Despite the potential benefits of Person Generated Health Data (PGHD), data quality issues impede its use. This study examined the effect of different methods for filtering armband data on determining the amount of healthy walking and the consistency between healthy walking captured using armbands and health diaries. Four weeks of armband and health diary data were acquired from 103 college students. Armband data filtering was performed using heart rate measures and minimum daily step counts as a proxy for adequate daily wear time. No substantial differences in the filtered armband datasets were observed by filtering methods. Significant gaps were observed between healthy walking amounts determined from armband data and through the health diary. Future studies need to explore more diverse data filtering methods and their impact on health outcome assessments.