Wikipedia:Village pump (policy): Difference between revisions

Hello. There was a discussion which went on for months, and it was sort of properly advertised. But that discussion was not an actual/formal RfC ([[Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Indian politics#Proposal : Wikipedia:Naming conventions Indian constituencies]]). This discussion was later disputed at [[Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (Indian constituencies)#Proposal state]], and again at [[Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)/Archive 173#Proposal for new article title naming convention - RfC or local consensus]]. In these discussions, at least four editors expressed their view as the proposal was put forward improperly, and a fresh RfC was advised. Yet the proposer ([[User:Venkat TL]]) continued to advertise the discussion up until four days ago ([[special:diff/1094440659]]). Later that discussion was improperly closed by [[User:Mellohi!]] as a "consensus" while there are still differing opinions about the bracketing, and capitalisation. Detailed information of proposal, and related discussions can be found at [[special:permalink/1095055925#Venkat TL mass page moves]]. I propose for a fresh AfD, and the current policy to be invalidated. I will shortly notify the talkpages. Regards, —usernamekiran [[User talk:usernamekiran|(talk)]] 06:48, 26 June 2022 (UTC)

*If you think the close was improper, at least talk with the closer ''before'' [[WP:DTS|continuing to flog it]] in high-visibility forums. Otherwise your argument of "sticking to the process" comes off as self-serving. I also think close reviews should go to [[WP:AN]], but you might of course know better. <span id="Hemantha:1656228665197:WikipediaBWLCLNVillage_pump_(policy)" class="BawlCmt">[[User:Hemantha|Hemantha]] ([[User talk:Hemantha|talk]]) 07:31, 26 June 2022 (UTC)</span>