|Viewers = 9.65<ref>{{cite pressrelease|url=http://abcmedianet.com/web/dnr/dispDNR.aspx?id=040808_06 |title=WEEKLY PROGRAM RANKINGS (WK OF 3/31) |publisher=ABC Medianet |date=2008-04-08 |accessdate=2010-10-13}}</ref>
|OriginalAirDate = {{Start date|2008|3|31}}
|ShortSummary = Cynthia and Allison investigate whether the recent kidnapping of a local girl named Melanie and Cynthia's daughter Suzie in 1998 are related. Joanna Wheeler is determined to be the common denominator in both cases when Allison realizes her previous dreams about Joanna being kept in the fall-out shelter with Suzie were correct. Allison continues to have dreams about Joanna, which reveal she is a psychopath who masterminded Suzie's kidnapping in 1998 and forced her then-boyfriend Peter Campbell to take part, and that Joanna killed her most recent boyfriend and let Melanie escape after realizing Cynthia and Allison were on her trail. Allison also has a dream in which Cynthia and Suzie are reunited before Suzie walks into a scenic lake and doesn't resurface. Cynthia and Allison track down Peter Campbell, and while he denies involvement in Suzie's kidnapping, his resolve is visibly cracking. While driving back to Phoenix, Allison sees the lake from her most recent dream and tells Cynthia about her dream; Suzie's skeleton is subsequently recovered from the bottom of the lake. Peter Campbell is soon found dead and with no physical evidence to connect Joanna to Suzie's murder, Cynthia takes matters into her own hands and kills Joanna herself. When Allison realizes what happened, Cynthia says that since she failed to stand up for Suzie in life, she killed Joanna in an attempt to make amends and has made peace with the fact that she will go to prison. Meanwhile, after helping Bridgette with her science project, Joe gets a prediction from his middle daughter about his future finances.
