Soviet partisans in Poland: Difference between revisions
rv - rm quote |
the quote is in connection with col. with Nazis. As it was you Irpen who insisted it is a relevant digression here I don't see why do you remove this now? |
||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
The Soviets partisants preferred to assault the poorly armed and trained Belarusan and Polish self-defense forces much more often then German military and police targets like military transports and or other hard targets<ref name="Chod"/>. By the end of 1943, the Soviet could claim a significant victory in their war aganst the Poles: most large landed estates, owned by the Poles, had been destroyed by the Soviet partisans.<ref name="Chod"/> |
The Soviets partisants preferred to assault the poorly armed and trained Belarusan and Polish self-defense forces much more often then German military and police targets like military transports and or other hard targets<ref name="Chod"/>. By the end of 1943, the Soviet could claim a significant victory in their war aganst the Poles: most large landed estates, owned by the Poles, had been destroyed by the Soviet partisans.<ref name="Chod"/> |
||
In late 1943, the actions of Soviet partisans, who were ordered to liquidate tha AK forces<ref name="Piotrowski"/> resulted in a limited amount of uneasy cooperation between some units of AK and the Germans. While AK still treated Germans as the enemy and conducted various operations against them<ref name="Piotrowski"/>, when Germans offered AK some arms and provisions to be used against the Soviet paristans, some Polish units in the [[Nowogródek]] and [[Wilno]] are decided to accept them. However any such arrangments were purerly tactical and did not evidenced a type of ideological collaboration as shown by [[Vichy regime]] in France, [[Quisling regime]] in Norway or closer to the region, the [[Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists]].<ref name="Piotrowski"/> The Poles main motivation wast to gain intelligence on German morale and preparedness and to acquire some badly needed weapons.<ref name="Radzilowski">[http://www.naszawitryna.pl/jedwabne_en_103.html Review] by [[John Radzilowski]] of [[Yaffa Eliach]]'s ''Big Book of Holocaust Revisionism'', [[Journal of Genocide Research]], vol. 1, no. 2 (June 1999), City University of New York.</ref> There are no known joint Polish-German actions, and the Germans were unsuccesfull in their attempt to turn the Poles toward fighting exclusively against Soviet partisans.<ref name="Piotrowski"/> Even so, most of such collaboration of local commanders with the Germans was condemned by AK High Command<ref name="Piotrowski"/>. |
In late 1943, the actions of Soviet partisans, who were ordered to liquidate tha AK forces<ref name="Piotrowski"/> resulted in a limited amount of uneasy cooperation between some units of AK and the Germans. While AK still treated Germans as the enemy and conducted various operations against them<ref name="Piotrowski"/>, when Germans offered AK some arms and provisions to be used against the Soviet paristans, some Polish units in the [[Nowogródek]] and [[Wilno]] are decided to accept them. However any such arrangments were purerly tactical and did not evidenced a type of ideological collaboration as shown by [[Vichy regime]] in France, [[Quisling regime]] in Norway or closer to the region, the [[Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists]].<ref name="Piotrowski"/> The Poles main motivation wast to gain intelligence on German morale and preparedness and to acquire some badly needed weapons.<ref name="Radzilowski">[http://www.naszawitryna.pl/jedwabne_en_103.html Review] by [[John Radzilowski]] of [[Yaffa Eliach]]'s ''Big Book of Holocaust Revisionism'', [[Journal of Genocide Research]], vol. 1, no. 2 (June 1999), City University of New York.</ref> There are no known joint Polish-German actions, and the Germans were unsuccesfull in their attempt to turn the Poles toward fighting exclusively against Soviet partisans.<ref name="Piotrowski"/> Even so, most of such collaboration of local commanders with the Germans was condemned by AK High Command<ref name="Piotrowski"/>. [[Tadeusz Piotrowski]] quotes [[Joseph Rotschild]] saying "The Polish Home Army was by and large untained by collaboration" and adds that "the honor of AK as a whole is beyond reproach".<ref name="Piotrowski"/>. |
||
The struggle continued until the arrival of the [[Red Army]] in [[1944]]. From then, [[History of Poland (1945-1989)|over the period of the next few years]], Soviets and their proxies, the [[Polish communists]], would work to succesfully eradicate the remains of the pro-Western Polish underground. |
The struggle continued until the arrival of the [[Red Army]] in [[1944]]. From then, [[History of Poland (1945-1989)|over the period of the next few years]], Soviets and their proxies, the [[Polish communists]], would work to succesfully eradicate the remains of the pro-Western Polish underground. |
||
Revision as of 22:04, 20 June 2006
- This article is about the activity of Soviet partisans in the territories of the Second Polish Republic that the Soviet Union in most part captured in 1939 and annexed in 1945. For a wider perspective refer to the original article.
Soviet partisans also operated in the territories of the Second Polish Republic. Poland was annexed and partitioned by Germany and the Soviet Union in the aftermath of the Polish September Campaign of 1939. On the pre-war Polish territory annexed by Soviets (Western Ukraine, Western Belarus, Lithuania and Białystok area, known to Poles as Kresy) the first Soviet partisan groups were formed in 1941, soon after the German’s invasion of the Soviet Union. Initially the Soviet partisan groups were formed primarily in the areas of Nowogródek (modern Navahrudak), Lida and Wilno (modern Vilnius) out of Red Army solders who evaded capture by the advancing German forces. Lacking support of the local population, the Soviet partisan groups retreated to various large forest complexes in the area, where they hid from the German rear and anti-partisan units.[1] [2]
Initially, until early 1943, the Soviet partisans focused primarily on survival deep behind enemy lines, with their activity limited mostly to sabotage and diversion rather than armed struggle against German forces and Lithuanian collaborationist police. During that period various Soviet partisan groups also collaborated with the local Polish resistance of ZWZ, later renamed to AK. The Polish underground was established in the area in fall 1939. It was both anti-Nazi and anti-Soviet. The latter attitude stemmed from the memories of Soviet terror between 1939 and 1941, and was reinforced by the conduct of the Soviet partisans.[2] Stalin's aim to ensure that an independent Poland would never reemerge in the postwar period.[3] The inhuman policies of both Hitler and Stalin were clearly aimed at the total extermination of Polish citizens, both Jews and ChristiansCite error: A <ref> tag is missing the closing </ref> (see the help page).
As the eastern front was nearing the area, and diplomatic relations between Polish government in exile and the Soviet Union were broken off in the aftermath of the discovery of the Katyn Massacre, most of the collaboration between Polish and Soviet partisans came to an end, and as ordered by Moscow on June 22 1943[4] the Soviet partisans started an open fight both against the German forces and the local Polish partisans[5] [2]. Frequent requisitions of food in local villages and brutal reprisal actions against villages considered disloyal to the Soviet Union sparked creation of numerous self-defence units, often joining the ranks of the Armia Krajowa[5][1]. Similar assaults on the Polish resistance organizations took place also in the Ukraine[6].
The Soviet partisans were despised by local population, as they engaged in plunder and terrorised the locals
[7]
Communist propaganda routinely referred to the pro-Western Polish underground army as “bands of the White Poles”. According to another propaganda directive, the Polish underground was to be referred to as “the protégés of the Gestapo”.[2] On 23 June 1943, the Soviet partisan leadership authorized denouncing the Polish underground to the Nazis. Later, orders went out to “shoot the [Polish] leaders” and “discredit, disarm, and dissolve” their units.[2] Feigning friendship, the Soviets lured at least two sizable Polish guerrilla detachments to their destruction.[2]
The Soviets partisants preferred to assault the poorly armed and trained Belarusan and Polish self-defense forces much more often then German military and police targets like military transports and or other hard targets[2]. By the end of 1943, the Soviet could claim a significant victory in their war aganst the Poles: most large landed estates, owned by the Poles, had been destroyed by the Soviet partisans.[2]
In late 1943, the actions of Soviet partisans, who were ordered to liquidate tha AK forces[4] resulted in a limited amount of uneasy cooperation between some units of AK and the Germans. While AK still treated Germans as the enemy and conducted various operations against them[4], when Germans offered AK some arms and provisions to be used against the Soviet paristans, some Polish units in the Nowogródek and Wilno are decided to accept them. However any such arrangments were purerly tactical and did not evidenced a type of ideological collaboration as shown by Vichy regime in France, Quisling regime in Norway or closer to the region, the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists.[4] The Poles main motivation wast to gain intelligence on German morale and preparedness and to acquire some badly needed weapons.[8] There are no known joint Polish-German actions, and the Germans were unsuccesfull in their attempt to turn the Poles toward fighting exclusively against Soviet partisans.[4] Even so, most of such collaboration of local commanders with the Germans was condemned by AK High Command[4]. Tadeusz Piotrowski quotes Joseph Rotschild saying "The Polish Home Army was by and large untained by collaboration" and adds that "the honor of AK as a whole is beyond reproach".[4].
The struggle continued until the arrival of the Red Army in 1944. From then, over the period of the next few years, Soviets and their proxies, the Polish communists, would work to succesfully eradicate the remains of the pro-Western Polish underground.
See also
References
- ^ a b Template:Pl icon Zygmunt Boradyn (1999). Niemen rzeka niezgody. Polsko-sowiecka wojna partyzancka na Nowogródczyźnie 1943-1944. Warsaw: Rytm. p. 336. ISBN 8387893080.
{{cite book}}: Cite has empty unknown parameters:|chapterurl=and|coauthors=(help) - ^ a b c d e f g h Review of Sowjetische Partisanen in Weißrußland, by Marek Jan Chodakiewicz, in Sarmatian Review, Arpil 2006
- ^ Judith Olsak-Glass, Review of Piotrowski's Poland's Holocaust in Sarmatian Review, January 1999.
- ^ a b c d e f g Tadeusz Piotrowski, Poland's Holocaust, McFarland & Company, 1997, ISBN 0786403713. Google Print, p.88, p.89, p.90
- ^ a b Template:Pl icon Michał Patyna (2004). "Raport z badań przeprowadzonych podczas obozu naukowego KWSM na Białorusi i Litwie w lipcu 2003 r.". In Marian Wolański (ed.). Zeszyty Naukowe Koła Wschodnioeuropejskiego Stosunków Międzynarodowych (pdf). Zdzisław J. Winnicki. Wrocław: Wrocław University. pp. 7–17. ISSN 1730-654X.
{{cite book}}: Unknown parameter|coauthors=ignored (|author=suggested) (help); Unknown parameter|month=ignored (help) - ^ Template:Pl icon Ryszard Zieliński. "W sierpniu 1943 r. partyzantka dokonała dywersji na torach kolejowych między Ostrogiem a Sławutą". Na Wołyniu i Podolu, Polacy Donbasu. Towarzystwo Kultury Polskiej na Donbasie. Retrieved 2006-05-01.
- ^ Template:Pl icon "Forms of constraint applied by the Soviet authorities in relation to the people of Wilejka region". Professor Franciszek Sielicki. Wrocławskie Studia Wschodnie, Wrocław, 1997 Villagers couldn't stand Soviet partisans because they conducted shamefull robberies. They stole whatever they could, even children't toys .One doesn't have to mention they stealed horses, cows, pigs, underwear, etc. They were many cases, when faced with resistance, they hanged poor peasents by their legs, upside down, to force them into giving something. Behind Willa, in forests and swamps, they formed new units constantly-otriads, which opressed our villages
- ^ Review by John Radzilowski of Yaffa Eliach's Big Book of Holocaust Revisionism, Journal of Genocide Research, vol. 1, no. 2 (June 1999), City University of New York.