All set up, and ZERO pay-off. Kalki 2898 A. D is a very weird mash-up of Star Wars, and Mahabharata. It's deeply incoherent, substantially void, and strangely unmoving. But does it mean that it's a bad film? No. It's the most visually accomplished Indian film. Technically redefining of the Indian genre filmmaking culture, which was practically inexistent in India until now, the movie succeeds in building CG ridden worlds with spectacle driven action. One could even say that, we have FINALLY tapped into the potential of sci-fi driven fantasy worlds, with a tinge of Indian cultural storytelling.
But despite that potential realised, the film winds up to be a middling effort of a moderately distracting, and disposable Marvel film. At the end of the day, it neither reaches the status of the technical inspiration and achievement of Star-Wars, nor the status of the epic of the Indian culture's contribution to religious literature: Mahabharata.
The movie just winds up to be a middling, Marvel-like homage to these two pieces of cultural iconographies. It does nothing more than that. It's the Marvel-movie equivalent of Thor. Heck, the movie is even building a CINEMATIC UNIVERSE. Why? Just why? No wonder Scorcese thinks Marvel films are not cinema. They just don't make you feel anything, with their pure visual noise. That's exactly how Kalki 2898 winds up to be: VISUAL NOISE THAT MAKES YOU FEEL NOTHING. At least, nothing tangible enough to be memorable.
And I'll tell you why.
First off, after the opening scene of a snippet of Mahabharata, and the titles, the movie begins with a wallpaper-like visual-effects ridden reality, where the narrative starts out bland. It tells the story of some Bhairava, who lazes around throughout half of the movie. Cringy scenes of Bhairava flirting around with Roxy and dancing around like he has all the time in the world, the story absolutely bores any sane person, looking for any meaningful conflict-driven story--to sleep and to death. Let alone little kids, for whom the movie is supposedly marketed towards, with dialogues from Bujji and Bhairava, like, "If my boss comes, he'll smash you all"; and "Yes, I won!!!" as Bhairava says after beating up an Immortal from Mahabharata. No wonder parents who take their kids for a fun time will be subjected to gruelling, bad dialogue writing and dull--borderline--conflict-less screenplay.
Aside from the cringy histrionics and the occasionally bad CG, the core flaw of this movie comes from the character of Bhairava, the PROTAGONIST, who winds up to be the most dullest of the characters from Kalki. His motivation and drive to want to get to the Complex (fictional megastructure with resources, divided from the resource-less Earth) is not tangible enough, and I could not care any less for this character to get his wants and needs. Imagine not really caring for the PROTAGONIST. How crushingly boring!
When you don't care about the motives of the side you want to be on, you cannot care about anything that happens when your side comes into conflict with another side. It will look like two stick-figures without depth, fighting. Bland and uninteresting.
Deepika Padukone's character segment is interesting, but it's absolutely undone by how she literally has nothing much to actively do in the plot. And her character feels such a waste of potential.
The Rebels are borderline nonsensical, as they don't even come off as any decently conflicting forces against...Supreme Yaskin.
Now, coming to Supreme Yaskin, he basically is the big bad guy, who appears only in TWO scenes and exits off the narrative, for the second part of this Chinematic Yuniverse. He was one character that I genuinely thought had some substantial purpose and depth, and his actions in the Complex are a topic of intrigue, but guess WHAT! It's all for the sequels, baby!!!!!!
In the place of Yaskin as the main antagonistic force, we get the ridiculous Commander Manas for the dull first part.
Forget about this Dark-Lord-ish Commander Manas, who comes off like a two-dimensional caricature of a villain. His dubbing in Telugu was so unintentionally bad that I was laughing out multiple times. We don't know anything about his life, his psychological conflict, internal motives, nothing. He has no real purpose other than to just mouth badly dubbed dialogue, stand in front of a green and die a dog's death.
Can't really criticise the Immortals from Mahabharata because I didn't read the text, but I can say they just come and go whenever they want in this movie, just to serve the plot. World in danger? BOOM! There's a Kalki in Deepika!!! Deepika in danger? BOOM, immortal Ashwattama at rescue!!! Bhairava in danger? BOOM! He's also an immortal! Ashwatthama himself in danger, by the randomly casted Vijay Devarakonda as Arjun?! BOOM! Another immortal to the rescue!!!
That's how it is. Adding deus-ex-machinas from the Mahabharata, to save the narrative from Nag Ashwin and his team's failure to tell an exciting and necessary story, is a crushing Adharma in and of itself.
Technically speaking, the CG can be bad at times, like REALLY noticeably bad -- especially the de-aged Amitabh Bachchan as a 3D model Ashwatthama; but is good enough for the most part. One can clearly say, money has been put into the CG. And it looks 80 percent really good.
The soundtrack is passable, but the songs are bad, except Kalki's theme.
The cinematography is okay, but nothing special. The production design feels pretty hollow, just like Shamabala Rebels' thermocol weapons.
The actors do their jobs, but, except Amitabh Bachchan, none stand out.
So yeah, finally, the film is marred with shallow and incomplete characters, a dull and unexciting storyline, where the movie is all set up and zero pay-off. This is the film's biggest adharma, that I hope Kalki comes and eliminates it in the next part of this CINEMATIC UNIVERSE.
God, I'm done with these universes.