Feature Settings for Editions

Protobuf Editions features and how they affect protobuf behavior.

This topic provides an overview of the features that are included in Edition 2023. Each subsequent edition’s features will be added to this topic. We announce new editions in the News section.

Prototiller

Prototiller is a command-line tool that converts proto2 and proto3 definition files to Editions syntax. It hasn’t been released yet, but is referenced throughout this topic.

Features

The following sections include all of the behaviors that are configurable using features in Edition 2023. Preserving proto2 or proto3 Behavior shows how to override the default behaviors so that your proto definition files act like proto2 or proto3 files. For more information on how Editions and Features work together to set behavior, see Protobuf Editions Overview.

Each of the following sections has an entry for what scope the feature applies to. This can include file, enum, message, or field. The following sample shows a mock feature applied to each scope:

edition = "2023";

// File-scope definition
option features.bar = BAZ;

enum Foo {
  // Enum-scope definition
  option features.bar = QUX;

  A = 1;
  B = 2;
}

message Corge {
  // Message-scope definition
  option features.bar = QUUX;

  // Field-scope definition
  Foo A = 1 [features.bar = GRAULT];
}

In this example, the setting GRAULT in the field-scope feature definition overrides the message-scope QUUX setting.

`features.enum_type`

This feature sets the behavior for how enum values that aren’t contained within the defined set are handled. See Enum Behavior for more information on open and closed enums.

This feature doesn’t impact proto3 files, so this section doesn’t have a before and after of a proto3 file.

Values available:

CLOSED: Closed enums store enum values that are out of range in the unknown field set.
OPEN: Open enums parse out of range values into their fields directly.

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Enum

Default behavior in Edition 2023: OPEN

Behavior in proto2: CLOSED

Behavior in proto3: OPEN

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

enum Foo {
  A = 2;
  B = 4;
  C = 6;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

enum Foo {
  option features.enum_type = CLOSED;
  A = 2;
  B = 4;
  C = 6;
}

`features.field_presence`

This feature sets the behavior for tracking field presence, or the notion of whether a protobuf field has a value.

Values available:

LEGACY_REQUIRED: The field is required for parsing and serialization. Any explicitly-set value is serialized onto the wire (even if it is the same as the default value).
EXPLICIT: The field has explicit presence tracking. Any explicitly-set value is serialized onto the wire (even if it is the same as the default value). For singular primitive fields, has_* functions are generated for fields set to EXPLICIT.
IMPLICIT: The field has no presence tracking. The default value is not serialized onto the wire (even if it is explicitly set). has_* functions are not generated for fields set to IMPLICIT.

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Field

Default value in the Edition 2023: EXPLICIT

Behavior in proto2: EXPLICIT

Behavior in proto3: IMPLICIT unless the field has the optional label, in which case it behaves like EXPLICIT. See Presence in Proto3 APIs for more information.

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

message Foo {
  required int32 x = 1;
  optional int32 y = 2;
  repeated int32 z = 3;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

message Foo {
  int32 x = 1 [features.field_presence = LEGACY_REQUIRED];
  int32 y = 2;
  repeated int32 z = 3;
}

The following shows a proto3 file:

syntax = "proto3";

message Bar {
  int32 x = 1;
  optional int32 y = 2;
  repeated int32 z = 3;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";
option features.field_presence = IMPLICIT;

message Bar {
  int32 x = 1;
  int32 y = 2 [features.field_presence = EXPLICIT];
  repeated int32 z = 3;
}

Note that the required and optional labels no longer exist in Editions, as the corresponding behavior is set explicitly with the field_presence feature.

`features.json_format`

This feature sets the behavior for JSON parsing and serialization.

This feature doesn’t impact proto3 files, so this section doesn’t have a before and after of a proto3 file. Editions behavior matches the behavior in proto3.

Values available:

ALLOW: A runtime must allow JSON parsing and serialization. Checks are applied at the proto level to make sure that there is a well-defined mapping to JSON.
LEGACY_BEST_EFFORT: A runtime does the best it can to parse and serialize JSON. Certain protos are allowed that can result in unspecified behavior at runtime (such as many:1 or 1:many mappings).

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Message, Enum

Default behavior in Edition 2023: ALLOW

Behavior in proto2: LEGACY_BEST_EFFORT

Behavior in proto3: ALLOW

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

message Foo {
  // Warning only
  string bar = 1;
  string bar_ = 2;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";
features.json_format = LEGACY_BEST_EFFORT;

message Foo {
  string bar = 1;
  string bar_ = 2;
}

`features.message_encoding`

This feature sets the behavior for encoding fields when serializing.

This feature doesn’t impact proto3 files, so this section doesn’t have a before and after of a proto3 file.

Depending on the language, fields that are “group-like” may have some unexpected capitalization in generated code and in text-format, in order to provide backwards compatibility with proto2. Message fields are “group-like” if all of the following conditions are met:

Has DELIMITED message encoding specified
Message type is defined in the same scope as the field
Field name is exactly the lowercased type name

Values available:

LENGTH_PREFIXED: Fields are encoded using the LEN wire type described in Message Structure.
DELIMITED: Message-typed fields are encoded as groups.

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Field

Default behavior in Edition 2023: LENGTH_PREFIXED

Behavior in proto2: LENGTH_PREFIXED except for groups, which default to DELIMITED

Behavior in proto3: LENGTH_PREFIXED. Proto3 doesn’t support DELIMITED.

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

message Foo {
  group Bar = 1 {
    optional int32 x = 1;
    repeated int32 y = 2;
  }
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

message Foo {
  message Bar {
    int32 x = 1;
    repeated int32 y = 2;
  }
  Bar bar = 1 [features.message_encoding = DELIMITED];
}

`features.repeated_field_encoding`

This feature is what the proto2/proto3 packed option for repeated fields has been migrated to in Editions.

Values available:

PACKED: Repeated fields of a primitive type are encoded as a single LEN record that contains each element concatenated.
EXPANDED: Repeated fields are each encoded with the field number for each value.

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Field

Default behavior in Edition 2023: PACKED

Behavior in proto2: EXPANDED

Behavior in proto3: PACKED

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

message Foo {
  repeated int32 bar = 6 [packed=true];
  repeated int32 baz = 7;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";
option features.repeated_field_encoding = EXPANDED;

message Foo {
  repeated int32 bar = 6 [features.repeated_field_encoding=PACKED];
  repeated int32 baz = 7;
}

The following shows a proto3 file:

syntax = "proto3";

message Foo {
  repeated int32 bar = 6;
  repeated int32 baz = 7 [packed=false];
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

message Foo {
  repeated int32 bar = 6;
  repeated int32 baz = 7 [features.repeated_field_encoding=EXPANDED];
}

`features.utf8_validation`

This feature sets how strings are validated. It applies to all languages except where there’s a language-specific utf8_validation feature that overrides it. See features.(pb.java).utf8_validation for the Java-language-specific feature.

This feature doesn’t impact proto3 files, so this section doesn’t have a before and after of a proto3 file.

Values available:

VERIFY: The runtime should verify UTF-8. This is the default proto3 behavior.
NONE: The field behaves like an unverified bytes field on the wire. Parsers may handle this type of field in an unpredictable way, such as replacing invalid characters. This is the default proto2 behavior.

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Field

Default behavior in Edition 2023: VERIFY

Behavior in proto2: NONE

Behavior in proto3: VERIFY

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

message MyMessage {
  string foo = 1;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

message MyMessage {
  string foo = 1 [features.utf8_validation = NONE];
}

Language-specific Features

Some features apply to specific languages, and not to the same protos in other languages. Using these features requires you to import the corresponding *_features.proto file from the language’s runtime. The examples in the following sections show these imports.

`features.(pb.cpp/pb.java).legacy_closed_enum`

Languages: C++, Java

This feature determines whether a field with an open enum type should be behave as if it was a closed enum. This allows editions to reproduce non-conformant behavior in Java and C++ from proto2 and proto3.

This feature doesn’t impact proto3 files, and so this section doesn’t have a before and after of a proto3 file.

Values available:

true: Treats the enum as closed regardless of enum_type.
false: Respect whatever is set in the enum_type.

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Field

Default behavior in Edition 2023: false

Behavior in proto2: true

Behavior in proto3: false

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

import "myproject/proto3file.proto";

message Msg {
  myproject.proto3file.Proto3Enum name = 1;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

import "myproject/proto3file.proto";

import "google/protobuf/cpp_features.proto";
import "google/protobuf/java_features.proto";

message Msg {
  myproject.proto3file.Proto3Enum name = 1 [
    features.(pb.cpp).legacy_closed_enum = true,
    features.(pb.java).legacy_closed_enum = true
  ];
}

`features.(pb.cpp).string_type`

Languages: C++

This feature determines how generated code should treat string fields. This replaces the ctype option from proto2 and proto3, and offers a new string_view feature. In Edition 2023, either ctype or string_view may be specified on a field, but not both.

Values available:

VIEW: Generates string_view accessors for the field. This will be the default in a future edition.
CORD: Generates Cord accessors for the field.
STRING: Generates string accessors for the field.

Applicable to the following scopes: File, Field

Default behavior in Edition 2023: STRING

Behavior in proto2: STRING

Behavior in proto3: STRING

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

message Foo {
  optional string bar = 6;
  optional string baz = 7 [ctype = CORD];
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

import "google/protobuf/cpp_features.proto";

message Foo {
  string bar = 6;
  string baz = 7 [features.(pb.cpp).string_type = CORD];
}

The following shows a proto3 file:

syntax = "proto3"

message Foo {
  string bar = 6;
  string baz = 7 [ctype = CORD];
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

import "google/protobuf/cpp_features.proto";

message Foo {
  string bar = 6;
  string baz = 7 [features.(pb.cpp).string_type = CORD];
}

`features.(pb.java).utf8_validation`

Languages: Java

This language-specific feature enables you to override the file-level settings at the field level for Java only.

This feature doesn’t impact proto3 files, and so this section doesn’t have a before and after of a proto3 file.

Values available:

DEFAULT: The behavior matches that set by features.utf8_validation.
VERIFY: Overrides the file-level features.utf8_validation setting to force it to VERIFY for Java only.

Applicable to the following scopes: Field, File

Default behavior in Edition 2023: DEFAULT

Behavior in proto2: DEFAULT

Behavior in proto3: DEFAULT

The following code sample shows a proto2 file:

syntax = "proto2";

option java_string_check_utf8=true;

message MyMessage {
  string foo = 1;
  string bar = 2;
}

After running Prototiller, the equivalent code might look like this:

edition = "2023";

import "google/protobuf/java_features.proto";

option features.utf8_validation = NONE;
option features.(pb.java).utf8_validation = VERIFY;
message MyMessage {
  string foo = 1;
}

Preserving proto2 or proto3 Behavior

You may want to move to the editions format but not deal with updates to the way that generated code behaves yet. This section shows the changes that the Prototiller tool makes to your .proto files to make Edition 2023 protos behave like a proto2 or proto3 file.

After these changes are made at the file level, you get the proto2 or proto3 defaults. You can override at lower levels (message level, field level) to consider additional behavior differences (such as required, proto3 optional) or if you want your definition to only be mostly like proto2 or proto3.

We recommend using Prototiller unless you have a specific reason not to. To manually apply all of these instead of using Prototiller, add the content from the following sections to the top of your .proto file.

Proto2 Behavior

edition = "2023";

import "google/protobuf/cpp_features.proto";
import "google/protobuf/java_features.proto";

option features.field_presence = EXPLICIT;
option features.enum_type = CLOSED;
option features.repeated_field_encoding = EXPANDED;
option features.json_format = LEGACY_BEST_EFFORT;
option features.utf8_validation = NONE;
option features.(pb.cpp).legacy_closed_enum = true;
option features.(pb.java).legacy_closed_enum = true;

Proto3 Behavior

// proto3 behaviors
edition = "2023";

import "google/protobuf/cpp_features.proto";
import "google/protobuf/java_features.proto";

option features.field_presence = IMPLICIT;
option features.enum_type = OPEN;
// `packed=false` needs to be transformed to field-level repeated_field_encoding
// features in Editions syntax
option features.json_format = ALLOW;
option features.utf8_validation = VERIFY;
option features.(pb.cpp).legacy_closed_enum = false;
option features.(pb.java).legacy_closed_enum = false;

Caveats and Exceptions

This section shows the changes that you’ll need to make manually if you choose not to use Prototiller.

Setting the file-level defaults shown in the previous section sets the default behaviors in most cases, but there are a few exceptions.

optional: Remove all instances of the optional label and change the features.field_presence to EXPLICIT if the file default is IMPLICIT.
required: Remove all instances of the required label and add the features.field_presence=LEGACY_REQUIRED option at the field level.
groups: Unwrap the groups into a separate message and add the features.message_encoding = DELIMITED option at the field level. See features.message_encoding for more on this.
java_string_check_utf8: Remove this file option and replace it with the features.(pb.java).utf8_validation. You’ll need to import Java features, as covered in Language-specific Features.
packed: For proto2 files converted to editions format, remove the packed field option and add [features.repeated_field_encoding=PACKED] at the field level when you don’t want the EXPANDED behavior that you set in Proto2 Behavior. For proto3 files converted to editions format, add [features.repeated_field_encoding=EXPANDED] at the field level when you don’t want the default proto3 behavior.