Jump to content

Democracy in Chains

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America
First edition
AuthorNancy MacLean
LanguageEnglish
GenreNon-fiction
PublisherViking Press
Publication date
2017
Publication placeUnited States
Pages368
ISBN978-1101980989
OCLC1033429279

Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America is a 2017 nonfiction book by Nancy MacLean published by Viking Press.[1] MacLean critically examines the school of economic thinking known as "public choice", focusing on its founder James M. Buchanan, who received the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economics in 1986. According to McLean, Buchanan's work has had a significant influence on the libertarian movement and in the US Republican Party, including the political activities of the Koch brothers.

MacLean argues that Buchanan believed democracy must be suppressed for capitalism to flourish, which explains why the right wing, funded behind the scenes by secretive dark money networks, engages in anti-democratic behavior and policy-making, such as opposing unions and Social Security, supporting voter suppression and privatization, and placing impenetrable barriers to popular and social democracy. The book was a finalist for the National Book Award for Nonfiction. Reviewers received it mostly along partisan political lines.[2]

Background and development

[edit]

The idea for the book came about while MacLean was researching school segregation in Prince Edward County, Virginia. She was studying the closure of public schools by segregationists from 1959 to 1964 in reaction to the 1954 U.S. Supreme Court landmark decision Brown v. Board of Education, which held that laws establishing racial segregation in public schools were unconstitutional.[3][4]

The former Robert Russa Moton High School in Farmville, Prince Edward County, Virginia. It is considered "the student birthplace of America's Civil Rights Movement".

MacLean learned that Prince Edward County refused to appropriate funds for the County School Board, effectively closing all public schools rather than integrate them, in a strategy known as massive resistance, an attempt to get Virginia's white politicians to pass laws and policies to prevent public school desegregation. "Black students were locked out of any formal education while their white peers went off to private, segregation academies with school vouchers, essentially punishing the black community in Prince Edward for having been part of the Brown v. Board of Education case," she recalled.[4]

Her research, which spanned a period of about ten years,[5] led her to American economist Milton Friedman and his defense of school vouchers, and to American economist James M. Buchanan. After Buchanan died in 2013, MacLean gained access to his papers at the Buchanan House at George Mason University. She discovered documents supporting the Kochs' investment in Buchanan's Center for Study of Public Choice, and this led her to develop her hypothesis about right-wing politics in the U.S. for the book.[6][3][4]

Content summary

[edit]

This book focuses on the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences-winning political economist James M. Buchanan and his work developing public choice theory, as well as the roles of Charles Koch and others, in nurturing the libertarian movement in the United States. MacLean argues that these figures undertook "a stealth bid to reverse-engineer all of America, at both the state and national levels back to the political economy and oligarchic governance of midcentury Virginia, minus the segregation."[7] According to MacLean, Buchanan represents "the true origin story of today’s well-heeled radical right."[8]

Reception

[edit]

The book was praised by liberal and progressive scholars and readers. In The Atlantic, Sam Tanenhaus called Democracy in Chains "A vibrant intellectual history of the radical right", writing that the book "is part of a new wave of historiography that has been examining the southern roots of modern conservatism" and that it "untangle[s] important threads in American history [...] to make us see how much of that history begins, and still lives, in the South."[9] George Monbiot, climate science author and columnist for The Guardian, wrote that the book was "the missing chapter: a key to understanding the politics of the past half century."[10] Colin Gordon, writing in Jacobin, called the book "a revelation, as politics and as history."[11] MacLean was interviewed by Rebecca Onion in Slate,[8] Alex Shephard in The New Republic, and Mark Karl in Alternet about her "remarkable"[12] and "groundbreaking"[13] book. Bethany Moreton of Dartmouth College called the book "indispensable reading [that] adds a critical storyline to the complex and multi-causal conservative counterrevolution."[14] For BillMoyers.com, Kristin Miller wrote that MacLean "has unearthed a stealth ideologue of the American right" whom Charles Koch "looked to for inspiration".[15] For NPR, Genevieve Valentie wrote the book "feels like it was written with a clock ticking down" after a "sixty-year campaign to make libertarianism mainstream and eventually take the government itself."[16] Marshall Steinbaum of the Roosevelt Institute described himself as "in sympathy with MacLean’s characterization of the Virginia School as profoundly antidemocratic and anti-academic" and called the book "an important warning, and it should be read by all despite its rhetorical shortcomings."[17] Luke Darby of GQ called Democracy in Chains "one of the nine books to read before the next election."[18] MacLean was an invited guest on several popular television and radio outlets, most notably Real Time with Bill Maher, where she appeared twice (in August and November 2018) to discuss contemporary politics and the history of the far right.[19]

Democracy in Chains was also criticized by libertarian scholars and readers in a special Volokh Conspiracy series that ran through June and July 2017. David Bernstein disputed her portrayal of Buchanan and George Mason University, where Bernstein is and Buchanan was a professor,[20][21][22] and questioned the accuracy of her depiction of Buchanan's influence on the libertarian movement.[23] Jonathan H. Adler noted allegations of serious errors and misleading quotations in Democracy in Chains raised by Russ Roberts, David R. Henderson, Don Boudreaux and others.[24] Adler, Ilya Somin[25] and Georg Vanberg[26] were all part of the Volokh Conspiracy series. Michael Munger, a libertarian political scientist at Duke University wrote that Democracy in Chains "is a work of speculative historical fiction".[27] Phil Magness argued that MacLean had "simply made up an inflammatory association" about Buchanan and the Southern Agrarians.[28][29][30][31] Steve Horwitz argued that it was "a book that gets almost everything wrong, from the most basic of facts to the highest of theory".[32] Brian Doherty argued, contra MacLean, that Buchanan had upbraided his colleagues who supported the Chilean dictatorship.[33][34][35] In response, MacLean said she was the target of a "coordinated and interlinked set of calculated hit jobs" by "the Koch team of professors who don't disclose their conflicts of interest and the operatives who work full time for their project to shackle our democracy".[36][37][38] She said her book's ranking on Amazon was being spammed by negative reviews and rankings and urged people to post positive ones in response (this is against Amazon policy).[39] Adler, Bernstein, Carden, and Magness responded to her, saying that any Koch relationship was already acknowledged.[40][20] Vanberg noted two later private letters in which Buchanan discussed his work on school vouchers and condemned the "evils of race-class-cultural segregation."[41]

Others who fell into neither "team Public Choice" or "team anti-Buchanan" offered mixed reviews. Henry Farrell and Steven Teles called the book a "conspiracy theory in the guise of intellectual history"[42][2] and wrote, "while we do not share Buchanan's ideology ... we think the broad thrust of the criticism is right. MacLean is not only wrong in detail but mistaken in the fundamentals of her account."[42][2] Similarly, Noah Smith agreed that MacLean had taken Tyler Cowen, whom he called "a staunch defender of democracy", out of context.[43] Heather Boushey wrote that MacLean had shone "a light on important truths" but cautioned that "her overt moral revulsion at her subject can sometimes make it seem as if we're getting only part of the picture".[44] Jack Rakove wrote that there "should be a thorough scholarly review of these points [raised by critics], and one suspects that MacLean will have to make a more concerted effort to justify her argument than she has yet provided". He concluded that "her questions remain important and well worth pondering".[45] Katherine Timpf of the National Review criticized MacLean for remarks she made during a February 7, 2018, talk in New York City. MacLean was asked to explain Buchanan's motivations. She replied, "As an author, I have struggled with this, and I could explain it in different ways. I didn’t put this in the book, but I will say it here. It’s striking to me how many of the architects of this cause seem to be on the autism spectrum —you know, people who don’t feel solidarity or empathy with others, and who have difficult human relationships sometimes."[46] In 2022, George Leef, writing in the National Review, called it "a screed" and "a brazenly dishonest book".[47]

In her review for the academic journal History of Political Economy, Jennifer Burns wrote that "the narrative of American history [that Democracy in Chains] presents is insular and highly politicized, laying out a drama of good versus evil with little attention paid to the larger worlds—global, economic, or intellectual—in which the story nests."[48] In a review for the academic journal International Social Science Review, Ben Sorensen wrote, "the leftist bias and the assertions of conspiracy render the book questionably credible, at best".[49]

Accolades

[edit]

Democracy in Chains was a finalist for the 2017 National Book Award for nonfiction,[50] a finalist for the "Los Angeles Times Book Award in Current Interest",[51] and the winner of the Lannar Foundation Cultural Freedom Award.[52] The book was also named "Most Valuable Book of 2017" by The Nation.[53] In 2018, Democracy in Chains won the Lillian Smith Book Award, for "books that are outstanding creative achievements, worthy of recognition because of their literary merit, moral vision, and honest representation of the South, its people, problems, and promises."[54]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ MacLean, Nancy (2018) [2017]. Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America. New York: Penguin Books. p. 368. ISBN 978-1101980972. OCLC 1029879485.
  2. ^ a b c Farrell, Henry; Teles, Steven (30 August 2017). "When Politics Drives Scholarship". Boston Review.
  3. ^ a b The Inspiration Behind 'Democracy in Chains'. Duke University. July 3, 2017. Retrieved December 14, 2021.
  4. ^ a b c Democracy in Chains: An interview with author Nancy MacLean. SPLC. March 8, 2018. Retrieved December 14, 2021.
  5. ^ "I have spent the better part of the past decade researching and unraveling the historical roots of the ideas that the radical libertarian right funded by Charles Koch and his network of dark money donors are applying to transform our country." See: After Janus v. AFSCME: Why Teachers and Workers are Fighting Back Against the Secret Money Campaign to Take Away Their Rights. Testimony of Dr. Nancy MacLean, William H. Chafe Professor of History and Public Policy, Duke University. Democratic Policy and Communications Committee (DPCC). Video.
  6. ^ MacLean (2018), xxi–xxiii
  7. ^ MacLean, Nancy (2017). Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America. Penguin. ISBN 978-1101980989.[page needed]
  8. ^ a b Onion, Rebecca (June 22, 2017). "What Is the Far Right's Endgame? A Society That Suppresses the Majority". Slate. ISSN 1091-2339. Retrieved July 10, 2017.
  9. ^ Tanenhaus, Sam. "The Architect of the Radical Right". The Atlantic. Retrieved 2017-07-06.
  10. ^ Monbiot, George (July 19, 2017). "A despot in disguise: one man's mission to rip up democracy". The Guardian.
  11. ^ Gordon, Colin (June 2017). "Democracy's Critics". Jacobin.
  12. ^ Shephard, Alex (June 27, 2017). "The Right's War Against Liberal Democracy". The New Republic.
  13. ^ Karlin, Mark (July 10, 2017). "This Libertarian Strategy to Make America as Screwed-Up as Texas". AlterNet.
  14. ^ Moreton, Bethany (2017-08-10). "Kochonomics: The Racist Roots of Public Choice Theory". Boston Review. Retrieved 2018-04-04.
  15. ^ "The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America". BillMoyers.com. Retrieved 2018-04-04.
  16. ^ "'Democracy In Chains' Traces The Rise Of American Libertarianism". NPR.org. Retrieved 2018-04-04.
  17. ^ Steinbaum, Marshall (14 August 2017). "The Book that Explains Charlottesville". Boston Review.
  18. ^ Darby, Luke (2018-11-08). "9 Books to Read Before the Next Election". GQ. Retrieved 2018-11-17.
  19. ^ "Duke professor Nancy MacLean appears on HBO's Real Time, discusses Koch brothers". The Chronicle. Retrieved 2018-11-17.
  20. ^ a b Bernstein, David (July 20, 2017). "Opinion: Did Nancy MacLean make stuff up in 'Democracy in Chains'?". Washington Post. The Volokh Conspiracy. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved April 2, 2022.
  21. ^ Bernstein, David. "Opinion: Yet more dubious claims in Nancy MacLean's 'Democracy in Chains'". Washington Post. The Volokh Conspiracy.
  22. ^ Bernstein, David. "Opinion | Some dubious claims in Nancy MacLean's 'Democracy in Chains,' continued". Washington Post. The Volokh Conspiracy.
  23. ^ Bernstein, David (July 17, 2017). "Opinion:How influential was James Buchanan among libertarians?". Washington Post. The Volokh Conspiracy.
  24. ^ Adler, Jonathan. "Opinion: Does 'Democracy in Chains' paint an accurate picture of James Buchanan?". Washington Post. The Volokh Conspiracy.
  25. ^ Somin, Ilya (July 10, 2017). "Opinion: Who wants to put democracy in chains?". Washington Post. The Volokh Conspiracy.
  26. ^ Vanberg, Georg. "Opinion: Duke professor Georg Vanberg on 'Democracy in Chains'". Washington Post. The Volokh Conspiracy.
  27. ^ Michael Munger. "On the Origins and Goals of Public Choice". The Independent Institute.
  28. ^ Carden, Art; Geloso, Vincent; Magness, Phillip W. (July 25, 2017). "Situating Southern Influences in James M. Buchanan and Modern Public Choice Economics". Social Science Research Network. SSRN 3008867. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  29. ^ Magness, Phillip. "How Nancy MacLean Went Whistlin' Dixie". historynewsnetwork.org.
  30. ^ "On Buchanan's Intellectual History and MacLean's Missing Leviathan". historynewsnetwork.org.
  31. ^ Carden, Art; Magness, Phil (July 17, 2017). "Buchanan the Evil Genius". Social Science Research Network. SSRN 3004029. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  32. ^ Horwitz, Steven (July 24, 2017). "Confirmation Bias Unchained: Nancy Maclean on James Buchanan, the History of Public Choice Theory, and Libertarianism". Social Science Research Network. SSRN 3007751. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  33. ^ "What Nancy MacLean Gets Wrong About James Buchanan". Reason.com. July 21, 2017.
  34. ^ "To Duke Historian Nancy MacLean, Advocating Free Markets Is Something 'The World Has Never Seen Anything Like...Before'". Reason.com. August 2, 2017.
  35. ^ Farrant, Andrew; Tarko, Vlad (16 January 2018). "James M. Buchanan's 1981 visit to Chile: Knightian democrat or defender of the 'Devil's fix'?". The Review of Austrian Economics. 32: 1–20. doi:10.1007/s11138-017-0410-3. ISSN 0889-3047. S2CID 159003961.
  36. ^ Parry, Marc (2017). "Nancy MacLean Responds to Her Critics". The Chronicle of Higher Education.
  37. ^ Parry, Marc (July 19, 2017). "A New History of the Right Has Become an Intellectual Flashpoint". The Chronicle of Higher Education.
  38. ^ Flaherty, Coleen (July 12, 2017). "Stealth Attack on Liberal Scholar?". Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved July 13, 2017.
  39. ^ Zakaria, Rafia (9 October 2017). "How Amazon reviews became the new battlefield of US Politics". The Guardian.
  40. ^ Adler, Jonathan H. (July 20, 2017). "Opinion | Nancy MacLean responds to her critics". Washington Post.
  41. ^ "Opinion: Georg Vanberg: Democracy in Chains and James M. Buchanan on school integration". Washington Post.
  42. ^ a b Farrell, Henry; Teles, Steven (14 July 2017). "Even the intellectual left is drawn to conspiracy theories about the right. Resist them". Vox.
  43. ^ "Be Clear-Eyed About Democracy's Weaknesses". Bloomberg.com. July 21, 2017.
  44. ^ Boushey, Heather (15 August 2017). "How the Radical Right Played the Long Game and Won". The New York Times.
  45. ^ Rakove, Jack. "Critical Inquiry". criticalinquiry.uchicago.edu.
  46. ^ Timpf, Katherine (February 14, 2018). "Duke Professor: Libertarians 'Seem to Be on the Autism Spectrum'". National Review. Retrieved April 8, 2022.
  47. ^ Leef, George (2022-06-20). "Welcome to the Brave New World of Leftist Scholarship". National Review.
  48. ^ Burns, Jennifer (2018). "Book Review: Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America by Nancy MacLean". History of Political Economy. 50 (3): 640–648. doi:10.1215/00182702-7023786. S2CID 149650365.
  49. ^ Sorensen, Ben (2019-09-03). "Book Review: Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right's Stealth Plan for America by Nancy MacLean". International Social Science Review. 95 (2). ISSN 0278-2308.
  50. ^ "2017 National Book Award finalists revealed". CBS News. October 4, 2017. Retrieved 2017-10-04.
  51. ^ Schaub, Michael (21 February 2018). "L.A. Times Book Prize finalists include Joyce Carol Oates and Ta-Nehisi Coates; John Rechy receives lifetime achievement award". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2018-04-04.
  52. ^ "Lannan Foundation". Lannan Foundation. Retrieved 2018-04-04.
  53. ^ Nichols, John (2017-12-20). "The 2017 Progressive Honor Roll". The Nation. ISSN 0027-8378. Archived from the original on 2018-04-05. Retrieved 2018-04-04.
  54. ^ "Lillian Smith Book Awards". www.libs.uga.edu. Hargrett Library : University of Georgia Libraries. Archived from the original on 2018-05-21. Retrieved 2018-05-20.

Further reading

[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Democracy_in_Chains&oldid=1260989377"