-
The NANOGrav 12.5-year data set: A computationally efficient eccentric binary search pipeline and constraints on an eccentric supermassive binary candidate in 3C 66B
Authors:
Gabriella Agazie,
Zaven Arzoumanian,
Paul T. Baker,
Bence Bécsy,
Laura Blecha,
Harsha Blumer,
Adam Brazier,
Paul R. Brook,
Sarah Burke-Spolaor,
J. Andrew Casey-Clyde,
Maria Charisi,
Shami Chatterjee,
Belinda D. Cheeseboro,
Tyler Cohen,
James M. Cordes,
Neil J. Cornish,
Fronefield Crawford,
H. Thankful Cromartie,
Megan E. DeCesar,
Paul B. Demorest,
Lankeswar Dey,
Timothy Dolch,
Justin A. Ellis,
Robert D. Ferdman,
Elizabeth C. Ferrara
, et al. (63 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The radio galaxy 3C 66B has been hypothesized to host a supermassive black hole binary (SMBHB) at its center based on electromagnetic observations. Its apparent 1.05-year period and low redshift ($\sim0.02$) make it an interesting testbed to search for low-frequency gravitational waves (GWs) using Pulsar Timing Array (PTA) experiments. This source has been subjected to multiple searches for contin…
▽ More
The radio galaxy 3C 66B has been hypothesized to host a supermassive black hole binary (SMBHB) at its center based on electromagnetic observations. Its apparent 1.05-year period and low redshift ($\sim0.02$) make it an interesting testbed to search for low-frequency gravitational waves (GWs) using Pulsar Timing Array (PTA) experiments. This source has been subjected to multiple searches for continuous GWs from a circular SMBHB, resulting in progressively more stringent constraints on its GW amplitude and chirp mass. In this paper, we develop a pipeline for performing Bayesian targeted searches for eccentric SMBHBs in PTA data sets, and test its efficacy by applying it on simulated data sets with varying injected signal strengths. We also search for a realistic eccentric SMBHB source in 3C 66B using the NANOGrav 12.5-year data set employing PTA signal models containing Earth term-only as well as Earth+Pulsar term contributions using this pipeline. Due to limitations in our PTA signal model, we get meaningful results only when the initial eccentricity $e_0<0.5$ and the symmetric mass ratio $η>0.1$. We find no evidence for an eccentric SMBHB signal in our data, and therefore place 95% upper limits on the PTA signal amplitude of $88.1\pm3.7$ ns for the Earth term-only and $81.74\pm0.86$ ns for the Earth+Pulsar term searches for $e_0<0.5$ and $η>0.1$. Similar 95% upper limits on the chirp mass are $(1.98 \pm 0.05) \times 10^9\,M_{\odot}$ and $(1.81 \pm 0.01) \times 10^9\,M_{\odot}$. These upper limits, while less stringent than those calculated from a circular binary search in the NANOGrav 12.5-year data set, are consistent with the SMBHB model of 3C 66B developed from electromagnetic observations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2024; v1 submitted 29 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Comparing recent PTA results on the nanohertz stochastic gravitational wave background
Authors:
The International Pulsar Timing Array Collaboration,
G. Agazie,
J. Antoniadis,
A. Anumarlapudi,
A. M. Archibald,
P. Arumugam,
S. Arumugam,
Z. Arzoumanian,
J. Askew,
S. Babak,
M. Bagchi,
M. Bailes,
A. -S. Bak Nielsen,
P. T. Baker,
C. G. Bassa,
A. Bathula,
B. Bécsy,
A. Berthereau,
N. D. R. Bhat,
L. Blecha,
M. Bonetti,
E. Bortolas,
A. Brazier,
P. R. Brook,
M. Burgay
, et al. (220 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Australian, Chinese, European, Indian, and North American pulsar timing array (PTA) collaborations recently reported, at varying levels, evidence for the presence of a nanohertz gravitational wave background (GWB). Given that each PTA made different choices in modeling their data, we perform a comparison of the GWB and individual pulsar noise parameters across the results reported from the PTA…
▽ More
The Australian, Chinese, European, Indian, and North American pulsar timing array (PTA) collaborations recently reported, at varying levels, evidence for the presence of a nanohertz gravitational wave background (GWB). Given that each PTA made different choices in modeling their data, we perform a comparison of the GWB and individual pulsar noise parameters across the results reported from the PTAs that constitute the International Pulsar Timing Array (IPTA). We show that despite making different modeling choices, there is no significant difference in the GWB parameters that are measured by the different PTAs, agreeing within $1σ$. The pulsar noise parameters are also consistent between different PTAs for the majority of the pulsars included in these analyses. We bridge the differences in modeling choices by adopting a standardized noise model for all pulsars and PTAs, finding that under this model there is a reduction in the tension in the pulsar noise parameters. As part of this reanalysis, we "extended" each PTA's data set by adding extra pulsars that were not timed by that PTA. Under these extensions, we find better constraints on the GWB amplitude and a higher signal-to-noise ratio for the Hellings and Downs correlations. These extensions serve as a prelude to the benefits offered by a full combination of data across all pulsars in the IPTA, i.e., the IPTA's Data Release 3, which will involve not just adding in additional pulsars, but also including data from all three PTAs where any given pulsar is timed by more than as single PTA.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The NANOGrav 12.5-year Data Set: Search for Gravitational Wave Memory
Authors:
Gabriella Agazie,
Zaven Arzoumanian,
Paul T. Baker,
Bence Bécsy,
Laura Blecha,
Harsha Blumer,
Adam Brazier,
Paul R. Brook,
Sarah Burke-Spolaor,
Rand Burnette,
Robin Case,
J. Andrew Casey-Clyde,
Maria Charisi,
Shami Chatterjee,
Tyler Cohen,
James M. Cordes,
Neil J. Cornish,
Fronefield Crawford,
H. Thankful Cromartie,
Megan E. DeCesar,
Dallas DeGan,
Paul B. Demorest,
Timothy Dolch,
Brendan Drachler,
Justin A. Ellis
, et al. (65 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present the results of a Bayesian search for gravitational wave (GW) memory in the NANOGrav 12.5-yr data set. We find no convincing evidence for any gravitational wave memory signals in this data set (Bayes factor = 2.8). As such, we go on to place upper limits on the strain amplitude of GW memory events as a function of sky location and event epoch. These upper limits are computed using a sign…
▽ More
We present the results of a Bayesian search for gravitational wave (GW) memory in the NANOGrav 12.5-yr data set. We find no convincing evidence for any gravitational wave memory signals in this data set (Bayes factor = 2.8). As such, we go on to place upper limits on the strain amplitude of GW memory events as a function of sky location and event epoch. These upper limits are computed using a signal model that assumes the existence of a common, spatially uncorrelated red noise in addition to a GW memory signal. The median strain upper limit as a function of sky position is approximately $3.3 \times 10^{-14}$. We also find that there are some differences in the upper limits as a function of sky position centered around PSR J0613$-$0200. This suggests that this pulsar has some excess noise which can be confounded with GW memory. Finally, the upper limits as a function of burst epoch continue to improve at later epochs. This improvement is attributable to the continued growth of the pulsar timing array.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The NANOGrav 15-year Gravitational-Wave Background Analysis Pipeline
Authors:
Aaron D. Johnson,
Patrick M. Meyers,
Paul T. Baker,
Neil J. Cornish,
Jeffrey S. Hazboun,
Tyson B. Littenberg,
Joseph D. Romano,
Stephen R. Taylor,
Michele Vallisneri,
Sarah J. Vigeland,
Ken D. Olum,
Xavier Siemens,
Justin A. Ellis,
Rutger van Haasteren,
Sophie Hourihane,
Gabriella Agazie,
Akash Anumarlapudi,
Anne M. Archibald,
Zaven Arzoumanian,
Laura Blecha,
Adam Brazier,
Paul R. Brook,
Sarah Burke-Spolaor,
Bence Bécsy,
J. Andrew Casey-Clyde
, et al. (71 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This paper presents rigorous tests of pulsar timing array methods and software, examining their consistency across a wide range of injected parameters and signal strength. We discuss updates to the 15-year isotropic gravitational-wave background analyses and their corresponding code representations. Descriptions of the internal structure of the flagship algorithms \texttt{Enterprise} and \texttt{P…
▽ More
This paper presents rigorous tests of pulsar timing array methods and software, examining their consistency across a wide range of injected parameters and signal strength. We discuss updates to the 15-year isotropic gravitational-wave background analyses and their corresponding code representations. Descriptions of the internal structure of the flagship algorithms \texttt{Enterprise} and \texttt{PTMCMCSampler} are given to facilitate understanding of the PTA likelihood structure, how models are built, and what methods are currently used in sampling the high-dimensional PTA parameter space. We introduce a novel version of the PTA likelihood that uses a two-step marginalization procedure that performs much faster when the white noise parameters remain fixed. We perform stringent tests of consistency and correctness of the Bayesian and frequentist analysis software. For the Bayesian analysis, we test prior recovery, injection recovery, and Bayes factors. For the frequentist analysis, we test that the cross-correlation-based optimal statistic, when modified to account for a non-negligible gravitational-wave background, accurately recovers the amplitude of the background. We also summarize recent advances and tests performed on the optimal statistic in the literature from both GWB detection and parameter estimation perspectives. The tests presented here validate current and future analyses of PTA data.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2023; v1 submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The NANOGrav 15-year Data Set: Evidence for a Gravitational-Wave Background
Authors:
Gabriella Agazie,
Akash Anumarlapudi,
Anne M. Archibald,
Zaven Arzoumanian,
Paul T. Baker,
Bence Becsy,
Laura Blecha,
Adam Brazier,
Paul R. Brook,
Sarah Burke-Spolaor,
Rand Burnette,
Robin Case,
Maria Charisi,
Shami Chatterjee,
Katerina Chatziioannou,
Belinda D. Cheeseboro,
Siyuan Chen,
Tyler Cohen,
James M. Cordes,
Neil J. Cornish,
Fronefield Crawford,
H. Thankful Cromartie,
Kathryn Crowter,
Curt J. Cutler,
Megan E. DeCesar
, et al. (89 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report multiple lines of evidence for a stochastic signal that is correlated among 67 pulsars from the 15-year pulsar-timing data set collected by the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves. The correlations follow the Hellings-Downs pattern expected for a stochastic gravitational-wave background. The presence of such a gravitational-wave background with a power-law-spectr…
▽ More
We report multiple lines of evidence for a stochastic signal that is correlated among 67 pulsars from the 15-year pulsar-timing data set collected by the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves. The correlations follow the Hellings-Downs pattern expected for a stochastic gravitational-wave background. The presence of such a gravitational-wave background with a power-law-spectrum is favored over a model with only independent pulsar noises with a Bayes factor in excess of $10^{14}$, and this same model is favored over an uncorrelated common power-law-spectrum model with Bayes factors of 200-1000, depending on spectral modeling choices. We have built a statistical background distribution for these latter Bayes factors using a method that removes inter-pulsar correlations from our data set, finding $p = 10^{-3}$ (approx. $3σ$) for the observed Bayes factors in the null no-correlation scenario. A frequentist test statistic built directly as a weighted sum of inter-pulsar correlations yields $p = 5 \times 10^{-5} - 1.9 \times 10^{-4}$ (approx. $3.5 - 4σ$). Assuming a fiducial $f^{-2/3}$ characteristic-strain spectrum, as appropriate for an ensemble of binary supermassive black-hole inspirals, the strain amplitude is $2.4^{+0.7}_{-0.6} \times 10^{-15}$ (median + 90% credible interval) at a reference frequency of 1/(1 yr). The inferred gravitational-wave background amplitude and spectrum are consistent with astrophysical expectations for a signal from a population of supermassive black-hole binaries, although more exotic cosmological and astrophysical sources cannot be excluded. The observation of Hellings-Downs correlations points to the gravitational-wave origin of this signal.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The NANOGrav 12.5-year Data Set: Bayesian Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
Authors:
Zaven Arzoumanian,
Paul T. Baker,
Laura Blecha,
Harsha Blumer,
Adam Brazier,
Paul R. Brook,
Sarah Burke-Spolaor,
Bence Bécsy,
J. Andrew Casey-Clyde,
Maria Charisi,
Shami Chatterjee,
Siyuan Chen,
James M. Cordes,
Neil J. Cornish,
Fronefield Crawford,
H. Thankful Cromartie,
Megan E. DeCesar,
Paul B. Demorest,
Timothy Dolch,
Brendan Drachler,
Justin A. Ellis,
E. C. Ferrara,
William Fiore,
Emmanuel Fonseca,
Gabriel E. Freedman
, et al. (53 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Pulsar timing array collaborations, such as the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav), are seeking to detect nanohertz gravitational waves emitted by supermassive black hole binaries formed in the aftermath of galaxy mergers. We have searched for continuous waves from individual circular supermassive black hole binaries using the NANOGrav's recent 12.5-year data s…
▽ More
Pulsar timing array collaborations, such as the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav), are seeking to detect nanohertz gravitational waves emitted by supermassive black hole binaries formed in the aftermath of galaxy mergers. We have searched for continuous waves from individual circular supermassive black hole binaries using the NANOGrav's recent 12.5-year data set. We created new methods to accurately model the uncertainties on pulsar distances in our analysis, and we implemented new techniques to account for a common red noise process in pulsar timing array data sets while searching for deterministic gravitational wave signals, including continuous waves. As we found no evidence for continuous waves in our data, we placed 95\% upper limits on the strain amplitude of continuous waves emitted by these sources. At our most sensitive frequency of 7.65 nanohertz, we placed a sky-averaged limit of $h_0 < $ $(6.82 \pm 0.35) \times 10^{-15}$, and $h_0 <$ $(2.66 \pm 0.15) \times 10^{-15}$ in our most sensitive sky location. Finally, we placed a multi-messenger limit of $\mathcal{M} <$ $(1.41 \pm 0.02) \times 10^9 M_\odot$ on the chirp mass of the supermassive black hole binary candidate 3C~66B.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2023; v1 submitted 9 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
The NANOGrav 12.5-year data set: Search for Non-Einsteinian Polarization Modes in theGravitational-Wave Background
Authors:
Zaven Arzoumanian,
Paul T. Baker,
Harsha Blumer,
Bence Becsy,
Adam Brazier,
Paul R. Brook,
Sarah Burke-Spolaor,
Maria Charisi,
Shami Chatterjee,
Siyuan Chen,
James M. Cordes,
Neil J. Cornish,
Fronefield Crawford,
H. Thankful Cromartie,
Megan E. DeCesar,
Dallas M. DeGan,
Paul B. Demorest,
Timothy Dolch,
Brendan Drachler,
Justin A. Ellis,
Elizabeth C. Ferrara,
William Fiore,
Emmanuel Fonseca,
Nathan Garver-Daniels,
Peter A. Gentile
, et al. (46 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We search NANOGrav's 12.5-year data set for evidence of a gravitational wave background (GWB) with all the spatial correlations allowed by general metric theories of gravity. We find no substantial evidence in favor of the existence of such correlations in our data. We find that scalar-transverse (ST) correlations yield signal-to-noise ratios and Bayes factors that are higher than quadrupolar (ten…
▽ More
We search NANOGrav's 12.5-year data set for evidence of a gravitational wave background (GWB) with all the spatial correlations allowed by general metric theories of gravity. We find no substantial evidence in favor of the existence of such correlations in our data. We find that scalar-transverse (ST) correlations yield signal-to-noise ratios and Bayes factors that are higher than quadrupolar (tensor transverse, TT) correlations. Specifically, we find ST correlations with a signal-to-noise ratio of 2.8 that are preferred over TT correlations (Hellings and Downs correlations) with Bayesian odds of about 20:1. However, the significance of ST correlations is reduced dramatically when we include modeling of the Solar System ephemeris systematics and/or remove pulsar J0030$+$0451 entirely from consideration. Even taking the nominal signal-to-noise ratios at face value, analyses of simulated data sets show that such values are not extremely unlikely to be observed in cases where only the usual TT modes are present in the GWB. In the absence of a detection of any polarization mode of gravity, we place upper limits on their amplitudes for a spectral index of $γ= 5$ and a reference frequency of $f_\text{yr} = 1 \text{yr}^{-1}$. Among the upper limits for eight general families of metric theories of gravity, we find the values of $A^{95\%}_{TT} = (9.7 \pm 0.4)\times 10^{-16}$ and $A^{95\%}_{ST} = (1.4 \pm 0.03)\times 10^{-15}$ for the family of metric spacetime theories that contain both TT and ST modes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
The NANOGrav 12.5-year Data Set: Search For An Isotropic Stochastic Gravitational-Wave Background
Authors:
Zaven Arzoumanian,
Paul T. Baker,
Harsha Blumer,
Bence Becsy,
Adam Brazier,
Paul R. Brook,
Sarah Burke-Spolaor,
Shami Chatterjee,
Siyuan Chen,
James M. Cordes,
Neil J. Cornish,
Fronefield Crawford,
H. Thankful Cromartie,
Megan E. DeCesar,
Paul B. Demorest,
Timothy Dolch,
Justin A. Ellis,
Elizabeth C. Ferrara,
William Fiore,
Emmanuel Fonseca,
Nathan Garver-Daniels,
Peter A. Gentile,
Deborah C. Good,
Jeffrey S. Hazboun,
A. Miguel Holgado
, et al. (36 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We search for an isotropic stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) in the $12.5$-year pulsar timing data set collected by the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves. Our analysis finds strong evidence of a stochastic process, modeled as a power-law, with common amplitude and spectral slope across pulsars. The Bayesian posterior of the amplitude for an $f^{-2/3}$ power-…
▽ More
We search for an isotropic stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) in the $12.5$-year pulsar timing data set collected by the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves. Our analysis finds strong evidence of a stochastic process, modeled as a power-law, with common amplitude and spectral slope across pulsars. The Bayesian posterior of the amplitude for an $f^{-2/3}$ power-law spectrum, expressed as the characteristic GW strain, has median $1.92 \times 10^{-15}$ and $5\%$--$95\%$ quantiles of $1.37$--$2.67 \times 10^{-15}$ at a reference frequency of $f_\mathrm{yr} = 1 ~\mathrm{yr}^{-1}$. The Bayes factor in favor of the common-spectrum process versus independent red-noise processes in each pulsar exceeds $10,000$. However, we find no statistically significant evidence that this process has quadrupolar spatial correlations, which we would consider necessary to claim a GWB detection consistent with general relativity. We find that the process has neither monopolar nor dipolar correlations, which may arise from, for example, reference clock or solar system ephemeris systematics, respectively. The amplitude posterior has significant support above previously reported upper limits; we explain this in terms of the Bayesian priors assumed for intrinsic pulsar red noise. We examine potential implications for the supermassive black hole binary population under the hypothesis that the signal is indeed astrophysical in nature.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2021; v1 submitted 9 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Modeling the uncertainties of solar-system ephemerides for robust gravitational-wave searches with pulsar timing arrays
Authors:
M. Vallisneri,
S. R. Taylor,
J. Simon,
W. M. Folkner,
R. S. Park,
C. Cutler,
J. A. Ellis,
T. J. W. Lazio,
S. J. Vigeland,
K. Aggarwal,
Z. Arzoumanian,
P. T. Baker,
A. Brazier,
P. R. Brook,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
S. Chatterjee,
J. M. Cordes,
N. J. Cornish,
F. Crawford,
H. T. Cromartie,
K. Crowter,
M. DeCesar,
P. B. Demorest,
T. Dolch,
R. D. Ferdman
, et al. (39 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The regularity of pulsar emissions becomes apparent once we reference the pulses' times of arrivals to the inertial rest frame of the solar system. It follows that errors in the determination of Earth's position with respect to the solar-system barycenter can appear as a time-correlated bias in pulsar-timing residual time series, affecting the searches for low-frequency gravitational waves perform…
▽ More
The regularity of pulsar emissions becomes apparent once we reference the pulses' times of arrivals to the inertial rest frame of the solar system. It follows that errors in the determination of Earth's position with respect to the solar-system barycenter can appear as a time-correlated bias in pulsar-timing residual time series, affecting the searches for low-frequency gravitational waves performed with pulsar timing arrays. Indeed, recent array datasets yield different gravitational-wave background upper limits and detection statistics when analyzed with different solar-system ephemerides. Crucially, the ephemerides do not generally provide usable error representations. In this article we describe the motivation, construction, and application of a physical model of solar-system ephemeris uncertainties, which focuses on the degrees of freedom (Jupiter's orbital elements) most relevant to gravitational-wave searches with pulsar timing arrays. This model, BayesEphem, was used to derive ephemeris-robust results in NANOGrav's 11-yr stochastic-background search, and it provides a foundation for future searches by NANOGrav and other consortia. The analysis and simulations reported here suggest that ephemeris modeling reduces the gravitational-wave sensitivity of the 11-yr dataset; and that this degeneracy will vanish with improved ephemerides and with the longer pulsar timing datasets that will become available in the near future.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2020; v1 submitted 2 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The NANOGrav 11-Year Data Set: Limits on Gravitational Wave Memory
Authors:
K. Aggarwal,
Z. Arzoumanian,
P. T. Baker,
A. Brazier,
P. R. Brook,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
S. Chatterjee,
J. M. Cordes,
N. J. Cornish,
F. Crawford,
H. T. Cromartie,
K. Crowter,
M. Decesar,
P. B. Demorest,
T. Dolch,
J. A. Ellis,
R. D. Ferdman,
E. C. Ferrara,
E. Fonseca,
N. Garver-Daniels,
P. Gentile,
D. Good,
J. S. Hazboun,
A. M. Holgado,
E. A. Huerta
, et al. (36 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The mergers of supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs) promise to be incredible sources of gravitational waves (GWs). While the oscillatory part of the merger gravitational waveform will be outside the frequency sensitivity range of pulsar timing arrays (PTAs), the non-oscillatory GW memory effect is detectable. Further, any burst of gravitational waves will produce GW memory, making memory a us…
▽ More
The mergers of supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs) promise to be incredible sources of gravitational waves (GWs). While the oscillatory part of the merger gravitational waveform will be outside the frequency sensitivity range of pulsar timing arrays (PTAs), the non-oscillatory GW memory effect is detectable. Further, any burst of gravitational waves will produce GW memory, making memory a useful probe of unmodeled exotic sources and new physics. We searched the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) 11-year data set for GW memory. This dataset is sensitive to very low frequency GWs of $\sim3$ to $400$ nHz (periods of $\sim11$ yr $-$ $1$ mon). Finding no evidence for GWs, we placed limits on the strain amplitude of GW memory events during the observation period. We then used the strain upper limits to place limits on the rate of GW memory causing events. At a strain of $2.5\times10^{-14}$, corresponding to the median upper limit as a function of source sky position, we set a limit on the rate of GW memory events at $<0.4$ yr$^{-1}$. That strain corresponds to a SMBHB merger with reduced mass of $ηM \sim 2\times10^{10}M_\odot$ and inclination of $ι=π/3$ at a distance of 1 Gpc.
As a test of our analysis, we analyzed the NANOGrav 9-year data set as well. This analysis found an anomolous signal, which does not appear in the 11-year data set. This signal is not a GW, and its origin remains unknown.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2019; v1 submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
The NANOGrav 11-Year Data Set: Evolution of Gravitational Wave Background Statistics
Authors:
J. S. Hazboun,
J. Simon,
S. R. Taylor,
M. T. Lam,
S. J. Vigeland,
K. Islo,
J. S. Key,
Z. Arzoumanian,
P. T. Baker,
A. Brazier,
P. R. Brook,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
S. Chatterjee,
J. M. Cordes,
N. J. Cornish,
F. Crawford,
K. Crowter,
H. T. Cromartie,
M. DeCesar,
P. B. Demorest,
T. Dolch,
J. A. Ellis,
R. D. Ferdman,
E. Ferrara,
E. Fonseca
, et al. (38 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
An ensemble of inspiraling supermassive black hole binaries should produce a stochastic background of very low frequency gravitational waves. This stochastic background is predicted to be a power law, with a spectral index of -2/3, and it should be detectable by a network of precisely timed millisecond pulsars, widely distributed on the sky. This paper reports a new "time slicing" analysis of the…
▽ More
An ensemble of inspiraling supermassive black hole binaries should produce a stochastic background of very low frequency gravitational waves. This stochastic background is predicted to be a power law, with a spectral index of -2/3, and it should be detectable by a network of precisely timed millisecond pulsars, widely distributed on the sky. This paper reports a new "time slicing" analysis of the 11-year data release from the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) using 34 millisecond pulsars. Methods to flag potential "false positive" signatures are developed, including techniques to identify responsible pulsars. Mitigation strategies are then presented. We demonstrate how an incorrect noise model can lead to spurious signals, and show how independently modeling noise across 30 Fourier components, spanning NANOGrav's frequency range, effectively diagnoses and absorbs the excess power in gravitational-wave searches. This results in a nominal, and expected, progression of our gravitational-wave statistics. Additionally we show that the first interstellar medium event in PSR J1713+0747 pollutes the common red noise process with low-spectral index noise, and use a tailored noise model to remove these effects.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2019; v1 submitted 18 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The NANOGrav 11-Year Data Set: Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
Authors:
K. Aggarwal,
Z. Arzoumanian,
P. T. Baker,
A. Brazier,
M. R. Brinson,
P. R. Brook,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
S. Chatterjee,
J. M. Cordes,
N. J. Cornish,
F. Crawford,
K. Crowter,
H. T. Cromartie,
M. DeCesar,
P. B. Demorest,
T. Dolch,
J. A. Ellis,
R. D. Ferdman,
E. Ferrara,
E. Fonseca,
N. Garver-Daniels,
P. Gentile,
J. S. Hazboun,
A. M. Holgado,
E. A. Huerta
, et al. (38 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Observations indicate that nearly all galaxies contain supermassive black holes (SMBHs) at their centers. When galaxies merge, their component black holes form SMBH binaries (SMBHBs), which emit low-frequency gravitational waves (GWs) that can be detected by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). We have searched the recently-released North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) 1…
▽ More
Observations indicate that nearly all galaxies contain supermassive black holes (SMBHs) at their centers. When galaxies merge, their component black holes form SMBH binaries (SMBHBs), which emit low-frequency gravitational waves (GWs) that can be detected by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). We have searched the recently-released North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) 11-year data set for GWs from individual SMBHBs in circular orbits. As we did not find strong evidence for GWs in our data, we placed 95\% upper limits on the strength of GWs from such sources as a function of GW frequency and sky location. We placed a sky-averaged upper limit on the GW strain of $h_0 < 7.3(3) \times 10^{-15}$ at $f_\mathrm{gw}= 8$ nHz. We also developed a technique to determine the significance of a particular signal in each pulsar using ``dropout' parameters as a way of identifying spurious signals in measurements from individual pulsars. We used our upper limits on the GW strain to place lower limits on the distances to individual SMBHBs. At the most-sensitive sky location, we ruled out SMBHBs emitting GWs with $f_\mathrm{gw}= 8$ nHz within 120 Mpc for $\mathcal{M} = 10^9 \, M_\odot$, and within 5.5 Gpc for $\mathcal{M} = 10^{10} \, M_\odot$. We also determined that there are no SMBHBs with $\mathcal{M} > 1.6 \times 10^9 \, M_\odot$ emitting GWs in the Virgo Cluster. Finally, we estimated the number of potentially detectable sources given our current strain upper limits based on galaxies in Two Micron All-Sky Survey (2MASS) and merger rates from the Illustris cosmological simulation project. Only 34 out of 75,000 realizations of the local Universe contained a detectable source, from which we concluded it was unsurprising that we did not detect any individual sources given our current sensitivity to GWs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2019; v1 submitted 30 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Noise-marginalized optimal statistic: A robust hybrid frequentist-Bayesian statistic for the stochastic gravitational-wave background in pulsar timing arrays
Authors:
Sarah J. Vigeland,
Kristina Islo,
Stephen R. Taylor,
Justin A. Ellis
Abstract:
Observations have revealed that nearly all galaxies contain supermassive black holes (SMBHs) at their centers. When galaxies merge, these SMBHs form SMBH binaries (SMBHBs) that emit low-frequency gravitational waves (GWs). The incoherent superposition of these sources produce a stochastic GW background (GWB) that can be observed by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). The optimal statistic is a frequentis…
▽ More
Observations have revealed that nearly all galaxies contain supermassive black holes (SMBHs) at their centers. When galaxies merge, these SMBHs form SMBH binaries (SMBHBs) that emit low-frequency gravitational waves (GWs). The incoherent superposition of these sources produce a stochastic GW background (GWB) that can be observed by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). The optimal statistic is a frequentist estimator of the amplitude of the GWB that specifically looks for the spatial correlations between pulsars induced by the GWB. In this paper, we introduce an improved method for computing the optimal statistic that marginalizes over the red noise in individual pulsars. We use simulations to demonstrate that this method more accurately determines the strength of the GWB, and we use the noise-marginalized optimal statistic to compare the significance of monopole, dipole, and Hellings-Downs (HD) spatial correlations and perform sky scrambles.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2018; v1 submitted 30 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
The NANOGrav 11-year Data Set: Pulsar-timing Constraints On The Stochastic Gravitational-wave Background
Authors:
Z. Arzoumanian,
P. T. Baker,
A. Brazier,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
S. J. Chamberlin,
S. Chatterjee,
B. Christy,
J. M. Cordes,
N. J. Cornish,
F. Crawford,
H. Thankful Cromartie,
K. Crowter,
M. DeCesar,
P. B. Demorest,
T. Dolch,
J. A. Ellis,
R. D. Ferdman,
E. Ferrara,
W. M. Folkner,
E. Fonseca,
N. Garver-Daniels,
P. A. Gentile,
R. Haas,
J. S. Hazboun,
E. A. Huerta
, et al. (35 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We search for an isotropic stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) in the newly released $11$-year dataset from the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav). While we find no significant evidence for a GWB, we place constraints on a GWB from a population of supermassive black-hole binaries, cosmic strings, and a primordial GWB. For the first time, we find that…
▽ More
We search for an isotropic stochastic gravitational-wave background (GWB) in the newly released $11$-year dataset from the North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav). While we find no significant evidence for a GWB, we place constraints on a GWB from a population of supermassive black-hole binaries, cosmic strings, and a primordial GWB. For the first time, we find that the GWB upper limits and detection statistics are sensitive to the Solar System ephemeris (SSE) model used, and that SSE errors can mimic a GWB signal. We developed an approach that bridges systematic SSE differences, producing the first PTA constraints that are robust against SSE uncertainties. We thus place a $95\%$ upper limit on the GW strain amplitude of $A_\mathrm{GWB}<1.45\times 10^{-15}$ at a frequency of $f=1$ yr$^{-1}$ for a fiducial $f^{-2/3}$ power-law spectrum, and with inter-pulsar correlations modeled. This is a factor of $\sim 2$ improvement over the NANOGrav $9$-year limit, calculated using the same procedure. Previous PTA upper limits on the GWB will need revision in light of SSE systematic uncertainties. We use our constraints to characterize the combined influence on the GWB of the stellar mass-density in galactic cores, the eccentricity of SMBH binaries, and SMBH--galactic-bulge scaling relationships. We constrain cosmic-string tension using recent simulations, yielding an SSE-marginalized $95\%$ upper limit on the cosmic string tension of $Gμ< 5.3\times 10^{-11}$---a factor of $\sim 2$ better than the published NANOGrav $9$-year constraints. Our SSE-marginalized $95\%$ upper limit on the energy density of a primordial GWB (for a radiation-dominated post-inflation Universe) is $Ω_\mathrm{GWB}(f)h^2<3.4\times10^{-10}$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2018; v1 submitted 8 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
From Spin Noise to Systematics: Stochastic Processes in the First International Pulsar Timing Array Data Release
Authors:
L. Lentati,
R. M. Shannon,
W. A. Coles,
J. P. W. Verbiest,
R. van Haasteren,
J. A. Ellis,
R. N. Caballero,
R. N. Manchester,
Z. Arzoumanian,
S. Babak,
C. G. Bassa,
N. D. R. Bhat,
P. Brem,
M. Burgay,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
D. Champion,
S. Chatterjee,
I. Cognard,
J. M. Cordes,
S. Dai,
P. Demorest,
G. Desvignes,
T. Dolch,
R. D. Ferdman,
E. Fonseca
, et al. (58 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We analyse the stochastic properties of the 49 pulsars that comprise the first International Pulsar Timing Array (IPTA) data release. We use Bayesian methodology, performing model selection to determine the optimal description of the stochastic signals present in each pulsar. In addition to spin-noise and dispersion-measure (DM) variations, these models can include timing noise unique to a single…
▽ More
We analyse the stochastic properties of the 49 pulsars that comprise the first International Pulsar Timing Array (IPTA) data release. We use Bayesian methodology, performing model selection to determine the optimal description of the stochastic signals present in each pulsar. In addition to spin-noise and dispersion-measure (DM) variations, these models can include timing noise unique to a single observing system, or frequency band. We show the improved radio-frequency coverage and presence of overlapping data from different observing systems in the IPTA data set enables us to separate both system and band-dependent effects with much greater efficacy than in the individual PTA data sets. For example, we show that PSR J1643$-$1224 has, in addition to DM variations, significant band-dependent noise that is coherent between PTAs which we interpret as coming from time-variable scattering or refraction in the ionised interstellar medium. Failing to model these different contributions appropriately can dramatically alter the astrophysical interpretation of the stochastic signals observed in the residuals. In some cases, the spectral exponent of the spin noise signal can vary from 1.6 to 4 depending upon the model, which has direct implications for the long-term sensitivity of the pulsar to a stochastic gravitational-wave (GW) background. By using a more appropriate model, however, we can greatly improve a pulsar's sensitivity to GWs. For example, including system and band-dependent signals in the PSR J0437$-$4715 data set improves the upper limit on a fiducial GW background by $\sim 60\%$ compared to a model that includes DM variations and spin-noise only.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Are we there yet? Time to detection of nanohertz gravitational waves based on pulsar-timing array limits
Authors:
S. R. Taylor,
M. Vallisneri,
J. A. Ellis,
C. M. F. Mingarelli,
T. J. W. Lazio,
R. van Haasteren
Abstract:
Decade-long timing observations of arrays of millisecond pulsars have placed highly constraining upper limits on the amplitude of the nanohertz gravitational-wave stochastic signal from the mergers of supermassive black-hole binaries ($\sim 10^{-15}$ strain at $f = 1/\mathrm{yr}$). These limits suggest that binary merger rates have been overestimated, or that environmental influences from nuclear…
▽ More
Decade-long timing observations of arrays of millisecond pulsars have placed highly constraining upper limits on the amplitude of the nanohertz gravitational-wave stochastic signal from the mergers of supermassive black-hole binaries ($\sim 10^{-15}$ strain at $f = 1/\mathrm{yr}$). These limits suggest that binary merger rates have been overestimated, or that environmental influences from nuclear gas or stars accelerate orbital decay, reducing the gravitational-wave signal at the lowest, most sensitive frequencies. This prompts the question whether nanohertz gravitational waves are likely to be detected in the near future. In this letter, we answer this question quantitatively using simple statistical estimates, deriving the range of true signal amplitudes that are compatible with current upper limits, and computing expected detection probabilities as a function of observation time. We conclude that small arrays consisting of the pulsars with the least timing noise, which yield the tightest upper limits, have discouraging prospects of making a detection in the next two decades. By contrast, we find large arrays are crucial to detection because the quadrupolar spatial correlations induced by gravitational waves can be well sampled by many pulsar pairs. Indeed, timing programs which monitor a large and expanding set of pulsars have an $\sim 80\%$ probability of detecting gravitational waves within the next ten years, under assumptions on merger rates and environmental influences ranging from optimistic to conservative. Even in the extreme case where $90\%$ of binaries stall before merger and environmental coupling effects diminish low-frequency gravitational-wave power, detection is delayed by at most a few years.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2016; v1 submitted 17 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Testing Theories of Gravitation Using 21-Year Timing of Pulsar Binary J1713+0747
Authors:
W. W. Zhu,
I. H. Stairs,
P. B. Demorest,
D. J. Nice,
J. A. Ellis,
S. M. Ransom,
Z. Arzoumanian,
K. Crowter,
T. Dolch,
R. D. Ferdman,
E. Fonseca,
M. E. Gonzalez,
G. Jones,
M. L. Jones,
M. T. Lam,
L. Levin,
M. A. McLaughlin,
T. Pennucci,
K. Stovall,
J. Swiggum
Abstract:
We report 21-yr timing of one of the most precise pulsars: PSR J1713+0747. Its pulse times of arrival are well modeled by a comprehensive pulsar binary model including its three-dimensional orbit and a noise model that incorporates correlated noise such as jitter and red noise. Its timing residuals have weighted root mean square $\sim 92$ ns. The new dataset allows us to update and improve previou…
▽ More
We report 21-yr timing of one of the most precise pulsars: PSR J1713+0747. Its pulse times of arrival are well modeled by a comprehensive pulsar binary model including its three-dimensional orbit and a noise model that incorporates correlated noise such as jitter and red noise. Its timing residuals have weighted root mean square $\sim 92$ ns. The new dataset allows us to update and improve previous measurements of the system properties, including the masses of the neutron star ($1.31\pm0.11$ $M_{\odot}$) and the companion white dwarf ($0.286\pm0.012$ $M_{\odot}$) and the parallax distance $1.15\pm0.03$ kpc. We measured the intrinsic change in orbital period, $\dot{P}^{\rm Int}_{\rm b}$, is $-0.20\pm0.17$ ps s$^{-1}$, which is not distinguishable from zero. This result, combined with the measured $\dot{P}^{\rm Int}_{\rm b}$ of other pulsars, can place a generic limit on potential changes in the gravitational constant $G$. We found that $\dot{G}/G$ is consistent with zero [$(-0.6\pm1.1)\times10^{-12}$ yr$^{-1}$, 95\% confidence] and changes at least a factor of $31$ (99.7\% confidence) more slowly than the average expansion rate of the Universe. This is the best $\dot{G}/G$ limit from pulsar binary systems. The $\dot{P}^{\rm Int}_{\rm b}$ of pulsar binaries can also place limits on the putative coupling constant for dipole gravitational radiation $κ_D=(-0.9\pm3.3)\times10^{-4}$ (95\% confidence). Finally, the nearly circular orbit of this pulsar binary allows us to constrain statistically the strong-field post-Newtonian parameters $Δ$, which describes the violation of strong equivalence principle, and $\hatα_3$, which describes a breaking of both Lorentz invariance in gravitation and conservation of momentum. We found, at 95\% confidence, $Δ<0.01$ and $\hatα_3<2\times10^{-20}$ based on PSR J1713+0747.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2015; v1 submitted 2 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
NANOGrav Constraints on Gravitational Wave Bursts with Memory
Authors:
Z. Arzoumanian,
A. Brazier,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
S. J. Chamberlin,
S. Chatterjee,
B. Christy,
J. M. Cordes,
N. J. Cornish,
P. B. Demorest,
X. Deng,
T. Dolch,
J. A. Ellis,
R. D. Ferdman,
E. Fonseca,
N. Garver-Daniels,
F. Jenet,
G. Jones,
V. M. Kaspi,
M. Koop,
M. T. Lam,
T. J. W. Lazio,
L. Levin,
A. N. Lommen,
D. R. Lorimer,
J. Luo
, et al. (17 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Among efforts to detect gravitational radiation, pulsar timing arrays are uniquely poised to detect "memory" signatures, permanent perturbations in spacetime from highly energetic astrophysical events such as mergers of supermassive black hole binaries. The North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) observes dozens of the most stable millisecond pulsars using the Areci…
▽ More
Among efforts to detect gravitational radiation, pulsar timing arrays are uniquely poised to detect "memory" signatures, permanent perturbations in spacetime from highly energetic astrophysical events such as mergers of supermassive black hole binaries. The North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) observes dozens of the most stable millisecond pulsars using the Arecibo and Green Bank radio telescopes in an effort to study, among other things, gravitational wave memory. We herein present the results of a search for gravitational wave bursts with memory (BWMs) using the first five years of NANOGrav observations. We develop original methods for dramatically speeding up searches for BWM signals. In the directions of the sky where our sensitivity to BWMs is best, we would detect mergers of binaries with reduced masses of $10^9$ $M_\odot$ out to distances of 30 Mpc; such massive mergers in the Virgo cluster would be marginally detectable. We find no evidence for BWMs. However, with our non-detection, we set upper limits on the rate at which BWMs of various amplitudes could have occurred during the time spanned by our data--e.g., BWMs with amplitudes greater than $10^{-13}$ must occur at a rate less than 1.5 yr$^{-1}$.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
NANOGrav Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Circular Orbits
Authors:
Z. Arzoumanian,
A. Brazier,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
S. J. Chamberlin,
S. Chatterjee,
J. M. Cordes,
P. B. Demorest,
X. Deng,
T. Dolch,
J. A. Ellis,
R. D. Ferdman,
N. Garver-Daniels,
F. Jenet,
G. Jones,
V. M. Kaspi,
M. Koop,
M. Lam,
T. J. W. Lazio,
A. N. Lommen,
D. R. Lorimer,
J. Luo,
R. S. Lynch,
D. R. Madison,
M. McLaughlin,
S. T. McWilliams
, et al. (14 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) project currently observes 43 pulsars using the Green Bank and Arecibo radio telescopes. In this work we use a subset of 17 pulsars timed for a span of roughly five years (2005--2010). We analyze these data using standard pulsar timing models, with the addition of time-variable dispersion measure and frequency-variable pul…
▽ More
The North American Nanohertz Observatory for Gravitational Waves (NANOGrav) project currently observes 43 pulsars using the Green Bank and Arecibo radio telescopes. In this work we use a subset of 17 pulsars timed for a span of roughly five years (2005--2010). We analyze these data using standard pulsar timing models, with the addition of time-variable dispersion measure and frequency-variable pulse shape terms. Within the timing data, we perform a search for continuous gravitational waves from individual supermassive black hole binaries in circular orbits using robust frequentist and Bayesian techniques. We find that there is no evidence for the presence of a detectable continuous gravitational wave; however, we can use these data to place the most constraining upper limits to date on the strength of such gravitational waves. Using the full 17 pulsar dataset we place a 95% upper limit on the sky-averaged strain amplitude of $h_0\lesssim 3.8\times 10^{-14}$ at a frequency of 10 nHz. Furthermore, we place 95% \emph{all sky} lower limits on the luminosity distance to such gravitational wave sources finding that the $d_L \gtrsim 425$ Mpc for sources at a frequency of 10 nHz and chirp mass $10^{10}{\rm M}_{\odot}$. We find that for gravitational wave sources near our best timed pulsars in the sky, the sensitivity of the pulsar timing array is increased by a factor of $\sim$4 over the sky-averaged sensitivity. Finally we place limits on the coalescence rate of the most massive supermassive black hole binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2014; v1 submitted 4 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Practical Methods for Continuous Gravitational Wave Detection using Pulsar Timing Data
Authors:
J. A. Ellis,
F. A. Jenet,
M. A. McLaughlin
Abstract:
Gravitational Waves (GWs) are tiny ripples in the fabric of space-time predicted by Einstein's General Relativity. Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) are well poised to detect low frequency ($10^{-9}$ -- $10^{-7}$ Hz) GWs in the near future. There has been a significant amount of research into the detection of a stochastic background of GWs from supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs). Recent work has…
▽ More
Gravitational Waves (GWs) are tiny ripples in the fabric of space-time predicted by Einstein's General Relativity. Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) are well poised to detect low frequency ($10^{-9}$ -- $10^{-7}$ Hz) GWs in the near future. There has been a significant amount of research into the detection of a stochastic background of GWs from supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs). Recent work has shown that single continuous sources standing out above the background may be detectable by PTAs operating at a sensitivity sufficient to detect the stochastic background. The most likely sources of continuous GWs in the pulsar timing frequency band are extremely massive and/or nearby SMBHBs. In this paper we present detection strategies including various forms of matched filtering and power spectral summing. We determine the efficacy and computational cost of such strategies. It is shown that it is computationally infeasible to use an optimal matched filter including the poorly constrained pulsar distances with a grid based method. We show that an Earth-term-matched filter constructed using only the correlated signal terms is both computationally viable and highly sensitive to GW signals. This technique is only a factor of two less sensitive than the computationally unrealizable optimal matched filter and a factor of two more sensitive than a power spectral summing technique. We further show that a pairwise matched filter, taking the pulsar distances into account is comparable to the optimal matched filter for the single template case and comparable to the Earth-term-matched filter for many search templates. Finally, using simulated data optimal quality, we place a theoretical minimum detectable strain amplitude of $h>2\times 10^{-15}$ from continuous GWs at frequencies on the order $\sim1/T_{\rm obs}$.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
