Now THIS is Art Some time ago I reviewed a film directed by Lars Von Trier called Antichrist (2009) and I laughed at it for its pretentious and inappropriate use of symbolism, sex, black-and-white scenes, and slow motion to utterly confuse the audience in a blitzkrieg-style assault (what he and some other European critics may call "art").
Here we have one of the few movies that actually does confusing modernist art right, but not in tawdry ways like less competent directors do.
It has, without a doubt, the most masterful use of subtlety I have ever seen. You often can't tell what's going on, but two characters looking at each other (or not looking at each other), in a tense way or at a critical moment just gives an impression that something important is boiling just under the surface and exploding behind the scenes.
The world these people inhabit would have been considered absurd and confusing just a few decades prior by the majority of the population in USA today and perhaps isn't even palatable to the majority today. Yet it's consistent and believable. And the way it accomplishes this environment is through sex, but unlike the pretentious and unskilled, it doesn't need to show stills of O faces or slow-motion genitals to do it. And again, delightfully indirect, without ever stating it directly. These people believe in free love, they eschew rules and order. They do what they want and who they want whenever they want. Sure, there are some hard feelings here and there, but freedom and love are paramount.
And it's not just the sex. When a friend needs help he has no problem asking for as much as he need and no one thinks to deny it him. The members of the group come and go as they please. Emotions are let fly loose. When a man strikes his wife, members of the tribe are upset, but all that happens is that he's told to cool it whereas this would be such a traumatic or dramatic scene in any other movie. But the subtext is that they're his emotions and he's entitled to them.
Arlo Guthrie gives one of the greatest acting performances I've seen as himself. He has the upper layer of that cool apathy of the confident artist that permeates the whole tone of the movie (and mirrors the tone of the song on which it's based), while still showing subtle sincere emotion throughout the film, as aptly in times of joy as those of sorrow.
Good work from Officer Obie, too, who also played himself and does the stereotypical gruff policeman to perfection. He's somehow a sympathetic character despite the film very clearly divulging that police are extremely unsympathetic to this long-haired communalistic subculture.
The film has some boring points and unnecessary digressions. Few of the characters are well-developed, but for the most part that works because they're just presented as typical humans with urges, desires, jealousies, stresses, ups and downs.
Unexpectedly sad, but not a surprising ending. I thought they had it all. Is it just that sadness is just a fact of life no matter what? Or was it that there was something missing in their lives?
Honourable Mentions: Simpsons Season 11, Episode 11: Faith Off (2000). Bart is a faith healer and the sailor character comes to him for help with his "crippling depression", which Bart says he can't cure. As he's walking away, Bart wonders aloud "And I thought he had it all." I got the same feeling as this film came to a close. They look like and usually act like they don't have a care in the world, but it's almost as if they've traded something valuable for freedom and community.