A Decently Entertaining Romp, If Not The Flagship Disney-Pixar Wants It To Be The Inside Out franchise is one that continues to vex me. On one hand, they are decently entertaining romps, to be sure. But on the other hand, I feel as if they don't quite (or even closely, sometimes) measure up to the Disney-Pixar magic of old.
For a very basic overview, Inside Out 2 picks up on the story of Riley (Kensington Tallman), now just entering puberty. As a result, Joy (Amy Poehler) and the emotions from the first installment begin being pushed aside by newcomers like Anxiety (Maya Hawke), Envy (Ayo Edebiri), Ennui (Adele Exarchopoulos), and Embarrassment (Paul Walter Hauser). This leads Riley to lose her Sense of Self, which the original emotional gang set out to retrieve from the depths of Riley's mind.
From a bare-bones story perspective, IO2 is pretty well put-together. It successfully links Riley's impending adolescence with new thoughts and feelings in a manner that feels authentic to real-world experiences. There are also some fun visuals and sight gags regarding the Emotions as they quest towards their goal--a "brain storm", a "stream of consciousness", and a "back of mind" waste dump. All of this is fairly entertaining in and of itself.
Yet, there are a few key ways in such this movie didn't grab me the way it potentially could/should have:
1. This franchise is now into "retread concept" territory in the sense that the use of animated characters representing emotions is no longer as novel of a concept as it was in 2015. Nothing to be done about this, obviously, but it makes this sequel seem less fresh.
2. There isn't enough Riley, oddly. IO2 really slants the needle towards the Emotions, to the point where I feel like the connection between what they are doing and how it is manifesting in Riley is sometimes tenuous.
3. When the (literal) giant red "Puberty" button flashes at the beginning of a movie, there are many directions it could go. I'm not saying that Pixar should (or would) do anything explicit, but having that concept turn into little more than a crisis of self-confidence for Riley feels like a big missed opportunity. Even in a non-sexual way, I feel as if many jokes or sight gags were lost in pursuit of this more serious plot line.
A telling moment, for me, towards the end of the film was an incredible monologue from Poehler's Joy. While spot-on and capable of giving you pause in your theater seat, it (sadly) is not altogether earned to that point in the movie. One could almost argue the entire experience needed to be built around this concept, rather than having it dropped seemingly out of nowhere.
Ironically, I also gave the original Inside Out a 6/10 score--if for completely different reasons. While I felt that film tilted too far in the "we need to have parents bawling" direction, this follow-up largely lacked the ability to even potentially persuade such high emotion. A really great balance of plot, emotion, humor, and gravitas has not yet been reached by either film.