ro d nse rn o s me a n b lu th rt o o ta to el t y h isla c ta teq eto lc nrn td yaie:Asb t e teEx c tv a d n t n e h th u sin o fo to a rss r ewen h euie n

teJdcaywhs itrrttnotelwso lcnrlojdca h u iir, oenepeai fh a hud ot frtiil o o l

e ly e? I Co gesh ds o e ce ryo teso eo F mpo es f n rs a p k n lal n h c p f EHBPc v rg , o ea e tcewol b n tigt itrrt n teeoen p tnilo c nl tn h r td e ohn o nepe a d h rfr o oe t fr o fi ig l a c itrrtt n . nep eai s o 6 k ,fre a l,h Ad nirt eOfieo teUntdSae Co rs Ta e o x mpe te mi s ai fc fh i tts ut t v e P ro n l t fl 9 , u . 1 -7 ,14Sa. 0 7 Th a c mp n igrp r es n e Ac o 9 0 P b L. 014 4 0 tt1 9 . e c o a yn e ot b teHo s n tdta teAO wa, th t o teat'oalree tn ... y h u e oe h th sa te i fh c,t ag xe t me t

sbetotecnrlfh eeuiebac ipronl tr. H.. e. ujct h ot o te xct rnh n esnemat s' R R p o v e' ll701,t (90,er tdi 19 U.. C. N.79 ll.I cnrs, 0-7()a6 l9)rpie n 90 SC. A. 10,70 n otat n (ot ud. cni e.) n .

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 23 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 1 ae 3

temao woklc poet nlwsapidtcnrsinlmpoesCoges h jr rpae rtci a p l o ogesoae lye; nrs o e

wore ta a pyn to elwsoi ef udga th Ex c tv tomu h rid h t p lig h s a t t lwo l rn te e uie o c s p we o e i afis S eg n rl HaodH. ufTh th La S al n o r v rt far. e e eal rl Brf, a te ws h lBid s y
Eq al OnAl: n rsin l n Ex c t eRoe i Ap ligLa t ul y lCo geso a a d eui lsn pyn ws o v

Coges4 Ar. . e.0,2 (94.T eCAAsle tipolmb nrs,8 kL R v l5 10 19) h ovdhs rbe y
cet gase ile ilt eb a c a e c e l dteOfieo Co l n e l . t rai p ea lgsai rn h g n y al h fc f mpi c . d a n v e a Th tofc,ah rta teEx c t e e fre tewok lc p oeto lws a fie rte h n h eui ,n ocsh rpa e rtcin a v

ta teCAA e tn e t Co ges h th xe d d o n rs.

l ogesiial cniee etn igte( Scvrg t d nrs ntl os rd xedn h CAA')oeaeo c iy d e lye o teuiilrnhbtmiduo tei otneojdca mpoes fh jdcabac u, nflfh mpr c fuiil a
atn my tt tl d cd da an tu hato . to , 9 F.da 1 3 uo o ,li ey eie g is sc cin' sn 3 8 3 t 7 . lma 'Do

lsed iak du t rp ro o refrst a o th CAA' sa d rs n ta ,t se s o e ot n u fot o d p te S tn ad

Ex clieBrn hs p riin. I.l od roc reth tay ty Co ges et v a c u evso ' d n re t o rc ta s mmer, n rs t ' d tr n dta teuh rt ga tdu d rsc 1w t teEq a Empo me t eemie h th t toi rne n e u h a o h u l ly n a y

6.cniud (. t e) .o n t eUntdSae cut, ihg e sre,.ae slfe o sc l i tts or whc t AO1evs..rmot re fuh lh e s h y

OpotntCo sin(E )teOfieo Pronl ngmetOP , pr i mmi o E OC,h f f esneMaae n ( M) u y s c teMeiSse Poet nBor ( P ,r n ohrgnyiteeeuie h r ytm rtci ad MS B)o ay teaec n h xct t o v

ba c ,h lb e ecsdb teAd nsrt eOfie' l. tl l .Nome to rn h sal e x rie y h miitai f . d a 7 2 v c' nin o sc ap we frh c u t wa n c say.Ou a toi , atsauoya dp r f u h o r o te o rs s e esr r uh rt p r tttr n at y ih rn,oc nrl t r ta tu ho teo eaino tec ut wa n ee tt o to mat s h to c n h p rt fh o rs s e o rc g ie ln b fr to ea e ce e itd S e eg, u gv UntdSae eo nzd o g eoe h s g n is xse . e , ..Yo n . i tts e

e rlVut neFlSA.4 1 S 7773(97, xPr Henn3 U.. x e. io t i . ,8 U..8,9 l8)E at n e,8 S t s . e (3Pt 202 16 (89. 1 e. 3 ,6- 2 13) )

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 24 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 1 ae 4

v lnai .2U.. (13 .T eJdca Co frneo teUntdSae ou trl SC.$ 4 4 h u iil neec fh i tts y e

sbmtdtarpri l9,el gCoges 'h jdcabac icmmie ulie hteotn 96tln nrs:S eu iilrnh s o td t i T t
t po iigteg n rl rtcin o teCAA lwsi ama n rta p eev s o rvdn h e ea p oeto s fh a n n e h t rsre

jdcaidpnec adtedcnrle amiirtnO tefdrlors' uiilneedne n h eet i d d nsai fl eeacut. az t o a '

Su yo J dca Brn hCo ea e s pan t 1 a 2 Asp ro ta c mmi n, td f u iil a c vra ,u r oe , t . at fh t o t t me teJ dca Co frn erp re ta iwa d v lpn pa t p o iete h u iil n ee c e otd h tt s e eo ig ln o rvd h a rg t, rtcin , n rme issmi rt toepo ie i teCAA. l a 1 . ihsp oeto sa d e de i l o h s rvd d n h a ' d. t 5 '
Th t lnb c meteMo e EDR Pa ,u r n t 1 u d r ihti c ut a pa e a h d l ln s pa oe , n e whc hs o r

a o td a dteJ dca Co n io teNit Cic ia p o e ,h EDRpa ta d pe , n h u iil u cl f h nh rut p rv d te ln h t

c nr1 teep-C e ig . O tOSh s 1 edn S o

Co gesto n frh r cin s imut a eb e stsidwi te n rs o k o ute a t , o t sh v e n aife t h o h J dcaysefrs OPM ' ato si ti c s h v u d r n dteb ln e u iir' fot. s cin n hs ae a e n emie h aa c Co gessrc i teCAA, n h v d n s i awa ta trae ste n rs tu k n h a d a e o e o n y h thetn h id p n e c o Co gessOfieo Co l n ea mu ha ta o o r n e e d n e f n rs' fc f mpi c s c s h t f u EDR a

tiu as 1d n'b l v Co gesitn e t ga t M ta a toi .lsed rb n l. o t ei e n rs ne d d o rn OP h t uh rt n ta , e y

1 odteCAA' rp rigpo iinrc g ie teJdcaysih rn a toi hl h s e ot rvso eo nzd h u iir ' n ee t uh rt n y t rslewok lc c mpanswi o tnefrn eb teEx c t e 1teeoe o eov rpa e o lit t u itree c y h eui . h rfr h v c n ld ta a EDR tiu a' rao a l itrrtto o a1w a pidt o cu e h t n r n ls esn be nepeain f a p le o b

jdcae lye mutipaefr up sso toe mpoesaycnrr uiilmpoes sdsl ,o proe fh se lye,n ot y c a

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 25 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg l ae 5
itlrtto b a a e c o ofc r fh Ex c t e ne- eain y n g n y r fie o te eui . p v
l a ed tr n dta, v na l tdb DOMA,h F h v eemie h te e s i e y mi te EHBPp r t emi s

jdcae lye t poiehat isrne oeaeotera -e soss uiilmpoeso rvd el nuac cvrg t hismesx pue. h
S eI r Gois i2 0 WL2 2 8 a * - .Thscutsn n dsrmiainpa e n e l k, 0 9 n 2 2 4 t 1 3 i o r' o -ici n to ln rq ie ta MsGoisi eafre ta b n ft EDRPlna 2.OP h d a d e urs h t . l k b fod d h t e ei. n a t M a ,n h s n a toi t c n ld oh r s . a, o uh rt o o cu e tewie y
Or e dr lod 1a f1 ws re-s o1 : o Ms Gois iscam u d rteBakP yAc.Wi i 7 d y h s al t mia . l k' li n e h c a t t n 0 a s e h lsl t n h b rp r a dlc mme d t n o tefct lsu sl tda o e S ep 6slr. e ot n ' o n ai s n h ata ise i e b v . e . t a e o l s p

() T imatrs eerdt teAp elt Co sinro ah aigo l hs t irfre o h p l e mmis e fr er n e a o n () Wi i 3 dy,h Ad ns aieOfieo te idSae Cors 2 t n 0 aste miit t f fh Unt tts ut h rv c e

sal--u miMs Gois isHel Be ei Elcinfr 2 0 t h r h ll sb t . l k' at n fs eto om 8 9 o e e n h t d sg ae isrrteBleCrs a dBleS il S rieBe eiPa .Th AO ein td nu e,h u o s n u hed evc n ft ln e sal rc s a yftr b n f fr wi o te adt tesxo tel td h lpo es n tue e ei oms t u rg r o h e fh i e l t h s so s .S ep . - slr. p ue e p 8 9 t a p

g ia c o drciet teBleCrs a dBleS il S rieBe eiPlna d ud n e r iet o h u o s n u hed evc n ft a n v a yoh rpa ta MsGois i wiei n t l i et b e rl da h rso s n te ln h t . l k' f s o ei bl o e n ol s e p u e n s g e u d rtetr o teFe ea Empo esHe l Be ei Prga b cu eo h r n e h ems fh d rl ly e at n ft o rm e a s f e h s sxo sx a oinain o ta tepa s udvoaeterc nrcswi OP e r e u l re tto , rh th ln wo l ilt h i o tat t M h b e r ln Ms Gois iswiea ab n fcay S ep . , -1 spa y nol g . l k' f s e eiir. e p 3 9 5 u r. i n

() Wi i 3 dy,h Ofc o P ro n l ngmeth lrsidi 3 t n 0 a ste f e f esn eMaa e n salecn t h i s

a vs Ms Goisish at pa ,h BleCrs a dBleS il S rieBe ei d ie . 1 k' el ln te u o s n u hed evc n f n h t

() T eOfieo P ro n l ngmeth lcaea o c i 4 h f f esn eMaa e n sales t n et c s itr rne i teui it no titbla.S eicl , P sal o nef ec w t h jrdci fhsr t l pcf al O M hlnt e h s o in i y

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 26 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 1 ae 6 Pa ,h t rvdn c v rg fr . l sis f voae DOMA o ayoh r ln ta po iig o eae o MsGoi k'wie ilts n r n te fdrla No sal M itreei aywa wi tedl eyo h at eea lw. r h lOP nefr n n y t h ei r f el h v h b n fsoMsGoisis f o teb sso hrsxo sx a oinain S e e ei t . l l'wie n h ai f e e r eu l rett . e t nc o p . , -1 spa p 3 9 5 u r.

Goisis f wi i 3 dy o rcit fteapo raefr fo te l k'wi t n 0 a s feep o h p rpit oms rm h n e h Ad nsrt eOfieo teUntdSae Co rswi o te adt h rsxo miitai fc fh i tts ut, t u rgr o e e r v e h sx a oinain e ul re tt . o
1atoieMsGoisiotk apo raeato t scr cmpin e uh rz . l k t a e p rpit cin o eue o l c n a

() T e u Cosn Bu SilSrie eeiPa salnol . 5 h Ble rsad le hed evc B nf ln hlerlMs t

wi ti od rsc a b p tinfrefre n o ma dmu . Jrs, o v r t hs re,u h s y eio o nocme t r n a s tuth we en h t ta sc at nwi n t en csay h tu h ci l o b eesr. o l

No e e l , 0 9 v mbr 9 2 0 Dae t

T eClr sale dtiodrt teAd nsrt eOfieo teUntd h el h lsn hs re o h miitai f fh i t v c e

Sae Co rsa dsreteod r n acp o o r pa o teOfieo tts ut n ev h re a d oy f u EDR ln n h fc f P ro n t n gmet n teBleCrs a dBleS il S rieBeeiPa i esn e Ma a e n a d h u os n u hed evc n f ln n t tema nrd srb db F d R. vP4h,i f M oBleCos se,t h n e ecie y e . Ci..()(.lOP r u rswihsi )
ma ap a s mu ho tiodra cn en iuigtepo eue o tn di y p eto c fhs re s o crs t s h r cd rs ul e n n i

tepa.Se: Pa a9De t f rc, o dadNurt nSrsv.LRA, h ln e DR ln t , p'o Agi.F o n tio ev. F ' i

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 27 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Pg 1 ae 7

89F2 6 5 6 8 5 (t Ci 1 8)vctdi p ro ohr ru d, 9 F2 7 .d 5, 5 - 9 9h r 9 9, aae n at n te go n s8 5 .d .

l3 (t Ci 19 ) An ohrn iiu l r at agiv db tipoedn 2 9 9h r 9 0. y te idvd ao pr g r e y hs rceig . y e
ra/ i4l1)a 1 a. r )s1i -/ 1) 1 l n al 7 e

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 28 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

P 1 ae 8
Co sl un e

Aru db Ri F. n Morsn& Fo rtr S nF a cso CA, owa g e y t Li, rio a ese LLP, a rn ic , wh s

jie o tebifb Jme R. Gur, rio &F eseL P Sn ond nh r s y a s Mc i Morsn ortr L ,a e e
F a cso CA,o Kae Goisi rn ic , f r rn l k. n

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 29 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

EXHI TA BI
. % i. l : ! ?G -+4 . , ' %

: o59'r i:S % k. d osv xt

v '

UNIEDS XFSOF I OFP R ONNE MANAGE NT T T E FCE E S L ME

Wahnl ,D 245 si o C 01 gn

Hmn c uc uaRs rs oc Puuladevc r c nSrc d s is Dvi, is) io

FB2 2 E 2%

NsNae'. ad f. nyE W' r DeuyAsitn Dico pt ss t r tr a e Ofieo HtllRecle f f ll) stcs c ta r Ad nsav Ofc ot U id teC tt miiric fe fh nt Sa s ols tt i c e t l ' WahltnD.. 04 sigo , C 2 54 Der . r: aMsWad Wclv rcnlbe cn cdb oilo te a eFudtnHel Pa aeeet en ott y fca fh K ir onao ah l y ae s s i t n ad tcBlcCrs ad Bu S il SrieBeei Pa rgrigcrl n n l t os n le hcd ovc nf ln cadl nol t l t t l me frl,n Oresf m teU.. ut f pasfrteNit Ciulsb td onsat dr r h S Coro Apel b h nh r i umie o c. t b yu ofe T etto 1eerl nfr wa tpoi lahLnfs y or fc. h net fh lol toms so rvd l l eei i l l me e et t cvrg frh smesxsoleo- . a L vno adMsKat Goisi o eac ote a -e pt . t Brd eesn l . rn l k. ss Mr n Asyuaea r, t 5catr8 o teUntdSae CccgvmsteFdrl o r waeTie >hpe 9 fh i tts d oe h eea l c E poes1 ahBlts(t )Porl. lpoi sfrcvlg o te m lye t l eet F! rga t rv e o oeae fl e t li ' HB u d ' t c lycad mc eso-h e lyesfni . Me eso-h fmi ae mpoe n mbr fte mpoe' aty mbr fte a l r l y d feli telw, l icueol cr i ullriddpletci rnmy te ei t 2 h a 2l nld ly cl n t ar ccl n hl e d h n 1 d l a n c d d slueo-h eiilen lyeo alil. PL 1419t Dccs o Ma ig l s 1 e l bc Tpoe r nl tl ..0-9 ,h fnc f rac o t g u at . c r AtD MA rqleaaec weitpeign tf ogtstdfnte c(O )etr 1 gny hnle rt aAcoCtrs.o ei l ts ) lr n l ll t wodtple?sapro o-h opst sxwl i ahsado awi .OP r l ot'a esn fte poi e l s ubn r f M s s c o e ise gpac t aece rgrigtedf io so 'nrig'adtp te'n sud tdnco gn iscadl h ci tn f< ar e'n t ol 'i i l ni l a s s B nfsAd nsrt nLtr9 -l,dt No c e 1, 96 TisLt rs eei miit i et 611 a d vmbr 5 19 . p cc i t ao e e i t aal lo tcOP w bse ttrw -l .vrte ss a adrnan vibe 1h M t i aht/ wwol a / i/l/ l n elis a 1 t n/ m o erpb b s i ef tOfca o acce prc aigi teFdrlbnfspo m n fc fil f gni ati t n h eea eei rpa s e -. i s s ip n t amiiee b OP mutol te udne rvdditeLtr. d nsrd y M sflw h giacpoic nh ecs t o t B cueo tepo iin o teJ IBlw,sfr e dt e b DOMA, ll i cas fh rvs s fh - I a a ut r ei d y o E h n Pal n s teF HB ma (1I'vd cvrg frd let pr es o lgl Iar d h E P y 1 l Le o eae o on si at l, real n ri 0 l o c ny c pr eso tesmesxee tog rcgielysaelw. at r fh a e,vnh uh eonztb tt a n

w w p.v w. mg o o

' r . O : :snsunu 1 Fdr Gvr c!a1ccteila 'k r wwu iso umsl itesr h eel oc m nhsn fcvc i qcfc w.ab.v lo ee a n , f : vi o o e p a so g

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 30 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

MsNac E. r . n. Wad y Wehv avstKi rFudtnH chadteBu CosadBt Sid ae di l ae onao el n h je rs n lc hc e s i t l l SricBnf Past tlyma ntceth crl n fnssblt b cv cci ll h tc y oacp tc nol tbn tnie y c t l al me l ld y u at ytpo iccvrg taintl we udr eea lw. o r gmc o rvd o caehts o al d n eFdrta o

Iyulvayusosytmarcnet226646. fo l el qetl,ol yt h ta(0)0-72 a p it a

Steey icrl, l
l rieE. et a xran D t'n l n Ast t ic r sia Dr l sn e o lslncSrie Polns ntac evcs rg' l r a

c:Kasr o nailHct Pa c ie F udt l at ln o h BleCrs adBleSpl SrieBcciPn t os n t led evc n f ln l l k

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 31 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

E PLO Y EN T DISPU TE R ESO LU TIO N PLA N

AD PE DE E E 19 OT D C MBR 97
B HE YT

U.. OU T F PA S O T ENIT CIC I SC R O APEL F R H N H R UT APR V DJN 19 PO E UE98 BYTHE J DCA CO N IO T ENIT CIC I U IIL U CL F H N H R UT Rei dDee e 2 0 vs cmb r 00 e

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 32 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Gen al ovi ons er Pr si

b te SC u oApelfrh NitCrutnacrac wi t Jdca MoePa aot yh U.. ol f pa o te nh i ii codne t h ui l dl l dpe 4 s c h e iy n d b teuiaC neeco te idSa snodro rvd rhsn poetn tNitCrut yh Jdc l ofrne fh Unt te i retpoiei tad rtci so nh i i i e t g o c e lye cmprbet toepoie t lgstebac e lye t e teC nrsinl mpoes o aal o hs rvdd o eiav rnh mpoesmdr h oges a li o Acon itAco 19. cuubly tf95 i

TiPa salenwnate mpomet sue eoui Pa (D Pa)Iwaaot h l hlbko shE ly nDi tRsltn l E R l .t sdpe s n p o n n d

Te DRPaspreeApedx ( sn 'tnad mpa trcdrsoticut hE l uesds pniA Di ' ni nCo li Poeue)fhsors n cmlao n ' cnnEulmpomet prmi Pa(E Pa)Ca asgmdrlsl ote E Pa u'tqaE ly nOpot t l E O l . li li t etiPa rhE O l e ty n n ms in t n n s lb tae iacrac wi tepoete stot itiPa.T e ui o tecut E O l ler t n codne t h rcdlsefr nhs l h dts fh ors E m ed h r h n e ' Codntr lb asme b teE ly nDiueRsltnCod arE Coriao) oriaowi e s d yh mpomet s t eoui orit (DR odntr l u p o no ,
ecp ta tedsuersltndts sindtteE OCoria r neteE OPa wi b xethth i t eoui ui as e o h E odnt udrh E l l e p o e g o n l rpae b te i uersltnpoete stotitiPa. elcd yh ds t eo i rcdlsefr nhs ln p uo r h

T iPa wib i l ne itea mm rsh E OPa. hs l l empe t nh sme meate E l n l me d n

l Scopeo Cover I . f age

7kpa api ta cutmpoesn apinsonnArcepsi snh U..or 7sl plso l ore lyead platfro- tlloio ite SC ut n e l c i tn oA pa frh NitCrutdf da flws f pel ote nh i i eme sol : s c, o
A

Al deadhisf 1ugsn t rlf j e s

ClkoC utn s f e f olad tf r ' a Apea Co sinrn sf plt mmi oead tf le s z a Crut irrnadsf i iLbai n tf c a a Sno Saf tme ads f eir tfAt y n tf o a C if iut da rn sf heCr iMeit ad tf c o x a

A A A A

A-lIn 1jdeadapcn f AtlI de i my ofe cmpi pr at lc ad1ugsn plat o lc j gsp anttao ln us n te 1 i i s r ie u h s l at u ttsl . o p isgit dea fepr at jd i rs nutrcdrs2 US . oh pa Cm ln aa sugsr id us nt uia nc dcpoeue.8 .. i n a t n j e l u o cl io C j32c. h f eapbidfneoteadteal t cutaeocvrdmdrhsl . 7()Tee rlul eedrfcsn hbn c or rntoeet etipa d c i ap y s n

E ly n Ds ueReouinPa mpo met ip t s lto ln

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 33 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

11 Ri sPr e t 1 . ght otced

O E ulmpomet potnt qaE l no prui y y Dsrlaoaa se lyebsdnlc,oo,ego,e(c dn sxahrsmet i iitngitmpoesaeo 'ecl rlinsxil igeulaas n) cnni n a ri nu , ntnlli aeals4 yasfgatei otelgdin ntn,iblyn ai aogn g (te t0 eroaet t fhaeeds' ao)ds i ad o i, a h me l cmi i a i t
sxaoi tinipoiid T eihsn poetnpoieudrh E OPa aosa eulrnao srhbt . h r tad rtcosrvdd nete E l l hl et e g i ns l apytalole lye. pl o 1cu'mpoes t

O Fmi adMei l ev a l n dc Lae y a Tt 1o teFmi adMeiaLaeAco l9,9U.. j21,plstcut i 1 fh a l n dcl ev t f 93 2 SC. 61api o or l e y e
e lye itemanr rsr e iVou 1 , hpeX,ucatr 601Sci R mpoes. h nepeci dn l - C at sbhpe 13.,etn , n b me C r o o t Gld tJ/jj/P lis 7 P oete. fh t eo i/ t. oie J? rcdt s e i tcz) c # i J r

O Wokr dut n adRta ig oictn re A js tn e in N ti i me rn fao

Noi l i ofe lig'rd sl olma ocr.tteedo a6-a pr datr kmpo n f c s ' sa f' y cu141h n f 0dy ei f e y g k o n o ma y ' 11 1 o e tempoi ofeevs ie nte fuhpopciels gol ofoe l es o h e l n fcsrewrt oi osc rset coi ra ft mpo ewh yg i tn c v n y y wib af t . hspoioshlntplta e ly g fc c sgomasaofht l efce T ee rvs nsa oapyo n mpoi ofe li r sl ft l ed i l n i on y a rsl t m te bec o aportf s eut k h asne fprpiet . so a md A Tetm kmpoigolec s g' ash pn aetre oaysudwno a h e :i ly fc li ' n te ennn o t rr hto f l e n i o n me mp sg se fmpometf ehto rsl ia e ly nlsatei lse r i l i oe l nit sudwneutn n mpometosth sgei o ne t y h s n t e l metun ay3-a pr do5 o moempoesxl igayprt mpo ndl g n 0dy ei fr0 r re lyeec dn n ati y i o u -me e l es mpo e. y A T ee sl ofmen aeutniwokfre lh h t sa f' aq rdci n r ocwlc mnma y o i inth rsloa e l i oe lsgad s oteeu fn mpo n fccoi ;n t yg n rsl ia e ly nlsateigei o e l metuigay3-a eutn n mpometosth s lse fmpo ndr n 0dy s n t y n

prdfr1alat3pretfh e lyeadals5 e lye ei o ()tes3 ecnotempoesn te t0 mpoes o a (xligprt e lyelo ()rtes50e lye(xldn ecdn ati mpoes;r2 oalat0 mpoesecuig u -me prt e lye) ati mpoes. -me Se2 USC j20. e 9 ... 11

O Empomet e ly n Rihso Me eso teUnfr dSrie ly ncempomet gt f mbr fh i me evcs o

AAmpoi ofehl odsraaegisa eg le l eodn a eg le l e Ie l n fcsanti ii taa tn liempo ereyn liempo e y g i l cnn n ib y ib y re l metihs r eett eteU ir dSri s mp y nadR e ly n empo n l to bnfsmdrh nf me evc E l metn empomet y g o e o
E ly n Ds ueReouinPa mpo met ip t s lt ln o 2

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 34 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

RgtAc,8U.. j40 esq ihs t3 SC. 31te.

O Ocuainlae ad ah rt tn cpt aSfy n HeI Poe i s o t t co

T e olsalrvd ti e lyea lcoe l metre o rcgi d aad ta h cuthl oieot mpoes pae fmpo nf 9m eonz hzrsht ' p s y e e cue rrle tcue etosru pyi lanadhli lmet hahadae asoaei l o asda rei shsahn ,n sa mpe na el n sft ky h o c l t y porm taesrsh poetn stuitipa. rga htnue te rtcoseotnhs l i n

E Plgah es D o rp T s y t
Noe lye yb rqidtt e plgahts. mpoe ma eeur oa a oyrp et e k

I Di t Res u i Pr dur V. spue olton oce es

Ane l e wh blvs eo sehs endne rhs rne udrhs l salek mpo e o ei e h rh a be ei i tgatd n etiPa hlse y e dg n rsltn fh c i tog tercdrsefr blw. nrl, ercdulrcscnis eoui otelm h uhh poeuestot e Geeayt poet'poesost o a r h o lh a s oi f
A C uslgad dao; onen n meiin i t

A Hanbfehcijdef eor(-dsnt jdi ofe iw i t aee elge rt h f got cut 1 ei aduia fcrn hhh lgd i o e eu h 0a g e cl i ) c e l
vo tnaisad ili re;n ao s

A Rve o tehan dcsnt epoete elbi e b teJdcaC uclfh ei fh el g eio mdr rcdls s lhd y h ui l onio te w i i r s i NitCr i nh iut c.

O G nrl rvi sn Poetn eeaPoio ad rtcos sn i

A Po btnaa srtltn rl io gi te ii i n ao C mpannsnetiPahv tei t b ermrtiincec noitrrne o l atudrhs l aeh rht e e f e lt ,ori ,rnefec i n go o aao o e bcue fln a o lnpzlnttiPa.Lkwi,n pr nwh prc aei easo fig cmpa tlsatohs l ie s ay es o ati tsn l i rl n e o ip t tig rrcsn oa o ln,uhaa e ly ndsueeo tn oriao, h in opoesg f cmpa tsc sn mpometi trsli cod t el i i p uo n r meio, teslpeetieoc- re,l ietl tg eo f mrtltn da rwi s,ersnav,rowokraos nie o edm r e ii . t n t s td o aao
A Rgtorpeettn iht ersnai o

E e idvdai oig te iuerslinpoete o tiPa hsteih t b vl niiuln kn h ds t eouo rcdrs fhs ln a h l to e y v p t l g rpeetdb a esnohs r ecoc isc pl niaal ladcnettb a ersne y pro f iohrhi fuh e o svibe n osnso e e s a rpeetieAcutmpoema acpteepniits fersn tnii lnt ersnav. ore lye y cet rsos li orpeeli ft lo t h bie o wi udlitfewi hs recutui ocrtt acnlt fneeta dtmie nuyne e t iohrordts rokil otco i rs s ee nd rr h e stt e i t , r
E ly n Dipt R s lt nPln mpo met s ue eoui a o

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 35 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

b teersn tesponigofe. yh rpeeui 'apit fcr v n i A C s peaain ae rprt o T teet tes l ee idvdaivln tedptrsltnpoeueotiPa oh xe faie vl niiulno gh iueeoui rcdrs fhs ln n b, y d s o ma ue raoala utffc li tpeael o hraes ln aident y saesnbe mono ofi t o rprls recs,oog stos o ia me i tdlitfe ths r ecutui ocntuea otcoitrs a dtrie m u ne e wi io hrordts rostt cnltfneet s e mnd y rr h e i i , e b t lpeetiesponigofe. yh 'rsnav'apit fcr ee t n i Tee lyn ofema moefr insao tecmpa ttn t ,fh ci i h mpoig fc y v o ds i lfh o ln aayi it lm s i rs i me e a fvl siaudeeeio oa rvoso li,altsta lmuo whc rlf r o u, n nu rptin f pei cmpa tfi o te c i pn i ei io s t u n s a a h e

cn e r t,roo er sn ptotb t ep y gofe Te hfug o a b g n dofrtre osuf h yh m l i fc. h ci jde r ae h a r e on e dsnt jd i ofemyatnhseus egaduia fcr a co t r et i e cl i iq .
A E t sn ot xe i sfi no me

Teheugoteoroo epeinjdi o cr yx nay f eedns hcijdef cutrtrr d guia f emaet dn ot dale f h , h si cl f , e h i

stor itiSci frodcue efut nhs etn ogo as. h o A R crs eod Ath cnlino fr ln ifr lrceig udrhs l ,lppr fe,n te oc s fomaadnomapoedns netiPa a aes isad uo n l ,l

rpl (xethsrltgtmeitnwib fe wi teors D Cod ar eot ecptoee i o dai ) l eid t h cut E R ori t. s an o l l h ' no
Noppr,iso rpl rligt adsuewi b te iaye l e'pr ne aesfe,reot ean o i t l ei dn n mpo es es nl l - t s p l l y o fle,xets eeslti l na ofi pr neatn odrecpancsa ompe tn fca es nlco. y me il o i
odntr O EDRCoriao

Tehf de idsntaeo tsreshE RCod arTe ueote D hcij gwl ega pr noevat D ori t. h dtsfh E R eu l i e s e no i
C odntrhlic d teol n: oria sal l eh flwig o nu o A T poieifnatnt tecutn eplye rgrigtelhsadpoetn o rvd non i o h orad n oes eadn h i t n rtcos ao g i afre udrhs l ; f dd netiPa o n A T codntadgnzte rcdrsn et lh n ma tio i teoteor o oriae n raieh poeuead sbi ad i n cais fh cut as n ll

plin t cmj isado e mae itt adpoes tdrtecut e n g o o ln n t r tr nie n rcse m e h ors %i a t h ts iad d l
e l meti ueeouo pa; mpo nds trsltn l y p i n A T codntte omslgoidvda iteitll eo t cmpa trcs;n o oria h ct ei fniiul nh ni sgs fh o lnpoesad e n s ia e i A T clc,nlz,n cnoiaesttadtadohrnontnpliigt te o ol taa ead osl t tii laa n te ifl ao ea n o h e y d asc n i ln cut e ly ndsueeouinpoes orsmpometi trsl o rcs. ' p t
Empo metDs ueReouinPa ly n ip t s lt ln o 4

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 36 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

O E RC u sl s D one r o Tehf de idsntoer rpr ntsles D C uslsT eone r h cij gwl ega n omo eosoe?aE R one r hcusls eu i e e s a o. o'
ci rsos itwib tat tnifr leoui oe l metiuebfrfr l le epnily l eo tmpa nomarsltn fmpo nds t eoeoma zf bi l e o y ps cmpa taefe.Cone rma astn cut fpele lyentuto oe o lis r id usl s y si ay oro apas mpoe, ojssmen n l o s wiite o ui tnhi wn nt h r .
An pr nseigdsulctn reuaoa E Rcusl,meioorve n ot a y es ekn i atao orcslfn D one r d trreiwi f l o q i i i o a g ki

E osul ctn D i asai q i o

sapo pytmi wiest ntt cijdexln ghr srf t rqet hl r t s t lt te t h l f gep int e o o h eusd l m l l a tn me o e l u a i e a s r e e b e dsulctn reua.n er nn whtedsulkai orcsl war t ,h cif i atai orcslldtmiig e ri ai tn reuai rne tehe qi o i e h q t o s ad jdehlcnirh ftr ccmsnead ose tn s fti2 USC j 5. ug sa oset aos iu t csn cniri se ohn 8 ... 45 l d e c ,r a d ao t r Idqatao oruaiw rn dt ci jdehl ei a ao ei idatat fiulctn re sl aat , el f g sa dsnt ntrn v ul c s i i c s re h l u i e g e h di o
a teE cuslrmeit,reiwigot i. Di ul ctno rcsl fh E sh DR oneo, da ro rve n fc l s afai reuao te DR o ia q i o cusl,meio o r i n oli o acuthlnt ew rne mee bcuete one r da r re e g fca f orsalob ar td rl eas h o t v wi i l a y cuts a daarsod gpr . orinme s epni at n y

V. Co s l g un ei n
A e lyewh blvstalsohrrhsudrtiPa hv be voae mutlt n mpoe o eee htl r e i t ne hs l ae en i td sfs i i g n l r rqetomslg eusct en. i

( Reus fr onen : D qet o C usl g s i

solb sb tdttecut E C odntr hud e umie oh ors DR oria ; l ' o

m sb md iwi gcp oapoe f asotndn ped A;n ute aen ri ( y fprvdo icn i iA pni )ad t o n m ae x
mute d wii3 dy ote lgdvoao owi n3 dy otei te sb mae tn 0 asfh aee ilin r t 0 asfh t h h l t l me e lye/eo swa ot aeev li . mpoe. abcmea r fh lgd iao / e e l o tn

E E RC u slr D D one o
T eoncn sa b cnutd y n D C tslr nesh E C t e rsiule h cuslghl eodc b a E R omeo, lst DR omsl ids afd i l e u e o qi f m sligo iohni uaaal.l sc isne,teh fug ot cuthl r e n,rs tevs nvibe n uhnt cs h cijde fh orsa o w e l a e e l ds ntaohrule id i atpr r t ct en fntn lte iuel lea ei a nteqai dnid lo efm h omslguco. fh ds ti vsn ge f vu o e i i p wo

aee v li otsl b auiaolet pl n h cnutt ctsi sab lgd iao fh Pa y jd i fcrh eow oodc h o en hl e l otn i n cl i , e s s e m lg l auiaofedsnt b t cijde jd i fcrei ad yh lf g. cl i g e e eu
T e upss fh cuslghlb tdsush e lyesocmsn ec ifr tn h p roe ote onen sa eo i ste mpoe'cne ad linomai i l c it o
E ly n DsueRslt nPa mpomet ipt eoui ln o 5

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 37 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

rgrigte tr i tee l eblvsostt a ilin t avs tee lye eadn h mat whc h mpo e eeecntue voao;o di h mpoe e h y i i s t e o hso hrrhsadrsos itsadtepoeue o tecutapi bet te f i r e i t n epnili n h rcdrs fh or plal o h g bie c e l met i uersltnpoest ea a temat;n t asth e lyei mpo n ds t eo i rcs;o vl t h trad o si te mpoe n y p uo ue e s aheiga er rsli ote tripsil ci n n al eouo fh mae, os e v y tn t f b.

E C nietly D of nii d at Alonensabkpcnietlbet iewavrrxgnccmsne(.,et l uslghl eetot niasnwrt ieoei tiu lcse. a c i l d a tn e r gd h tra,hetovoecohrsmetioee dun tecuslgpoes. lettrasfil eraas nds vrd t gh onei rcs) ls n c i n E ste n D el t tme
T e DRC odntrhleueo in ayste naleed n teomslg rcs h E oria sardctwrign etmetci d migh ct en poes o l t l lv i adscrt sntrsfh e lyehsrerpeetieiayadh me eote n eueh i aueotempoe,iohrersn t ,fn,n te mbrfh eg v e ly gofeuhle tetrn ste no tee lyn oles eaf mpoi fc atoi do neit etmetnh mpoig fc'bhl n z o l i

E C uslg ei D onen Pr d i o Te eo fronei sab 3 dy (rhrrfomeigcnl eaaeredt) h pldocuslghl e 0 asosot ictsl ocdstn alra , i n l e n u i e
bg n' o tedt teE C odntrrcie terqeto cuslg T eE R ei ig n h ae h DR oriao ee sh eusfr onen. h D nl t v i C odntrhlntyt e lyenmin oten oteonen pr dAsatfh ori osaloi h mpoei tg fh ed fh cuslg ei . prote a f e i i o nteteE RC odntrhlifr tee lyeo tel h adolao,hudte oi ,h D ori o salnom h mpoe fh i tn bi tn sol h c a g gi e lyecos t pr elso hrc i t tewi teE R C odntrarqeto mpoe hoe o us l r e lm,o i t h D oria eusfr u i a l h o meitn dai . o

VI Medi i . aton
Wii 1 dy at tempoe r e ente fh cnlsnoct en,h e l e tn 5 as frh e lyee i s oi o te oc i fomslgte mpo e h e cv c uo i y mate tte DRC odnt aeusfr dai . h rqet sb maen in ad s yi wi h E oria r rqetomei o T eeusmute d iwlig n mut l h o tn t

stteca speetd(oyo apoe fr iicue aApedxB) Fil tpru teh li ) rsne qp fprvdom snldd s pni . aleo use a mt t r

meiin l rc d fr epoes gotempoe'c i udrn ohrrvsn otiPa. dao wipel eut rrcsn fh e lyeslm neay tepoios fhs l t l u h i a i n

O Meitr dao
Asonapsilat rciigteeusfr dainte DRcodntrhlds nt so sos e free n h rqetomei o, E oria salei a b e v t h o g e ameio ad rvd wrt nte fuhds ntn da rn poie ie oi o sc ei ao. t tn c g i A ypro wi tes l t astnrsligdsue,xeth E Coneo wh fs n esn t h l l o si i eovn i tsecp te DR uslr o lt h ds s p r at tdt rsl tedsueifr l, ysrea ameio t e tiPa.Ite tmpe o eov h i t nomay ma ev s da rmdrhs l fh e e p l t n

cm lnaeet tjdi o ehsiadt rh pocd yl Pa, e eio o p i lgsh auia crav le h i t rtt b ts l t m d t a t l a cl ot e g s ee i n h ar sa b auiaofedsnt b t cijde hl e jd i fcrei ad yh hfug. l cl i g e e e
E ly n DsueR slt nPa mpomet ipt eoui ln o 6

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 38 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Te d t sa metea tyn/jilwttem l ead iohrereti , hmeio hl espre ad ro t i h ep yen h rer e nte ar l al o ny h o s p s av

iayadtee ly g fctdsuslmavsorslig dsueic dn ayad l fn,n h mpoi ofeo i sae tefreo n a i t, l i n n al n c t i v p nu g psiii orahn a omtymullstfc rrsltn os le feci vl r, hny as tyeo i . bi s t g t l iao uo

E Cnietly D of nii d at
An pro opl i ovdite dao poeshlntils,nwhloipr ay y esn r ayn le nh meiin rcssalodsoei oe rn at n t v t c , ifr tn reodotie to g,rrprdpctalfrte dain rcs,xet nomai orcrsbandl uhopeae seicl o, meit poesecp o u i y h o a ncsa tcnut tte ats rhirpeetie. s eesl o oslwi h preo te ersnavs y h .i r t

( ste n D el t tme
T emeitrhlrdc t wrigayste nalee dun te dao poesn h da sa eueo in n etmetci d t gh meiin rcsad o l t l lv i t scr tes ntr o tee lyehs r erpeetieiay adteme eo te eueh i aue fh mpoe,io hrersnav,fn,n h mbr fh g t e l igofeuhre tet itste no te mpoigofes eaf mpo n fc atoi do ne no el tnh e lyn fc'bhl y z r tme

E MeitnPr d D dai ei o o Temeitnprdsale3 dy (rhlrimeiincnldsaa eredt, h dai ei hlb 0 asosot f dao oc e tn alr ae o o e t u i ) bgni o tedtterqetommeiinircie.T ipl dma b etne b ei n n h a h eusfr dao see d hs eo y e xedd y ng e t v i cnetfh preowtapoaot Ci Jde fh Cu oa egaduia osnot ai r i pr lfh hfug ot ol r dsnt jd i e ts h v e e e 4 i e cl
ote.T e mpoe irqidtat dalatn meiinsso.T eefrh ose fcr h e l eseur o tn tesoe dao esn hrat,e rh i y e e t i e ma poedttea o lit y rce oi cmpa . l n

VI Compl n,Re e a He i I . ait viw nd arng laten ote dao prdteatsae orslete trhtomsh bs f th ed fh meitn ei , prehvnteovdhmat tafr teai ) i oh i e s

o terqetfrmeitn teE R Coria rsa poietee lye tee lyes fh eus o dai ,h D od t hl rvd h mpoe,h mpoe' o no l rpeetteiayadtee l igofe ie ntehth meiinprdhsoc dd ersnav,fn,n h mpo n fc wlt oi tate d t ei a cnl e. i y tn c ao o u T ente l salno t e l e ohs rerhtfe fr lo li. h oi ao hlifl h mpo e fiohri to l aomacmpa t c s m e y g n

O C mpa t o ln i
Nole ta 1 dy at rciigwrt nteo teedo temeiinprd te a rhn 5 as fr ee n ie oi fh n fh dao ei ,h t e v tn c t o e lyeaeigavoai o teE Pa w oprc a di temeiinma fea mpoe lgn iltn fh DR l h ati t l h aao y i l o n ip e z dt l

cmpatTecmpanmuteitefr apoe b tecutseapoe fr i o ln. h o l t sb rh om prvd yh or(e prvdom n i i l ApniC,n mzb f d tt cijdeot cu ot e l i ofe hhs ped ) d tte l wi h he ug f eol f emp y g fcw i i x a s e he f h t h on c teepnet teo li. h rsodnia cmpa tsab tempoig fc ta h rsodnt h cmpa tT eepnetn l o lishl eh e l n oteht o n l n l y i wolbrsoslfrersigcrci oaan teilintal eiteo lit ud eepnieordes ,or tgrbtghvoaos)lgdnhcmpa . b n en i t s e n
Noidvdasale a daaepnetntecmpa t niiulhlb nme s rsodni h o li. n
7

E ly nDsueRslt nPa mpomet ipt eoui l o n

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 39 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

O Rve poeue ei rcdrs w

Teo lnad n o edcmetsa b r i e b t ci jde fh cutry h cmpi n ay trou n hl ee e d yh le ug ot orob at h s vw e lf e , ao ejd i oteot cutei ad yt ci jde lt csoa o pa t nt ruia fcrfh ordsnt b h h fug. nh a f cm ln h cl i e ge e e e e i aei ttnAtlIjdeav lerhsrtt b t Pa, ajde a ect lg gh a rc Iug hsiaditpocd yh l tt g m y lto n a ie l o t g ee e n h u e hv aelg odcd y jdefntroradsnt b t Jd iCuc ot ae han cnut b augoao ecutsei adyh uia oni f e i e h , g e e cl l h Nn Cr i A y ei ao oauiaofefmao ecut haad ei t cs ih iu. n dsntn fjdi fcrr ntrort ern dc eh a t ct gi cl i o h o dee sa baagd ygemetfh ci jdeot aet ctsltevnt ci hl enneb ar not he ugsfh fcd o l nh eeth he e e f e f e u. e f j giuaaaltsl tdrh sbetn radqasdre s h sl reel u esnvib oev m etsusco ohsiuleorue i e ohrl d le ' e i i s i c d m f st t cijde idsntao ejdi o etsr at r i i o i. h l f gwl ei a ntruia croev sh e e n cl e z u l g e h cl e e e vw g a At ntett cm lnnad noprrytrsodte l fug odsnt fr oc oh o pa atn a pott o e n,h ci jde r ei a d e i e i ui p t e ge j iaofemy insn ln aycmpi fudtb fvl sudlr ete f u clf r adri iwi g n o ln on o ero u,nu e tv oa di k ss t i at io y pi i
pei s o li w i fi tsta lmuo whc rlf yb g ne. rvo cmpa t hc aso le c i pn i eema e l t u n h l a h i a d

E Her g rcdrs D ai poeue n

lt cijde regaduiaotedenti st cmp iudr er ei fh h f godsnt jd i f rosods s eo ln net pe d g e eu i e cl k mi h at h c n sbetnt cijde rei aduiaofe,cn at han ok rhl o a us i , ehfug odsnt jd i fcratg sh eig f e, ahl co h e g e cl i e l t s d
han o te ls fh cmpa tmlsh osedt nnshtofc adsue xs el g nh meto t o lnl es e rh e nie tan at li tei. i i e i e u p t

Ter injd iotem yrv eoscdcvradnetaoaincs r.h hped guia fcr apoi f uhioe ni sgtn s eea Te si cl i d r s y v i i s sy dsoe poes. E cssint atob a etniea icnetnl ieV1 i vl rcs i DR ae s o men t e s xes sn ovni aTt I c y n v o l lgtn,n ma b l id th dctnot ped guiao e.lgnrlh iaosad y ei t at iri fh rsi jd i cr n ee , e ti i m e e seo e in cl at ped guiaolesa dtmn t t epaeadmneocnutgt hmn. rin jd i fcrhl eri h i ,l ,n anr fodcn h eig si cl i e e em c i e
Ho vrt flwigseic rvs n sa apythansodce udrhsetn wee, eol n pc poioshl pl o el g cnut netisci : h o s i l i d o A T e eighlcmmecn lt ta 6 dy atteln oteo li; h hmn sa o ne oae hn 0 asfrl fig fh cmpa t l r e: l n

A T e o lnnadte edote fc aa swhc te o lnhs en h cmpa atn h ha fh olegi t i h cmpa tabe i i n h i fe mutee ewie nte fh hmn ;uhntehlaob poie z, srci rt oi ote eigsc oi sall e rvdd l d v tn c c s tteniiullgdthv voa drhs rtc db tiPa whnvr oh idvdaal e o ae ile i tpoet yhs ln eee e t g e

sci idaiauiaoirr hnh p si jd io eo eve uhn vul jci fc ow e t rin uia crtni di s l l e c e ed g cl h s
dtmiesc nteob aport; ee nsuh oi t e prpie r c a

A Ath han,h cmpann wihv terh trpeetint peet te elgte o l at l aeh i to elsnao,o rsn i i l g - t

eiec o hso hr ealadt cosxmieavlewiesste vdne n i r ebhl n o rs- a n des t se;h t e - n

A Avrai rcr oteel g sb kpadsa b teoe fc leod . ebt eod fh han mute etn hl eh sloti rcr m i l ia o te rceig fh poedn;
E ly n Dipt R s lt nPa mpo me t s ue e oui ln o

e l ig fcwihv teihso rsneieco ibhladtcos mpo n ofe l aeh l ttpeetvdne nt eafn o rsy i l g s ea n avre mess xmie deswi se;

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 40 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

A Irci h ohreio, ehejderei aduiao esa me h g i redci t ci ugodsnt jdi crhl an s sn h f g e cl b gidb t jdi ad d isav dci snet l set t e ud yh uia n amntte eio udrh a rado e e cl iri sn e w le
Sco I o ts l ad ydci s fh Jdc l oni etn l fh Pa n b eio oteuiaC ucl i l i n sn i ; A Rmeis yb poie iacrac wi ScinI otiPa w eeh e dema e rvddn codne t et X fhs l hrte h o n han ofefd tatecmpa ata et lhdb a rpne neo elg fcri shth o li n hssbi e y peodr c f i i n n as a teeiec taausnieihpoet b tiPa hs envoa d h vdneht sbt t l trt e yhs l abe ile; a v g cd n t

A Teci jdeodsnt jdi otem siu tkfadci i h h fug r egaduia fcr utseh mleio n e i e cl i s e sn
wlign leta 3 dy at tecnlino te elgad in oa rhn 0 asfrh oc s fh han ;n t t e uo i

A Almtsoayagi e i ida,hlhv teihtwlt nte fn l -e,rn grvdn v ul a aeh r t ie oi oay pi e di s l g o tn c atnt e a aeutf haig co a n s rsloa er . i k n

VII Revi ofDecsi I . ew i on Apl oi idaapeeb a nleio ot cijderegaduiaote ay rn v ulgi d y 6adci f eheugodsnt jdi fcr ' di t v sn h f i e cl i ,
o b auu ayds s lfh cmpa tma ptinfrei otadcin Sc rve mut r y snnl i s o te o ln, y ei orve fhteio. uhei s ' mia i t o w s w b rqet iwrigoh Jdc l omc ote nh rutoleta 3 dy flwigh dt eeusdn in tteuii C t i fh NitCi in arhn 0 asol n te ae e t a l c t o

ot tadci ot cijderhdsnt jdi ofeoflwn t dtoat ma f ei leio f eh f got ei aduia fcrroo i h a f sm l h n sn h eu e g e cl i ge e t y l

dsslfh cmpa t i s o teo ln. n a i An r i wib cnutdb te mbro teEeuie o teo teNnhCiut ye e i e odc yh me es fh xct C mmie fh it r i vw l e v l c Jdc loniote ds ne. h dcsnote xcte ou iesa b bsdo teeod uiaC uclrhi ei esT e eio f E eui C nntehl e ae nh rcr i r g i h v t l

dvl e b te elgote,n t dci ot ci jde rei a duiaofeo eepd yh han fcradh eio fh h fug odsnt jdclfcr r o i i e sn e e ge i i
snmm ds sasa b at dispot b sbl tlvdne ul y i slhl e fr fuprd y usni eiec. mi l fme e a

I Reme es X. di Whrjd i ofe atg usat Sco Vlr l ots l fdt t s snv e uia fcl cn pr nt etn 1oVI fl Pa i h du ute e cl i s i u o i I z nn a b i i
lhpoet b hs l hs envoae,hyma odr ncsayadaportrmey A ' t rtce y iPa abe il dte y rea eesr n prpiee d. i g d n t a rmeyma b dr t acrcn apsvoai ,rsete iuigcmpi c wi terhs e d y e ice tor tg ati tnpopcvl n r o lne t h i t e d ei lo iysn a h g poetdb tiPa,roh Ar d sa b ilrdac slapsilttepcivo tn rt e yhs l o bt. e y hl e i e sl e s os eoh seic ili c n me l o oy b t ao ivle. novd

E R mei A al ltS ces l o liat D e de vibeo ucsuC mpanns s a f

A Pae no a e l eia oio pei s dne l metfn mpo en psin rvo l eid c y t uy A Pae nia o aalaent e oio lcmetn cmprbe lrav psin t i t h Ristmetoa oio f mwhc pei s rmoe e te nt psi r i rvo l e vd na tn o h u y E ly n DsueRslt nPa mpomet i t eoui ln p o 9

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 41 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

A Popcie rmointa oio rset po t o psin v o t A Pilycnieainfr ftrpo tnopsin l i os rt oa ute rmoi roio ot d o z o t A B c pyadasca d eet ic dn at ysesw eeh sttlcir ote . ak a n soie bntsnl ig tme'fe, hrtelt y rei fh t i, u o z ta o

BalPyAc, U.. j59,rstfd c a t5 SC. 56aeaii t se

A R crs dfao ado epmgmet eod moictn n/rxt e n ii A k qibe rlfsc at oa s s fdesatn . i ut l'eetuh se rl iy oavre cos E a 'i mp y i A Gmni ofmi admei lev tg fa l n dc l e n y aa A Aco dtno dsbli truh teprhs o seiie eup n o te cmmoao f i its hog h ucae f pcazd qi t r h i a ie l me rsutr godtsn wokhts etcui fui ad r ol r n e r

E Re deN t ealA al l D mei o Lgl vibe s y a A Py noaonysesecpaatoidl ete akPyAc) ametftre'fe(xetsuhre mdrh Bc a t l z
A C mpna l dmae adpnte a gs o esty a gsn uiv dmae o i

X. Rec dofFi De si or nal ci on

T ecnls no terv wi pnlnayfa dcs n rahdf acrac wi te h oc i fh ei l ae i t t l ciosece n codne t l uo e v z n i hz poiosoSci W1otiPa sale d aaaltt pbi9 mt Ofco te iut rvsn f etn 1fhs l hlb maevibeoh u l o h fe fh Cr i i o n l e c e i c E eui uo wlt rqetO l ite vn te aedtmie taalr otn o teete xcte pn ie eus nynh eeth pnler nshtlopros fh ni v tn . e i r dcs n solb mae ul sa adtnlotn ote eio b maevibeote ul. eioshud e d pbi hl dioapros fh dcs n e d aal lt h pbi i c l i i i a c

Teei i pnlrt ie s ojsc ad fa esot ple, a dt nn nt mae hr e n ae i h n rt futen o fm st h atsm y en i ot k v w g ,l e tes i i ei e e o

aaal ttepbitecnlsno ayf l eio ipbidsls'wol cmpons te vibeo h ul h ocui fn madcsn f ul i ote ud o rri h l c o i c c u e iei o l ima cndnilyo tepre o tecuto t poet pr o pro 9 m n jt re t t ot et i fh ats rh ol ro rt a at r esn o tpy g i e i at i ' , c y a ynee arsmetopes n udebre o epneo frn ohresn tate l ac,mbl s n, prsi ,nu udn r xes,ro ay te raoshth mo a o

amnttn fute a r ue d is i ojscm ye i. im o i qr XI Elc i o Re de . e ton f me is iadi tao p i udl iPa cne i tea e rusnayt s sb cmae, n di no cm ln nets l ocrn h sm osbt tl h n uj t tr t o at - n n g h a il e me e t tempoemutltie()h E Pao()h giac/desatnapapoele h e l e secehrate DR l rbte rvne vreci pelrcdrs y e t n e a o z udr i teo lnitb poesd A1mpoemanttieoh()r ()Smir, newhc hcmpa tso ercse. Je lye y ouizbt aadb.i ll h i l l ay iacmpanhslaybe poesdt eoeoteepoeue (etegi ac/des f o l taar d en rcse mdrn fhs rcdrsi.h rvne vr i e ., e a e atnpelrcdrot poeueits l)im y ob t sbetf cm lnudr co apapoeue rh rcdrsnh Pa , a nteh uj oao patne i e i nt e c i
te te. h ohr E ly n DsueR sltnPa mpomet ipt eoui ln o 1 0

Ia e lye rne l e rpeettete a apao a avre ci oagivne fn mpoe o a mpo eersnai isn pelfn desatn r r ac y v l o e

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 42 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

XI Deer ni Ti Perods I t mi ng me i .
T e oddy'na si ad tet prd seie itipa sal a cl dras h w rwasi 1 lg n ohri ei spcfdnhsl hlmen ae ady, d ' ln me o i n n ecptaitedale a fl o aStra,udyohla,h dalehlb et ddt xethtfh edi dt as n audy Sna roi yte edi sa e xe e o n e l d n l n teflwi Modyo cutuies a rsete . h ol n na rorbs sdy epci l o g n vy

XIIAnnual I . Repor t
TeE C odntr l rpra anarplfrh tcleri i tgh nmbrn h DR oriaowipeaen nuleoto tei aya,n c i te u ead l ' s d an tp O : ye f h Algdvoaosowhc ct en wacnutd l e ilin fr i omslg sodc e t h i e A Algdvoaosowhc meiinwacnut l e ilin fr i dao sodce e t h t d A C mpa tte o lnsid i l A Helg cnutd ansodce i A Fnleiosedrdrl tgt nmbrowhc smeeewa gat iadcs n rnee ee i h u efr i o rlf s rne i fcn e h i d

U dtd1//0 p ae 280

E ly n Ds ueReouinPa mpo met ip t s lt ln o

1 1

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 43 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

A PPEND I X

A. Couns lng For ei m

B. M e aton For di i m

C. Com pl i Fo a nt rm

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 44 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

RE STF COUNSELNG UNDER E PL QUE OR I DR AN

Sb tdU drh Poeleote mpomet sue eo tnPa frh umie nete rcdrs fh E ly nDi tR sli l o te t z p uo n UntdSaeC utf p elfrh NitCr i i tt oroA pa o te nh iut e s s c Pirocmpen tifl ,laeeette mpomet sueR slinPa fror l t o lighsom pesrfroh E ly nDi t eouo l oyu o t ' p t n cutntPescmpe tifmAeiy olui lae o lehso lg l. ' . t b

Hl Poe ) o ehn( u

Wokhn( ) rPoe

8 .

Alyuwiigtwav cn-etlyiodropr ite oneotcnath e poigofeot ' o ln o ie ot nii n ret elthcuslro ot te l lyn fi ro e I i at d n c m c atnt rsltnote i ue latl tlpaeoui fh ds t nt ' e o p d e? lys En : e Eo l 1

Sgaue intr Na e f one ro ousblt ' l oC usl twhl ulie. m o td

Dt ae

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 45 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

RE STF MEDI ON UNDER EDR PL QUE OR ATI AN

Sb tdU drh Poeueo te mpomet sue eouinPa frh umie nete rcdrs fh E ly nDi tR slt l ote t p o n UntdS ts oroApelfrh NitCrut i teC utf pasote nh i i e c

wi timatr t hs te. h

Pesatc acp ote laetah oy fh REQUES F COUNS LNGF fe icn et n T OR E I ORM idn onci l o

FlNa o Pr nRqetgMeitn ul me f cs eusi dai o n o

Iayfhio aospldnhRQ ETFRC U SLN U D RE RPA F R fei fnot n r tnupeit E U S O O NEIG N E D L N O Mldn e fm i i e l cnetlwi tilat in Ineacrt,lae oetenlbrfh et o teeusfr onci) t hsltrs oogrcuaepesnt h uneotenr nh rqeto o l le ) y cuslgoltbcagdadtehcagt yu i tnk: onenfr oehne,nstt hnes o ws on e i n a e ) h a

Dtcuslgwaiiad aeonei sntt : l 1 ie Nle fesn o lvddcuslg a opro wh p- ie onei ' m o n.

Sgaue intr

Da t e

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 46 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

COMPL NT UNDER EDR PL AI AN

Fl Unete rcdrs fh E l met sueRsltnPa frh id drh Poeueo te mpo nDi t eoui l ote e y p o n Ult Sa s oro A pa frh NitCrut e te C utf pel ote nh i i d t s c Pirocmpen tifl'pesrfrote mpomet i ue eouinPa fr or l t o liglsom,l eeet h E ly nDs tR slt l o yu o t l l a p o n cutn. l scmpe tsom l il. orui Pe e o lt l fr e by t a el i g
FlNleoPlo FlgClpan uIal fesl in oll t ' 'l i ' i ' l

Hne hn ( ) onPoe

qokPoe ) /r hn (

Iyuae cttl1oe,ttteoIwig fo la olenlyes eh fI n: ' l ') a o C ut nt1N i)lIoe olU ii v c e)lyd h l ll 4b ie o Tt I

Ietytentroyucal. dni h ate fo1li f l ' ' n E Dsluntn E I i - iai ci o l ! Rc . ae 2 C lr . oo 3 Rlin . eio g 4 Gnesxil esxahrs'n . edre(cdseula set / nu al ) n 5 NaoaOin . tnlri i g ( Ag 4 . e 7 . Dsbly i it ai 8 SxaOrnain . eul i t o et Fmi adMeilev Rgt a l n daLae ihs y

qo eA itetnRtii Ntitn it /kl d s nad ea n ofao Rg s r ' ul n rn g ici h

Em l letn RellynnRgtoMeaesfh U ine Sri s lpo pnad elpolet ihsf lbrote nf -d evc yn l on e E ) PlgahTs oyrp et s

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 47 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

D:()f)ee voain ) so8I d il 0 t lg t e

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 48 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Dae l )Icuslgwarqetd to wlc onei seus ' ) il n e. Da o wlc cuslpwaclpee: t n )h oneig so ltd e i l u Daenwhc leitnwseus d to i ndai arqet ' h o e. Dto wIc leit1wsoc dd aen lhmdai acnl e: i 0 u Nal(pl nwh sle aC uslrntilatr le) es o evd s oneoo hslt lf' o ' le Na eopl lwl sle aMeitrntilatr l fes) l evd s daoo hsnt m - o o e Pessllaieh atn oocrnegvn leo o clpan.Epaniw awyyublv l eu lr te ci sfcur cs iig- tyu o l t xl n ht a o ei e a nl z o e i s u i i e ytr hs neteE RPa wee iltd Ietya pros h prcptditilatrr ocn ol i tudrl D l rvoa .dni 1 esn w o atiae nhsmt owh a rg n e fl i e

poi reatn raocne i yucm ln ( triistcnsaee wyurytc rv eevnioltnocrn oro pi.Ih esnufitpcb1 ,ol aah d l f li ng at f e -e i o l t a adt nIae. dioapgs i )

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 49 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10

Iyspespoieh tlwigifr ao cnenn tapro: fe,lae lvd tebl n nol tn ocrightesn o ui Nle al l Adrs des
Wo-Poe( ) l hl k Fx ) a(

Ifi'tateifr)tnpoie iticlpanitead orctte etfm ko eg. afl lth nolai rvddnhsonlitsr n cr toh bsoIy nwlde r l n o ' u e

Dt ae

Aao w

Case: 09-80173 12/16/2009 Page: 50 of 50

ID: 7166651 DktEntry: 10a e1 f Pg o 1

FO :o-oAae(33-65 R M JeSsprls )7e1 C lh nde1OPTa T Le g 2S3 4 m

T AlxK zn k(1)3 46 5 o: e ois i2 337 1

9 Se e t Sre 5 v nh te t
n ,s e ol

8 sS v n Sre 1 Wet eet t t h e Ls nee,A907 oAglsG 01

III!1I! III!J! II!I!1 )! !I l 1

SFO

C D : 384 A # 8 169 S I DT :7 0V 9 HP AE2 N 0 WEG T1 B IH: L

rsrll:ql! la?y t rlll ; l

IIAIESId1DII .A.zoayAw l1ISIEI1 IRlDRI1x-ER)I IY DI(III I le DLE EI V F

TK 75244 Eo R# 9 1110 fM 16 r
9 1 -AU 419 c -s

111111 T 111111 A 11111 D 11 1 1 0 1 e U l i v E e C r 6 b 9 y :

S C N D BA
CS mX LI E

ht:arwmewok cs/op ViwLae.sxDol= 7 3 9 DE2 4 E A1E8 . 1/42 0 t / ro t rAcess e bl p ? cd 6 6 4 1 C12 E 6 6. 12 /0 9 p/ a .