Pinchas Roth
Bar-Ilan University, Talmud, Faculty Member
- Medieval Jewish History, History of Halakhah, Medieval Provence, Talmud, Hebrew Manuscripts, European Genizah, and 39 moreMedieval History, Medieval France, Hebrew Girona Manucripts, History of Halakha and Jewish Law, bibliography of the Hebrew books, Rashi, Medieval Languedoc, Israel Ta-Shma, Micrography, Sefer Ha Pardes, Anglo-Jewish History, Medieval Ashkenaz, Cairo Genizah, Jewish Studies, HISTORY OF CRIME AND LAW, Halacha, Historical Development of Halakhah, Medieval Catalonia, Canon Law, Medieval Occitania, Codicology of medieval manuscripts, Rabbinical literature (The Mishnah, Babylonian and Palestinian Talmudim, aggadic midrashim), Medieval Occitan Literature, Hebrew Codicology, Jewish Law, Vine and Wines History, Microhistory, Manuscript Studies, Occitan Language, French & Occitan Medieval Language & Literature, Medieval Canon & Roman Law, Medieval Law, Anglo Norman and Angevin England, History of wine, Judeo-Provencal, Food History, Medieval Food Studies, Benjamin of Tudela, and Rabbinic Literatureedit
Addenda and corrigenda to our publication - Responsa of Rabbi Isaac ben Samuel of Dampierre: A Critical Edition (Jerusalem: Mekize Nirdamim, 2019)
Research Interests:
Jewish communities existed across the county of Provence throughout the Middle Ages. In This Land reveals the changes that those communities underwent during the late-thirteenth and fourteenth centuries and the social and cultural... more
Jewish communities existed across the county of Provence throughout the Middle Ages. In This Land reveals the changes that those communities underwent during the late-thirteenth and fourteenth centuries and the social and cultural tensions that shaped their identity. Legal responsa and other genres of rabbinic literature produced in Provence during this period-many of them previously unpublished-provide access to aspects of the past that have long gone unno-ticed. Engagement with legal culture played a central role in the formation of medieval communal identity, providing both a language and a forum for the airing of grievances and the demarcation of social legitimacy. Relations among different ethnic and religious groups, warring spouses, legists and local power brokers were negotiated through the intricacies of Jewish law or Halakhah. Through a close and historically contextualized reading of rabbinic sources, this book provides a startlingly vivid portrait of Jewish life in southern France during the later Middle Ages.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Since antiquity, many people have believed that the length of human gestation is variable, ranging from seven months to ten or even twelve months. The significance of this belief is not confined to the medical sphere, since it has... more
Since antiquity, many people have believed that the length of human gestation is variable, ranging from seven months to ten or even twelve months. The significance of this belief is not confined to the medical sphere, since it has important legal ramifications. If pregnancy could last for an extended period, a mother could claim that her offspring was legitimately conceived from her husband even if she had not had physical contact with her husband for more than nine months prior to the birth. After surveying the history of the belief in prolonged pregnancy in ancient Greek and Talmudic literature, this article presents a new rabbinic discussion of the topic from medieval Languedoc, a hitherto unknown passage from Rabbi Meir ben Simeon ha-Meʿili’s work Sefer ha-Meʾorot.
Very few Hebrew poems are known to have survived from medieval England. A newly discovered poem found in Vatican City, Biblioteca Apostolica Vaticana, MS Ebr. 402 and attributed to a Jew from Saltwharf, a London street on the north shore... more
Very few Hebrew poems are known to have survived from medieval England. A newly discovered poem found in Vatican City, Biblioteca Apostolica Vaticana, MS Ebr. 402 and attributed to a Jew from Saltwharf, a London street on the north shore of the Thames, is published and discussed here. The verses belong to the genre of debate poem. They describe an argument between the components of a candle, the wick and the tallow, each claiming the prestige of the candle's flame. Linguistic hints and the historical and ritual uses of tallow in medieval Europe suggest that this poem is a metaphorical critique of Jewish religious authenticity.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Fragments of a Hebrew manuscript in thirteenth-century Sephardic script were recently discovered in the binding of a fourteenth-century notarial manual in Perpignan. These fragments are identified here as originating in a copy of Tosafot... more
Fragments of a Hebrew manuscript in thirteenth-century Sephardic script were recently discovered in the binding of a fourteenth-century notarial manual in Perpignan. These fragments are identified here as originating in a copy of Tosafot redacted by a disciple of Isaac ben Samuel of Dampierre. It is suggested that the redactor was Samson ben Abraham of Sens. This find is doubly significant—for the study of Tosafot, and for the intellectual history of medieval Perpignan Jewry.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Moses Botarel, who was active in Avignon during the fourteenth and early fifteenth centuries, is remembered mostly for his commentary on Sefer Yezirah. In that commentary, Botarel cited many literary works that never existed. Several... more
Moses Botarel, who was active in Avignon during the fourteenth and
early fifteenth centuries, is remembered mostly for his commentary on
Sefer Yezirah. In that commentary, Botarel cited many literary works
that never existed. Several decades ago, additional writings by Botarel
were published. Those writings relate to Jewish law, and they too contain numerous quotations from imaginary books. This article publishes, for the first time, a legal responsum written by Botarel, found in a manuscript held by the Bodleian Library in Oxford. The responsum does not contain any explicit mention of fictional titles, but philological
analysis reveals the ways in which Botarel reworked and obscured his
sources.
early fifteenth centuries, is remembered mostly for his commentary on
Sefer Yezirah. In that commentary, Botarel cited many literary works
that never existed. Several decades ago, additional writings by Botarel
were published. Those writings relate to Jewish law, and they too contain numerous quotations from imaginary books. This article publishes, for the first time, a legal responsum written by Botarel, found in a manuscript held by the Bodleian Library in Oxford. The responsum does not contain any explicit mention of fictional titles, but philological
analysis reveals the ways in which Botarel reworked and obscured his
sources.
Research Interests:
Very little is known about the internal life of the Jewish community in Provence and the Comtat Venaissin during the fifteenth century. Most of the community came to an end with the expulsion from the county of Provence in 1501. One of... more
Very little is known about the internal life of the Jewish community in Provence and the Comtat Venaissin during the fifteenth century. Most of the community came to an end with the expulsion from the county of Provence in 1501. One of the few rabbinic scholars from this period whose name has been preserved is Mordechai Nathan, a physician and scholar from Avignon. Nathan is known as the owner of several monumental Hebrew manuscripts, and Rabbi Joseph Colon (Maharik) referred to him respectfully. This article analyzes for the first time a trove of responsa from fifteenth-century Provence, some of which were written by Mordechai Nathan and others that were sent to him. The responsa shed light on several aspects of Jewish life during this period, including the Hebrew vocabulary used by Provençal Jews, donations of Torah scrolls to the synagogue, private ownership of seats in the synagogue, communal charity for orphan brides, levirate marriage and divorce. An edition of the newly discovered responsa appears at the end of the article.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Responsa literature from southern France provides detailed information about the production of and commerce in kosher wine. Because the cases in medieval rabbinic sources were recorded for its legal significance rather than their economic... more
Responsa literature from southern France provides detailed information about the production of and commerce in kosher wine. Because the cases in medieval rabbinic sources were recorded for its legal significance rather than their economic importance, they can shed light on aspects of medieval life that escape the reach of historians working with notarial or municipal documents. For example, piquette (pressed grapes mixed with water) was considered a low quality beverage, and is not mentioned in commercial records from the Middle Ages as much as wine is. However, Provençal rabbis devoted many discussions to the status of piquette in Jewish law. The responsa preserve detailed information about the ways in which kosher wine was produced on a commercial scale, and how it was marketed to kosher consumers in local and international markets. Read critically, these sources also demonstrate that the Jewish laity in medieval Provence and Languedoc were more conscientious in upholding the laws of kosher wine than is often assumed
Research Interests:
Responsa literature from southern France provides detailed information about the production of and commerce in kosher wine. Because the cases in medieval rabbinic sources were recorded for its legal significance rather than their economic... more
Responsa literature from southern France provides detailed information about the production of and commerce in kosher wine. Because the cases in medieval rabbinic sources were recorded for its legal significance rather than their economic importance, they can shed light on aspects of medieval life that escape the reach of historians working with notarial or municipal documents. For example, piquette (pressed grapes mixed with water) was considered a low quality beverage, and is not mentioned in commercial records from the Middle Ages as much as wine is. However, Provençal rabbis devoted many discussions to the status of piquette in Jewish law. The responsa preserve detailed information about the ways in which kosher wine was produced on a commercial scale, and how it was marketed to kosher consumers in local and international markets. Read critically, these sources also demonstrate that the Jewish laity in medieval Provence and Languedoc were more conscientious in upholding the laws of kosher wine than is often assumed
Research Interests:
This paper discusses the use and confusion of two Hebrew words, rdom and drom, that denote geographical locations in a 13th-century poem and a late 12-century letter. My conclusion, in regard to these two specific texts, is that they... more
This paper discusses the use and confusion of two Hebrew words, rdom
and drom, that denote geographical locations in a 13th-century poem and a late 12-century letter. My conclusion, in regard to these two specific texts, is that they refer to Rouen, and that the correct reading is Radom, as previously proposed by other scholars, but that the word was also meant to be read – at the same time, as a kind of wordplay – as Darom.
and drom, that denote geographical locations in a 13th-century poem and a late 12-century letter. My conclusion, in regard to these two specific texts, is that they refer to Rouen, and that the correct reading is Radom, as previously proposed by other scholars, but that the word was also meant to be read – at the same time, as a kind of wordplay – as Darom.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
A short survey of rabbis and rabbinic literature from medieval Normandy and Norman England, for the catalogue accompanying an exhibition in Rouen about the medieval Jews of northern Europe.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
English abstract - full Hebrew version will be available online in one year. The article describes a religious-legal (halakhic) controversy that erupted within the Jewish community of 14th-century Avignon. The controversy concerned the... more
English abstract - full Hebrew version will be available online in one year.
The article describes a religious-legal (halakhic) controversy that erupted within the Jewish community of 14th-century Avignon. The controversy concerned the question of whether sturgeon is a kosher fish permitted for Jewish consumption, but the roots of the controversy lie in larger issues of religious philosophy. The article is based upon a description of the controversy penned by one of its participants, Astrug Moses
d’Milhau. His description found in the National Library of Israel, ms. 28˚2033 appears here as an appendix to the article.
The article describes a religious-legal (halakhic) controversy that erupted within the Jewish community of 14th-century Avignon. The controversy concerned the question of whether sturgeon is a kosher fish permitted for Jewish consumption, but the roots of the controversy lie in larger issues of religious philosophy. The article is based upon a description of the controversy penned by one of its participants, Astrug Moses
d’Milhau. His description found in the National Library of Israel, ms. 28˚2033 appears here as an appendix to the article.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Basing their conclusions on Latin documents, historians have painted the Jewish courts of medieval England as limited and haphazard affairs, their jurisdiction limited mostly to family law. They have also assumed that rabbinic courts... more
Basing their conclusions on Latin documents, historians have painted the Jewish courts of medieval England as limited and haphazard affairs, their jurisdiction limited mostly to family law. They have also assumed that rabbinic courts ceased their activity in England after 1242. Hebrew rabbinic sources from the same period—some of which have never been published—provide more detailed information. These sources describe several professional courts staffed by learned scholars and adjudicating a range of legal issues. These courts existed throughout the thirteenth century—until the Expulsion of 1290—and included some of the leading rabbis in medieval England: Benjamin of Cambridge, Moses of London, and Moses’s son Elijah Menahem. The London court of Rabbi Elijah Menahem in particular possessed significant powers and utilized Elijah’s royal connections to enforce its rulings. Besides correcting the scholarly perception of rabbinic courts in medieval England, this article demonstrates how...
Basing their conclusions on Latin documents, historians have painted the Jewish courts of medieval England as limited and haphazard affairs, their jurisdiction limited mostly to family law. They have also assumed that rabbinic courts... more
Basing their conclusions on Latin documents, historians have painted the Jewish courts of medieval England as limited and haphazard affairs, their jurisdiction limited mostly to family law. They have also assumed that rabbinic courts ceased their activity in England after 1242. Hebrew rabbinic sources from the same period—some of which have never been published—provide more detailed information. These sources describe several professional courts staffed by learned scholars and adjudicating a range of legal issues. These courts existed throughout the thirteenth century—until the Expulsion of 1290—and included some of the leading rabbis in medieval England: Benjamin of Cambridge, Moses of London, and Moses’s son Elijah Menahem. The London court of Rabbi Elijah Menahem in particular possessed significant powers and utilized Elijah’s royal connections to enforce its rulings. Besides correcting the scholarly perception of rabbinic courts in medieval England, this article demonstrates how crucially important rabbinic texts and responsa are for historians as a source alongside other types of medieval documentation.
Research Interests:
A Hebrew manuscript in the Parma Palatinate Library, produced in the fourteenth century, probably in Provence, contains adaptations from Latin/Romance texts, including two that originate in the Christian crusading tradition. These two... more
A Hebrew manuscript in the Parma Palatinate Library, produced in the fourteenth century, probably in Provence, contains adaptations from Latin/Romance texts, including two that originate in the Christian crusading tradition. These two sections consist mainly of historical and geographical data relating to the Levant. The Hebrew adaptations,
although selective, are religiously neutral, reflecting the redactor’s keen interest in the history and geography of the Orient and his willingness to absorb information about it from Christian sources.
although selective, are religiously neutral, reflecting the redactor’s keen interest in the history and geography of the Orient and his willingness to absorb information about it from Christian sources.
Research Interests:
The divorce case between David Bonjorn and Esther Caravita, which took place in Girona and Perpignan in 1337, is extraordinarily well documented. Hebrew and Latin documents shed light on the stages of the controversy, the wide range of... more
The divorce case between David Bonjorn and Esther Caravita, which took place in Girona and Perpignan in 1337, is extraordinarily well documented. Hebrew and Latin documents shed light on the stages of the controversy, the wide range of personalities involved in the case and, most notably, the strategies mobilised by the two sides in their attempt to uphold or invalidate the divorce. The ways in which personal strengths and weaknesses were utilised in this legal battle enrich recent scholarly discussions about legal strategy in medieval Europe.
Research Interests:
A short, preliminary piece about Naphtali Halevy (1840-1894), an Eastern European rabbinic maskil who found his way to Victorian England.
Research Interests:
Posing a Halakhic query to a rabbi is often taken for granted, as the backdrop to a legal process that begins with the rabbi composing his responsum. At times, however, the question itself is the product of a calculated decision on the... more
Posing a Halakhic query to a rabbi is often taken for granted, as the backdrop to a legal process that begins with the rabbi composing his responsum. At times, however, the question itself is the product of a calculated decision on the part of a layperson to become involved in the Halakhic process. Focusing on responsa from medieval Provence, this article claims that the tensions that existed within the Jewish community between rabbis and philosophers were sometimes played out by asking Halakhic questions. Sensitivity to rhetorical dimensions in both the question and the answer, and to the cultural and social contexts in which the responsum was created, reveals a hidden polemic about Jewish law and power.
Research Interests:
Yeshurun 29 (2013), pp. 28-32 (Hebrew)
Research Interests:
David ben Saul, a rabbinic sage active in southern France during the mid-thirteenth century, is known to scholars primarily because of his attempt (alongside his teacher Solomon ben Abraham of Montpellier) to eradicate the rational... more
David ben Saul, a rabbinic sage active in southern France during the mid-thirteenth century, is known to scholars primarily because of his attempt (alongside his teacher Solomon ben Abraham of Montpellier) to eradicate the rational philosophy of Maimonides from the Jewish community of Provence and Languedoc. This article examines a letter written by David ben Saul in which he criticized a halakhic work on the laws of kosher wine. The critique reveals further significant aspects of Rabbi David’s personality as a zealot opposed not only to philosophical innovations but also to new halakhic positions – whether voiced by Maimonides or by the French Tosafists. The article analyzes a number of the legal positions that David ben Saul rejected, placing his opposition in its historical and legal context. An appendix to the article presents a new section of the letter, published from a manuscript in the Bibliothèque nationale de France, in which David ben Saul attacked the legal rulings of Rabbi Jacob ben Meir of Ramerupt (Rabenu Tam).
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Introduction to a new edition of Sefer ha-Mikhtam, published by Makhon Ahavat Shalom, Jerusalem 2015. Rabbi David ben Levi lived in Narbonne during the second half of the thirteenth century. Heir to a local rabbinic tradition that had... more
Introduction to a new edition of Sefer ha-Mikhtam, published by Makhon Ahavat Shalom, Jerusalem 2015.
Rabbi David ben Levi lived in Narbonne during the second half of the thirteenth century. Heir to a local rabbinic tradition that had included such dominant figures as Rabbi Avraham ben Yitzhak, the judge of Narbonne, his son-in-law the great Rabad of Posquieres and, in the first half of the thirteenth century, Meir ben Shimon ha-Meili. Like ha-Meili and his uncle, Meshulam ben Moshe of Beziers, David ben Levi wrote his life's work as a halakhic commentary on Rabbi Yitzhak Alfasi (Rif)'s Halakhot Rabbati. A number of manuscripts of Rabbi David's book, which he titled Sefer ha-Mikhtam, have survived, and several tractates from that book were published over the course of the twentieth century. Machon Ahavat Shalom have now published the first of two volumes which will comprise a new critical edition of all surviving sections of Sefer ha-Mikhtam, based upon all available manuscripts.
Rabbi David ben Levi lived in Narbonne during the second half of the thirteenth century. Heir to a local rabbinic tradition that had included such dominant figures as Rabbi Avraham ben Yitzhak, the judge of Narbonne, his son-in-law the great Rabad of Posquieres and, in the first half of the thirteenth century, Meir ben Shimon ha-Meili. Like ha-Meili and his uncle, Meshulam ben Moshe of Beziers, David ben Levi wrote his life's work as a halakhic commentary on Rabbi Yitzhak Alfasi (Rif)'s Halakhot Rabbati. A number of manuscripts of Rabbi David's book, which he titled Sefer ha-Mikhtam, have survived, and several tractates from that book were published over the course of the twentieth century. Machon Ahavat Shalom have now published the first of two volumes which will comprise a new critical edition of all surviving sections of Sefer ha-Mikhtam, based upon all available manuscripts.
Research Interests:
AJS Review 38:2 (2014), 375-393
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Publication and analysis of a fragmentary manuscript of She'iltot de-Rav Ahai Gaon, found in Ravenna.
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Book event in honour of Ephraim Kanarfogel, Brothers From Afar: Rabbinic Approaches to Apostasy and Reversion in Medieval Europe (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 2021), Center for the Study of Conversion and Inter-Religious... more
Book event in honour of Ephraim Kanarfogel, Brothers From Afar: Rabbinic Approaches to Apostasy and Reversion in Medieval Europe (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 2021), Center for the Study of Conversion and Inter-Religious Encounters, Ben-Gurion University, 2 June 2021 (online).
Book event in honour of Avraham (Rami) Reiner, Rabbenu Tam: Interpretation, Halakhah, Controversy. Ben-Gurion University, 31 May 2021
With Dr. Pinchas Roth discussing Medieval Jewry of Provence (South France). We discuss the communities history, its overall "hashkafa", famous Provencial Rabbinic figures like: Ra'avad, Ibn Tibbon's, Kimhi's (Radak, etc.), Meiri, Ralbag,... more
With Dr. Pinchas Roth discussing Medieval Jewry of Provence (South France).
We discuss the communities history, its overall "hashkafa", famous Provencial Rabbinic figures like: Ra'avad, Ibn Tibbon's, Kimhi's (Radak, etc.), Meiri, Ralbag, and more.
We also discuss his new book, " In This Land: Jewish Life and Legal Culture in Late Medieval Provence".
To order the book and get 25% off, use code SC21 (valid until 4/30/21) via email: [email protected].
We discuss the communities history, its overall "hashkafa", famous Provencial Rabbinic figures like: Ra'avad, Ibn Tibbon's, Kimhi's (Radak, etc.), Meiri, Ralbag, and more.
We also discuss his new book, " In This Land: Jewish Life and Legal Culture in Late Medieval Provence".
To order the book and get 25% off, use code SC21 (valid until 4/30/21) via email: [email protected].
Jews, Credit and Usury in Medieval and Early Modern Times: What's New in the Field?
Workshop, Centre de Recherche Francais a Jerusalem, May 23 2019
Workshop, Centre de Recherche Francais a Jerusalem, May 23 2019
Research Interests:
Talk at book launch for Ram Ben-Shalom, The Jews of Provence and Languedoc : renaissance in the shadow of the Church (Hebrew; Raanana: Open University, 2018)
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Lecture delivered at: Transitions: An International Conference of the Department of Talmud, Bar-Ilan University, 13 March 2018
Research Interests:
A response to Rami Reiner's lecture 'Halakhah and Practice in Sefer Hasidim' at the Sefer Hasidim conference, Jerusalem, 19 March 2017
http://beyond-the-elite.huji.ac.il/book/sefer-hassidim-conference-19-2203
http://beyond-the-elite.huji.ac.il/book/sefer-hassidim-conference-19-2203
Research Interests:
A keynote lecture at: Making Early Middle English: An International Conference on English Literature and its Contexts, ca. 1100-1350, University of Victoria, Victoria BC Canada, 23 September 2016
Research Interests:
Short lecture analyzing one responsum by Rabbi Isaac of Dampierre (Ri ha-Zaken). The responsum deals with the laws of kosher wine, and provides a glimpse of the famous Tosafist's attitude towards his teacher, Rabenu Tam, and towards... more
Short lecture analyzing one responsum by Rabbi Isaac of Dampierre (Ri ha-Zaken). The responsum deals with the laws of kosher wine, and provides a glimpse of the famous Tosafist's attitude towards his teacher, Rabenu Tam, and towards popular custom (minhag).
Research Interests:
Departmental seminar, Goldstein-Goren Department of Jewish Thought, Ben Gurion University, 25 March 2015
Research Interests:
A lecture delivered at a conference on Jewish Thought in Late Medieval Provence, Beer Sheva, 19 November 2014
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Research Interests:
Speakers - Prof. Simcha Emanuel, Dr. Judah Galinsky, Prof. Elisheva Baumgarten.
Johns Hopkins University's Stulman Program in Jewish Studies External Link has organized a virtual Book Symposium on a recent PIMS publication, Pinchas Roth's In This Land: Jewish Life and Legal Culture in Late Medieval Provence. The... more
Johns Hopkins University's Stulman Program in Jewish Studies External Link has organized a virtual Book Symposium on a recent PIMS publication, Pinchas Roth's In This Land: Jewish Life and Legal Culture in Late Medieval Provence. The symposium will take place on Sunday 31 October via Zoom.
The symposium will begin on 31 October at 11:30 AM EST (17:30 Israel time).
The Zoom link is: https://zoom.us/j/92661426812 External Link
Panelists:
Rebecca Winer (Villanova University)
Ram Ben-Shalom (Hebrew University of Jerusalem)
David Katz (Johns Hopkins University)
Moshe Chechik (Hebrew University of Jerusalem)
For more information, please email Yitzhak Melamed at [email protected].
https://pims.ca/news-item/roth-book-symposium/
The symposium will begin on 31 October at 11:30 AM EST (17:30 Israel time).
The Zoom link is: https://zoom.us/j/92661426812 External Link
Panelists:
Rebecca Winer (Villanova University)
Ram Ben-Shalom (Hebrew University of Jerusalem)
David Katz (Johns Hopkins University)
Moshe Chechik (Hebrew University of Jerusalem)
For more information, please email Yitzhak Melamed at [email protected].
https://pims.ca/news-item/roth-book-symposium/
Research Interests:
Rella Kushelevsky, Tales in Context: Sefer ha-ma’asim in Medieval Northern France (Bodleian Library, Ms. Bodl. Or. 135), trans. Ruchie Avital and Chaya Naor, with a historical epilogue by Elisheva Baumgarten. (Raphael Patai Series in Jewish Folklore and Anthropology.) Detroit: Wayne State Univers...more