-
Comparing second-order gravitational self-force and effective-one-body waveforms from inspiralling, quasi-circular black hole binaries with a non-spinning primary and a spinning secondary
Authors:
Angelica Albertini,
Alessandro Nagar,
Josh Mathews,
Georgios Lukes-Gerakopoulos
Abstract:
We present the first comparison of waveforms evaluated using the effective-one-body (EOB) approach and gravitational self-force (GSF) theory for inspiralling black hole binaries with a non-spinning primary and a spinning secondary. This paper belongs to a series of papers comparing the EOB model TEOBResumS to GSF results, where the latter are used to benchmark the EOB analytical choices in the lar…
▽ More
We present the first comparison of waveforms evaluated using the effective-one-body (EOB) approach and gravitational self-force (GSF) theory for inspiralling black hole binaries with a non-spinning primary and a spinning secondary. This paper belongs to a series of papers comparing the EOB model TEOBResumS to GSF results, where the latter are used to benchmark the EOB analytical choices in the large-mass-ratio regime. In this work, we explore the performance of two gauge choices for the gyro-gravitomagnetic functions GS, GS* entering the spin-orbit sector within the EOB dynamics. In particular, we consider the usual gauge of TEOBResumS, where GS and GS* only depend on the inverse radius and the radial momentum, and a different gauge where these functions also depend on the azimuthal momentum. The latter choice allows us to exploit as prefactor in GS* the complete expression GKS* for a spinning particle on Kerr. As done previously, we employ both waveform alignments in the time domain and a gauge-invariant frequency-domain analysis to gain a more complete understanding of the impact of the new analytical choice. The frequency-domain analysis is particularly useful in confirming that the gyro-gravitomagnetic functions in the new chosen gauge bring the EOB spin contribution at 1st post-adiabatic order closer to the GSF one. We finally implement the improved functions within the public code for TEOBResumS-Dalí, which already incorporates eccentricity. In this way, we upgrade the EOB model for extreme-mass-ratio inspirals presented in our previous work.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Waveform Modelling for the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
Authors:
LISA Consortium Waveform Working Group,
Niayesh Afshordi,
Sarp Akçay,
Pau Amaro Seoane,
Andrea Antonelli,
Josu C. Aurrekoetxea,
Leor Barack,
Enrico Barausse,
Robert Benkel,
Laura Bernard,
Sebastiano Bernuzzi,
Emanuele Berti,
Matteo Bonetti,
Béatrice Bonga,
Gabriele Bozzola,
Richard Brito,
Alessandra Buonanno,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Marc Casals,
David F. Chernoff,
Alvin J. K. Chua,
Katy Clough,
Marta Colleoni,
Mekhi Dhesi,
Adrien Druart
, et al. (121 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
LISA, the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, will usher in a new era in gravitational-wave astronomy. As the first anticipated space-based gravitational-wave detector, it will expand our view to the millihertz gravitational-wave sky, where a spectacular variety of interesting new sources abound: from millions of ultra-compact binaries in our Galaxy, to mergers of massive black holes at cosmologic…
▽ More
LISA, the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, will usher in a new era in gravitational-wave astronomy. As the first anticipated space-based gravitational-wave detector, it will expand our view to the millihertz gravitational-wave sky, where a spectacular variety of interesting new sources abound: from millions of ultra-compact binaries in our Galaxy, to mergers of massive black holes at cosmological distances; from the beginnings of inspirals that will venture into the ground-based detectors' view to the death spiral of compact objects into massive black holes, and many sources in between. Central to realising LISA's discovery potential are waveform models, the theoretical and phenomenological predictions of the pattern of gravitational waves that these sources emit. This white paper is presented on behalf of the Waveform Working Group for the LISA Consortium. It provides a review of the current state of waveform models for LISA sources, and describes the significant challenges that must yet be overcome.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023; v1 submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Effective-one-body waveforms for extreme-mass-ratio binaries: Consistency with second-order gravitational self-force quasicircular results and extension to nonprecessing spins and eccentricity
Authors:
Angelica Albertini,
Rossella Gamba,
Alessandro Nagar,
Sebastiano Bernuzzi
Abstract:
We present a first complete implementation of an effective-one-body (EOB) model for extreme-mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs) that incorporates aligned spins (on both the primary and the secondary) as well as orbital eccentricity. The model extends TEOBResumS-Dalí for these binaries by (i) recasting conservative first-order gravitational self-force (1GSF) information in the resummed EOB potentials; (ii…
▽ More
We present a first complete implementation of an effective-one-body (EOB) model for extreme-mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs) that incorporates aligned spins (on both the primary and the secondary) as well as orbital eccentricity. The model extends TEOBResumS-Dalí for these binaries by (i) recasting conservative first-order gravitational self-force (1GSF) information in the resummed EOB potentials; (ii) employing a post-Newtonian (PN) $3^{+19}$PN-accurate (3PN comparable-mass terms hybridized with test-particle terms up to 22PN relative order) expression for the gravitational-wave flux at infinity; (iii) using an improved implementation of the horizon flux that better approximates its test-mass representation. With respect to our previous work [Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 8, 084062], we demonstrate that the inclusion of the $3^{+19}$PN-accurate $\ell=9$ and $\ell=10$ modes in the flux at infinity significantly improves the model's agreement with second-order accurate GSF (2GSF) circular waveforms. For a standard EMRI with mass ratio $q \equiv m_1/m_2 = 5 \times 10^4$ and $m_2 = 10 M_\odot$, the accumulated EOB/2GSF dephasing is $\lesssim $ rad for $\sim 1$ yr of evolution, which is consistent with the standard accuracy requirements for EMRIs. We also showcase the generation of eccentric and spinning waveforms and discuss future extensions of our EOB towards a physically complete model for EMRIs.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2024; v1 submitted 20 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Analytic systematics in next-generation of effective-one-body gravitational waveform models for future observations
Authors:
Alessandro Nagar,
Piero Rettegno,
Rossella Gamba,
Simone Albanesi,
Angelica Albertini,
Sebastiano Bernuzzi
Abstract:
The success of analytic waveform modeling within the effective-one-body (EOB) approach relies on the precise understanding of the physical importance of each technical element included in the model. The urgency of constructing progressively more sophisticated and complete waveform models (e.g. including spin precession and eccentricity) partly defocused the research from a careful comprehension of…
▽ More
The success of analytic waveform modeling within the effective-one-body (EOB) approach relies on the precise understanding of the physical importance of each technical element included in the model. The urgency of constructing progressively more sophisticated and complete waveform models (e.g. including spin precession and eccentricity) partly defocused the research from a careful comprehension of each building block (e.g. Hamiltonian, radiation reaction, ringdown attachment). Here we go back to the spirit of the first EOB works. We focus first on nonspinning, quasi-circular, black hole binaries and analyze systematically the mutual synergy between numerical relativity (NR) informed functions and the high post-Newtonian corrections (up to 5PN) to the EOB potentials. Our main finding is that it is essential to correctly control the noncircular part of the dynamics during the late plunge up to merger. We then improve the {\tt TEOBResumS-GIOTTO} waveform model for quasi-circular, spin-aligned black hole binaries. We obtain maximal EOB/NR unfaithfulness ${\bar{F}}^{\rm max}_{\rm EOBNR}\sim 10^{-3}$ (with Advanced LIGO noise and in the total mass range $10-200M_\odot$) for the dominant $\ell=m=2$ mode all over the 534 spin-aligned configurations available through the Simulating eXtreme Spacetime catalog. The model performance, also including higher modes, is then explored using the NR surrogates \nrsurqeight{} and \nrsurqfifteen, to validate it up to mass ratio $m_1/m_2=15$. We find that, over the set of configurations considered, more than $98\%$ of the total-mass-maximized unfaithfulness lie below the $3\%$ threshold when comparing to the surrogate models.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2023; v1 submitted 19 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Comparing second-order gravitational self-force and effective one body waveforms from inspiralling, quasi-circular and nonspinning black hole binaries II: the large-mass-ratio case
Authors:
Angelica Albertini,
Alessandro Nagar,
Adam Pound,
Niels Warburton,
Barry Wardell,
Leanne Durkan,
Jeremy Miller
Abstract:
We compare recently computed waveforms from second-order gravitational self-force (GSF) theory to those generated by a new, GSF-informed, effective one body (EOB) waveform model for (spin-aligned, eccentric) inspiralling black hole binaries with large mass ratios. We focus on quasi-circular, nonspinning, configurations and perform detailed GSF/EOB waveform phasing comparisons, either in the time d…
▽ More
We compare recently computed waveforms from second-order gravitational self-force (GSF) theory to those generated by a new, GSF-informed, effective one body (EOB) waveform model for (spin-aligned, eccentric) inspiralling black hole binaries with large mass ratios. We focus on quasi-circular, nonspinning, configurations and perform detailed GSF/EOB waveform phasing comparisons, either in the time domain or via the gauge-invariant dimensionless function $Q_ω\equiv ω^2/\dotω$, where $ω$ is the gravitational wave frequency. The inclusion of high-PN test-mass terms within the EOB radiation reaction (notably, up to 22PN) is crucial to achieve an EOB/GSF phasing agreement below 1~rad up to the end of the inspiral for mass ratios up to 500. For larger mass ratios, up to $5\times 10^4$, the contribution of horizon absorption becomes more and more important and needs to be accurately modeled. Our results indicate that our GSF-informed EOB waveform model is a promising tool to describe waveforms generated by either intermediate or extreme mass ratio inspirals for future gravitational wave detectors
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2022; v1 submitted 3 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Comparing second-order gravitational self-force, numerical relativity and effective one body waveforms from inspiralling, quasi-circular and nonspinning black hole binaries
Authors:
Angelica Albertini,
Alessandro Nagar,
Adam Pound,
Niels Warburton,
Barry Wardell,
Leanne Durkan,
Jeremy Miller
Abstract:
We present the first systematic comparison between gravitational waveforms emitted by inspiralling, quasi-circular and nonspinning black hole binaries computed with three different approaches: second-order gravitational self-force (2GSF) theory, as implemented in the 1PAT1 model; numerical relativity (NR), as implemented by the SXS collaboration; and the effective one body (EOB) formalism, as impl…
▽ More
We present the first systematic comparison between gravitational waveforms emitted by inspiralling, quasi-circular and nonspinning black hole binaries computed with three different approaches: second-order gravitational self-force (2GSF) theory, as implemented in the 1PAT1 model; numerical relativity (NR), as implemented by the SXS collaboration; and the effective one body (EOB) formalism, as implemented in the TEOBResumS waveform model. To compare the models we use both a standard, time-domain waveform alignment and a gauge-invariant analysis based on the dimensionless function $Q_ω(ω)\equiv ω^2/\dotω$, where $ω$ is the gravitational wave frequency. We analyse the domain of validity of the 1PAT1 model, deriving error estimates and showing that the effects of the final transition to plunge, which the model neglects, extend over a significantly larger frequency interval than one might expect. Restricting to the inspiral regime, we find that, while for mass ratios $q = m_1/m_2\le 10$ TEOBResumS is largely indistinguishable from NR, 1PAT1 has a significant dephasing $\gtrsim 1$rad; conversely, for $q\gtrsim 100$, 1PAT1 is estimated to have phase errors $<0.1$rad on a large frequency interval, while TEOBResumS develops phase differences $\gtrsim1$rad with it. Most crucially, on that same large frequency interval we find good agreement between TEOBResumS and 1PAT1 in the intermediate regime $15\lesssim q\lesssim 64$, with $<0.5$rad dephasing between them. A simple modification to the TEOBResumS flux further improves this agreement for $q\gtrsim 30$, reducing the dephasing to $\approx0.27$rad even at $q=128$. Our results pave the way for the construction of GSF-informed EOB models for both intermediate and extreme mass ratio inspirals for the next generation of gravitational wave detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2022; v1 submitted 1 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Numerical-relativity validation of effective-one-body waveforms in the intermediate-mass-ratio regime
Authors:
Alessandro Nagar,
James Healy,
Carlos O. Lousto,
Sebastiano Bernuzzi,
Angelica Albertini
Abstract:
One of the open problems in developing binary black hole (BBH) waveforms for gravitational wave astronomy is to model the intermediate mass ratio regime and connect it to the extreme mass ratio regime. A natural approach is to employ the effective one body (EOB) approach to the two-body dynamics that, by design, can cover the entire mass ratio range and naturally incorporates the extreme mass rati…
▽ More
One of the open problems in developing binary black hole (BBH) waveforms for gravitational wave astronomy is to model the intermediate mass ratio regime and connect it to the extreme mass ratio regime. A natural approach is to employ the effective one body (EOB) approach to the two-body dynamics that, by design, can cover the entire mass ratio range and naturally incorporates the extreme mass ratio limit. Here we use recently obtained numerical relativity (NR) data with mass ratios $m_1/m_2=(7,15,\,32,\,64,\,128)$ to test the accuracy of the state-of-the-art EOB model TEOBResumS in the intermediate mass ratio regime. We generally find an excellent EOB/NR consistency around merger and ringdown for all mass ratios and for all available subdominant multipoles, except for the $\ell=m=5$ one. This mode can be crucially improved using the new large-mass ratio NR data of this paper. The EOB/NR inspirals are also consistent with the estimated NR uncertainties. We also use several NR datasets taken by different public catalogs to probe the universal behavior of the multipolar hierarchy of waveform amplitudes at merger, that smoothly connects the equal-mass BBH to the test-mass result. Interestingly, the universal behavior is strengthened if the nonoscillatory memory contribution is included in the NR waveform. Future NR simulations with improved accuracy will be necessary to further probe, and possibly quantitatively refine, the TEOBResumS transition from late inspiral to plunge in the intermediate mass ratio regime.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Waveforms and fluxes: Towards a self-consistent effective one body waveform model for nonprecessing, coalescing black-hole binaries for third generation detectors
Authors:
Angelica Albertini,
Alessandro Nagar,
Piero Rettegno,
Simone Albanesi,
Rossella Gamba
Abstract:
We present a comprehensive comparison between numerical relativity (NR) angular momentum fluxes at infinity and the corresponding quantity entering the radiation reaction in TEOBResumS, an Effective-One-Body (EOB) waveform model for nonprecessing coalescing black hole binaries on quasi-circular orbits. This comparison prompted us to implement two changes in the model: (i) including Next-to-Quasi-C…
▽ More
We present a comprehensive comparison between numerical relativity (NR) angular momentum fluxes at infinity and the corresponding quantity entering the radiation reaction in TEOBResumS, an Effective-One-Body (EOB) waveform model for nonprecessing coalescing black hole binaries on quasi-circular orbits. This comparison prompted us to implement two changes in the model: (i) including Next-to-Quasi-Circular corrections in the $\ell=m$, $\ell\leq 5$ multipoles entering the radiation reaction and (ii) consequently updating the NR-informed spin-orbital sector of the model. This yields a new waveform model that presents a higher self-consistency between waveform and dynamics and an improved agreement with NR simulations. We test the model computing the EOB/NR unfaithfulness $\bar{F}_{\rm EOB/NR}$ over all 534 spin-aligned configurations available through the Simulating eXtreme Spacetime catalog, notably using the noise spectral density of Advanced LIGO, Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer, for total mass up to $500M_\odot$. We find that the maximum unfaithfulness $\bar{F}^{\rm max}_{\rm EOB/NR}$ is mostly between $10^{-4}$ and $10^{-3}$, and the performance progressively worsens up to $\sim 5\times 10^{-3}$ as the effective spin of the system is increased. We perform similar analyses on the \SEOB{} model, that delivers $\bar{F}^{\rm max}_{\rm EOB/NR}$ values uniformly distributed versus effective spin and mostly between $10^{-3}$ and $10^{-2}$. We conclude that the improved TEOBResumS model already represents a reliable and robust first step towards the development of highly accurate waveform templates for third generation detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
TEOBResumS: assessment of consistent next-to-quasicircular corrections and post-adiabatic approximation in multipolar binary black holes waveforms
Authors:
Gunnar Riemenschneider,
Piero Rettegno,
Matteo Breschi,
Angelica Albertini,
Rossella Gamba,
Sebastiano Bernuzzi,
Alessandro Nagar
Abstract:
The use of effective-one-body (EOB) waveforms for black hole binaries analysis in gravitational-wave astronomy requires faithful models and fast generation times. A key aspect to achieve faithfulness is the inclusion of numerical-relativity (NR) informed next-to-quasicircular corrections(NQC), dependent on the radial momentum, to the waveform and radiation reaction. A robust method to speed up the…
▽ More
The use of effective-one-body (EOB) waveforms for black hole binaries analysis in gravitational-wave astronomy requires faithful models and fast generation times. A key aspect to achieve faithfulness is the inclusion of numerical-relativity (NR) informed next-to-quasicircular corrections(NQC), dependent on the radial momentum, to the waveform and radiation reaction. A robust method to speed up the waveform generation is the post-adiabatic iteration to approximate the solution of the EOB Hamiltonian equations. In this work, we assess the performances of a fast NQC prescription in combination to the post-adiabatic method for generating multipolar gravitational waves. The outlined approach allows a consistent treatment of NQC in both the waveform and the radiation-reaction, does not require iterative procedures to achieve high faithfulness, and can be efficiently employed for parameter estimation. Comparing to 611 NR simulations, for total mass $10M_\odot\leq M \leq 200M_\odot$ and using the Advanded LIGO noise, the model has EOB/NR unfaithfulness well below $0.01$, with 78.5\% of the cases below $0.001$. We apply the model to the parameter estimation of GW150914 exploring the impact of the new NQC and of the higher modes up to $\ell=m=8$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2021; v1 submitted 15 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.