talair2000

IMDb member since June 2004
    Lifetime Total
    5+
    IMDb Member
    20 years

Reviews

Les filles de Caleb
(1990)

Much more that a soap opera
I loved this series. Though I'm English speaking I have enough French to understand it. (I also later watched the English version with my parents but prefer it in french.)

This series is NOT superficial and unbelievable like soap operas are. My parents grew up in conditions much like this series portrayed, so we all found it very realistic. (My paternal grandmother gave birth to her last four children at home alone.) This series told it like it was for many families in this time period. Many diseases were not curable/controllable, and children died. Times were harsh, people were poor. We saw them as real people with all their flaws. This show spared no punches.

I also thought the entire casting was excellent. Because it was a series there was time to fully develop many characters and I cared about them all.

I have the first book in the series and have finally managed to obtain the series on DVD. I am looking forward to revisiting this excellent series.

Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End
(2007)

Not a movie for people with the attention span of a gnat.
I was very satisfied with this movie and although POTC: COTBP will always remain my favorite (for sheer fun) this one is a very close second and works for me on a different level than COTBP.

Just the scenes with Geoffrey Rush & Johnny Depp made this movie worth seeing as far as I'm concerned. The two of them play their characters so well off of each other. If any more Pirates sequels are made I'll be very disappointed if Barbossa isn't back.

Unlike with COTBP, I find the final battle scenes still interesting after repeated viewings and though there are a few areas in the movie that I would have shortened, for me this movie went by very fast.

However, it really bemuses me that people had such a difficult time with this movie. Is it because people today are spoon fed everything? Is it because they no longer can use their own imaginations to fill in the blanks? Is it because some people have the attention span of a gnat?

I had no trouble understanding the movie the first time I watched it and I enjoyed it very much (unlike DMC which for me was only enjoyable in the last 40 mins.) The subsequent viewings of AWE have allowed me to enjoy many details and underlying currents. I like the fact that it doesn't have a pat Disney ending. I like the fact that it makes one discuss and think of possibilities.

"At World's End" was never meant to be a movie like, say "Transformers," so I guess people going into it expecting mindless special effects with no need to pay attention to dialogue and visual clues will never like this movie. It's their loss.

The Count of Monte Cristo
(2002)

So Disappointing
Perhaps if you've never read the book it is possible to enjoy this movie, but it certainly has little in common with the real story from the novel other than the title and names of the characters.

The Count of Monte Cristo is one of my favorite reads. As a child I was first exposed to the story by the wonderful serial adaptation of the book on BBC Television. This movie version just doesn't convey the layers of the characters nor the emotion of the book at all. I kept hoping the movie would improve as it went along, but it didn't. Hollywood bastardizes another great novel.

So if you want something that is shallow and mindless this movie is for you, but if you want to enjoy a really good story, read the book instead.

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
(2005)

Excellent adaptation of the book!
Having never seen the 1971 movie Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory I could enjoy it for what it is, an excellent adaptation of R. Dahl's book (which I have read!). The movie is a visual feast for the eyes. There are also some sly nods to other films like Space 2001, Psycho and Burton's Ed Wood, Edward Scissorhands, etc. that made me grin. Like many of Burton's movies one needs to see it more than once to appreciate all the little details. It's twisted, askew and dark in some ways, (as the book is) yet delivers the message of what is and isn't truly important in life.

I also like that Elfman took Dahl's lyrics from the book and set them to music, I just wish it had been a little easier to make out what was being sung. Perhaps the problem was that the sound was too loud in the theater I saw it at.

I didn't see the Michael Jackson connection at all. In looks Willy reminded me far more of 60's pop stars than MJ. His voice also does recall those of children's' game show hosts from the 60's. Wonka is, to all intents and purposes, stuck in a time warp of his own making. Depp portrays Willy as a creative, brilliant inventor, who due to his upbringing and to living like a recluse for 15 years or so, is socially unskilled and awkward with adults and children alike. He doesn't like to touch or be touched and doesn't know how to relate to people or the world outside his factory. As usual Depp totally disappears in the role and becomes Mr. Wonka. Freddie Highmore again was excellent, and I've been a fan of David Kelly since the marvelous comedy "Waking Ned Devine." Deep Roy also was good. All in all CATCF is a very satisfying time at the movies. I rate it in the 8.5 to 9 range.

Finding Neverland
(2004)

A touching look at creative Inspiration and dealing with loss
First of all it's NOT A BIOGRAPHY, and doesn't pretend to be! It is about finding inspiration for creativity and how it can help deal with loss. I found it to be perfectly cast, and a beautifully crafted movie. Each actor makes his or her role believable.

Depp's accent was convincing, as was his character. He was able to convey perfectly what those who knew Barrie said, that he was asexual and enjoyed the company of children because he never truly grew up. I thought the relationship with his wife was very well done. So much was said without words. Barrie couldn't give her what she needed, and visa versa. They cared about each other but could not connect or sustain their relationship. All the children were superb, especially Freddie. I loved the scenes between Hoffman and Depp also, so droll. I'd like to see them work together again.

I'll be seeing it again as I was so involved in the dialogue and expressions that I really didn't have time to absorb all the detail that went into this movie. It's definitely worth a visit to Finding Neverland. HOWEVER, if you have the attention span of a gnat, hate period drama or want lots of action you'll likely miss the entire point of this movie. It's also not for young children.

See all reviews