Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Music: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
El Sandifer (talk | contribs) |
→Guidelines for the way music genres are listed: new section |
||
Line 139:
I just noticed that the "list of songs in key X" sections were removed from the key articles for sourcing problems. I am skeptical of this - the obvious and implied source here would be the original recording. This seems a valid use of a primary source. I suppose you could argue that it's "specialist knowledge," but I'm skeptical of that - it seems much more akin to using a source in a foreign language. In which case listening to the recordings themselves should be a perfectly valid way to create these sections. Unless anyone has a more persuasive reason, I am going to re-add these sections. [[User:Phil Sandifer|Phil Sandifer]] ([[User talk:Phil Sandifer|talk]]) 04:44, 7 July 2008 (UTC)
== Guidelines for the way music genres are listed ==
We need some guidelines whether we break genres up with commas, or line breaks. This discussion has been going on in WP:METAL and we need some way of resolving this. [[User:Metalhead of the East|MOTE]] [[User talk:Metalhead of the East|Speak to me]] 13:01, 8 July 2008 (UTC)
| |||