Elon Musk Wins Twitter Layoff Lawsuit, Dodging $500 Million Payout

Twitter/X owner Elon Musk has won a lawsuit fired Twitter employee Courtney McMillian brought against Musk and the company last year.

The suit alleged that 6,000 fired Twitter staff were owed $500 million or more in collective severance pay. The judge dismissed the lawsuit Tuesday, writing that the claims, made under US ERISA law, did not apply to the case. Therefore, no such payments were applicable. ERISA, or the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, is a federal law that sets minimum requirements for health and retirement plans.

McMillian, who previously oversaw Twitter's employee benefits programs as its Head of People Experience, had claimed that Musk and X didn't adequately inform staff about their severance plan changes and didn't adhere to the severance plan set up before Musk bought Twitter. McMillian and other laid-off staff reportedly only received one month's severance pay before being forced out in November 2022 after Musk's takeover.

The judge, however, concluded that X did tell fired staff that the old plan was dead and Musk's cash-only severance plan was the only one applicable.

"After the takeover or merger, there were only cash payments promised. There were no promises to continue healthcare benefits or outplacement services provided by a third-party," the judge's decision states.

Recommended by Our Editors

Elon Musk: Grok 2 AI Arrives in August

X Is Putting Another Previously Free Feature Behind a Paywall

Elon Musk's X Stalls at 250M Daily Users While Threads Plays Catch-Up

McMillian can still file another, amended suit against Musk if she believes a breach of contract or other violation has occurred, but won't be able to use the ERISA law to back it up, the judge said. An amended filing could tie this lawsuit to one of three other pending cases from other laid-off Twitter employees, who are also suing Musk and X for similar reasons.

Musk and his companies face a range of lawsuits, but the Tesla CEO may be about to get a massive $56 billion pay package. If finalized, the compensation would make Musk the highest-paid person in US history.

About Kate Irwin

Reporter

I’m a reporter covering early morning news. Prior to joining PCMag in 2024, I was a reporter and producer at Decrypt and launched its gaming vertical, GG. I have previous bylines with Input, Game Rant, and Dot Esports. I’ve been a PC gamer since The Sims (yes, the original). In 2020, I finally built my first PC with a 3090 graphics card, but also regularly use Mac and iOS devices as well. As a reporter, I’m passionate about uncovering scoops and documenting the wide world of tech and how it affects our daily lives.

Read Kate's full bio

Read the latest from Kate Irwin

• Microsoft Gives Controversial Recall AI Feature Some Extra Security
• 'Octo2' Trojan Malware Poses as VPN, Chrome Apps to Steal Funds
• Feds Charge 2 Russians for Laundering Over $1B in Crypto for Cybercriminals
• Uninstall Now: This Android App Is Secretly Stealing Crypto
• Toyota-Backed Robotaxi With T-Mobile 5G Hits the Road in Atlanta
• More from Kate Irwin