Who Attacked Cindy?: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Further copy edit.
 
(18 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{Short description|Storyline from the BBC soap opera EastEnders}}
{{long plot|date=December 2024}}
{{original research|date=December 2024}}
<!-- Please do not remove or change this AfD message until the discussion has been closed. -->
{{Article for deletion/dated|page=Who Attacked Cindy?|timestamp=20250101214808|year=2025|month=January|day=1|substed=yes}}
<!-- Once discussion is closed, please place on talk page: {{Old AfD multi|page=Who Attacked Cindy?|date=1 January 2025|result='''keep'''}} -->
<!-- End of AfD message, feel free to edit beyond this point -->
 
'''"Who Attacked Cindy?"''' is a storyline from the [[BBC]] [[soap opera]] ''[[EastEnders]]''. The storyline began on 25 December 2024, [[Christmas|Christmas Day]], when the character [[Cindy Beale]], played by [[Michelle Collins]], was attacked by an unknown assailant in the middle of [[Albert Square]]. After Cindy was disowned by her entire family afterfollowing her affair with [[Junior Knight]] ([[Micah Balfour]]), which was revealed in [[Episode 7037/7038|that episode]], many characters were implicated in the attack, resulting in a [[whodunnit]] mystery being cultivated. The storyline will tie into the show's [[EastEnders Live (2025 episode)|40th anniversary]], with the culprit set to be revealed on the week of the celebrations, similar to how the [[Who Killed Archie|"Who Killed Archie"]] and [[Who Killed Lucy Beale?|"Who Killed Lucy Beale"]] storylines were used to mark the show's [[EastEnders Live (2010 episode)|25th]] and [[EastEnders Live Week|30th]] anniversaries, respectively.
 
Currently, the main suspects for the attack are Cindy's fiancé, [[Ian Beale]] ([[Adam Woodyatt]]); her ex-husband [[George Knight (EastEnders)|George Knight]] ([[Colin Salmon]]); George's wife, [[Elaine Peacock]] ([[Harriet Thorpe]]); her son [[Peter Beale]] ([[Thomas Law]]); Peter's ex-girlfriend [[Lauren Branning]] ([[Jacqueline Jossa]]); George's son and Cindy's lover, [[Junior Knight]] ([[Micah Balfour]]); Ian's mother, [[Kathy Cotton]]; and Cindy and George's daughters, [[Gina Knight|Gina]] ([[Francesca Henry]]) and [[Anna Knight]] ([[Molly Rainford]]).
 
==Storyline creation and development==
In 2023, [[executive producer]] [[Chris Clenshaw]] decided to reintroduce the character of [[Cindy Beale]], played by [[Michelle Collins]], thus resurrecting the character from the dead.<ref>{{cite news |last1=Glynn |first1=Paul |title=EastEnders: Michelle Collins returns as Cindy Beale after 25 years |url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-65986136 |access-date=2025-01-01 |work=Culture |publisher=BBC News |date=22 June 2023}}</ref> ProducersThe mademain Cindy pivotalbuild-up to several of the show'sstoryline mostresulted importantfrom storylines,her includingfeelings thefor returnher ofex-husband [[DeanGeorge WicksKnight (EastEnders)|George Knight]] ([[MattColin DiSalmon]]) Angelodespite her relationship with [[Ian Beale]] ([[Adam Woodyatt]]). The two kissed in April 2024,<ref>{{cite webnews |last1=Carenno |first1=Laura |title=BBC EastEnders' Deanviewers Wicksfuming isas backexplosive innew Walfordaffair is 'sealed' and inbeg businessbosses withto thetake Bealesaction |url=https://www.bbcmirror.comco.uk/mediacentretv/2023tv-news/bbc-eastenders-deanviewers-wicksfuming-backexplosive-in32602458 |access-businessdate=2025-with01-the-beales01 |websitework=bbc.co.ukTV |publisher=BBCReach Media Centreplc |access-date=20252024-0104-0116}}</ref>; supportingbut George throughultimately thechose trialnot ofto hisresume fathertheir [[Eddie Knight]] ([[Christopher Fairbank]]), resulting in them sharing a kissrelationship.<ref>{{cite web |last1=DalyDenby |first1=HelenLaura |title=EastEnders' ColinJunior Salmonspies teaseselectric George and Cindy importanceencounter afterin devastatingearly EddieBBC trialiPlayer release |url=https://www.radiotimes.com/tv/soaps/eastenders/eastenders-colinjunior-salmongeorge-cindy-eddie-trialencounter-newsupdate/ |website=radiotimes.com |publisher=Immediate Media Company |access-date=20242025-1201-3001}}</ref>;. After this, she began an affair with George's son [[Junior Knight]] ([[Micah Balfour]]) after George rejects her<ref>{{cite web |last1=KnightDenby |first1=LewisLaura |title=EastEnders airs messyJunior move forand Cindy Beale amid familyaffair dramatwist in early BBC iPlayer release |url=https://www.radiotimes.com/tv/soaps/eastenders/eastenders-cindy-beale-junior-knightcindy-affairgeorge-startsaffair-iplayertwist-newsupdate/ |website=radiotimes.com |publisher=Immediate Media Company |access-date=20242025-1201-3001}}</ref>; reunitingand withwas challenged in her efforts to conceal it, including convincing her former flamelover [[David Wicks]] ([[Michael French]]) when [[Episode 6994|he returns]] not to [[Walford]];expose her,<ref name="David Wicks">{{cite web |last1=SarrubbaDenby |first1=StefaniaLaura |title=EastEnders starairs teasesepic "intense"cameo Cindy andin David reunionWicks scenesstory in early iPlayer release |url=https://www.digitalspyradiotimes.com/tv/soaps/eastenders/a62500983/eastenders-cindyepic-cameo-david-reunionjoe-sceneswicks-newsupdate/ |website=digitalspyradiotimes.com |publisher=HearstImmediate MagazinesMedia UKCompany |access-date=20242025-1201-3001}}</ref> and fuellingbribing [[Lauren Branning]]'s ([[Jacqueline Jossa]]) drugwith addictiondrugs whenand shemanipulating risksGeorge's findingautistic outbrother about[[Kojo herAsare]] affair(Dayo Koleosho) when both risk exposing her.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Denby |first1=Laura |title=EastEnders airs dangerous Cindy Beale decision in early iPlayer release |url=https://www.radiotimes.com/tv/soaps/eastenders/eastenders-dangerous-cindy-lauren-decision-newsupdate/ |website=radiotimes.com |publisher=Immediate Media Company |access-date=2025-01-01}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |last1=Stedman |first1=Emily |title=EastEnders reveals Kojo outcome after Cindy threat |url=https://www.digitalspy.com/soaps/eastenders/a63082966/eastenders-kojo-outcome-cindy-threat/ |website=digitalspy.com |publisher=Hearst Magazines UK |access-date=2025-01-01}}</ref>
 
On 9 September 2024, prior tobefore the storyline's announcement, the [[BBC]] announced that the show would broadcast a [[live television|live episode]] of the soap to mark the show's [[EastEnders Live (2025 episode)|40th anniversary]].<ref name="Anniversary">{{cite web|url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/2024/eastenders-40th-anniversary-live-episode-twist/ |title=EastEnders set to go live once more with a first-of-its-kind twist for its 40th anniversary |first= |last= |date=9 September 2024 |access-date=15 September 2024 |website=BBC Media Centre |language=English |url-status=live |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20240910082226/https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/2024/eastenders-40th-anniversary-live-episode-twist/ |archive-date=10 September 2024 }}</ref> Producers decided to incorporate Cindy into the show's 40th anniversaryThe storyline whenwas itofficially becameannounced clearon how26 pivotalDecember the character had become2024, with Clenshaw stating: "Our 40th anniversary storylines have been in the works for some time, but even at the very start of planning, we knew that we wanted to reveal the identity of Cindy’s attacker as part of this."<ref name="Storyline announced">{{cite web |title=EastEnders Cindy's Christmas Day attacker to be revealed as part of 40th anniversary |url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/2024/eastenders-cindy-christmas-day-attacker-to-be-revealed-40th-anniversary |website=bbc.co.uk |publisher=BBC Media Centre |access-date=2025-01-01}}</ref> Consequently, the revelation of Cindy and Junior's affair served as the show's Christmas 2024 storyline,<ref>{{cite web |last1=Hutchinson |first1=Emily |title=EastEnders drops dramatic new Christmas trailer teasing Cindy's affair reveal |url=https://www.digitalspy.com/soaps/eastenders/a63161506/eastenders-christmas-trailer-cindy-affair-reveal/ |website=digitalspy.com |publisher=Hearst Magazines UK |access-date=2025-01-01}}</ref> with [[Episode 6994|a recording of Cindy confessing the affair]] to her former lover David being played to all of her family and neighbours on Christmas Day. Cindy is then disowned by her entire family before being [[attempted murder|viciously attacked]] and left for dead at the end of that day's double-episode, with Clenshaw officially confirming the storyline as part of the 40th anniversary celebrations the next day.<ref name="Storyline announced" /> With most of her family having motives for wanting Cindy dead, Clenshaw noted: "Many characters currently find themselves in the line of question, but over the coming weeks, the audience can look out for clues themselves to who may be the culprit."<ref name="Storyline announced" />
 
==Plot==
===Events leading up to the attack===
Depressed, Cindyafter endsbeing uprejected havingby her ex-husband [[one-nightGeorge standKnight (EastEnders)|sexGeorge Knight]] with([[Colin George'sSalmon]]) sonfor his fiancée [[JuniorElaine KnightPeacock]] ([[MicahHarriet BalfourThorpe]])., Though[[Cindy theBeale]] twobegins concealan theaffair encounter,with JuniorGeorge's wifeson [[MoniqueJunior Knight|MoniqueJunior]] (Busayo Ige) ends up leaving Junior, anyway,despite owingher to his one-night standrelationship with [[BiancaIan JacksonBeale]] ([[PatsyAdam PalmerWoodyatt]]); as a result, Junior continues to flirt with Cindy. This culminates in Cindy returning to Junior to have an affair with him a few months after their initial encounter, with Junior eventually developing romantic feelings for Cindy. The twoThey have sex in a locked office in Peggy's Nightclub during a crush. As they had blocked one of the escape routes, Cindy's son [[Peter Beale|Peter]]'s girlfriend [[Lauren Branning]] ([[Jacqueline Jossa]]) is seriously injured. Lauren goes on to develop an addiction to prescription painkillers; she is forced to obtain them by other means when doctors discover she is pregnant.
After returning to [[Walford]] in 2023, [[Cindy Beale]] ([[Michelle Collins]]) redevelops feelings for her ex-husband [[George Knight (EastEnders)|George Knight]] ([[Colin Salmon]]) despite her relationship with [[Ian Beale]] ([[Adam Woodyatt]]). When George falls into a depression after his adoptive father [[Eddie Knight]] ([[Christopher Fairbank]]) is convicted of murdering his biological father Henry Kofi Asare, and his adoptive mother [[Gloria Knight]] ([[Elizabeth Counsell]]) dies shortly afterwards, Cindy becomes an emotional support for George, culminating in them kissing on the tenth anniversary of Lucy's death. Cindy helps the Knights rescue George from an illegal fight club, during which George's fiancée [[Elaine Peacock]] ([[Harriet Thorpe]]) discovers the kiss; she goes on to expose this to Ian. Ian is heartbroken but accepts Cindy's apology, much to his mother [[Kathy Cotton|Kathy]]'s disgust. Despite this, Cindy attempts to convince George to resume their relationship; George rejects her and reconciles with Elaine.
 
Throughout late 2024, Cindy and Junior risk being exposed several times: first by Cindy's former lover [[David Wicks]] ([[Michael French]]), to whom she emotionally [[Episode 6994|confesses to]] (unaware she has been accidentally recorded by [[Freddie Slater]] ([[Bobby Brazier]])) and convinces to maintain the secret; by George's brother [[autism|autistic]] brother [[Kojo Asare]] (Dayo Koleosho), whom she later accidentally [[coma|comatoses]] and later manipulates into silence; and Lauren, who discovers Cindy near the site of Kojo's accident, and whom she bribes into silence by supplying her with drugs.
Depressed, Cindy ends up having [[one-night stand|sex]] with George's son [[Junior Knight]] ([[Micah Balfour]]). Though the two conceal the encounter, Junior's wife [[Monique Knight|Monique]] (Busayo Ige) ends up leaving Junior, anyway, owing to his one-night stand with [[Bianca Jackson]] ([[Patsy Palmer]]); as a result, Junior continues to flirt with Cindy. This culminates in Cindy returning to Junior to have an affair with him a few months after their initial encounter, with Junior eventually developing romantic feelings for Cindy. The two have sex in a locked office in Peggy's Nightclub during a crush. As they had blocked one of the escape routes, Cindy's son [[Peter Beale]]'s girlfriend [[Lauren Branning]] ([[Jacqueline Jossa]]) is seriously injured. Lauren goes on to develop an addiction to prescription painkillers; she is forced to obtain them by other means when doctors discover she is pregnant.
 
In December, Cindy discovers Lauren's pregnancy and attempts to end her and Lauren's arrangement, but decides against it when Lauren threatens to investigate Kojo's accident That night, Lauren becomes [[substance intoxication|intoxicated]] and accidentally sets fire to her house. While she survives, the Beales soon discover her addiction and disown her, refusing to believe that Cindy was supplying the drugs. Shortly afterwards, Elaine discovers the recording of Cindy and David and uses it to blackmail Cindy into leaving Walford. Cindy convinces Ian to move to [[France]] but the tape soon goes missing.
In October 2024, Ian's half-brother [[David Wicks]] ([[Michael French]]), with whom Cindy had an affair in the 1990s, returns to Walford. Ian is irritated by David's presence, prompting him to propose to Cindy in the Queen Vic; Cindy accepts. David disapproves, knowing that Cindy doesn't truly love Ian, but is ignored by Cindy. As he goes to leave during Ian and Cindy's engagement party, he catches Cindy and Junior kissing and realises the affair. [[Episode 6994|Cindy emotionally confesses to David]] about the affair, during which she states that she only has sex with Junior as it reminds her of George, with whom she is truly in love. David decides not to tell Ian and leaves Walford; however, the two are unaware that they have been accidentally recorded by [[Freddie Slater]] ([[Bobby Brazier]]), who was testing his recording equipment. Initially, Freddie never discovers the affair. In the aftermath, Cindy tries to push Junior away; subsequently, Junior confesses to Peter that he was responsible for causing Lauren's injuries by blocking the escape route as part of a mind game against Cindy. Meanwhile, Kathy, struggling with the incarceration of her husband [[Rocky Cotton|Rocky]] ([[Brian Conley]]) and her role in the [[The Six (EastEnders)|murder of]] [[Keanu Taylor]] ([[Danny Walters (actor)|Danny Walters]]), gets closer to [[Harvey Monroe]] ([[Ross Boatman]]), culminating in them sharing a kiss, despite Harvey's relationship with [[Jean Slater]] ([[Gillian Wright]]).
 
[[Episode 7037/7038|On Christmas Day]], Lauren reveals she has stolen the recording to Cindy and joins the Beales and the Knights for Christmas dinner. The recording is soon played before the whole Queen Vic, thus exposing Cindy for her bribery of Lauren and manipulation of Kojo. She is disowned by her family and Ian ends their relationship; meanwhile, Elaine kicks George out of the Queen Vic when he accidentally calls Cindy his wife. Alone in Albert Square, Cindy calls for a taxi before being violently struck down by an [[whodunnit|unseen figure]] with a [[snow shovel]] and left for dead.
In November, Elaine becomes paranoid that George doesn't truly love her; she decides to get Cindy to try to seduce George to prove his loyalty. When George rejects Cindy, she reveals Elaine's deception, resulting in George ending their relationship the day before their wedding. However, the two reunite the next day and get married, upsetting Cindy. That night, she kisses Junior outside her house, resuming their affair; however, they are spotted by George's [[autism|autistic]] brother [[Kojo Asare]] (Dayo Koleosho). Cindy pursues Kojo and attempts to pacify him; during the confrontation, Kojo falls from the stairs and is severely injured. Lauren soon arrives and discovers a panicked Cindy next to an unconscious Kojo; Lauren agrees to give a false statement to the police so as not to implicate Cindy in Kojo's accident, but threatens to uncover the truth. Cindy decides to bribe Lauren by obtaining the drugs for her instead. When Kojo emerges from his [[coma]], Cindy lies to him that he will be sent back to [[Ghana]] if he tells the truth about what he saw; Junior is disgusted by Cindy exploiting Kojo and tells him he can reveal the affair if he feels it is right. Regardless, Kojo keeps what he saw a secret.
 
In December, Lauren attempts to stop taking the drugs but [[drug withdrawal|collapses]] shortly afterwards. She is taken to the hospital, where she is told that giving up the drugs may also harm her baby. Cindy soon discovers Lauren is pregnant and demands that Lauren tell Peter; Lauren explains that stopping could harm the baby and Cindy agrees to give her one last dosage. That night, Lauren becomes [[substance intoxication|intoxicated]] and accidentally sets fire to her house. While she survives, the Beales soon discover her addiction. Lauren attempts to explain that it was Cindy supplying her but fails to convince the Beales of the truth when Kojo refuses to verify that Cindy was responsible for his accident. Shortly afterwards, Elaine overhears the tape of Cindy and David as Freddie leaves the tape playing; she copies it onto a [[USB flash drive|USB stick]] and demands that Cindy leave Walford in exchange for the recording being destroyed. Cindy agrees and convinces Ian to move to [[France]] in the New Year; George confesses his disappointment at Cindy's departure to Junior and decides to invite the Beales to spend [[Christmas|Christmas Day]] with the Knights at the Queen Vic. As Elaine goes to retrieve the recording to give to Cindy, she is horrified to discover it is missing; unbeknownst to her, an unseen intruder has stolen it and hidden it in the Knight's [[Secret Santa]] box.
 
On Christmas Day, Lauren convinces Kathy to persuade Peter to allow her to join the Beales at the Queen Vic for dinner; there, Lauren reveals that she has stolen the recording, having overheard Cindy and Elaine discussing it. The recording is soon played before the whole Queen Vic. Enraged, Ian punches Junior and ends his relationship with Cindy; meanwhile, Elaine, believing that George is upset about the affair because he has still has feelings for Cindy, kicks George out of the Vic. George disowns Junior and Peter ends his relationship with Lauren. Cindy furiously disowns her entire family and returns home to try to convince Ian to give her another chance; unconvinced, Ian kicks Cindy out. Having lost her entire family, Cindy arranges for a taxi to collect her from [[Albert Square]]. As she is about to leave, her daughter [[Anna Knight]] ([[Molly Rainford]]) tearfully watches Cindy from the Queen Vic Window; [[Gina Knight]] ([[Francesca Henry]]) sneaks out of the Vic; Peter drinks alone; Lauren begins taking the pills again; Ian becomes upset and storms out of the house in front of a stunned Kathy; Elaine mourns the end of her marriage; Junior furiously attempts to contact Cindy; and George becomes upset at the boxing gym. As Cindy stands alone in the middle of the Square, an unseen figure picks up a snow shovel and [[attempted murder|smashes it against Cindy's head]]; she collapses, lying face-down in the snow.
 
===Aftermath of the attack===
Some time afterward, Cindy's unconscious body, now facing up, is found by a stunned KathyGeorge and George. Elaine discovers Anna washing herIan's handsmother, claiming [[TysonKathy Cotton]]. threw up on her, and Gina returning home from a "walk"; everybodyCindy is stunnedthen upon learning of the attack. George, Elaine, Kathy, Peter, Lauren, Gina and Anna accompany Cindytaken to the hospital, where she isand placed intoin an [[induced coma]]. Ian arrives shortly afterwards, having been missing during the time of Cindy's attack. [[Denise Fox]] ([[Diane Parish]]) spots Junior hiding behind the café after Cindy is discovered and informs George; George goes to Junior's flat to confront him, where he discovers Junior packing to return to [[Dubai]] to see Monique and his son [[Xavier Knight|Xavier]] (Dean Chase-Williams); George demands that Junior stay in Walford to avoid being implicated in the attack. Upon returning to the Queen Vic, George manipulates Kojo into giving him a [[false alibi]] for the attack and pulls out a blood-stained shirt. Meanwhile, [[DCI Peter Arthurs]] ([[Ian Burfield]]) arrives at the hospital to interview the others, where heKathy informsrealises KathyIan that,will soon become a basedprime onsuspect due to the injurieshumiliation Cindyhe has sustained,just thefaced attackerand his lack of an alibi (orhaving evenstormed aout secondof person)the mayhouse haveangrily turnedshortly Cindybefore over.the others).
 
Kathy becomes one of the leading suspects in the attack owing to her rivalry with Cindy and lack of an [[alibi]]. When Arthurs interviews her in the Bridge Street Café, her friend [[Harvey Monroe]] lies to Arthurs by [[false alibi|claiming Kathy was with him]] when the attack took place; Jean's former [[son-in-law]] [[Martin Fowler (EastEnders)|Martin Fowler]] ([[James Bye]]) overhears this and accuses the two of having an affair. Despite the two explaining that they lied to the police, they both confess to theirhaving kisskissed several months prior. Martin resolves to tell Jean the truth; however, whendespite heHarvey's realisesrelationship howwith [[DepressionJean (mood)|depressedSlater]] Jean already is owing to being ([[internetGillian fraud|conned out of her live savingsWright]],); heMartin decidesresolves to keep Kathy and Harvey'stheir secret, butin warnsexchange herfor toKathy keepmaintaining her distance from Harvey in order to avoid an affair. When Arthurs arrives in the Queen Vic on New Year's Eve, Kathy attempts to convince him that Junior was responsible for the attack to remove suspicion from Ian, due to Cindy humiliating him in the audio tape, – having said she slept with him only to remind herself of George – but Arthurs points out that Ian was also humiliated in the audio tape, thus not disproving Ian's potential motive.
 
==Suspects and motives== <!-- DO ''not'' REMOVE ANYONE FROM THIS LIST, AT ONE POINT EVERYONE WAS A SUSPECT SO SHOULD STILL BE LISTED -->
*'''[[Ian Beale]]''', played by [[Adam Woodyatt]].
*'''[[Peter Beale]]''', played by [[Thomas Law]].
*'''[[Lauren Branning]]''', played by [[Jacqueline Jossa]].
 
==Reception==
The double-episode where the storyline began, which aired on 25 December 2024, achieved 4.4 million viewers, becoming the fifth most-watched show on Christmas Day and facilitating [[BBC One]] occupying the top ten most-viewed shows at Christmas for the first time ever. The episode also saw an increase of 800,000 viewers from the show's previous Christmas episode in 2023.<ref>{{cite news |last1=Gecsoyler |first1=Sammy |title=Gavin and Stacey finale tops Christmas television ratings |url=https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2024/dec/26/gavin-and-stacey-finale-tops-christmas-television-ratings#:~:text=EastEnders%20came%20a%20close%20fifth,overnight%20figures%20for%2025%20December. |access-date=2024-12-30 |work=Culture |publisher=Guardian Media Group |date=2024-12-26}}</ref>
 
The attack on Cindy [[cliffhanger|at the episode's conclusion]] was praised by Erin Zammitt of [[Digital Spy]], who praised Cindy's attack as "an exciting climax" to her long running affair storyline with Junior, while also noting that the mystery of her attacker would provide "some momentum and direction as it enters its [[EastEnders Live (2025 episode)|milestone year]]".<ref name="HOMAGES 1">{{cite web |last1=Zammitt |first1=Erin |title=Why EastEnders’ Christmas Cindy twist simply had to happen |url=https://www.digitalspy.com/soaps/eastenders/a63273820/eastenders-spoilers-christmas-cindy-beale-twist-review/ |website=digitalspy.com |publisher=Hearst Magazines UK |access-date=2024-12-31}}</ref> Charlotte Tutton of the ''[[Daily Mirror]]'' referenced the "deadly twist" of the attack and described the storyline as an "explosive [[whodunnit]]."<ref name="Homage of Lauren">{{cite news |last1=Tutton |first1=Charlotte |title=Cindy Beale left for dead in EastEnders Christmas Day shock as explosive whodunnit revealed |url=https://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/cindy-beale-dead-eastenders-christmas-34371906 |access-date=2025-01-01 |work=TV |publisher=Reach plc |date=2024-12-25}}</ref> However, Eilis O'Hanlon of the ''[[Irish Independent]]'' reacted negatively to the constant darkness of the show.<ref>{{cite news |last1=O'Hanlon |first1=Eilis |title=Television reviews: EastEnders needs more ‘ho, ho, ho’ and less ‘woe, woe, woe’ |url=https://www.independent.ie/entertainment/television/television-reviews-eastenders-needs-more-ho-ho-ho-and-less-woe-woe-woe/a1109088648.html |access-date=2024-12-30 |work=Entertainment |publisher=Mediahuis Ireland |date=2024-12-19}}</ref> Critics noticed the many [[homage (arts)|homages]] to the show's history in the episode, such as Ian's breakdown being similar to that of [[Arthur Fowler]] ([[Bill Treacher]]) in 1986, and Lauren being the one to expose the affair, as she did in 2007.<ref name="HOMAGES 1">{{cite web |last1=Zammitt |first1=Erin |title=Why EastEnders’ Christmas Cindy twist simply had to happen |url=https://www.digitalspy.com/soaps/eastenders/a63273820/eastenders-spoilers-christmas-cindy-beale-twist-review/ |website=digitalspy.com |publisher=Hearst Magazines UK |access-date=2024-12-31}}</ref><ref name="Homage of Lauren />
 
==References==