-
Hybrid single-electron turnstiles with thick superconducting electrodes for improved quasiparticle relaxation
Authors:
J. T. Peltonen,
A. Moisio,
V. F. Maisi,
M. Meschke,
J. S. Tsai,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We demonstrate shadow evaporation-based fabrication of high-quality ultrasmall normal metal -- insulator -- superconductor tunnel junctions where the thickness of the superconducting electrode is not limited by the requirement of small junction size. The junctions are formed between a film of manganese-doped aluminium acting as the normal conducting electrode, covered by a thicker, superconducting…
▽ More
We demonstrate shadow evaporation-based fabrication of high-quality ultrasmall normal metal -- insulator -- superconductor tunnel junctions where the thickness of the superconducting electrode is not limited by the requirement of small junction size. The junctions are formed between a film of manganese-doped aluminium acting as the normal conducting electrode, covered by a thicker, superconducting layer of pure Al. We characterize the junctions by sub-gap current--voltage measurements and charge pumping measurements in a gate-driven hybrid single-electron transistor, operated as a turnstile for single electrons. The technique allows to advance towards turnstiles with close to ideally thermalized superconducting reservoirs, prerequisite for reaching metrological current quantization accuracy in a hybrid turnstile. We further present an alternative way to realize small junctions with thick Al leads based on multi-angle deposition. The work enables the future investigation of turnstiles based on superconductors other than Al, and benefits various other Al tunnel junction devices for which quasiparticle thermalization is essential.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
On-and-off chip cooling of a Coulomb blockade thermometer down to 2.8 mK
Authors:
M. Palma,
C. P. Scheller,
D. Maradan,
A. V. Feshchenko,
M. Meschke,
D. M. Zumbühl
Abstract:
Cooling nanoelectronic devices below 10 mK is a great challenge since thermal conductivities become very small, thus creating a pronounced sensitivity to heat leaks. Here, we overcome these difficulties by using adiabatic demagnetization of \emph{both} the electronic leads \emph{and} the large metallic islands of a Coulomb blockade thermometer. This reduces the external heat leak through the leads…
▽ More
Cooling nanoelectronic devices below 10 mK is a great challenge since thermal conductivities become very small, thus creating a pronounced sensitivity to heat leaks. Here, we overcome these difficulties by using adiabatic demagnetization of \emph{both} the electronic leads \emph{and} the large metallic islands of a Coulomb blockade thermometer. This reduces the external heat leak through the leads and also provides on-chip refrigeration, together cooling the thermometer down to 2.8$\pm$0.1 mK. We present a thermal model which gives a good qualitative account and suggests that the main limitation is heating due to pulse tube vibrations. With better decoupling, temperatures below 1 mK should be within reach, thus opening the door for microkelvin nanoelectronics.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Nanosecond thermometry with Josephson junction
Authors:
M. Zgirski,
M. Foltyn,
A. Savin,
M. Meschke,
J. Pekola
Abstract:
We demonstrate a novel approach to thermometry at the nanoscale exploiting a superconducting weak link. Such a weak link probed with nanosecond current pulses serves as a temperature sensing element and, due to the fast inherent dynamics, is capable of delivering unprecedented temporal resolution. We employ the thermometer to measure dynamic temperature of electrons in a long superconducting wire…
▽ More
We demonstrate a novel approach to thermometry at the nanoscale exploiting a superconducting weak link. Such a weak link probed with nanosecond current pulses serves as a temperature sensing element and, due to the fast inherent dynamics, is capable of delivering unprecedented temporal resolution. We employ the thermometer to measure dynamic temperature of electrons in a long superconducting wire relaxing to the bath temperature after application of the heating pulse. Our measurement delivers nanosecond resolution thus providing the proof-of-concept of the fastest-todate all-solid-state thermometry. Our method improves the state-of-the-art temporal resolution of mesoscopic thermometry by at least two orders of magnitude, extending temporal resolution of existing experiments and introducing new possibilities for ultra-sensitive calorimeters and radiation detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Thermal Conductance of a Single-Electron Transistor
Authors:
B. Dutta,
J. T. Peltonen,
D. S. Antonenko,
M. Meschke,
M. A. Skvortsov,
B. Kubala,
J. König,
C. B. Winkelmann,
H. Courtois,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We report on combined measurements of heat and charge transport through a single-electron transistor. The device acts as a heat switch actuated by the voltage applied on the gate. The Wiedemann-Franz law for the ratio of heat and charge conductances is found to be systematically violated away from the charge degeneracy points. The observed deviation agrees well with the theoretical expectation. Wi…
▽ More
We report on combined measurements of heat and charge transport through a single-electron transistor. The device acts as a heat switch actuated by the voltage applied on the gate. The Wiedemann-Franz law for the ratio of heat and charge conductances is found to be systematically violated away from the charge degeneracy points. The observed deviation agrees well with the theoretical expectation. With large temperature drop between the source and drain, the heat current away from degeneracy deviates from the standard quadratic dependence in the two temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Traceable Coulomb Blockade Thermometry
Authors:
Ossi Hahtela,
Emma Mykkanen,
Antti Kemppinen,
Matthias Meschke,
Mika Prunnila,
David Gunnarsson,
Leif Roschier,
Jari Penttila,
Jukka Pekola
Abstract:
We present a measurement and analysis scheme for determining traceable thermodynamic temperature at cryogenic temperatures using Coulomb blockade thermometry. The uncertainty of the electrical measurement is improved by utilizing two sampling digital voltmeters instead of the traditional lock-in technique. The remaining uncertainty is dominated by that of the numerical analysis of the measurement…
▽ More
We present a measurement and analysis scheme for determining traceable thermodynamic temperature at cryogenic temperatures using Coulomb blockade thermometry. The uncertainty of the electrical measurement is improved by utilizing two sampling digital voltmeters instead of the traditional lock-in technique. The remaining uncertainty is dominated by that of the numerical analysis of the measurement data. Two analysis methods are demonstrated: numerical fitting of the full conductance curve and measuring the height of the conductance dip. The complete uncertainty analysis shows that using either analysis method the relative combined standard uncertainty (k = 1) in determining the thermodynamic temperature in the temperature range from 20 mK to 200 mK is below 0.5 %. In this temperature range, both analysis methods produced temperature estimates that deviated from 0.39 % to 0.67 % from the reference temperatures provided by a superconducting reference point device calibrated against the Provisional Low Temperature Scale of 2000.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2016; v1 submitted 22 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
A cascade electronic refrigerator using superconducting tunnel junctions
Authors:
H. Q. Nguyen,
J. T. Peltonen,
M. Meschke,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
Micro-refrigerators that operate in the sub-kelvin regime are a key device in quantum technology. A well-studied candidate, an electronic cooler using Normal metal - Insulator - Superconductor (NIS) tunnel junctions offers substantial performance and power. However, its superconducting electrodes are severely overheated due to exponential suppression of their thermal conductance towards low temper…
▽ More
Micro-refrigerators that operate in the sub-kelvin regime are a key device in quantum technology. A well-studied candidate, an electronic cooler using Normal metal - Insulator - Superconductor (NIS) tunnel junctions offers substantial performance and power. However, its superconducting electrodes are severely overheated due to exponential suppression of their thermal conductance towards low temperatures, and the cooler performs unsatisfactorily - especially in powerful devices needed for practical applications. We employ a second NIS cooling stage to thermalize the hot superconductor at the backside of the main NIS cooler. Not only providing a lower bath temperature, the second stage cooler actively evacuates quasiparticles out of the hot superconductor, especially in the low temperature limit. The NIS cooler approaches its ideal theoretical expectations without compromising cooling power. This cascade design can also be employed to manage excess heat in other cryo-electronic devices.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Accurate Coulomb Blockade Thermometry up to 60 Kelvin
Authors:
M. Meschke,
A. Kemppinen,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We demonstrate experimentally a precise realization of Coulomb Blockade Thermometry (CBT) working at temperatures up to 60 K. Advances in nano fabrication methods using electron beam lithography allow us to fabricate a uniform arrays of sufficiently small tunnel junctions to guarantee an overall temperature reading uncertainty of about 1\%
We demonstrate experimentally a precise realization of Coulomb Blockade Thermometry (CBT) working at temperatures up to 60 K. Advances in nano fabrication methods using electron beam lithography allow us to fabricate a uniform arrays of sufficiently small tunnel junctions to guarantee an overall temperature reading uncertainty of about 1\%
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Quasiparticle trapping in Meissner and vortex states of mesoscopic superconductors
Authors:
M. Taupin,
I. M. Khaymovich,
M. Meschke,
A. S. Mel'nikov,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
Nowadays superconductors serve in numerous applications, from high-field magnets to ultra-sensitive detectors of radiation. Mesoscopic superconducting devices, i.e. those with nanoscale dimensions, are in a special position as they are easily driven out of equilibrium under typical operating conditions. The out-of-equilibrium superconductors are characterized by non-equilibrium quasiparticles. The…
▽ More
Nowadays superconductors serve in numerous applications, from high-field magnets to ultra-sensitive detectors of radiation. Mesoscopic superconducting devices, i.e. those with nanoscale dimensions, are in a special position as they are easily driven out of equilibrium under typical operating conditions. The out-of-equilibrium superconductors are characterized by non-equilibrium quasiparticles. These extra excitations can compromise the performance of mesoscopic devices by introducing, e.g., leakage currents or decreased coherence times in quantum devices. By applying an external magnetic field, one can conveniently suppress or redistribute the population of excess quasiparticles. In this article we present an experimental demonstration and a theoretical analysis of such effective control of quasiparticles, resulting in electron cooling both in the Meissner and vortex states of a mesoscopic superconductor. We introduce a theoretical model of quasiparticle dynamics which is in quantitative agreement with the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2016; v1 submitted 30 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Tunnel-Junction Thermometry Down to Millikelvin Temperatures
Authors:
A. V. Feshchenko,
L. Casparis,
I. M. Khaymovich,
D. Maradan,
O. -P. Saira,
M. Palma,
M. Meschke,
J. P. Pekola,
D. M. Zumbühl
Abstract:
We present a simple on-chip electronic thermometer with the potential to operate down to 1 mK. It is based on transport through a single normal-metal - superconductor tunnel junction with rapidly widening leads. The current through the junction is determined by the temperature of the normal electrode that is efficiently thermalized to the phonon bath, and it is virtually insensitive to the tempera…
▽ More
We present a simple on-chip electronic thermometer with the potential to operate down to 1 mK. It is based on transport through a single normal-metal - superconductor tunnel junction with rapidly widening leads. The current through the junction is determined by the temperature of the normal electrode that is efficiently thermalized to the phonon bath, and it is virtually insensitive to the temperature of the superconductor, even when the latter is relatively far from equilibrium. We demonstrate here the operation of the device down to 7 mK and present a systematic thermal analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2015; v1 submitted 15 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
A robust platform cooled by superconducting electronic refrigerators
Authors:
Hung Q. Nguyen,
Matthias Meschke,
Jukka P. Pekola
Abstract:
A biased tunnel junction between a superconductor and a normal metal can cool the latter electrode. Based on a recently developed cooler with high power and superior performance, we have successfully integrated it with a dielectric silicon nitride membrane, and cooled phonons from 305 mK down to 200 mK. Without perforation and covered under a thin alumina layer, the membrane is rigorously transfor…
▽ More
A biased tunnel junction between a superconductor and a normal metal can cool the latter electrode. Based on a recently developed cooler with high power and superior performance, we have successfully integrated it with a dielectric silicon nitride membrane, and cooled phonons from 305 mK down to 200 mK. Without perforation and covered under a thin alumina layer, the membrane is rigorously transformed into a cooling platform that is robust and versatile for multiple practical purposes. We discuss our results and possibilities to further improve the device.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2015; v1 submitted 24 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Fast electron thermometry towards ultra-sensitive calorimetric detection
Authors:
S. Gasparinetti,
K. L. Viisanen,
O. -P. Saira,
T. Faivre,
M. Arzeo,
M. Meschke,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We demonstrate radiofrequency thermometry on a micrometer-sized metallic island below 100 mK. Our device is based on a normal metal-insulator-superconductor tunnel junction coupled to a resonator with transmission readout. In the first generation of the device, we achieve 90 μK/Hz^1/2 noise-equivalent temperature with 10 MHz bandwidth. We measure the thermal relaxation time of the electron gas in…
▽ More
We demonstrate radiofrequency thermometry on a micrometer-sized metallic island below 100 mK. Our device is based on a normal metal-insulator-superconductor tunnel junction coupled to a resonator with transmission readout. In the first generation of the device, we achieve 90 μK/Hz^1/2 noise-equivalent temperature with 10 MHz bandwidth. We measure the thermal relaxation time of the electron gas in the island, which we find to be of the order of 100 μs. Such a calorimetric detector, upon optimization, can be seamlessly integrated into superconducting circuits, with immediate applications in quantum-thermodynamics experiments down to single quanta of energy.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2014; v1 submitted 29 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Silver-Epoxy Microwave Filters and Thermalizers for Millikelvin Experiments
Authors:
C. P. Scheller,
S. Heizmann,
K. Bedner,
D. Giss,
M. Meschke,
D. M. Zumbühl,
J. D. Zimmerman,
A. C. Gossard
Abstract:
We present Silver-epoxy filters combining excellent microwave attenuation with efficient wire thermalization, suitable for low temperature quantum transport experiments. Upon minimizing parasitic capacitances, the attenuation reaches >100 dB above ~150 MHz and - when capacitors are added - already above ~30 MHz. We measure the device electron temperature with a GaAs quantum dot and demonstrate exc…
▽ More
We present Silver-epoxy filters combining excellent microwave attenuation with efficient wire thermalization, suitable for low temperature quantum transport experiments. Upon minimizing parasitic capacitances, the attenuation reaches >100 dB above ~150 MHz and - when capacitors are added - already above ~30 MHz. We measure the device electron temperature with a GaAs quantum dot and demonstrate excellent filter performance. Upon improving the sample holder and adding a second filtering stage, we obtain electron temperatures as low as 7.5 +/- 0.2 mK in metallic Coulomb blockade thermometers.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Sub-50 mK electronic cooling with large-area superconducting tunnel junctions
Authors:
H. Q. Nguyen,
M. Meschke,
H. Courtois,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
In electronic cooling with superconducting tunnel junctions, the cooling power is counterbalanced by the interaction with phonons and by the heat flow from the overheated leads. We study aluminium-based coolers that are equipped with a suspended normal metal and an efficient quasi-particle drain. At intermediate temperatures, the phonon bath of the suspended normal metal is cooled. At lower temper…
▽ More
In electronic cooling with superconducting tunnel junctions, the cooling power is counterbalanced by the interaction with phonons and by the heat flow from the overheated leads. We study aluminium-based coolers that are equipped with a suspended normal metal and an efficient quasi-particle drain. At intermediate temperatures, the phonon bath of the suspended normal metal is cooled. At lower temperatures, by adjusting the junction transparency, we control the injection current, and thus the superconductor temperature. The device shows a strong cooling from 150 mK down to about 30 mK, a factor of five in temperature. We suggest that spatial non-uniformity in the superconductor gap limits the cooling toward lower temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2014; v1 submitted 24 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Non-hysteretic superconducting quantum interference proximity transistor with enhanced responsivity
Authors:
Robab Najafi Jabdaraghi,
Matthias Meschke,
Jukka Pekola
Abstract:
This letter presents fabrication and characterization of an optimized SQUIPT (superconducting quantum interference proximity transistor). The present device, characterized with reduced tunnel junction area and shortened normal-metal section, demonstrates no hysteresis at low temperatures as we increased the Josephson inductance of the weak link by decreasing its cross section. It has consequently…
▽ More
This letter presents fabrication and characterization of an optimized SQUIPT (superconducting quantum interference proximity transistor). The present device, characterized with reduced tunnel junction area and shortened normal-metal section, demonstrates no hysteresis at low temperatures as we increased the Josephson inductance of the weak link by decreasing its cross section. It has consequently almost an order of magnitude improved magnetic field responsivity as compared to the earlier design. The modulation of both the current and the voltage across the junction have been measured as a function of magnetic flux piercing the superconducting loop.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Trapping hot quasi-particles in a high-power superconducting electronic cooler
Authors:
H. Q. Nguyen,
T. Aref,
V. J. Kauppila,
M. Meschke,
C. B. Winkelmann,
H. Courtois,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
The performance of hybrid superconducting electronic coolers is usually limited by the accumulation of hot quasi-particles in the superconducting leads. This issue is all the more stringent in large-scale and high-power devices, as required by applications. Introducing a metallic drain connected to the superconducting electrodes via a fine-tuned tunnel barrier, we efficiently remove quasi-particle…
▽ More
The performance of hybrid superconducting electronic coolers is usually limited by the accumulation of hot quasi-particles in the superconducting leads. This issue is all the more stringent in large-scale and high-power devices, as required by applications. Introducing a metallic drain connected to the superconducting electrodes via a fine-tuned tunnel barrier, we efficiently remove quasi-particles and obtain electronic cooling from 300 mK down to 130 mK with a 400 pW cooling power. A simple thermal model accounts for the experimental observations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2013; v1 submitted 5 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Primary thermometry in the intermediate Coulomb blockade regime
Authors:
A. V. Feshchenko,
M. Meschke,
D. Gunnarsson,
M. Prunnila,
L. Roschier,
J. S. Penttilä,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We investigate Coulomb blockade thermometers (CBT) in an intermediate temperature regime, where measurements with enhanced accuracy are possible due to the increased magnitude of the differential conductance dip. Previous theoretical results show that corrections to the half width and to the depth of the measured conductance dip of a sensor are needed, when leaving the regime of weak Coulomb block…
▽ More
We investigate Coulomb blockade thermometers (CBT) in an intermediate temperature regime, where measurements with enhanced accuracy are possible due to the increased magnitude of the differential conductance dip. Previous theoretical results show that corrections to the half width and to the depth of the measured conductance dip of a sensor are needed, when leaving the regime of weak Coulomb blockade towards lower temperatures. In the present work, we demonstrate experimentally that the temperature range of a CBT sensor can be extended by employing these corrections without compromising the primary nature or the accuracy of the thermometer.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2013; v1 submitted 4 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Micrometre-scale refrigerators
Authors:
Juha T. Muhonen,
Matthias Meschke,
Jukka P. Pekola
Abstract:
A superconductor with a gap in the density of states or a quantum dot with discrete energy levels is a central building block in realizing an electronic on-chip cooler. They can work as energy filters, allowing only hot quasiparticles to tunnel out from the electrode to be cooled. This principle has been employed experimentally since the early 1990s in investigations and demonstrations of micromet…
▽ More
A superconductor with a gap in the density of states or a quantum dot with discrete energy levels is a central building block in realizing an electronic on-chip cooler. They can work as energy filters, allowing only hot quasiparticles to tunnel out from the electrode to be cooled. This principle has been employed experimentally since the early 1990s in investigations and demonstrations of micrometre-scale coolers at sub-kelvin temperatures. In this paper, we review the basic experimental conditions in realizing the coolers and the main practical issues that are known to limit their performance. We give an update of experiments performed on cryogenic micrometre-scale coolers in the past five years.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Metallic Coulomb Blockade Thermometry down to 10 mK and below
Authors:
L. Casparis,
M. Meschke,
D. Maradan,
A. C. Clark,
C. Scheller,
K. K. Schwarzwalder,
J. P. Pekola,
D. M. Zumbuhl
Abstract:
We present an improved nuclear refrigerator reaching 0.3 mK, aimed at microkelvin nanoelectronic experiments, and use it to investigate metallic Coulomb blockade thermometers (CBTs) with various resistances R. The high-R devices cool to slightly lower T, consistent with better isolation from the noise environment, and exhibit electron-phonon cooling ~ T^5 and a residual heat-leak of 40 aW. In cont…
▽ More
We present an improved nuclear refrigerator reaching 0.3 mK, aimed at microkelvin nanoelectronic experiments, and use it to investigate metallic Coulomb blockade thermometers (CBTs) with various resistances R. The high-R devices cool to slightly lower T, consistent with better isolation from the noise environment, and exhibit electron-phonon cooling ~ T^5 and a residual heat-leak of 40 aW. In contrast, the low-R CBTs display cooling with a clearly weaker T-dependence, deviating from the electronphonon mechanism. The CBTs agree excellently with the refrigerator temperature above 20 mK and reach a minimum-T of 7.5 +/- 0.2 mK.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2012; v1 submitted 8 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Magnetic-Field-Induced Stabilization of Non-Equilibrium Superconductivity
Authors:
J. T. Peltonen,
J. T. Muhonen,
M. Meschke,
N. B. Kopnin,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
A small magnetic field is found to enhance relaxation processes in a superconductor thus stabilizing superconductivity in non-equilibrium conditions. In a normal-metal (N) - insulator - superconductor (S) tunnel junction, applying a field of the order of 100 μT leads to significantly improved cooling of the N island by quasiparticle (QP) tunneling. These findings are attributed to faster QP relaxa…
▽ More
A small magnetic field is found to enhance relaxation processes in a superconductor thus stabilizing superconductivity in non-equilibrium conditions. In a normal-metal (N) - insulator - superconductor (S) tunnel junction, applying a field of the order of 100 μT leads to significantly improved cooling of the N island by quasiparticle (QP) tunneling. These findings are attributed to faster QP relaxation within the S electrodes as a result of enhanced QP drain through regions with locally suppressed energy gap due to magnetic vortices in the S leads at some distance from the junction.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Tunnel Spectroscopy of a Proximity Josephson Junction
Authors:
M. Meschke,
J. T. Peltonen,
J. P. Pekola,
F. Giazotto
Abstract:
We present tunnel spectroscopy experiments on the proximity effect in lateral superconductor-normal metal-superconductor (SNS) Josephson junctions. Our weak link is embedded into a superconducting (S) ring allowing phase biasing of the Josephson junction by an external magnetic field. We explore the temperature and phase dependence of both the induced mini-gap and the modification of the density o…
▽ More
We present tunnel spectroscopy experiments on the proximity effect in lateral superconductor-normal metal-superconductor (SNS) Josephson junctions. Our weak link is embedded into a superconducting (S) ring allowing phase biasing of the Josephson junction by an external magnetic field. We explore the temperature and phase dependence of both the induced mini-gap and the modification of the density of states in the normal (N) metal. Our results agree with a model based on the quasiclassical theory in the diffusive limit. The device presents an advanced version of the superconducting quantum interference proximity transistor (SQUIPT), now reaching flux sensitivities of 3 nA$/Φ_0$ where $Φ_0$ is the flux quantum.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
Laterally proximized aluminum tunnel junctions
Authors:
J. V. Koski,
J. T. Peltonen,
M. Meschke,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
This letter presents experiments on junctions fabricated by a new technique that enables the use of high quality aluminum oxide tunnel barriers with normal metal electrodes at low temperatures. Inverse proximity effect is applied to diminish the superconductivity of an aluminum dot through a clean lateral connection to a normal metal electrode. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this method, full…
▽ More
This letter presents experiments on junctions fabricated by a new technique that enables the use of high quality aluminum oxide tunnel barriers with normal metal electrodes at low temperatures. Inverse proximity effect is applied to diminish the superconductivity of an aluminum dot through a clean lateral connection to a normal metal electrode. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this method, fully normal-state single electron transistors (SET) and normal metal-insulator-superconductor (NIS) junctions applying proximized Al junctions were fabricated. The transport characteristics of the junctions were similar to those obtained from standard theoretical models of regular SETs and NIS junctions.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.
-
Ex-situ Tunnel Junction Process Technique Characterized by Coulomb Blockade Thermometry
Authors:
M. Prunnila,
M. Meschke,
D. Gunnarsson,
S. Enouz-Vedrenne,
J. M. Kivioja,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We investigate a wafer scale tunnel junction fabrication method, where a plasma etched via through a dielectric layer covering bottom Al electrode defines the tunnel junction area. The ex-situ tunnel barrier is formed by oxidation of the bottom electrode in the junction area. Room temperature resistance mapping over a 150 mm wafer give local deviation values of the tunnel junction resistance that…
▽ More
We investigate a wafer scale tunnel junction fabrication method, where a plasma etched via through a dielectric layer covering bottom Al electrode defines the tunnel junction area. The ex-situ tunnel barrier is formed by oxidation of the bottom electrode in the junction area. Room temperature resistance mapping over a 150 mm wafer give local deviation values of the tunnel junction resistance that fall below 7.5 % with an average of 1.3 %. The deviation is further investigated by sub-1 K measurements of a device, which has one tunnel junction connected to four arrays consisting of N junctions (N = 41, junction diameter 700 nm). The differential conductance is measured in single-junction and array Coulomb blockade thermometer operation modes. By fitting the experimental data to the theoretical models we found an upper limit for the local tunnel junction resistance deviation of ~5 % for the array of 2N+1 junctions. This value is of the same order as the minimum detectable deviation defined by the accuracy of our experimental setup.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Comparison of Coulomb Blockade Thermometers with the International Temperature Scale PLTS-2000
Authors:
Matthias Meschke,
Jost Engert,
Dieter Heyer,
Jukka P. Pekola
Abstract:
The operation of the primary Coulomb blockade thermometer (CBT) is based on a measurement of bias voltage dependent conductance of arrays of tunnel junctions between normal metal electrodes. Here we report on a comparison of a CBT with a high accuracy realization of the PLTS-2000 temperature scale in the range from 0.008 K to 0.65 K. An overall agreement of about 1% was found for temperatures abov…
▽ More
The operation of the primary Coulomb blockade thermometer (CBT) is based on a measurement of bias voltage dependent conductance of arrays of tunnel junctions between normal metal electrodes. Here we report on a comparison of a CBT with a high accuracy realization of the PLTS-2000 temperature scale in the range from 0.008 K to 0.65 K. An overall agreement of about 1% was found for temperatures above 0.25 K. For lower temperatures increasing differences are caused by thermalization problems which are accounted for by numerical calculations based on electron-phonon decoupling.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Thermal conductance of a proximity superconductor
Authors:
J. T. Peltonen,
P. Virtanen,
M. Meschke,
J. V. Koski,
T. T. Heikkilä,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We study heat transport in hybrid normal metal - superconductor - normal metal (NSN) structures. We find the thermal conductance of a short superconducting wire to be strongly enhanced beyond the BCS value due to inverse proximity effect. The measurements agree with a model based on the quasiclassical theory of superconductivity in the diffusive limit. We determine a crossover temperature below wh…
▽ More
We study heat transport in hybrid normal metal - superconductor - normal metal (NSN) structures. We find the thermal conductance of a short superconducting wire to be strongly enhanced beyond the BCS value due to inverse proximity effect. The measurements agree with a model based on the quasiclassical theory of superconductivity in the diffusive limit. We determine a crossover temperature below which quasiparticle heat conduction dominates over the electron-phonon relaxation.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2010;
originally announced March 2010.
-
SQUIPT - Superconducting Quantum Interference Proximity Transistor
Authors:
F. Giazotto,
J. T. Peltonen,
M. Meschke,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We present the realization and characterization of a novel-concept interferometer, the superconducting quantum interference proximity transistor (SQUIPT). Its operation relies on the modulation with the magnetic field of the density of states of a proximized metallic wire embedded in a superconducting ring. Flux sensitivities down to $\sim 10^{-5} Φ_0$Hz$^{-1/2}$ can be achieved even for a non-o…
▽ More
We present the realization and characterization of a novel-concept interferometer, the superconducting quantum interference proximity transistor (SQUIPT). Its operation relies on the modulation with the magnetic field of the density of states of a proximized metallic wire embedded in a superconducting ring. Flux sensitivities down to $\sim 10^{-5} Φ_0$Hz$^{-1/2}$ can be achieved even for a non-optimized design, with an intrinsic dissipation ($\sim 100$ fW) which is several orders of magnitude smaller than in conventional superconducting interferometers. Our results are in agreement with the theoretical prediction of the SQUIPT behavior, and suggest that optimization of the device parameters would lead to a large enhancement of sensitivity for the detection of tiny magnetic fields. The features of this setup and their potential relevance for applications are further discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Electronic Radio-Frequency Refrigerator
Authors:
S. Kafanov,
A. Kemppinen,
Yu. A. Pashkin,
M. Meschke,
J. S. Tsai,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We demonstrate experimentally that a hybrid single-electron transistor with superconducting leads and a normal-metal island can be refrigerated by an alternating voltage applied to the gate electrode. The simultaneous measurement of the dc current induced by the rf gate through the device at a small bias voltage serves as an in-situ thermometer.
We demonstrate experimentally that a hybrid single-electron transistor with superconducting leads and a normal-metal island can be refrigerated by an alternating voltage applied to the gate electrode. The simultaneous measurement of the dc current induced by the rf gate through the device at a small bias voltage serves as an in-situ thermometer.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Electronic Refrigeration at the Quantum Limit
Authors:
Andrey V. Timofeev,
Meri Helle,
Matthias Meschke,
Mikko Möttönen,
Jukka P. Pekola
Abstract:
We demonstrate quantum limited electronic refrigeration of a metallic island in a low temperature micro-circuit. We show that matching the impedance of the circuit enables refrigeration at a distance, of about 50 um in our case, through superconducting leads with a cooling power determined by the quantum of thermal conductance. In a reference sample with a mismatched circuit this effect is absen…
▽ More
We demonstrate quantum limited electronic refrigeration of a metallic island in a low temperature micro-circuit. We show that matching the impedance of the circuit enables refrigeration at a distance, of about 50 um in our case, through superconducting leads with a cooling power determined by the quantum of thermal conductance. In a reference sample with a mismatched circuit this effect is absent. Our results are consistent with the concept of electromagnetic heat transport. We observe and analyze the crossover between electromagnetic and quasiparticle heat flux in a superconductor.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2009; v1 submitted 16 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Calorimetric readout of a superconducting proximity-effect thermometer
Authors:
M. Meschke,
J. T. Peltonen,
H. Courtois,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
A proximity-effect thermometer measures the temperature dependent critical supercurrent in a long superconductor - normal metal - superconductor (SNS) Josephson junction. Typically, the transition from the superconducting to the normal state is detected by monitoring the appearance of a voltage across the junction. We describe a new approach to detect the transition based on the temperature incr…
▽ More
A proximity-effect thermometer measures the temperature dependent critical supercurrent in a long superconductor - normal metal - superconductor (SNS) Josephson junction. Typically, the transition from the superconducting to the normal state is detected by monitoring the appearance of a voltage across the junction. We describe a new approach to detect the transition based on the temperature increase in the resistive state due to Joule heating. Our method increases the sensitivity and is especially applicable for temperatures below about 300 mK.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Primary tunnel junction thermometry
Authors:
Jukka P. Pekola,
Tommy Holmqvist,
Matthias Meschke
Abstract:
We describe the concept and experimental demonstration of primary thermometry based on a four probe measurement of a single tunnel junction embedded within four arrays of junctions. We show that in this configuration random sample specific and environment-related errors can be avoided. This method relates temperature directly to Boltzmann constant, which will form the basis of the definition of…
▽ More
We describe the concept and experimental demonstration of primary thermometry based on a four probe measurement of a single tunnel junction embedded within four arrays of junctions. We show that in this configuration random sample specific and environment-related errors can be avoided. This method relates temperature directly to Boltzmann constant, which will form the basis of the definition of temperature and realization of official temperature scales in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2008;
originally announced August 2008.
-
Electronic cooling of a submicron-sized metallic beam
Authors:
J. T. Muhonen,
A. O. Niskanen,
M. Meschke,
Yu. A. Pashkin,
J. S. Tsai,
L. Sainiemi,
S. Franssila,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We demonstrate electronic cooling of a suspended AuPd island using superconductor-insulator-normal metal tunnel junctions. This was achieved by developing a simple fabrication method for reliably releasing narrow submicron sized metal beams. The process is based on reactive ion etching and uses a conducting substrate to avoid charge-up damage and is compatible with e.g. conventional e-beam litho…
▽ More
We demonstrate electronic cooling of a suspended AuPd island using superconductor-insulator-normal metal tunnel junctions. This was achieved by developing a simple fabrication method for reliably releasing narrow submicron sized metal beams. The process is based on reactive ion etching and uses a conducting substrate to avoid charge-up damage and is compatible with e.g. conventional e-beam lithography, shadow-angle metal deposition and oxide tunnel junctions. The devices function well and exhibit clear cooling; up to factor of two at sub-kelvin temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2008; v1 submitted 2 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
Origin of Hysteresis in a Proximity Josephson Junction
Authors:
Hervé Courtois,
M. Meschke,
J. T. Peltonen,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We investigate hysteresis in the transport properties of Superconductor - Normal metal - Superconductor (S-N-S) junctions at low temperatures by measuring directly the electron temperature in the normal metal. Our results demonstrate unambiguously that the hysteresis results from an increase of the normal metal electron temperature once the junction switches to the resistive state. In our geomet…
▽ More
We investigate hysteresis in the transport properties of Superconductor - Normal metal - Superconductor (S-N-S) junctions at low temperatures by measuring directly the electron temperature in the normal metal. Our results demonstrate unambiguously that the hysteresis results from an increase of the normal metal electron temperature once the junction switches to the resistive state. In our geometry, the electron temperature increase is governed by the thermal resistance of the superconducting electrodes of the junction.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2008; v1 submitted 29 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Recombination limited energy relaxation in a BCS superconductor
Authors:
A. V. Timofeev,
C. Pascual Garcia,
N. B. Kopnin,
A. M. Savin,
M. Meschke,
F. Giazotto,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We study quasiparticle energy relaxation at sub-kelvin temperatures by injecting hot electrons into an aluminium island and measuring the energy flux from electrons into phonons both in the superconducting and in the normal state. The data show strong reduction of the flux at low temperatures in the superconducting state, in qualitative agreement with the presented quasiclassical theory for clea…
▽ More
We study quasiparticle energy relaxation at sub-kelvin temperatures by injecting hot electrons into an aluminium island and measuring the energy flux from electrons into phonons both in the superconducting and in the normal state. The data show strong reduction of the flux at low temperatures in the superconducting state, in qualitative agreement with the presented quasiclassical theory for clean superconductors. Quantitatively, the energy flux exceeds that from the theory both in the superconducting and in the normal state, possibly suggesting an enhanced or additional relaxation process.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Quantized current of a hybrid single-electron transistor with superconducting leads and a normal-metal island
Authors:
Antti Kemppinen,
Matthias Meschke,
Mikko Möttönen,
Dmitri V. Averin,
Jukka P. Pekola
Abstract:
We discuss the operation of the superconductor - insulator - normal-metal - insulator - superconductor (SINIS) turnstile. This voltage-biased hybrid single-electron transistor (SET) provides current quantization even with only one radio-frequency (rf) control parameter, namely the gate voltage of the single island. We give an overview of the main error mechanisms of the turnstile and consider it…
▽ More
We discuss the operation of the superconductor - insulator - normal-metal - insulator - superconductor (SINIS) turnstile. This voltage-biased hybrid single-electron transistor (SET) provides current quantization even with only one radio-frequency (rf) control parameter, namely the gate voltage of the single island. We give an overview of the main error mechanisms of the turnstile and consider its feasibility as a quantum current standard. We also present experimental results of pumping with the SINIS structure which show decreased leakage current compared to earlier measurements with the opposite NISIN structure.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2009; v1 submitted 11 March, 2008;
originally announced March 2008.
-
Hybrid single-electron transistor as a source of quantized electric current
Authors:
Jukka P. Pekola,
Juha J. Vartiainen,
Mikko Mottonen,
Olli-Pentti Saira,
Matthias Meschke,
Dmitri V. Averin
Abstract:
The basis of synchronous manipulation of individual electrons in solid-state devices was laid by the rise of single-electronics about two decades ago. Ultra-small structures in a low temperature environment form an ideal domain of addressing electrons one by one. A long-standing challenge in this field has been the realization of a source of electric current that is accurately related to the ope…
▽ More
The basis of synchronous manipulation of individual electrons in solid-state devices was laid by the rise of single-electronics about two decades ago. Ultra-small structures in a low temperature environment form an ideal domain of addressing electrons one by one. A long-standing challenge in this field has been the realization of a source of electric current that is accurately related to the operation frequency $f$. There is an urgent call for a quantum standard of electric current and for the so-called metrological triangle, where voltage from Josephson effect and resistance from quantum Hall effect are tested against current via Ohm's law for a consistency check of the fundamental constants of Nature, $\hbar$ and $e$. Several attempts to create a metrological current source that would comply with the demanding criteria of extreme accuracy, high yield, and implementation with not too many control parameters have been reported. However, no satisfactory solution exists as yet despite many ingenious achievements that have been witnessed over the years. Here we propose and prove the unexpected concept of a hybrid metal-superconductor turnstile in the form of a one-island single-electron transistor with one gate, which demonstrates robust current plateaus at multiple levels of $ef$ within the uncertainty of our current measurement. Our theoretical estimates show that the errors of the present system can be efficiently suppressed by further optimizations of design and proper choice of the device parameters and therefore we expect it to eventually meet the stringent specifications of quantum metrology.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2007; v1 submitted 15 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Parity effect in Al and Nb single electron transistors in a tunable environment
Authors:
A. M. Savin,
M. Meschke,
J. P. Pekola,
Yu. A. Pashkin,
T. F. Li,
H. Im,
J. S. Tsai
Abstract:
Two different types of Cooper pair transistors, with Al and Nb islands, have been investigated in a tunable electromagnetic environment. The device with an Al island demonstrates gate charge modulation with 2e-periodicity in a wide range of environmental impedances at bath temperatures below 340 mK. Contrary to the results of the Al sample, we were not able to detect 2e-periodicity under any con…
▽ More
Two different types of Cooper pair transistors, with Al and Nb islands, have been investigated in a tunable electromagnetic environment. The device with an Al island demonstrates gate charge modulation with 2e-periodicity in a wide range of environmental impedances at bath temperatures below 340 mK. Contrary to the results of the Al sample, we were not able to detect 2e-periodicity under any conditions on similar samples with Nb island. We attribute this to the material properties of Nb.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Heat Transistor: Demonstration of Gate-Controlled Electron Refrigeration
Authors:
Olli-Pentti Saira,
Matthias Meschke,
Francesco Giazotto,
Alexander M. Savin,
Mikko Mottonen,
Jukka P. Pekola
Abstract:
We present experiments on a superconductor-normal metal electron refrigerator in a regime where single-electron charging effects are significant. The system functions as a heat transistor, i.e., the heat flux out from the normal metal island can be controlled with a gate voltage. A theoretical model developed within the framework of single-electron tunneling provides a full quantitative agreemen…
▽ More
We present experiments on a superconductor-normal metal electron refrigerator in a regime where single-electron charging effects are significant. The system functions as a heat transistor, i.e., the heat flux out from the normal metal island can be controlled with a gate voltage. A theoretical model developed within the framework of single-electron tunneling provides a full quantitative agreement with the experiment. This work serves as the first experimental observation of Coulombic control of heat transfer and, in particular, of refrigeration in a mesoscopic system.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Wide-band detection of the third moment of shot noise by a hysteretic Josephson junction
Authors:
A. V. Timofeev,
M. Meschke,
J. T. Peltonen,
T. T. Heikkila,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We use a hysteretic Josephson junction as an on-chip detector of the third moment of shot noise of a tunnel junction. The detectable bandwidth is determined by the plasma frequency of the detector, which is about 50 GHz in the present experiment. The third moment of shot noise results in a measurable change of the switching rate when reversing polarity of the current through the noise source. We…
▽ More
We use a hysteretic Josephson junction as an on-chip detector of the third moment of shot noise of a tunnel junction. The detectable bandwidth is determined by the plasma frequency of the detector, which is about 50 GHz in the present experiment. The third moment of shot noise results in a measurable change of the switching rate when reversing polarity of the current through the noise source. We analyze the observed asymmetry assuming adiabatic response of the detector.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
Detecting Current Noise with a Josephson Junction in the Macroscopic Quantum Tunneling Regime
Authors:
J. T. Peltonen,
A. V. Timofeev,
M. Meschke,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
We discuss the use of a hysteretic Josephson junction to detect current fluctuations with frequencies below the plasma frequency of the junction. These adiabatic fluctuations are probed by switching measurements observing the noise-affected average rate of macroscopic quantum tunneling of the detector junction out of its zero-voltage state. In a proposed experimental scheme, frequencies of the n…
▽ More
We discuss the use of a hysteretic Josephson junction to detect current fluctuations with frequencies below the plasma frequency of the junction. These adiabatic fluctuations are probed by switching measurements observing the noise-affected average rate of macroscopic quantum tunneling of the detector junction out of its zero-voltage state. In a proposed experimental scheme, frequencies of the noise are limited by an on-chip filtering circuit. The third cumulant of current fluctuations at the detector is related to an asymmetry of the switching rates.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2006;
originally announced November 2006.
-
Influence of Supercurrents on Low-Temperature Thermopower in Mesoscopic N/S Structures
Authors:
J. Zou,
I. Sosnin,
P. Virtanen,
M. Meschke,
V. T. Petrashov,
T. T. Heikkila
Abstract:
The thermopower of mesoscopic normal metal/superconductor structures has been measured at low temperatures. Effect of supercurrent present in normal part of the structure was studied in two cases: when it was created by applied external magnetic field and when it was applied directly using extra superconducting electrodes. Temperature and magnetic field dependencies of thermopower are compared t…
▽ More
The thermopower of mesoscopic normal metal/superconductor structures has been measured at low temperatures. Effect of supercurrent present in normal part of the structure was studied in two cases: when it was created by applied external magnetic field and when it was applied directly using extra superconducting electrodes. Temperature and magnetic field dependencies of thermopower are compared to the numerical simulations based on the quasiclassical theory of the superconducting proximity effect.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
Single-mode heat conduction by photons
Authors:
M. Meschke,
W. Guichard,
J. P. Pekola
Abstract:
Electrical conductance is quantized in units of $σ_{\rm Q}=2e^2/h$ in ballistic one-dimensional conductors. Similarly, thermal conductance at temperature $T$ is expected to be limited by the quantum of thermal conductance of one mode, $G_{\rm Q} = \frac{πk_{\rm B}^2}{6\hbar}T$, when physical dimensions are small in comparison to characteristic wavelength of the carriers. The relation between…
▽ More
Electrical conductance is quantized in units of $σ_{\rm Q}=2e^2/h$ in ballistic one-dimensional conductors. Similarly, thermal conductance at temperature $T$ is expected to be limited by the quantum of thermal conductance of one mode, $G_{\rm Q} = \frac{πk_{\rm B}^2}{6\hbar}T$, when physical dimensions are small in comparison to characteristic wavelength of the carriers. The relation between $σ_{\rm Q}$ and $G_{\rm Q}$ obeys the Wiedemann-Franz law for ballistic electrons (apart from factor 2 in $σ_{\rm Q}$ due to spin degeneracy), but somewhat amazingly the same expression of $G_{\rm Q}$ is expected to hold also for phonons and photons, or any other particles with arbitrary exclusion statistics. The single-mode heat conductance is particularly relevant in nano-structures, e.g., when studying heat conduction by phonons in dielectric materials, or cooling of electrons in metals at very low temperatures. Here we show, based on our experimental results, that at low temperatures heat is transferred by photon radiation, in our case along a superconducting line, when electron-phonon as well as normal electronic heat conduction are frozen out. Thermal conductance is limited by $G_{\rm Q}$, approaching this value towards low temperatures. Our observation has implications on, e.g., performance and design of ultra-sensitive bolometers and electronic micro-refrigerators, whose operation is largely dependent on weak thermal coupling between the device and its environment.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2006;
originally announced May 2006.
-
Shot-noise-driven escape in hysteretic Josephson junctions
Authors:
J. P. Pekola,
T. E. Nieminen,
M. Meschke,
J. M. Kivioja,
A. O. Niskanen,
J. J. Vartiainen
Abstract:
We have measured the influence of shot noise on hysteretic Josephson junctions initially in macroscopic quantum tunnelling (MQT) regime. Escape threshold current into the resistive state decreases monotonically with increasing average current through the scattering conductor, which is another tunnel junction. Escape is predominantly determined by excitation due to the wide-band shot noise. This…
▽ More
We have measured the influence of shot noise on hysteretic Josephson junctions initially in macroscopic quantum tunnelling (MQT) regime. Escape threshold current into the resistive state decreases monotonically with increasing average current through the scattering conductor, which is another tunnel junction. Escape is predominantly determined by excitation due to the wide-band shot noise. This process is equivalent to thermal activation (TA) over the barrier at temperatures up to about four times above the critical temperature of the superconductor. The presented TA model is in excellent agreement with the experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Study of Field-Induced Magnetic Order in Singlet-Ground-State Magnet CsFeCl$_3$
Authors:
Mitsuru Toda,
Yutaka Fujii,
Shinji Kawano,
Takao Goto,
Meiro Chiba,
Shizumasa Ueda,
Kenji Nakajima,
Kazuhisa Kakurai,
Jens Klenke,
Ralf Feyerherm,
Matthias Meschke,
Hans Anton Graf,
Michael Steiner
Abstract:
The field-induced magnetic order in the singlet-ground-state system CsFeCl$_3$ has been studied by measuring magnetization and neutron diffraction. The field dependence of intensity for the neutron magnetic reflection has clearly demonstrated that the field-induced ordered phase is described by the order parameter $<S_x>$. A condensate growth of magnons is investigated through the temperature de…
▽ More
The field-induced magnetic order in the singlet-ground-state system CsFeCl$_3$ has been studied by measuring magnetization and neutron diffraction. The field dependence of intensity for the neutron magnetic reflection has clearly demonstrated that the field-induced ordered phase is described by the order parameter $<S_x>$. A condensate growth of magnons is investigated through the temperature dependence of $M_z$ and $M_{\perp}$, and this ordering is discussed in the context of a magnon Bose-Einstein condensation. Development of the coherent state and the static correlation length has been observed in the incommensurate phase in the field region of $5 < H < 6$ T at 1.8 K. At $H > H_{\rm c}$, a satellite peak was found in coexistence with the commensurate peak at the phase boundary around 10 T, which indicates that the tilt of the c-axis would be less than $\sim 0.5^{\circ}$ in the whole experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2004; v1 submitted 8 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.