Wikipedia

Talk:Mary L. Trump: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
SineBot (talk | contribs)
Bots
2,554,756 edits
m Signing comment by 78.144.72.204 - ""
→Grammar fix?: new section
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit New topic
(30 intermediate revisions by 25 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{talk headerTalkheader}}
{{User:MiszaBot/config
{{WikiProject banner shell |living=yes |1=
| algo = old(365d)
{{WikiProject Biography|class=C|living=yes|listas=Trump, Mary L.|s&a-work-group=yes|s&a-priority=low|needs-photo=yes|needs-infobox=y}}
| archive = Talk:Mary L. Trump/Archive %(counter)d
{{WikiProject Psychology |class=C |importance=Low}}
| counter = 1
{{WikiProject Business |class=C |importance=Low}}
| maxarchivesize = 150K
{{WikiProject Women writers |class=C |importance=Low}}
| archiveheader = {{Automatic archive navigator}}
{{WikiProject Politics |class=C |importance=Low |American=y}}
| minthreadstoarchive = 1
{{WikiProject Donald Trump |class=C |importance=Mid}}
| minthreadsleft = 1
{{WikiProject LGBT studies |class=C |person=y}}
{{WikiProject New York (state) |class=C |importance=Low |Columbia=y}}
}}
{{WikiProject banner shell|collapsed=yes|class=C|listas=Trump, Mary L.|1=
{{WIR-150}}
{{WikiProject Biography|s&a-work-group=yes|s&a-priority=Low}}
{{WikiProject Psychology|importance=Low}}
{{WikiProject Business|importance=Low}}
{{WikiProject Women writers|importance=Low}}
{{WikiProject Politics |importance=Low|American=y|American-importance=Low}}
{{WikiProject United States|USPresidents=yes|importance=Mid|USPresidents-importance=Mid}}
{{WikiProject LGBT studies|person=y}}
{{WikiProject New York (state)|importance=Low|Columbia=y|Columbia-importance=Low}}
{{WikiProject Women scientists|importance=Low}}
{{WikiProject Women in Red|150}}
| blp=yes
}}
{{Contentious topics/talk notice|blp}}{{Contentious topics/talk notice|ap|long}}
{{Annual readership}}
{{photo requested}}
 
== explanation ==
 
I reverted [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Mary_L._Trump&type=revision&diff=963798097&oldid=963699147 these edits]. I think Mary L. Trump merits an article. But, for over a decade or more, BLP articles with zero references are eligible for rapid deletion.
 
Since there should be a real properly referenced article here, I am reverting this back to a redirect. A real properly referenced article might get challenged, at AFD, and the fact that a previous version had been speedy deleted could sway some contributors to a delete opinion. [[User:Geo Swan|Geo Swan]] ([[User talk:Geo Swan|talk]]) 22:01, 22 June 2020 (UTC)
 
:Should be a redirect. The only notability is the (as-yet-unpublished) book. A smattering of gossip pieces and [[churnalism]] pieces that are in reality discussing the book background does not warrant a permanent encyclopedic article. But some people just can't stop scraping the barrel. [[User:Animalparty|--Animalparty!]] ([[User talk:Animalparty|talk]]) 00:52, 4 July 2020 (UTC)
 
== Proposed merge of [[Too Much and Never Enough]] with [[Mary L. Trump]] ==
{{archive top|result=[[WP:SNOW]] close. Let's give this 30-90 days before raising the question of a merge again.|status=No action}}
Merge [[Mary L. Trump]] ''into'' [[Too Much and Never Enough]]. Per [[WP:BLP1E]] and [[WP:BIO1E]]: The author is a low-profile individual whose only credible notability is the as-yet-unpublished ''[[Too Much and Never Enough]]''. The ''only'' relevant third-party coverage in the past 20 years have been trivial coverage relating to family issues, and this book. All relevant background can be summarized in the book's article without dumpster-diving for dregs of verifiable but trivial facts to pad out a separate article. Earning a a PhD and writing a scholarly article does not meet [[WP:PROF]]. [[User:Animalparty|--Animalparty!]] ([[User talk:Animalparty|talk]]) 01:03, 4 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Support''' not known for anything of her own merit outside of this book. On another note, when WP:BLP1E and WP:BIO1E link to the same page, one only needs to mention one or the other. [[User:SNUGGUMS|<b style="color:#009900">SNUGGUMS</b>]] ([[User talk:SNUGGUMS|<b style="color:#009900">talk</b>]] / [[Special:Contributions/SNUGGUMS|<b style="color:#009900">edits</b>]]) 12:47, 4 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Oppose'''. [[User:Nablais|Nablais]] ([[User talk:Nablais|talk]]) 05:10, 5 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Support''' as she was not notable until her book hit the news, a case of BLP1E. BTW the title of this thread is a little ambiguous; I want to make it clear that I am supporting a merge of [[Mary L. Trump]] into [[Too Much and Never Enough]], not the other way around - with Mary L. Trump reverting to a redirect. -- [[User:MelanieN|MelanieN]] ([[User talk:MelanieN|talk]]) 14:56, 5 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' the two supports, above, assert Mary L. Trump is a BLP1E, ignoring that she also received significant RS coverage twenty years ago, when she contested her grandfather's will, and she is also the source of the tax documents behind the Pullitzer Prize winning reporting on Trump's taxes. <p>I think it would be a disservice to readers who read about the disputed will, in the articles on [[Fred Trump Sr.]], [[Donald Trump]], or the articles on her Donald Trump's siblings, and want to read about the other parties in the dispute. They click on a wikilink they would reasonably expect to take them to an article on Fred Trump's granddaughter, only to find themselves reading an article about a book on Trump. I think this kind of merge reduces the confidence our readers have in the wikipedia's usefulness and reliability. <p>Similarly, readers interested in the background to the Pullitzer don't want to be sent to an article on the book. <p>I think it should be noted that BLP1E explicitly says that when someone is known for one event, but their role is central, they may, after all, still merit a standalone article. I suggest that, even if she were known for only her publication of this book, the coverage of her would measure up to our criteria for a standalone article. [[User:Geo Swan|Geo Swan]] ([[User talk:Geo Swan|talk]]) 18:58, 5 July 2020 (UTC)
::Wikipedia is not a paper of record. It is entirely possible to make a single decent, comprehensive article that fairly and [[WP:NPOV|proportionally]] covers the author ''and'' their sole work of notability. Wikipedia does not need to be run on reflexive, compulsive [[WP:RECENTISM|recentism]] just because of viral news cycles. [[User:Animalparty|--Animalparty!]] ([[User talk:Animalparty|talk]])
:* {{U|Animalparty}}, I think you offer the wrong counter-arguments.
:: Topics are inter-related - are linked to one another. Individual real-world GNG-compliant topics, that are linked to one another, should have individual standalone articles, that are wiki-linked to one another.
:# As I pointed out, readers solely interested in the 2017 Pullitzer will be interested in Ms Trump, not in a book published in 2020. So, why are you arguing it is a good idea to send them to an article on a book, only peripherally related to the Pullitzer.
:# If the book makes a real-world best-seller list, or receives real world awards for literary value, or political impact, readers reviewing all books that won that award, may have no interest in the author. So, don't send them to an omnibus article that discusses multiple topics, when each of those multiple topics measures up to GNG. <p>''' Reserve covering both the author, and their works, for author/works combos, where one or both don't measure up to GNG, all by themselves. '''
:# Succumbing to an unnecessary urge to merge erodes the value of the ''[what links here]'' buttons. Watchlists, and the ''[what links here]'' button, are powerful features - features that work best when we are disciplined enough to keep each article focussed around a single topic. In general, if a GNG-compliant topic is worthy of a wikilink, it is worthy of a standalone article. [[User:Geo Swan|Geo Swan]] ([[User talk:Geo Swan|talk]]) 23:00, 6 July 2020 (UTC)
 
*'''Oppose''' Notability is not inherited and she got her own significant coverage. The book is a bestseller before it’s even released. Inevitably, when it is released, coverage will continue at this rate. Sadly, by Wikipedia standards, she is a notable author. The coverage over the will wouldn’t have been enough. [[User:Trillfendi|Trillfendi]] ([[User talk:Trillfendi|talk]]) 15:36, 6 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''': Author and book are sufficiently notable independently from one another. - [[User:DVdm|DVdm]] ([[User talk:DVdm|talk]]) 15:33, 7 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' per above. [[User:KingSkyLord|KingSkyLord]] ([[User talk:KingSkyLord|talk]] &#124; [[Special:Contributions/KingSkyLord|contribs]]) 22:15, 7 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Strongly oppose''' It has just been published and there are already ''Washington Post'' and ''New York Times'' ' articles about the book not the author.[[User:Oceanflynn|Oceanflynn]] ([[User talk:Oceanflynn|talk]]) 00:43, 8 July 2020 (UTC)
* Oppose merge. ---[[User:Another Believer|<span style="color:navy">Another Believer</span>]] <sub>([[User talk:Another Believer|<span style="color:#C60">Talk</span>]])</sub> 02:54, 8 July 2020 (UTC)
* '''Oppose merger''': The book is notable and deserves it's own article to allow expansion. [[User:Blockhouse321|Blockhouse321]] ([[User talk:Blockhouse321|talk]]) 08:53, 8 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''String oppose''', undoubtedly notable book, easily meets GNG. [[User:Gleeanon409|Gleeanon409]] ([[User talk:Gleeanon409|talk]]) 17:41, 8 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Comment''': To clarify, I am proposing to '''merge [[Mary L. Trump]] ''into'' [[Too Much and Never Enough]]''', as the book is clearly notable, while the author primarily notable for this alone. [[User:Animalparty|--Animalparty!]] ([[User talk:Animalparty|talk]]) 19:23, 8 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' Per comments above. It could be argued that she is known only for being Donald Trump's niece and for writing an exposé book on/about him, but that alone, especially the latter, warrants an article on her. There is a clear claim of notability here. [[User:AshMusique|AshMusique]] ([[User talk:AshMusique|talk]]) 02:43, 9 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' Per comments above (again). [[User:DividedFrame|Brad]] ([[User talk:DividedFrame|talk]]) 05:47, 9 July 2020 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' There is enough coverage to have notability for book and author. ~'''''[[User:Editorofthewiki|<span style="color: #F90000;">EDDY</span>]]'' <sup>([[User talk:Editorofthewiki|<span style="color: Green;">talk</span>]]/[[Special:Contributions/Editorofthewiki|<span style="color: Green;">contribs</span>]])</sup>'''~ 12:47, 9 July 2020 (UTC)
{{archive bottom}}
 
== LGBT category ==
 
Cited in her own look that she was living with and engaged to another woman in the 1990s
 
Also extensively in RS on that basis.
 
Mary Trump decided not to tell her grandmother, she writes, that she was then “living with and engaged to a woman”.
 
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jul/08/mary-trump-profile-donald-book
 
 
Mary Trump didn’t mention her own scheduling conflict: In a week, she was supposed to marry the woman she loved on a beach in Maui. She hadn’t told anybody in the family about her sexual orientation
 
https://www.usatoday.com/story/entertainment/books/2020/07/08/mary-trump-book-family-memoir-worst-moments-donald-trump/5396178002/
 
In the ‘90s, Mary writes, she and her grandmother “had been talking about Princess Diana’s funeral, and when she had said with some vehemence, ‘It’s a disgrace they’re letting that little f----- Elton John sing at the service,’ I’d realized it was better that she didn’t know I was living with … a woman.”
 
https://people.com/politics/mary-trump-tell-all-describes-trump-family-father-death/ <!-- Template:Unsigned --><small class="autosigned">—&nbsp;Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[User:Thumpwicca|Thumpwicca]] ([[User talk:Thumpwicca#top|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Thumpwicca|contribs]]) 15:05, 13 July 2020 (UTC)</small> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->
 
== Weasely sentence ==
 
:''In her book Mary relates a time when she was speaking with her grandmother, Mary Anne MacLeod Trump, and decided not to tell her that she had been married to and divorced from a woman, with whom she raised a daughter, Avery.''
 
Why not just come out and state that Mary Trump is a lesbian? The above sentence is worded in a way that apparently is trying (unsuccessfully) to obscure her sexuality.
 
== New Development ==
::[[Special:Contributions/216.152.18.131|216.152.18.131]] ([[User talk:216.152.18.131|talk]]) 19:51, 17 July 2020 (UTC)
:::That is how the sources described the encounter. The sources never explicitly identify her sexual orientation. [[User:TJMSmith|TJMSmith]] ([[User talk:TJMSmith|talk]]) 23:26, 17 July 2020 (UTC)
 
An additional sentence should probably be added to the introduction to mention the dismissal of this lawsuit and the order by a NY Judge for Trump to pay for the NYT's legal fees. https://apnews.com/article/trump-new-york-times-taxes-lawsuit-slapp-f39342501d9a2a5cfd36181f9f336215 [[Special:Contributions/2601:184:407F:ADA0:ECD9:A13E:DBA5:153B|2601:184:407F:ADA0:ECD9:A13E:DBA5:153B]] ([[User talk:2601:184:407F:ADA0:ECD9:A13E:DBA5:153B|talk]]) 02:09, 16 January 2024 (UTC)
== Typo s/b corrected ==
 
Mary:Already Trump'sincluded daughter'sat namethe isend spelledof AvAry''Will (Avary)of notFred AvEryTrump (Avery)Sr.'' [[User:Hume4oakUpdateNerd|Hume4oakUpdateNerd]] ([[User talk:Hume4oakUpdateNerd|talk]]) 0504:1131, 1816 JulyJanuary 20202024 (UTC)
: {{u|Hume4oak}}: Just fixed it. [[User:Trivialist|Trivialist]] ([[User talk:Trivialist|talk]]) 20:05, 18 July 2020 (UTC)
 
== Grammar fix? ==
== another reference: ''Advocate'' exclusive interview ==
 
Incomplete sentence.
[https://www.advocate.com/exclusives/2020/7/27/mary-l-trump-growing-gay-anti-everything-family This] was a great read, and might have a place in this article. I might revisit later, but figured I'd leave here if anyone else wants to add it. = [[User:Paul2520|paul2520]] [[User talk:Paul2520|💬]] 15:59, 2 August 2020 (UTC)
 
"A niece of US president-elect Donald Trump, she has been critical of him." [[Special:Contributions/199.45.206.94|199.45.206.94]] ([[User talk:199.45.206.94|talk]]) 00:05, 8 November 2024 (UTC)
=="Businessperson"==
It seems a little ridiculous to insist on having her as a "businessperson" when she's even in a category of "businesswomen"; within the category of "businessperson" are "businesswomen" and "businessmen". But whatever! <!-- Template:Unsigned IP --><small class="autosigned">—&nbsp;Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[Special:Contributions/78.144.72.204|78.144.72.204]] ([[User talk:78.144.72.204#top|talk]]) 18:07, 17 August 2020 (UTC)</small> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->
Add topic
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Mary_L._Trump"