-
First constraints on non-minimally coupled Natural and Coleman-Weinberg inflation and massive neutrino self-interactions with Planck+BICEP/Keck
Authors:
Nilay Bostan,
Shouvik Roy Choudhury
Abstract:
In this work, for the first time in literature, we study the predictions of non-minimally coupled Natural and Coleman-Weinberg potentials in the $n_s-r$ plane, and an extended $Λ$CDM model where we include non-standard self-interactions among massive neutrinos, mediated by a heavy scalar or vector boson. Constraints were derived using the Planck 2018 + BICEP/Keck 2018 datasets along with other dat…
▽ More
In this work, for the first time in literature, we study the predictions of non-minimally coupled Natural and Coleman-Weinberg potentials in the $n_s-r$ plane, and an extended $Λ$CDM model where we include non-standard self-interactions among massive neutrinos, mediated by a heavy scalar or vector boson. Constraints were derived using the Planck 2018 + BICEP/Keck 2018 datasets along with other data. For the inflationary potentials, we consider two different formulations in gravity that are non-minimally coupled to the scalar field of the inflaton: \textit{Metric and Palatini.} We only consider the self-interaction to be present among $τ$-neutrinos and only at moderate strengths. This is because strong interactions among $τ$-neutrinos, or any strength self-interaction among electron- and muon-neutrinos, as well as any strength flavor-universal interactions, are strongly disfavoured from particle physics experiments.
In terms of cosmological data, we use the latest public CMB datasets from Planck 2018 and BICEP/Keck 2018 collaborations, along with other data from CMB lensing, BAO, RSD, and SNe Ia luminosity distance measurements. We find that there are some situations where predictions from the inflationary models are ruled out at more than 2$σ$ by the minimal $Λ$CDM$+r$ model, but they are allowed in the self-interacting neutrino scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2024; v1 submitted 2 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A gravitational constant transition within cepheids as supernovae calibrators can solve the Hubble tension
Authors:
Ruchika,
Himansh Rathore,
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Vikram Rentala
Abstract:
Local universe measurements of the Hubble constant (H0) using SNe Ia with Cepheids as calibrators yield a value of H0 which is in tension with the value inferred from the CMB and other higher redshift probes. In ref. [1], the authors proposed a rapid transition in the value of the effective Newtonian gravitational constant G in order to alleviate the Hubble tension. The transition point was chosen…
▽ More
Local universe measurements of the Hubble constant (H0) using SNe Ia with Cepheids as calibrators yield a value of H0 which is in tension with the value inferred from the CMB and other higher redshift probes. In ref. [1], the authors proposed a rapid transition in the value of the effective Newtonian gravitational constant G in order to alleviate the Hubble tension. The transition point was chosen so as to only affect distance estimates to Hubble flow SNe. However, in this study, the authors made the assumption that SNe Ia peak luminosity $L$ increases with Chandrashekhar mass $M_c$. This hypothesis contradicts a previous semi-analytic study of SN light curves in the presence of G-transition [2] which found that $L\propto M_c^{-0.97}$. Motivated by the results of refs. [1] and [2], we propose a hypothesis of a sudden recent change in the effective G at an epoch which corresponds to a look-back distance between $\sim$ 7 - 80 Mpc. A transition in G at these distances would affect both our estimate of the distances to Cepheids in calibrator galaxies, as well as to the Hubble flow supernovae. Upon fitting the observational data to this hypothesis, we find three interesting results: (i) we find mild evidence for a G-transition at 22.4 Mpc (73 million years ago) which is preferred (using certain estimators) by the calibrator type Ia SNe data over no G-transition, (ii) the H0 parameter inferred under this hypothesis is in good agreement with the value obtained from the CMB for a 4% larger value of G at earlier times, thus potentially resolving the Hubble tension, (iii) we obtain a fit to the scaling relationship between SN peak luminosity $L$ and Chandrasekhar mass $M_c$, as $L\propto M_c^{-1.68 \pm 0.68}$, which is in good agreement with the prediction of the theoretical study of ref. [2]. We also discuss how other probes could be used to verify this transition in the value of G.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2024; v1 submitted 8 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Massive neutrino self-interactions and inflation
Authors:
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Steen Hannestad,
Thomas Tram
Abstract:
Certain inflationary models like Natural inflation (NI) and Coleman-Weinberg inflation (CWI) are disfavoured by cosmological data in the standard $Λ\textrm{CDM}+r$ model (where $r$ is the scalar-to-tensor ratio), as these inflationary models predict the regions in the $n_s-r$ parameter space that are excluded by the cosmological data at more than 2$σ$ (here $n_s$ is the scalar spectral index). The…
▽ More
Certain inflationary models like Natural inflation (NI) and Coleman-Weinberg inflation (CWI) are disfavoured by cosmological data in the standard $Λ\textrm{CDM}+r$ model (where $r$ is the scalar-to-tensor ratio), as these inflationary models predict the regions in the $n_s-r$ parameter space that are excluded by the cosmological data at more than 2$σ$ (here $n_s$ is the scalar spectral index). The same is true for single field inflationary models with an inflection point that can account for all or majority of dark matter in the form of PBHs (primordial black holes). Cosmological models incorporating strongly self-interacting neutrinos (with a heavy mediator) are, however, known to prefer lower $n_s$ values compared to the $Λ\rm CDM$ model. Considering such neutrino self-interactions can, thus, open up the parameter space to accommodate the above inflationary models. In this work, we implement the massive neutrino self-interactions with a heavy mediator in two different ways: flavour-universal (among all three neutrinos), and flavour-specific (involving only one neutrino species). We implement the new interaction in both scalar and tensor perturbation equations of neutrinos. Interestingly, we find that the current cosmological data can support the aforementioned inflationary models at 2$σ$ in the presence of such neutrino self-interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2022; v1 submitted 14 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Neutrino mass and mass ordering: No conclusive evidence for normal ordering
Authors:
Stefano Gariazzo,
Martina Gerbino,
Thejs Brinckmann,
Massimiliano Lattanzi,
Olga Mena,
Thomas Schwetz,
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Katherine Freese,
Steen Hannestad,
Christoph A. Ternes,
Mariam Tórtola
Abstract:
The extraction of the neutrino mass ordering is one of the major challenges in particle physics and cosmology, not only for its implications for a fundamental theory of mass generation in nature, but also for its decisive role in the scale of future neutrinoless double beta decay experimental searches. It has been recently claimed that current oscillation, beta decay and cosmological limits on the…
▽ More
The extraction of the neutrino mass ordering is one of the major challenges in particle physics and cosmology, not only for its implications for a fundamental theory of mass generation in nature, but also for its decisive role in the scale of future neutrinoless double beta decay experimental searches. It has been recently claimed that current oscillation, beta decay and cosmological limits on the different observables describing the neutrino mass parameter space provide robust decisive Bayesian evidence in favor of the normal ordering of the neutrino mass spectrum [arXiv:2203.14247]. We further investigate these strong claims using a rich and wide phenomenology, with different sampling techniques of the neutrino parameter space. Contrary to the findings of Jimenez et al [arXiv:2203.14247], no decisive evidence for the normal mass ordering is found. Neutrino mass ordering analyses must rely on priors and parameterizations that are ordering-agnostic: robust results should be regarded as those in which the preference for the normal neutrino mass ordering is driven exclusively by the data, while we find a difference of up to a factor of 33 in the Bayes factors among the different priors and parameterizations exploited here. An ordering-agnostic prior would be represented by the case of parameterizations sampling over the two mass splittings and a mass scale, or those sampling over the individual neutrino masses via normal prior distributions only. In this regard, we show that the current significance in favor of the normal mass ordering should be taken as $2.7σ$ (i.e. moderate evidence), mostly driven by neutrino oscillation data.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Neutrino Properties with Ground-Based Millimeter-Wavelength Line Intensity Mapping
Authors:
Azadeh Moradinezhad Dizgah,
Garrett K. Keating,
Kirit S. Karkare,
Abigail Crites,
Shouvik Roy Choudhury
Abstract:
Line intensity mapping (LIM) is emerging as a powerful technique to map the cosmic large-scale structure and to probe cosmology over a wide range of redshifts and spatial scales. We perform Fisher forecasts to determine the optimal design of wide-field ground-based mm-wavelength LIM surveys for constraining properties of neutrinos and light relics. We consider measuring the auto-power spectra of s…
▽ More
Line intensity mapping (LIM) is emerging as a powerful technique to map the cosmic large-scale structure and to probe cosmology over a wide range of redshifts and spatial scales. We perform Fisher forecasts to determine the optimal design of wide-field ground-based mm-wavelength LIM surveys for constraining properties of neutrinos and light relics. We consider measuring the auto-power spectra of several CO rotational lines (from J=2-1 to J=6-5) and the [CII] fine-structure line in the redshift range of $0.25<z<12$. We study the constraints with and without interloper lines as a source of noise in our analysis, and for several one- and multi-parameter extensions of $Λ$CDM. We show that LIM surveys deployable this decade, in combination with existing CMB (primary) data, could achieve order of magnitude improvements over Planck constraints on $N_{\rm eff}$ and $M_ν$. Compared to next-generation CMB and galaxy surveys, a LIM experiment of this scale could achieve bounds that are a factor of $\sim3$ better than those forecasted for surveys such as EUCLID (galaxy clustering), and potentially exceed the constraining power of CMB-S4 by a factor of $\sim1.5$ and $\sim3$ for $N_{\rm eff}$ and $M_ν$, respectively. We show that the forecasted constraints are not substantially affected when enlarging the parameter space, and additionally demonstrate that such a survey could also be used to measure $Λ$CDM parameters and the dark energy equation of state exquisitely well.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022; v1 submitted 30 September, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Updated constraints on massive neutrino self-interactions from cosmology in light of the $H_0$ tension
Authors:
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Steen Hannestad,
Thomas Tram
Abstract:
We have updated the constraints on flavour universal neutrino self-interactions mediated by a heavy scalar, in the effective 4-fermion interaction limit. We use the relaxation time approximation to modify the collisional neutrino Boltzmann equations, which is known to be very accurate for this particular scenario. Based on the latest CMB data from the Planck 2018 data release as well as auxiliary…
▽ More
We have updated the constraints on flavour universal neutrino self-interactions mediated by a heavy scalar, in the effective 4-fermion interaction limit. We use the relaxation time approximation to modify the collisional neutrino Boltzmann equations, which is known to be very accurate for this particular scenario. Based on the latest CMB data from the Planck 2018 data release as well as auxiliary data we confirm the presence of a region in parameter space with relatively strong self-interactions which provides a better than naively expected fit. However, we also find that the most recent data, in particular high-$\ell$ polarisation data from the Planck 2018 release, disfavours this solution even though it cannot yet be excluded. Our analysis takes into account finite neutrino masses (parameterised in terms of $\sum m_ν$) and allows for a varying neutrino energy density (parameterised in terms of $N_{\rm eff}$), and we find that in all cases the neutrino mass bound inferred from cosmological data is robust against the presence of neutrino self-interactions. Finally, we also find that the strong neutrino self-interactions do not lead to a high value of $H_0$ being preferred, i.e.\ this model is not a viable solution to the current $H_0$ discrepancy.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2021; v1 submitted 14 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Updated results on neutrino mass and mass hierarchy from cosmology with Planck 2018 likelihoods
Authors:
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Steen Hannestad
Abstract:
In this work we update the bounds on $\sum m_ν$ from latest publicly available cosmological data and likelihoods using Bayesian analysis, while explicitly considering particular neutrino mass hierarchies. In the minimal $Λ\textrm{CDM}+\sum m_ν$ model with most recent CMB data from Planck 2018 TT,TE,EE, lowE, and lensing; and BAO data from BOSS DR12, MGS, and 6dFGS, we find that at 95\% C.L. the bo…
▽ More
In this work we update the bounds on $\sum m_ν$ from latest publicly available cosmological data and likelihoods using Bayesian analysis, while explicitly considering particular neutrino mass hierarchies. In the minimal $Λ\textrm{CDM}+\sum m_ν$ model with most recent CMB data from Planck 2018 TT,TE,EE, lowE, and lensing; and BAO data from BOSS DR12, MGS, and 6dFGS, we find that at 95\% C.L. the bounds are: $\sum m_ν<0.12$ eV (degenerate), $\sum m_ν<0.15$ eV (normal), $\sum m_ν<0.17$ eV (inverted). The bounds vary across the different mass orderings due to different priors on $\sum m_ν$. Also, we find that the normal hierarchy is very mildly preferred relative to the inverted, using both minimum $χ^2$ values and Bayesian Evidence ratios. In this paper we also provide bounds on $\sum m_ν$ considering different hierarchies in various extended cosmological models: $Λ\textrm{CDM}+\sum m_ν+r$, $w\textrm{CDM}+\sum m_ν$, $w_0 w_a \textrm{CDM}+\sum m_ν$, $w_0 w_a \textrm{CDM}+\sum m_ν$ with $w(z)\geq -1$, $Λ\textrm{CDM} + \sum m_ν + Ω_k$, and $Λ\textrm{CDM} + \sum m_ν + A_{\textrm{Lens}}$. We do not find any strong evidence of normal hierarchy over inverted hierarchy in the extended models either.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2020; v1 submitted 29 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Constraining light sterile neutrino mass with the BICEP2/Keck Array 2014 B-mode polarization data
Authors:
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Sandhya Choubey
Abstract:
We explore the thermal light sterile neutrino situation from cosmological perspective in the $Λ\textrm{CDM} + r_{0.05} + N_{\textrm{eff}} + m^{\textrm{eff}}_{\textrm{s}}$ model using combinations of latest data sets available. Here, $r_{0.05}$ is the tensor-to-scalar ratio at the pivot scale of $k_*=0.05h$ Mpc$^{-1}$, $N_{\textrm{eff}}$ is the effective number of relativistic species during recomb…
▽ More
We explore the thermal light sterile neutrino situation from cosmological perspective in the $Λ\textrm{CDM} + r_{0.05} + N_{\textrm{eff}} + m^{\textrm{eff}}_{\textrm{s}}$ model using combinations of latest data sets available. Here, $r_{0.05}$ is the tensor-to-scalar ratio at the pivot scale of $k_*=0.05h$ Mpc$^{-1}$, $N_{\textrm{eff}}$ is the effective number of relativistic species during recombination, and $m^{\textrm{eff}}_{\textrm{s}}$ is the effective mass of the sterile neutrino. Among Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) datasets, we use Planck 2015 temperature and low-$l$ ($l <$ 30) polarization data and the latest data release on the B-mode polarization up to and including 2014 from the BICEP2/Keck collaboration (BK14). We also use the latest BAO data from SDSS-III BOSS DR12, MGS, and 6dFS; and a Gaussian prior (HST) on the Hubble constant ($H_0 = 73.24 \pm 1.74$ km/sec/Mpc) from direct measurements. We find that inclusion of BK14 data makes the constraints on the effective mass of sterile neutrino ($m^{\textrm{eff}}_{\textrm{s}}$) slightly stronger by preferring higher $σ_8$ values. The bound of $m^{\textrm{eff}}_{\textrm{s}} <$ 0.46 eV (95\% C.L.) is found for the combination of Planck 2015, BAO and BK14 datasets, whereas the bound is $m^{\textrm{eff}}_{\textrm{s}} <$ 0.53 eV (95\% C.L.) without the BK14 data. Our most aggressive bound of $m^{\textrm{eff}}_{\textrm{s}} <$ 0.28 eV (95\% C.L.) is obtained with Planck 2015, HST and BK14. However, the HST prior also leads to very high $N_{\textrm{eff}}$ which might be in conflict with bounds from BBN. Our analysis indicates that fully thermalized sterile neutrinos with mass $\sim 1$ eV are slightly more disfavoured with the inclusion of BK14 data. It also seems to make the agreement between Planck 2015 and CFHTLenS (weak gravitational lensing data) worse due to the higher $σ_8$ values (abstract abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2019; v1 submitted 26 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Strong Bounds on Sum of Neutrino Masses in a 12 Parameter Extended Scenario with Non-Phantom Dynamical Dark Energy ($w(z)\geq -1$)
Authors:
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Abhishek Naskar
Abstract:
We obtained constraints on a 12 parameter extended cosmological scenario including non-phantom dynamical dark energy (NPDDE) with CPL parametrization. We also include the six $Λ$CDM parameters, number of relativistic neutrino species ($N_{\textrm{eff}}$) and sum over active neutrino masses ($\sum m_ν$), tensor-to-scalar ratio ($r_{0.05}$), and running of the spectral index ($n_{run}$). We use CMB…
▽ More
We obtained constraints on a 12 parameter extended cosmological scenario including non-phantom dynamical dark energy (NPDDE) with CPL parametrization. We also include the six $Λ$CDM parameters, number of relativistic neutrino species ($N_{\textrm{eff}}$) and sum over active neutrino masses ($\sum m_ν$), tensor-to-scalar ratio ($r_{0.05}$), and running of the spectral index ($n_{run}$). We use CMB Data from Planck 2015; BAO Measurements from SDSS BOSS DR12, MGS, and 6dFS; SNe Ia Luminosity Distance measurements from the Pantheon Sample; CMB B-mode polarization data from BICEP2/Keck collaboration (BK14); Planck lensing data; and a prior on Hubble constant ($73.24\pm1.74$ km/sec/Mpc) from local measurements (HST). We have found strong bounds on the sum of the active neutrino masses. For instance, a strong bound of $\sum m_ν <$ 0.123 eV (95\% C.L.) comes from Planck+BK14+BAO. Although we are in such an extended parameter space, this bound is stronger than a bound of $\sum m_ν <$ 0.158 eV (95\% C.L.) obtained in $Λ\textrm{CDM}+\sum m_ν$ with Planck+BAO. Varying $A_{\textrm{lens}}$ instead of $r_{0.05}$ however leads to weaker bounds on $\sum m_ν$. Inclusion of the HST leads to the standard value of $N_{\textrm{eff}} = 3.045$ being discarded at more than 68\% C.L., which increases to 95\% C.L. when we vary $A_{\textrm{lens}}$ instead of $r_{0.05}$, implying a small preference for dark radiation, driven by the $H_0$ tension.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2019; v1 submitted 8 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Updated Bounds on Sum of Neutrino Masses in Various Cosmological Scenarios
Authors:
Shouvik Roy Choudhury,
Sandhya Choubey
Abstract:
We present strong bounds on the sum of three active neutrino masses ($\sum m_ν$) in various cosmological models. We use the following baseline datasets: CMB temperature data from Planck 2015, BAO measurements from SDSS-III BOSS DR12, the newly released SNe Ia dataset from Pantheon Sample, and a prior on the optical depth to reionization from 2016 Planck Intermediate results. We constrain cosmologi…
▽ More
We present strong bounds on the sum of three active neutrino masses ($\sum m_ν$) in various cosmological models. We use the following baseline datasets: CMB temperature data from Planck 2015, BAO measurements from SDSS-III BOSS DR12, the newly released SNe Ia dataset from Pantheon Sample, and a prior on the optical depth to reionization from 2016 Planck Intermediate results. We constrain cosmological parameters in $ΛCDM$ model with 3 massive active neutrinos. For this $ΛCDM+\sum m_ν$ model we find a upper bound of $\sum m_ν <$ 0.152 eV at 95$\%$ C.L. Adding the high-$l$ polarization data from Planck strengthens this bound to $\sum m_ν <$ 0.118 eV, which is very close to the minimum required mass of $\sum m_ν \simeq$ 0.1 eV for inverted hierarchy. This bound is reduced to $\sum m_ν <$ 0.110 eV when we also vary r, the tensor to scalar ratio ($ΛCDM+r+\sum m_ν$ model), and add an additional dataset, BK14, the latest data released from the Bicep-Keck collaboration. This bound is further reduced to $\sum m_ν <$ 0.101 eV in a cosmology with non-phantom dynamical dark energy ($w_0 w_a CDM+\sum m_ν$ model with $w(z)\geq -1$ for all $z$). Considering the $w_0 w_a CDM+r+\sum m_ν$ model and adding the BK14 data again, the bound can be even further reduced to $\sum m_ν <$ 0.093 eV. For the $w_0 w_a CDM+\sum m_ν$ model without any constraint on $w(z)$, the bounds however relax to $\sum m_ν <$ 0.276 eV. Adding a prior on the Hubble constant ($H_0 = 73.24\pm 1.74$ km/sec/Mpc) from Hubble Space Telescope (HST), the above mentioned bounds further improve to $\sum m_ν <$ 0.117 eV, 0.091 eV, 0.085 eV, 0.082 eV, 0.078 eV and 0.247 eV respectively. This substantial improvement is mostly driven by a more than 3$σ$ tension between Planck 2015 and HST measurements of $H_0$ and should be taken cautiously. (abstract abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2018; v1 submitted 28 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
How delicate are the $f(R)$ gravity models with disappearing cosmological constant?
Authors:
I. Thongkool,
M. Sami,
S. Rai Choudhury
Abstract:
We consider stability of spherically symmetric solutions in $f(R)$ gravity model proposed by Starobinsky. We find that the model suffers from a severe fine tuning problem when applied to compact objects like neutron stars. The problem can be remedied by introducing a cut off on the mass of the scalar degree of freedom present in the model. A new mass scale associated with neutron stars density i…
▽ More
We consider stability of spherically symmetric solutions in $f(R)$ gravity model proposed by Starobinsky. We find that the model suffers from a severe fine tuning problem when applied to compact objects like neutron stars. The problem can be remedied by introducing a cut off on the mass of the scalar degree of freedom present in the model. A new mass scale associated with neutron stars density is then required for the stabilities of $f(R)$ gravity solutions inside relativistic stars.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2009; v1 submitted 12 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
