Talk:Q79182
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Autodescription — Eilean Donan (Q79182)
description: small tidal island in the western Highlands of Scotland
- Useful links:
- View it! – Images depicting the item on Commons
- Report on constraint conformation of “Eilean Donan” claims and statements. Constraints report for items data
- See also
- This documentation is generated using
{{Item documentation}}.
duplicate of Eilean Donan Castle (Q20816698)
Duplicates or different subjects?
[edit]In most languages (28), the page is named after the island, eg "Eilean Donan". In a smaller set of languages (11), there is a page for the castle, which usually translates to "Eilean Donan Castle" or "Castle of Eilean Donan", but there are two languages which have a page for both.
"Eilean Donan": ar, bg, br, ceb, cs, dsb, en, eu, fa, fi, fr, he, hsb, id, it, ja, lb, mk, ms, na, nn, no, pl, pnb, sco, sv, tr, zh
"Eilean Donan Castle": az, ca, cy, de, es, gd, hu, nds, nl, pt, ru
Both:
- ga; Eilean_Donnain and Caisteal Eilean Donan - both of which are hardly providing any information.
- uk: Ейлін Донан and Замок Ейлен-Донан
What is the general consensus on such cases? As, for me, they all clearly are about the same subject, I'd like to click directly from, for instance, the Dutch version to the English version