Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Halo: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Scope: clarify |
→Scope: thoughts on Red vs. Blue |
||
Line 454:
:::::Nope, no lazy people here! :) Judt gotta clean them to our standard. [[User:Judgesurreal777|Judgesurreal777]] ([[User talk:Judgesurreal777|talk]]) 13:27, 24 March 2013 (UTC)
::::::IF we do take on these articles, Slipstream will need a page one rewrite, the red vs blue character list should be changed to an article, and all the rest of the Red vs. Blue articles (except the main one) should be merged to one [[List of Red vs. Blue media]] article, because they all have basically no notability as individual seasons. [[User:Judgesurreal777|Judgesurreal777]] ([[User talk:Judgesurreal777|talk]]) 23:36, 25 March 2013 (UTC)
{{OD}} I think a [[List of Red vs. Blue media]] article (treating each season as an individual media item) is an excellent idea. It'll keep the plot stuff in check by de-emphasizing the repetition of plot across different articles: the big problem with maintaining ''Red vs. Blue'' is that Rooster Teeth guys just keep churning out stuff, and it's real mess to keep an article for each season. I think the thought back in 2005-06 was that the first few seasons were getting a few reviews comparing/contrasting the individual seasons among each other, so it might have been tenable to keep separate articles, but I think the trend for the past few years (especially in serious academic treatment of machinima) is to treat ''Red vs. Blue'' as a single body of work, so we should probably do the same. It's somewhat a unique situation in that it's essentially a long-running episodic work grouped into "seasons" that end up released on DVDs pretty much as a standard full-length movie, and then supplemented by miniseries. I don't think anyone had ever really considered a single media list/article, but it's probably the best way to handle this situation and keep it in check going forward. —[[User:TKD|TKD]] '''[[User talk:TKD|<span style="color:#030;">[talk]</span>]]'''[[Special:Contributions/TKD|<span style="color:#000;">[c]</span>]] 20:45, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
| |||