-
Effects of Assortativity on Consensus Formation with Heterogeneous Agents
Authors:
Ece Çiğdem Mutlu,
Ivan Garibay
Abstract:
Despite the widespread use of Barabasi's scale-free networks and Erdos-Renyi networks of which degree correlation (assortativity) is neutral, numerous studies demonstrated that online social networks tend to show assortative mixing (positive degree correlation), while non-social networks show a disassortative mixing (negative degree correlation). First, we analyzed the variability in the assortati…
▽ More
Despite the widespread use of Barabasi's scale-free networks and Erdos-Renyi networks of which degree correlation (assortativity) is neutral, numerous studies demonstrated that online social networks tend to show assortative mixing (positive degree correlation), while non-social networks show a disassortative mixing (negative degree correlation). First, we analyzed the variability in the assortativity coefficients of different groups of the same platform by using three different subreddits in Reddit. Our data analysis results showed that Reddit is disassortative, and assortativity coefficients of the aforementioned subreddits are computed as -0.0384, -0.0588 and -0.1107, respectively. Motivated by the variability in the results even in the same platform, we decided to investigate the sensitivity of dynamics of consensus formation to the assortativity of the network. We concluded that the system is more likely to reach a consensus when the network is disassortatively mixed or neutral; however, the likelihood of the consensus significantly decreases when the network is assortatively mixed. Surprisingly, the time elapsed until all nodes fix their opinions is slightly lower when the network is neutral compared to either assortative or disassortative networks. These results are more pronounced when the thresholds of agents are more heterogeneously distributed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
The Degree-Dependent Threshold Model: Towards a Better Understanding of Opinion Dynamics on Online Social Networks
Authors:
Ece C. Mutlu,
Ivan Garibay
Abstract:
With the rapid growth of online social media, people become increasingly overwhelmed by the volume and the content of the information present in the environment. The threshold model is currently one of the most common methods to capture the effect of people on others' opinions and emotions. Although many studies employ and try to improve upon the threshold model, the search for an appropriate thre…
▽ More
With the rapid growth of online social media, people become increasingly overwhelmed by the volume and the content of the information present in the environment. The threshold model is currently one of the most common methods to capture the effect of people on others' opinions and emotions. Although many studies employ and try to improve upon the threshold model, the search for an appropriate threshold function for defining human behavior is an essential and yet unattained quest. The definition of heterogeneity in thresholds of individuals is oftentimes poorly defined, which leads to the rather simplistic use of uniform and binary functions, albeit they are far from representing the reality. In this study, we use Twitter data of size 30,704,025 tweets to mimic the adoption of a new opinion. Our results show that the threshold is not only correlated with the out-degree of nodes, which contradicts other studies but also correlated with nodes' in-degree. Therefore, we simulated two cases in which thresholds are out-degree and in-degree dependent, separately. We concluded that the system is more likely to reach a consensus when thresholds are in-degree dependent; however, the time elapsed until all nodes fix their opinions is significantly higher in this case. Additionally, we did not observe a notable effect of mean-degree on either the average opinion or the fixation time of opinions for both cases, and increasing seed size has a negative effect on reaching a consensus. Although threshold heterogeneity has a slight influence on the average opinion, the positive effect of heterogeneity on reaching a consensus is more pronounced when thresholds are in-degree dependent.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Deep Agent: Studying the Dynamics of Information Spread and Evolution in Social Networks
Authors:
Ivan Garibay,
Toktam A. Oghaz,
Niloofar Yousefi,
Ece C. Mutlu,
Madeline Schiappa,
Steven Scheinert,
Georgios C. Anagnostopoulos,
Christina Bouwens,
Stephen M. Fiore,
Alexander Mantzaris,
John T. Murphy,
William Rand,
Anastasia Salter,
Mel Stanfill,
Gita Sukthankar,
Nisha Baral,
Gabriel Fair,
Chathika Gunaratne,
Neda B. Hajiakhoond,
Jasser Jasser,
Chathura Jayalath,
Olivia Newton,
Samaneh Saadat,
Chathurani Senevirathna,
Rachel Winter
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This paper explains the design of a social network analysis framework, developed under DARPA's SocialSim program, with novel architecture that models human emotional, cognitive and social factors. Our framework is both theory and data-driven, and utilizes domain expertise. Our simulation effort helps in understanding how information flows and evolves in social media platforms. We focused on modeli…
▽ More
This paper explains the design of a social network analysis framework, developed under DARPA's SocialSim program, with novel architecture that models human emotional, cognitive and social factors. Our framework is both theory and data-driven, and utilizes domain expertise. Our simulation effort helps in understanding how information flows and evolves in social media platforms. We focused on modeling three information domains: cryptocurrencies, cyber threats, and software vulnerabilities for the three interrelated social environments: GitHub, Reddit, and Twitter. We participated in the SocialSim DARPA Challenge in December 2018, in which our models were subjected to extensive performance evaluation for accuracy, generalizability, explainability, and experimental power. This paper reports the main concepts and models, utilized in our social media modeling effort in developing a multi-resolution simulation at the user, community, population, and content levels.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2021; v1 submitted 25 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
How polarization can provide an increase in content dissemination amongst the highly ranked influencers
Authors:
Cameron E. Taylor,
Ivan Garibay,
Alexander V. Mantzaris
Abstract:
This work extends a model of simulating influence in a network of stochastic edge dynamics to account for polarization. The model built upon is termed Dynamic Communicators and seeks to understand the process which produces low volume, high influence amongst users. This model is extended to introduce the effects polarization. The fundamental assumption of the model is that a parameter of importanc…
▽ More
This work extends a model of simulating influence in a network of stochastic edge dynamics to account for polarization. The model built upon is termed Dynamic Communicators and seeks to understand the process which produces low volume, high influence amongst users. This model is extended to introduce the effects polarization. The fundamental assumption of the model is that a parameter of importance governs the rate of message responsiveness. With the introduction of relative incremental changes according to the response incurred in adjacent nodes receiving content, the changes in the power brokerage of a network can be examined. This provides a content agnostic interpretation for the desire to proliferate content amongst peers. From the results of the simulations, the analysis shows that a lack of polarization incrementally develops a more level discussion network with more even response rates whereas the polarization introduction leads to a gradual increase in response rate disparity.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
