I Teach 5th Grade. Two Incidents Involving Two Wallets Shook Me

It is tough teaching 5th grade in deprived schools. I have previously taught in Samoa, Korea, England and Connecticut, but this particular incident occurred in Castroville California. It involves two kids and two wallets. Two incidents in the same day.

One of my boys, Frederico, is cherubic with huge, bulbous eyes. At first I thought he was a smart-ass. He'd have this or that to say. But I get it now. He's just verbal and so sharp he can't keep the words to himself. They flow.

We played frozen tag. He got nailed and had to freeze—no movement. Frederico, feet planted in place, commented, "Well, I'll just sit and rest. This is an opportunity to rest." He meant it. No malice in his words, no sarcasm. He gave in to gravity and sat on the grass. I sat near him and we B.S.-ed. After a minute he asked, "Mr. K, do you have a ten for two fives?"

"I think so?" I took out my wallet and he took out his. I said, "Dude, looks like we're doing a drug deal on the playground."

"I have fifty-six dollars." He showed them to me.

I noticed he didn't say bucks. Frederico is well-spoken. Little guy, under four feet. Super short hair, black as night. As we exchanged the bills I asked, "So, why a ten instead of two fives?"

"I can press the bills together better. They're easier to hide. My brother steals my money." He was quiet, then added, "We used to get along before he moved in with our mom in Watsonville. We played Halo and lots of computer games. Now he's just mean to me. He's twelve. Gram says he went bad."

Paul Henry Karrer
Paul Henry Karrer (L& R) is a teacher. He recalls a specific story involving two wallets that bothered him. Paul Henry Karrer

I had a fistful of questions, but the only one I got out was, "Can't you find a good place to hide your money in your room?"

He smiled at me. "I sleep in the living room. On the couch at Gram's house."

My heart twisted. The frozen tag game swirling around me was forgotten long ago. "Actually,' Frederico said, "that's why I'm saving my money. I'm going to buy my very own bed." Pride and power resonated from him.

"Can I ask a question? You don't have to say anything if you don't want to."

His big eyes ate me as they waited for the question. "What's the story on mom and dad? Why are you with your gram?"

Matter of factly this ten-year old child said, "It's kinda' sad. Somebody broke into our house and they stabbed my dad, shot him and strangled him. I was only three."

Frederico eye-balled me. I knew the cold truth when a fifth-grader shot it my way. I looked away. I refocused on the game and saw that it was mostly over. I stood, patted Frederico on the back, and yelled, "Guys, let's head back to class."

Heavy.

At the end of the same day, the kids left for home. Some bolted, some dawdled, a few gave me hugs. Eventually I had the room to myself. I cleaned up my desk, trying to escape ASAP. A shadow hit the doorway. It was Rosaria, a beaming smiler. She stopped, shot a glance behind herself. She wanted to share something in private.

"Need to shut the door?" I asked.

She shook her head, "No, nobody's around. It's okay." She still smiled.

"What's up?"

"My dad is getting sentenced tomorrow."

Rosaria and I cemented our relationship last year at county jail while I was visiting a former student. I had felt a tug on my jacket in the waiting line. I turned to find Rosaria. She was waiting her turn to see her mom. It became our big secret. She fidgeted a bit in class the Monday after that had happened. I knew she felt uncomfortable.

When I walked by her desk, I whispered, "No probs kiddo. It goes with me to the grave. Just make sure when I'm in... you'll visit ME!" She laughed and knew her secret was safe when we pinkie promised on it.

"So" I asked, "What are your dad's sentencing options?"

"Thirty three years or he's out free."

I gave her a goofy look. "Thirty-three years or free is quite a difference." I held my hands up indicating a scale balancing. "What's he in for?"

She laughed. "This time?"

"Uh oh, more than once huh. That's not good."

"Robbery. He dropped his wallet and the cops I.D.ed him. Stupid, huh?"

She gave me a test smile, it grew to her ears. I shot her a return smile and we burst out laughing. We had a hard time to stop.

"Rosario, I'm sorry to laugh."

"Nah, it' okay, Mr. K. Everybody laughs when I tell them." She sighed, "Dad's a dumb ass."

She hugged me and ran off.

These kids are only ten. I never thought two wallets would bother me so much.

Paul Henry Karrer is a teacher. He has previously taught in Samoa, Korea, England, CT, and Castroville California. He is published in the L.A. Times, Teacher Magazine, Education Week and Chicken Soup. He is a podcast host at Teacher Tails.

All views expressed are the author's own.

Do you have a unique experience or personal story to share? See our Reader Submissions Guide and then email the My Turn team at [email protected].

fairness meter

fairness meter

Newsweek is committed to journalism that's factual and fair.


Hold us accountable and submit your rating of this article on the meter.

Newsweek is committed to journalism that's factual and fair.


Hold us accountable and submit your rating of this article on the meter.

Click On Meter
To Rate This Article
Comment about your rating
Share your rating

About the writer

Paul Henry Karrer

Paul Henry Karrer is a teacher. He has previously taught in Samoa, Korea, England, CT, and Castroville California. He is ... Read more

To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, Click here.
Newsweek cover
  • Newsweek magazine delivered to your door
  • Newsweek Voices: Diverse audio opinions
  • Enjoy ad-free browsing on Newsweek.com
  • Comment on articles
  • Newsweek app updates on-the-go
Newsweek cover
  • Newsweek Voices: Diverse audio opinions
  • Enjoy ad-free browsing on Newsweek.com
  • Comment on articles
  • Newsweek app updates on-the-go