Preprocessor-Based Variability in Open-Source and Industrial Software Systems: An Empirical Study

kaestner@cs.cmu.edu (C. Hunsen, J. Siegmund, O. Leßenich, S. Apel, B. Zhang, C. Kästner, M. Becker)
Sun, 13 Mar 2016 14:06:02 -0400

Claus Hunsen, Janet Siegmund, Olaf Leßenich, Sven Apel, Bo Zhang, Christian Kästner, and Martin Becker. Preprocessor-Based Variability in Open-Source and Industrial Software Systems: An Empirical Study. Empirical Software Engineering (EMSE), Special Issue on Empirical Evidence on Software Product Line Engineering, 1--34, 2015.

Almost every sufficiently complex software system today is configurable. Conditional compilation is a simple variability-implementation mechanism that is widely used in open-source projects and industry. Especially, the C preprocessor (cpp) is very popular in practice, but it is also gaining (again) interest in academia. Although there have been several attempts to understand and improve cpp, there is a lack of understanding of how it is used in open-source and industrial systems and whether different usage patterns have emerged. The background is that much research on configurable systems and product lines concentrates on open-source systems, simply because they are available for study in the first place. This leads to the potentially problematic situation that it is unclear whether the results obtained from these studies are transferable to industrial systems. We aim at lowering this gap by comparing the use of cpp in open-source projects and industry—especially from the embedded-systems domain—, based on a substantial set of subject systems and well-known variability metrics, including size, scattering, and tangling metrics. A key result of our empirical study is that, regarding almost all aspects we studied, the analyzed open-source systems and the considered embedded systems from industry have comparable distributions regarding most metrics, including systems that have been developed in industry and made open source at some point. So, our study indicates that, regarding cpp as variability-implementation mechanism, insights, methods, and tools developed based on studies of open- source systems are transferable to industrial systems—at least, with respect to the metrics we considered.